Pelvic Shadowing as a Diagnostic Predictor of Orthopedic Pathology in Orthopedic Trauma Patients

Abstract

Introduction The Throckmorton sign, or John Thomas sign, is a well-established orthopedic eponym, anecdotally used in orthopedic surgery to correlate the direction of male genitalia, observed on a pelvic radiograph, with the laterality of an associated orthopedic pathology. In earlier studies, the direction of pelvic shadowing on X-ray has been neither a credible nor a reliable predictor of fracture laterality. Given this small body of evidence, we sought to further investigate the relationship between peri-trochanteric hip fracture laterality and male genitalia lie. Method A single-center retrospective chart review was conducted of 397 consecutive male patients who received pelvic radiographs performed upon entry to an urban level 1 trauma center. Exclusion criteria included age less than 18 years or a prior history of pelvic or urological surgery. Of this cohort, 360 patients met the inclusion criteria and underwent investigation. Results The study population had an average age of 42 years (range: 18-91 years). Statistical analysis yielded a 4.24 relative risk with pelvic shadowing laterality and respective peri-trochanteric hip fracture sidedness. Additionally, there was a 4.63 and 9.88 relative risk of tibial shaft fractures and distal radius fractures having a concomitant positive Throckmorton Sign, respectively. Conclusion Pelvic shadowing can be used as an additional diagnostic tool in predicting peri-trochanteric hip fracture sidedness in a trauma bay setting.