Research on Validity of Performance Evaluation Methods of Local Government’s Precaution of Land Expropriation

Abstract

Based on the practice of performance evaluation of local government’s precaution of mass incidents triggered by land expropriation, connotations of validity of performance evaluation methods of local government’s precaution of mass incidents triggered by land expropriation were defined; a measurement model to verify validity of performance evaluation methods was established; and Xiangyang City was taken as an example for empirical analysis, so as to sequence 9 performance evaluation methods according to their validity. The results showed that in the case of performance evaluation of Xiangyang’s precaution of mass incidents triggered by land expropriation, the Artificial Neural Network Comprehensive Evaluation (ANNCE) and Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation (FCE) methods were of the highest validity. Introduction During the transition period, governments at all levels attach great importance to the work of Mass Incidents Triggered by Land Expropriation (MITLE) and accelerate the formation of a scientific and effective emergency management system and performance evaluation systems. However, in the process of vigorously preventing MITLE, there are phenomena such as behavioral misconduct and results which are difficult to obtain social identification. This highlights the low performance of local governments in preventing MITLE and the difficulty in accurately measuring the performance of local government’s precautions. The choice of performance evaluation methods directly affects the results of preventive performance measurements. Studying the effectiveness of local government s precautions of MITLE performance evaluation methods can scientifically and reasonably evaluate the performance of precautions of MITLE, and reduce the bias of evaluation results, which would provide support for comprehensive and profound evaluation of local government s ability to prevent MITLE and improve local governments’ performance evaluation. Certain results in the effectiveness research of performance evaluation methods were achieved by scholar at home and abroad. Szmidt (2011) indicated that the effectiveness of a comprehensive evaluation method is to calculate the Spearman rank correlation coefficient (SRCC) between the rank sequence and the benchmark rank sequence obtained by various evaluation methods. Sun Yanwu (2013) studied the effectiveness of eight comprehensive evaluation methods by generating benchmark rank sequence, rank correlation coefficient calculation and rank correlation coefficient test. Li Jiaona (2013) applied the analytic hierarchy process to conduct an empirical study on the government response management performance evaluation of the Wukan incident. Li Yanan (2015) established a performance evaluation index system for precautions of MITLE, and utilized fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to conduct performance evaluations. Defining the Validity of Performance Evaluation Methods of Local Government’s Precaution of MITLE The validity of performance evaluation methods of precaution of MITLE refers to the degree of correlation between the evaluation value and the real performance value calculated from the performance of the local government s precautions of MITLE by using performance evaluation methods. The ultimate goal of precautions of MITLE performance evaluation is to sequence and 4th International Conference on Social Science and Contemporary Humanity Development (SSCHD 2018) Copyright © 2019, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/). Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 281