Peer review declaration

Abstract

All papers published in this volume of Journal of Physics: Conference Series have been peer reviewed through processes administered by the Editors. Reviews were conducted by expert referees to the professional and scientific standards expected of a proceedings journal published by IOP Publishing. • Type of peer review: Single-blind / Double-blind / Triple-blind / Open / Other (please describe) • The review process of all papers of MISEIC 2020 is conducted using single-blind peer review as the authors are able to see reviewers’ comments and are still unable to know the reviewers’ identities. This method ensures enough space for all reviewers to comment on all papers, and therefore, the quality of those can be guaranteed in terms of clarity and validity. ✓ Conference submission management system: The system for managing the paper submission in MISEIC 2020 is Open Conference System (OCS) at www.miseic.conference.unesa.ac.id. The authors need to register before use. They start submitting the abstract followed by uploading the full-paper. • ✓ Number of submissions received: The total abstract received were 147 abstracts, but the total papers received were 87 papers. • ✓ Number of submissions sent for review: The total papers sent for review were 87 papers. • • Number of submissions accepted: The total submissions accepted were 71 papers, but only 47 of those are finally eligible to be submitted in IOP. The rest papers were published elsewhere or rejected. The rejection was caused by high similarity index, out of topic/scope, and authors’ incapability to revise on schedule. ✓ Acceptance Rate (Number of Submissions Accepted / Number of Submissions Received X 100): The acceptance rate for MISEIC paper was 54%. • • Average number of reviews per paper: Each paper is reviewed twice. First, it is reviewed after the abstract is accepted. Second, the review is conducted after the authors revise their paper in accordance with the first reviewers’ comments. ✓ Total number of reviewers involved: MISEIC involved twenty reviewers from six different disciplines, including Pure and Applied Mathematics, Mathematics Education, Science and Technology, Computer Science and Science Education. • ✓ Any additional info on review process: The plagiarism checker software was applied twice, before and after review, to keep originality of ideas and sentences in all papers. • ✓ Contact person for queries: Contact person: Aris Rudi Purnomo (Universitas Negeri Surabaya), email: [email protected] •