A. I. Kalfas

Unsteady Flow Physics and Performance of a One-and-1∕2-Stage Unshrouded High Work Turbine

This paper presents an experimental study of the flow mechanisms of tip leakage across a blade of an unshrouded turbine rotor. It shows the design of a new one-and-1/2-stage, unshrouded turbine configuration, which has been developed within the Turbomachinery Laboratory of ETH Zurich. This test case is a model of a high work (Δh/u 2 = 2.36) axial turbine. The experimental investigation comprises data from unsteady and steady probe measurements, which has been acquired around all the bladerows of the one-and-1/2-stage, unshrouded turbine. A newly developed 2-sensor Fast Response Aerodynamic Probe (FRAP) technique has been used in the current measurement campaign. The paper contains a detailed analysis of the unsteady interaction between rotor and stator blade rows, with particular attention paid on the flow in the blade tip region. It has been found that the interaction of the rotor and the downstream stator has an influence on the development of the tip leakage vortex of the rotor. The vortex is modulated by the stator profiles and shows variation in size and relative position to the rotor trailing edge when it stretches around the stator leading edge. Thereby a deflection of the tip leakage vortex has been observed, which expresses in a varying circumferential distance between two neighboring vortices of ±20% of a rotor pitch. Furthermore, a significant influence of quasi-stationary secondary flow features of the upstream stator row on the secondary flow of the rotor has been detected. The geometry and flow field data of the one-and-1/2-stage turbine will be available to the turbomachinery community for validation and improvement of numerical tools.

Blade Row Interaction in a High Pressure Turbine

This paper presents a study of the three-dimensional e owe eld within the blade rows of a single-stage highpressure axial turbine (low-speed, large-scale ). Measurements have been performed in the stationary and rotating frames of reference. Time-mean data have been obtained using e ve-hole pneumatic probes. The transport mechanisms of the stator wake and passage vortices through the rotor blade row have been studied using smoke e ow visualization. Furthermore, unsteady measurements have been carried out using a three-axis hot wire. Steady and unsteady numerical simulations have been performed using a structured three-dimensional Navier ‐Stokes solver to further understand the blade-row interactions. The transport of the stator viscous e ow through the rotor blade-row is described. The rotor passage vortices are affected by the transport of the stator secondary e ow. It is observed that the stator secondary e ow vortices are convected through the downstream rotor blade-row in a similar but not identical way to the wake. At the hub the kinematic interaction between the stator and the rotor passage vorticeshas two effects. First,thesuction sideleg of the statorpassagevortex isdisplaced radially upwards over the developing rotor passage vortex at the hub. Additionally, the pressure side leg of the stator passage vortex is entrained into the rotor passage vortex. The predicted e owe eld was interrogated from the perspective of loss production. The contribution of the unsteady e ow to the stage loss has been evaluated using unsteady numerical simulations. The effect of stator viscous e ow transport on the rotor e ow angles is also discussed in brief. Finally, a kinematic model is proposed for the transport of the secondary-e ow vortices in the downstream blade-row based on the understanding obtained from the measurements and numerical simulations.

Blade Row Interaction in a High-Pressure Steam Turbine

This paper presents a study of the three-dimensional flow field within the blade rows of a high-pressure axial flow steam turbine stage. Compound lean angles have been employed to achieve relatively low blade loading for hub and tip sections and so reduce the secondary losses. The flow field is investigated in a Low-Speed Research Turbine using pneumatic and hot-wire probes downstream of the blade row. Steady and unsteady numerical simulations were performed using structured 3D Navier-Stokes solver to further understand the flow field. Agreement between the simulations and the measurements has been found. The unsteady measurements indicate that there is a significant effect of the stator flow interaction in the downstream rotor blade. The transport of the stator viscous flow through the rotor blade row is described. Unsteady numerical simulations were found to be successful in predicting accurately the flow near the secondary flow interaction regions compared to steady simulations. A method to calculate the unsteady loss generated inside the blade row was developed from the unsteady numerical simulations. The contribution of various regions in the blade to the unsteady loss generation was evaluated. This method can assist the designer in identifying and optimizing the features of the flow that are responsible for the majority of the unsteady loss production. An analytical model was developed to quantify this effect for the vortex transport inside the downstream blade.Copyright

Turbulence Measurements and Analysis in a Multistage Axial Turbine

This paper presents turbulence measurements and detailed flow analysis in an axial turbine stage. Fast response aerodynamic probes were used to resolve aperiodic fluctuations along the three directions. Assuming incompressible flow, the effective turbulence level and Reynolds stress are retrieved by evaluating the stochastic velocity component out of the measured time-resolved pressure and flow angle fluctuations along the streamwise, radial, and circumferential direction. A comparison between turbulence intensity and measured total pressure shows that flow structures with higher turbulence level are identified in the region of loss cores at the exit of the second stator passage. Turbulence intensity is evaluated under isotropic and nonisotropic assumption in order to quantify the departure from isotropic conditions. The measurements show that locally the streamwise fluctuating component can be twice bigger than the radial and tangential component. The current analysis shows that multisensor fast response aerodynamic probes can be used to provide information about the mean turbulence levels in the flow and the Reynolds stress tensor, in addition to the measurements of unsteady total pressure loss.

A Fully Integrated Approach to Component Zooming Using Computational Fluid Dynamics

Background . This study focuses on a simulation strategy that will allow the performance characteristics of an isolated gas turbine engine component, resolved from a detailed, high-fidelity analysis, to be transferred to an engine system analysis carried out at a lower level of resolution. This work will enable component-level, complex physical processes to be captured and analyzed in the context of the whole engine performance, at an affordable computing resource and time. Approach . The technique described in this paper utilizes an object-oriented, zero-dimensional (0D) gas turbine modeling and performance simulation system and a high-fidelity, three-dimensional (3D) computational fluid dynamics (CFD) component model. The work investigates relative changes in the simulated engine performance after coupling the 3D CFD component to the 0D engine analysis system. For the purposes of this preliminary investigation, the high-fidelity component communicates with the lower fidelity cycle via an iterative, semi-manual process for the determination of the correct operating point. This technique has the potential to become fully automated, can be applied to all engine components, and does not involve the generation of a component characteristic map. Results . This paper demonstrates the potentials of the “fully integrated” approach to component zooming by using a 3D CFD intake model of a high bypass ratio turbofan as a case study. The CFD model is based on the geometry of the intake of the CFM56-5B2 engine. The high-fidelity model can fully define the characteristic of the intake at several operating condition and is subsequently used in the 0D cycle analysis to provide a more accurate, physics-based estimate of intake performance (i.e., pressure recovery) and hence, engine performance, replacing the default, empirical values. A detailed comparison between the baseline engine performance (empirical pressure recovery) and the engine performance obtained after using the coupled, high-fidelity component is presented in this paper. The analysis carried out by this study demonstrates relative changes in the simulated engine performance larger than 1%. Conclusions . This investigation proves the value of the simulation strategy followed in this paper and completely justifies (i) the extra computational effort required for a more automatic link between the high-fidelity component and the 0D cycle, and (ii) the extra time and effort that is usually required to create and run a 3D CFD engine component, especially in those cases where more accurate, high-fidelity engine performance simulation is required.

Unsteady Flow Interactions Within the Inlet Cavity of a Turbine Rotor Tip Labyrinth Seal

This paper focuses on the flow within the inlet cavity of a turbine rotor tip labyrinth seal of a two stage axial research turbine. Highly resolved, steady and unsteady three-dimensional flow data are presented. The probes used here are a miniature five-hole probe of 0.9 mm head diameter and the novel virtual four sensor fast response aerodynamic probe (FRAP) with a head diameter of 0.84 mm. The cavity flow itself is not only a loss producing area due to mixing and vortex stretching, it also adversely affects the following rotor passage through the fluid that is spilled into the main flow. The associated fluctuating mass flow has a relatively low total pressure and results in a negative incidence to the rotor tip blade profile section. The dominating kinematic flow feature in the region between cavity and main flow is a toroidal vortex, which is swirling at high circumferential velocity. It is fed by strong shear and end wall fluid from the pressure side of the stator passage. The static pressure field interaction between the moving rotor leading edges and the stator trailing edges is one driving force of the cavity flow. It forces the toroidal vortex to be stretched in space and time. A comprehensive flow model including the drivers of this toroidal vortex is proposed. This labyrinth seal configuration results in about 1.6% turbine efficiency reduction. This is the first in a series of papers focusing on turbine loss mechanisms in shrouded axial turbines. Additional measurements have been made with variations in seal clearance gap. Initial indications show that variation in the gap has a major effect on flow structures and turbine loss.

Effects of Labyrinth Seal Variation on Multistage Axial Turbine Flow

The need to increase overall turbine efficiency is always a driving force for redesigning a turbine stage. In particular, the labyrinth leakage flows in the endwall regions contribute to an increase of the overall loss generation. In order to asses this mechanism, a detailed study of the effects of labyrinth seal geometry variation on the blade performance is presented. Two different shroud seal geometries have been experimentally investigated in a two stage low speed turbine facility. The seal geometries differ in the size and shape of the re-entry cavity. The baseline seal is designed with a large rectangular re-entry cavity volume in order to dissipate the kinetic energy of the accelerated leakage flow after the seal gap. The re-entry cavity volume of the alternative seal design is reduced in size and a spline shaped contour is added to the endwall using annular inserts. This modification alters the gas path of the leakage jet and changes the incidence angles on the downstream blade rows. The measurements are performed with state of the art pneumatic and fast response pressure probes at various planes within the turbine stage. It is found that the inserts improved the flow profile uniformity at the endwalls. The measurements within the stator passage reveal the origin of the tip passage vortex formation at the blade suction side, already at the inlet to the stator passage. This result does not conform to the classical secondary flow theory, which suggests that the passage vortex migrates from the pressure to the suction side within the stator passage. The origin and formation of the secondary flow passage vortices at rotor hub and stator tip is described in a flow schematic. The generation of streamwise and tangential vorticity at the interaction area of leakage and main flow field also is studied and discussed. The measured overall polytropic turbine efficiency for the second seal configuration, relative to the baseline case, is reduced by 0.3%. The change in the re-entry flow angle of the leakage gas path reduces the negative incidence angle on the rotor hub and increases it at the stator tip leading edge. The secondary flow and mixing loss is reduced at the hub and increased at the tip in the second test case with the smaller cavity volume. Hence, the combination of small clearances and inserts in the re-entry cavities shows no beneficial effect on the overall turbine efficiency.Copyright

EVA: A Tool for Environmental Assessment of Novel Propulsion Cycles

This paper presents the development of a tool for EnVironmental Assessment (EVA) of novel propulsion cycles implementing the Technoeconomical Environmental and Risk Analysis (TERA) approach. For nearly 3 decades emissions certification and legislation has been mainly focused on the landing and take-off cycle. Exhaust emissions measurements of NOx, CO and unburned hydrocarbons are taken at Sea Level Static (SLS) conditions for 4 different power settings (idle, descent, approach and take-off) and are consecutively used for calculating the total emissions during the ICAO landing and take-off cycle. With the global warming issue becoming ever more important, stringent emissions legislation is soon to follow, focusing on all flight phases of an aircraft. Unfortunately, emissions measurements at altitude are either extremely expensive, as in the case of altitude test facility measurements, or unrealistic, as in the case of direct in flight measurements. Compensating for these difficulties, various existing methods can be used to estimate emissions at altitude from ground measurements. Such methods, however, are of limited help when it comes to assessing novel propulsion cycles or existing engine configurations with no SLS measurements available. The authors are proposing a simple and fast method for the calculation of SLS emissions, mainly implementing ICAO exhaust emissions data, corrections for combustor inlet conditions and technology factors. With the SLS emissions estimated, existing methods may be implemented to calculate emissions at altitude. The tool developed couples emissions predictions and environmental models together with engine and aircraft performance models in order to estimate the total emissions and Global Warming Potential of novel engine designs during all flight phases (i.e. the whole flight cycle). The engine performance module stands in the center of all information exchange. In this study, EVA and the described emissions prediction methodology have been used for the preliminary design analysis of three spool high bypass ratio turbofan engines. The capability of EVA to radically explore the design space available in novel engine configurations, while accounting for fuel burn and global warming potential during the whole flight cycle of an aircraft, is illustrated.

Vortex-Wake-Blade Interaction in a Shrouded Axial Turbine

This paper presents time-resolved flow field measurements at the exit of the first rotor blade row of a two stage shrouded axial turbine. The observed unsteady interaction mechanism between the secondary flow vortices, the rotor wake and the adjacent blading at the exit plane of the first turbine stage is of prime interest and analyzed in detail. The results indicate that the unsteady secondary flows are primarily dominated by the rotor hub passage vortex and the shed secondary flow field from the upstream stator blade row. The analysis of the results revealed a roll-up mechanism of the rotor wake layer into the rotor indigenous passage vortex close to the hub endwall. This interesting mechanism is described in a flow schematic within this paper. In a second measurement campaign the first stator blade row is clocked by half a blade pitch relative to the second stator in order to shift the relative position of both stator indigenous secondary flow fields. The comparison of the time-resolved data for both clocking cases showed a surprising result. The steady flow profiles for both cases are nearly identical. The analysis of the probe pressure signal indicates a high level of unsteadiness that is due to the periodic occurrence of the shed first stator secondary flow field.

Fluid Dynamics and Performance of Partially and Fully Shrouded Axial Turbines

A unique comparative experimental and numerical investigation carried out on two test cases with shroud configurations, differing only in the labyrinth seal path, is presented in this paper. The blade geometry and tip clearance are identical in the two test cases. The geometries under investigation are representative of an axial turbine with a full and partial shroud, respectively. Global performance and flow field data were acquired and analysed. Computational simulations were carried out to complement the investigation and to facilitate the analysis of the steady and unsteady flow measurements. A detailed comparison between the two test cases is presented in terms of flow field analysis and performance evaluation. The analysis focuses on the flow effects reflected on the overall performance in a multi-stage environment. Strong interaction between the cavity flow and the blade tip region of the rotor blades is observed up to the blade midspan. A marked effect of this interaction can be seen in the downstream second stator where different vortex structures are observed. Moreover, in the partial shroud test case, a strong tip leakage vortex is developed from the first rotor and transported through the downstream blade row. A measurable change in the second stage efficiency was observed between the two test cases. In low aspect ratio blades within a multi-stage environment, small changes in the cavity geometry can have a significant effect on the mainstream flow. The present analysis has shown that an integrated and matched blade-shroud aerodynamic design has to be adopted to reach optimal performances. The additional losses resulting from small variations of the sealing geometry could result in a gain of up to one point in the overall stage efficiency.