Functional traits of carabid beetles reveal seasonal variation in community assembly in annual crops

Abstract

Trait-based community assembly studies have mostly been addressed along spatial gradients, and do not consider explicitly a fundamental dimension governing community assembly, the time. Nevertheless, such consideration seems particularly necessary in systems in which organisms have to face regular disturbances and rapid changes in vegetation phenology, such as in intensively managed farmlands. In this study, we aimed at understanding how the functional diversity of carabid beetle communities varied across the growing season in response to crop type. We tested three alternative hypotheses on mechanisms underlying the community assembly. We used data from a long-term monitoring conducted over nine years in an intensively-managed farmland in central western France, in a total of 625 fields. First, we measured morphological traits related to body size, dispersal mode, and resource acquisition on the 13 dominant carabid species (> 85 % of all trapped individuals) and identified three independent dimensions of functional specialization within our species pool along axes of a PCA and highlighted key traits for community assembly. Second, we evaluated the community assembly temporal dynamics and the impact of habitat filtering and niche differentiation in the different crop types with time, using linear mixed-effects models. We showed that functional species assembly of carabid beetle communities occurring in crop fields varies importantly intra-annually, with strong variations in these dynamics depending on crop type and crop phenology. Each crop acted as a filter on carabid communities for body size and resource-acquisition traits, and functional differentiation between crops increased with time. We did not find any evidence of habitat filtering on traits related to dispersal mode. Our results emphasize the major role of crop phenology but also disturbances involved by agricultural practices such as crop harvesting on changes in community assembly, likely due to seasonal and inter-annual redistributions of species in agricultural landscapes in response to such changes. The temporal dimension cannot be ignored to understand the assembly of local carabid communities in farmlands.