Is energetics or competition a stronger driver of male smallmouth bass seasonal reproductive timing?

Abstract

Intraspecific competitive ability is often associated with body size and has been shown to influence reproductive timing in many species. However, energetic constraints provide an alternative explanation for size-related differences of reproductive timing. In temperate fishes that experience a winter starvation period, for instance, a negative allometric relationship between body size and winter energy loss might explain why larger males spawn earlier in a season than smaller males, especially in fishes that exhibit paternal care, which is energetically costly and limits parental foraging opportunities. Male smallmouth bass, Micropterus dolomieu, defend nesting territories in which they care for offspring over an extended period. In northern populations, males rely on energy reserves over a winter starvation period and in spring must recoup energy losses before initiating reproduction, making them ideal systems in which to study contributions of competition and energetic allometry on differences of reproductive timing. Here, we harness data on parental male M. dolomieu from a 10-year study and show that larger males required fewer degree days—a measure of thermal energy experienced—in spring before they spawned each year and that the time of peak seasonal reproduction in the population was negatively related to the number of degree days accumulated before reproduction started. Furthermore, we found that growth of individual males between seasons better predicted changes in timing of reproduction than changes in size relative to competitors. Together, these results suggest that timing of reproduction in this population is more strongly influenced by energetic constraints than size-based competition amongst males. LAY SUMMARY In many animals, larger individuals reproduce earlier in a season. We collected data on reproductive timing in a wild population of bass, and examined whether bigger males breed earlier because they are better competitors, or because they are energetically prepared to breed earlier in the season. Our results suggest that larger males reproduce earlier in a season because they recuperate energy lost in the over-winter period of starvation more rapidly, not because of competitive advantage.