Language
Country/Area
No result found
rom death to acceptance: How do these five emotional stages affect our lives
When faced with loss, the torrent of emotions can make one feel overwhelmed. According to the five-stage grief model proposed by Swiss-American psychiatrist Elisabeth Kübler-Ross in 1969, individuals typically experience five important emotions during the loss process: denial, Anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. These emotions not only affect individuals, but also the people around them and society as a whole. However, the application and interpretation of this model has been controversial. Does it appropriately reflect the human grieving process?
When experiencing loss, people's emotions often interweave and it is not necessarily a linear process.
Historical Background of the Stages of Grief
Kubler-Ross elaborated on this model in her book Death and Dying, based on her experience with terminally ill patients and how they responded psychologically to death. The basis of her theory is a series of research and seminars she conducted at the University of Chicago Medicine. At the time, there was a lack of education about death and grief in medical schools, which drove her to delve deeper into how humans deal with their own and others' death.
“Technological advances have exacerbated people’s fear of death, leading them to deny their own mortality.”
Analysis of the five stages of grief
The five stages of grief described by Kubler-Ross are often referred to by the acronym DABDA. They are:
- Denial: This is the first reaction people have when faced with a loss or an impending loss. The individual may believe that the event was wrong and cling to an acceptable false reality.
- Anger: When denial can no longer continue, the individual may feel angry and frustrated with the people and things around him or her and begin to look for responsibility and a way out.
- Bargaining: Sympathetic hope leads some people to try to prolong life or avoid tragedy by changing their lifestyle.
- Depression: As reality becomes clearer, the individual may experience great sadness and even negative self-reflection.
- Acceptance: Eventually, the individual comes to terms with this reality and begins to rebuild their life and mind.
Criticisms and Controversies of the Model
Although the Kubler-Ross model is widely used in psychology and social work, it has also received a lot of criticism. Critics point out that the model lacks sufficient empirical research and does not take into account cultural differences. Many experts believe that this model may reflect emotional responses in a specific culture and time and may not apply to everyone.
“Not everyone goes through these stages, and the lack of consideration of environmental factors calls into question the applicability of the model.”
Studies have shown that the emotional responses of many critically ill patients cannot be accurately graded according to the Kubler-Ross model. Some patients even express grief in a variety of ways and do not follow the traditional five stages. Within this complex emotional canvas, there are many underlying factors that influence how each person grieves.
Conceptual significance and future direction
Despite much controversy, Kubler-Ross's theory still inspires subsequent research and discussion. Today, more and more scholars view grief as a dynamic process involving the alternation and interweaving of multiple emotions. Through more nuanced interpretations, psychology is also exploring more complex theories of grief, such as the impact of emotion regulation and cultural background on grief responses.
"When facing loss for the first time, many people may experience confusion and pain, but learning how to locate your emotions and accept changes is an important step in life."
Against this background, we can't help but wonder: Amidst the many difficulties in life, how can we find our own path to emotional redemption?
