Indicators of wood frog (Lithobates sylvaticus) condition in a suburbanizing landscape

Abstract

Wood frogs (Lithobates sylvaticus) are threatened by habitat degradation associated with suburbanization. Suburban development near pools may affect larvae with ramifications for population persistence and vitality. We studied larval development and documented key vernal pool and terrestrial characteristics within 1000 m of 43 pools across the suburban development gradient near Bangor, Maine, USA. Specifically, we examined how survival and morphological characteristics (e.g., developmental phenology, condition, body length, and tail length and shape) varied with characteristics at pool and landscape scales. Secondarily, we explored associations between morphology and survival. Differences in tadpole morphology were associated with suburban land development, hydrology, within-pool vegetation indicative of light availability at the water’s surface, and density of pool-breeding amphibian egg masses. Across all pools, tadpoles had delayed development and were larger in pools with longer hydroperiods, while tadpoles in suburban pools developed earlier and were larger than those in rural pools with comparable hydroperiods. Tadpoles developed later and had longer tails in pools with greater canopy cover. Morphology profiles also differed between rural and suburban sites and among years. Survival in suburban pools was predicted to be 15 times greater than in rural pools, but across all pools (including those at intermediate intensities of suburbanization), survival was not predicted to vary with either morphology or site characteristics. No strong relationship existed between developmental phenology and any condition or size metric. Because rural and suburban tadpoles responded similarly to within-pool conditions, our results support the need to maintain natural hydrology and vegetation conditions in pools even in developing areas. Although we detected benefits to tadpoles with increasing suburbanization, suburbanization is well known to extirpate breeding populations; thus, it is likely that wood frog population declines associated with suburbanization are responding to stressors beyond the pool at terrestrial life stages.