How Far Should We Explore Hypospadias? Next-generation Sequencing Applied to a Large Cohort of Hypospadiac Patients.

Abstract

BACKGROUND\nNext-generation sequencing (NGS) is generally used for patients with severe disorders of sex development (DSD). However, NGS has not been applied extensively for patients with hypospadias only, and most affected children do not benefit from an etiological diagnosis.\n\n\nOBJECTIVE\nTo evaluate the clinical usefulness of NGS for patients with hypospadias, regardless of severity.\n\n\nDESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS\nProspective multicenter research included 293 children with glandular to penoscrotal hypospadias (no undescended testis and no micropenis). After excluding likely pathogenic androgen receptor (AR) variants by Sanger sequencing, an NGS panel tested 336 genes including unexplored candidates in 284 patients.\n\n\nOUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS\nThe rate of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants was assessed using REVEL, ClinVar, and in-house tools (Captain-ACHAB, MobiCNV, and MobiDetails).\n\n\nRESULTS AND LIMITATIONS\nLikely pathogenic variants were identified in 16 (5.5%) patients with both Sanger sequencing and NGS taken into account. Some genes were related to DSD (AR, NR5A1, HSD17B3, and MAMLD1), but reverse phenotyping revealed two syndromic disorders with midline defects (MID1) and alteration in the retinoic acid signaling pathway (RARA). Coverage analysis revealed an 18q deletion. Identification of likely pathogenic variants increased with hypospadias severity. Other variants of unknown significance (VUSs) in genes implicated in hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, Noonan syndrome, and genital tubercle development were also identified. Genetic study mainly focused on exonic variants, and most cases remain unexplained.\n\n\nCONCLUSIONS\nNGS reveals minor forms of DSD, undiagnosed syndromes, or candidate rare variants in new genes, indicating that even patients with mild hypospadias benefit from advanced sequencing techniques. Early molecular diagnosis would help improve follow-up at puberty and medical counseling for initially undiagnosed syndromes. Future studies will improve the diagnosis by investigating the contribution of VUSs.\n\n\nPATIENT SUMMARY\nNext-generation sequencing enables simultaneous testing of numerous genes and should not be limited to disorders of sex development cases. Even patients with mild hypospadias would benefit from early diagnosis of a genetic defect implicated in sex development or other syndromes.