Stability of DNA methylation and chromatin accessibility in structurally diverse maize genomes

Abstract

Accessible chromatin and unmethylated DNA are associated with many genes and cis-regulatory elements. Attempts to understand natural variation for accessible chromatin regions (ACRs) and unmethylated regions (UMRs) often rely upon alignments to a single reference genome. This limits the ability to assess regions that are absent in the reference genome assembly and monitor how nearby structural variants influence variation in chromatin state. In this study, de novo genome assemblies for four maize inbreds (B73, Mo17, Oh43 and W22) are utilized to assess chromatin accessibility and DNA methylation patterns in a pan-genome context. The number of UMRs and ACRs that can be identified is more accurate when chromatin data is aligned to the matched genome rather than a single reference genome. While there are UMRs and ACRs present within genomic regions that are not shared between genotypes, these features are substantially enriched within shared regions, as determined by chromosomal alignments. Characterization of UMRs present within shared genomic regions reveals that most UMRs maintain the unmethylated state in other genotypes with only a small number being polymorphic between genotypes. However, the majority of UMRs between genotypes only exhibit partial overlaps suggesting that the boundaries between methylated and unmethylated DNA are dynamic. This instability is not solely due to sequence variation as these partially overlapping UMRs are frequently found within genomic regions that lack sequence variation. The ability to compare chromatin properties among individuals with structural variation enables pan-epigenome analyses to study the sources of variation for accessible chromatin and unmethylated DNA. Article summary Regions of the genome that have accessible chromatin or unmethylated DNA are often associated with cis-regulatory elements. We assessed chromatin accessibility and DNA methylation in four structurally diverse maize genomes. There are accessible or unmethylated regions within the non-shared portions of the genomes but these features are depleted within these regions. Evaluating the dynamics of methylation and accessibility between genotypes reveals conservation of features, albeit with variable boundaries suggesting some instability of the precise edges of unmethylated regions.