Influence of humeral stem inclination in reverse shoulder arthroplasty on range of motion: a meta-analysis

Abstract

Abstract Hypothesis The reversed shoulder arthroplasty, as introduced by Grammont, has had many modifications over time. One of these modifications was reducing the neck-shaft angle (NSA) from 155 degrees to 135 degrees. Biomechanical studies indicated that lowering the NSA increases external rotation, and reduces abduction and the incidence of scapular notching. The purpose of this study was to compare range of motion, functional outcome measures and complications in patients undergoing reversed shoulder arthroplasty, depending on the NSA, through a systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods A literature search was conducted (articles published from January 1985 till January 2020) in the PubMed/Medline, Embase, CINAHL databases and the Cochrane library. All studies reporting outcomes after primary reversed shoulder arthroplasty for osteoarthritis and rotator cuff-related disease were included. Patients were divided into two groups: a medialized design (MD) with a NSA of 150-155 degrees and a lateralized design (LD) with a NSA of less than 150 degrees. Pooled effects were calculated in the form of mean differences and 95% confidence intervals (CI). Risk of bias was assessed using the ROBINS-1 tool for non-RCTs and the RoB tool for RCTs. Results A total of 21 studies and 3134 arthroplasties were included: 1366 with a MD and 1678 with a LD. The mean age was 73.0 years (MD 74.0 and LD 72.5). A direct comparative meta-analysis was not feasible, and therefore all data were compared using the minimal clinical important difference. The MD group demonstrated a larger improvement in abduction (56.76°, 95% CI 37.03 – 76.49) compared to the LD group (48.52°, 95% CI 28.27 – 68.78), however the LD group demonstrated a larger improvement in external rotation with the arm at the side (MD: 7.69°, 95% CI 0.01 – 15.37; LD: 16.14° 95% CI 7.18 – 25.09). When looking at the postoperative range of motion, the MD group had more abduction than the LD group (MD: 136.28°, 95% CI 127.36 – 145.20; LD: 127.77° 95% CI 117.02 – 138.52). Both designs had a comparable improvement in the Constant Murley Score (MD 42.04 points, LD 41.14 points). Lowering the NSA was accompanied by a decrease in dislocation rate (MD: 4.6%; LD: 1.4%; P-value 0.037) and notching rate (MD: 40.3%; LD: 17.3%; P-value Conclusion In our analysis lowering the NSA decreases the amount of abduction, but increases the amount of external rotation. This change in ROM is accompanied by less scapular notching and dislocations. There is no clear impact on functional outcome measures.