Bifocal Compression-Distraction for combined Bone and Soft Tissue Defects in Post-traumatic Tibial Nonunion.

Abstract

OBJECTIVE\nTo compare two distraction osteogenesis techniques in post-traumatic tibial nonunion patients with composite bone and soft tissue defects.\n\n\nDESIGN\nNon-randomized prospective, case series, single-center study.\n\n\nSETTING\nDepartment of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Limb Reconstruction Unit, El-Helal hospital, Cairo, Egypt.\n\n\nPARTICIPANTS\nFifty post-traumatic tibial nonunion patients with composite bone and soft tissue defects.\n\n\nINTERVENTION\n25 patients were treated using bone transport (BT) technique and 25 patients were treated using acute shortening (AS) and distraction technique.\n\n\nOUTCOME MEASUREMENTS\nThe external fixation index (EFI); functional and bone results, and complication rates.\n\n\nRESULTS\nAll patients were followed for a minimum of 18 months after removal of their Ilizarov frame. AS and BT groups were followed up for a mean of 19.7 and 20.3 months respectively. The mean bone gap after resection and debridement was 4 cm in AS group and 5.9 cm in BT group (p=0.06). The mean EFI was statistically significant and lower in the AS group compared to BT group (p=0.03). There were no other statistically significant differences between either intervention groups.\n\n\nCONCLUSION\nBoth techniques achieved comparable good to excellent results, and the differences in number of complications and ASAMI scores for bone or function were not statistically significant. Yet, it appears that the AS technique may be superior because it has a significantly lower EFI. This may not be feasible in all cases however, because the acute shortening technique is limited by the defect size and the condition of the surrounding soft tissues.\n\n\nLEVEL OF EVIDENCE\nLevel II, Therapeutic Study.