An adaptive power prior for sequential clinical trials – Application to bridging studies

Abstract

During drug evaluation trials, information from clinical trials previously conducted on another population, indications or schedules may be available. In these cases, it might be desirable to share information by efficiently using the available resources. In this work, we developed an adaptive power prior with a commensurability parameter for using historical or external information. It allows, at each stage, full borrowing when the data are not in conflict, no borrowing when the data are in conflict or “tuned” borrowing when the data are in between. We propose to apply our adaptive power prior method to bridging studies between Caucasians and Asians, and we focus on the sequential adaptive allocation design, although other design settings can be used. We weight the prior information in two steps: the effective sample size approach is used to set the maximum desirable amount of information to be shared from historical data at each step of the trial; then, in a sort of Empirical Bayes approach, a commensurability parameter is chosen using a measure of distribution distance. This approach avoids elicitation and computational issues regarding the usual Empirical Bayes approach. We propose several versions of our method, and we conducted an extensive simulation study evaluating the robustness and sensitivity to prior choices.