A. Roger D. Thornton

Neural Correlates of Perceptual Learning in the Auditory Brainstem: Efferent Activity Predicts and Reflects Improvement at a Speech-in-Noise Discrimination Task

An extensive corticofugal system extends from the auditory cortex toward subcortical nuclei along the auditory pathway. Corticofugal influences reach even into the inner ear via the efferents of the olivocochlear bundle, the medial branch of which modulates preneural sound amplification gain. This corticofugal system is thought to contribute to neuroplasticity underlying auditory perceptual learning. In the present study, we investigated the involvement of the medial olivocochlear bundle (MOCB) in perceptual learning as a result of auditory training. MOCB activity was monitored in normal-hearing adult listeners during a 5 d training regimen on a consonant–vowel phoneme-in-noise discrimination task. The results show significant group learning, with great inter-individual variability in initial performance and improvement. As observed in previous auditory training studies, poor initial performers tended to show greater learning. Strikingly, MOCB activity measured on the first training day strongly predicted the subsequent amount of improvement, such that weaker initial MOCB activity was associated with greater improvement. Moreover, in listeners that improved significantly, an increase in MOCB activity was observed after training. Thus, as discrimination thresholds of listeners converged over the course of training, differences in MOCB activity between listeners decreased. Additional analysis showed that MOCB activity did not explain variation in performance between listeners on any training day but rather reflected an individual listeners performance relative to their personal optimal range. The findings suggest an MOCB-mediated listening strategy that facilitates speech-in-noise perception. The operation of this strategy is flexible and susceptible to training, presumably because of task-related adaptation of descending control from the cortex.

Effect of subject task on contralateral suppression of click evoked otoacoustic emissions

Contralateral suppression of click evoked otoacoustic emissions (CEOAEs) is widely used as a non-invasive measure of the activity of the (uncrossed) medial olivocochlear bundle (MOCB). There is evidence that the uMOCB receives descending input from the cortex, potentially mediating top-down control during higher order processing. This study investigated whether the contralateral suppression measure is affected by top-down influences during different tasks performed by the participants during recording. Suppression of CEOAEs evoked at 50 and 60dB SPL was measured under four different task conditions: (1) no task; (2) passive visual (watching a silent subtitled DVD); (3) active visual (responding to visually presented sums); (4) active auditory (detecting tone pips embedded in the evoking click train). The most significant effect of task was found on the recording noise, with both the passive visual and the active auditory task producing significantly lower noise levels than the no task condition. In the passive visual task, this was associated with a reduced inter-subject variability, which enhanced the effect size relative to the no task condition. A main effect of subject task was also found on the change in CEOAE I/O slope due to contralateral noise. This effect reflected a significantly smaller suppression during the active auditory task compared to the no task condition, leading to a reduced effect size. No significant difference in suppression strength between the no task condition and the two non-auditory tasks was observed, suggesting that the main effect of task reflects a specific effect of auditory attention. The data suggest that MOCB activity is inhibited due to top-down influences when selective attention is focussed on the ipsilateral ear.

The order of testing effect in otoacoustic emissions and its consequences for sex and ear differences in neonates

The amplitude values of transient-evoked otoacoustic emissions, recorded from a large sample of neonates, were used to examine the asymmetry between ears tested and the differences due to the sex of the subject. Whilst the sex difference, with females having larger responses than males, has been a consistent finding in previous reports, the right/left ear difference, with the right ear giving a larger response than the left, has produced variable results that differed between laboratories. In this study, the sex difference was confirmed with females giving a 1.2 dB greater response than males. It was not affected by the age of the neonate. A significant effect of test order was found. The measured right/left difference was enhanced when the right ear was tested first but was diminished when the left ear was tested first. If the left ear is tested first then the measured right/left difference would be about 0.5 dB whereas, if the right ear is tested first, the measured right/left difference would be about 1.5 dB. When male/female comparisons were made for right and left ears separately and for the same ear tested first, the sex differences were the same for all four conditions. The sex and right/left differences have been confirmed as statistically significant effects and the order effect could explain the discrepancies and variability of the right/left differences reported in the literature.

Selective attention increases the temporal precision of the auditory N100 event-related potential.

Selective attention increases the amplitude of the averaged N100 event-related potential (ERP). This increase may result from more neurons responding to the stimulus or from the same number of neurons better synchronised with the stimulus, or both. We investigated the synchronization mechanism using a new response latency jitter measurement algorithm that performed well for all the signal-to-noise ratios obtained in the experiment. We found that the significantly increased N100 amplitude is accounted for by a significantly decreased latency jitter variance for the attended stimuli.

The use of high stimulus rate auditory brainstem responses in the estimation of hearing threshold.

This normative study investigates the efficiency of using the maximum length sequence (MLS) technique applied to auditory brainstem evoked response (ABR) testing to estimate hearing thresholds. Using a commercially available system, ABRs were recorded in sixteen subjects at two conventional rates--9.1 and 33.3 clicks/s--and six MLS rates between 88.8 and 1000 clicks/s. Each subject was tested at five stimulus levels from 60 down to 10 dBnHL. The wave JV amplitude input-output (I/O) functions, relative signal to noise ratio (SNR) and speed of test were calculated for all conditions. The JV amplitude and detectability decrease as the stimulus rate increases and level decreases. The latency of JV increases as the stimulus rate increases and the intensity decreases. While the slope of the amplitude I/O function was maximal at 200 clicks/s, at 300 clicks/s it was comparable with that obtained at conventional rates. At higher rates, the slope of the I/O function decreases. When compared with the conventional recording rate of 33.3 clicks/s there is a small improvement in SNR for MLS rates between 200 and 600 clicks/s at levels above 30 dBnHL. The calculated speed improvement at 300 clicks/s is a factor between 1.4 to 1.6 at a screening level of 30-40 dBnHL. It is felt therefore that there may be a small advantage to using MLS in screening and that the optimal rate for this lies at around 200 to 300 clicks/s. However even at these rates, as a consequence of the adaptation of the response with both rate and level, the improvement in SNR or speed of test would be modest when estimating threshold.

Methodological factors involved in neonatal screening using transient-evoked otoacoustic emissions and automated auditory brainstem response testing.

The methodological factors involved in screening neonates for hearing loss, using transient-evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) and automated auditory brainstem responses, have been evaluated from a large sample of neonates. The risk factors, commonly used to select babies for a targeted screen, have very little correlation with failing TEOAE testing. The parameters used to determine passing or failing the TEOAE test and the false alarm rate change markedly with age in the first few days of life as, of course, did the percentage of babies who failed the test. The stimulus level used was the default setting for the Otodynamics equipment but the stimulus level measured in the ear canal decreased over the first 140 h of life. It is thought that this reflects the impedance changes in outer and middle ears and possible changes in middle ear dynamics. The methodological variables investigated here can illuminate some of the differences in previous reports of neonatal screening, in particular the reported hit and false alarm rates.

Evaluation of a technique to measure latency jitter in event-related potentials.

Auditory selective attention results in larger event-related potentials (ERPs) than those recorded to unattended stimuli. Larger ERPs arise from either a greater number of neurons being stimulated or the same number of neurons with better synchrony. The synchrony aspect was studied in an attention experiment recording the N1 response and showed that the latency jitter was significantly less (p=0.002) for the responses to attended stimuli compared with those to unattended stimuli. Here the improved technique to measure latency jitter is the focus of study. Simulated responses were used to evaluate the techniques performance at different signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) and compare it to the standard technique. Checks that the technique had performed satisfactorily in each case were achieved and a measure of reliability for each result was developed. The parameters defining the technique were varied and the optimum values chosen. This new technique opens the way for researchers to investigate the latency properties of lower SNR ERPs and gives a new insight into auditory selective attention.

Comparison of transient evoked otoacoustic emission thresholds recorded conventionally and using maximum length sequences

Presenting clicks according to maximum length sequences (MLSs) enables transient evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) to be recorded at very high stimulation rates. Despite a decrease in TEOAE amplitude, the very large number of responses obtainable at high rates means that both signal to noise ratio (SNR) and detection sensitivity increase as the click rate increases. This study characterises conventional and MLS TEOAEs near threshold for a group of normally hearing adults. Stimulus presentation rates of 40 clicks/s (conventional) and 5000 clicks/s (MLS) were used. Compared to conventional recordings, the MLS technique enabled smaller responses to be detected, when averaged for the same time and to the same SNR. TEOAE amplitude recorded at detection threshold for MLS responses was 13 dB lower than that recorded conventionally. For each individual, MLS recording also produced clear, repeatable responses at stimulus levels below the detection threshold for conventional TEOAEs. The click level at TEOAE threshold was 12 dB lower for MLS compared to conventional emissions. These results suggest that TEOAE thresholds are not absolute but strongly related to the detection sensitivity of the recording system and physiological noise. The initial growth rates and the shape of input/output functions were found to be similar for the two recording techniques.

Effects of Maturation on Parameters Used for Pass/Fail Criteria in Neonatal Hearing Screening Programmes Using Evoked Otoacoustic Emissions

We aimed to investigate the incidence of false alarms that occurred with the pass/fail criteria used in a published series of neonatal hearing screening programmes, as a function of age. We analysed the database of 19137 normally hearing babies (38274 ears) tested in the Wessex Universal Neonatal Hearing Screening Project. Otoacoustic emissions were recorded prior to discharge from maternity units, using IL088 equipment. We assessed the pass/fail rate using the Wessex criteria and 10 other pass/fail criteria published in the literature. Using Pearson’s correlation coefficient, a statistically significant correlation between signal-to-noise ratio at each of the frequency bands 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 kHz and babies’ age in hours at the 0.01 level was identified. The correlation was also significant (0.01 level) between age and frequency reproducibility in each of the bands at 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 kHz as well as the whole reproducibility. The number of false alarms reduced significantly after the first 24 h of life with all the criteria examined. We conclude that in the first hours after birth due to insufficient maturation of the otoacoustic emission, there is a high rate of false alarms. This increase in the false alarm rate, whilst dependent on the criteria used, occurs with all criteria. This leads to the consideration of whether the establishment of age-dependent pass/fail criteria could reduce the false alarm rate and the subsequent strain on diagnostic centres.

The interaction between ear and sex differences and stimulus rate

Evoked otoacoustic emissions (EOAEs) are produced by the cochlea in response to acoustic stimuli and provide an objective and non-invasive measure of cochlear function. A new technique, based on maximum length sequences (MLSs), enables stimulus rates of up to 5000 clicks/s to be used. Conventional EOAE amplitude differs between ears and sexes, female subjects having responses of greater amplitude than male subjects and right ears larger responses than left ears. As a prerequisite to clinical use it is necessary to establish if these differences occur with the MLS OAE technique and whether they change with stimulus rate. Eighty ears of normally hearing adults between the ages of 18 and 40 years were tested. MLS OAEs were recorded at eight stimulus rates ranging from 40/s to 5000/s. Two stimulus levels and two recordings were made at each stimulus rate. Female subjects were found to have statistically significantly larger MLS OAEs than male subjects and gave larger amplitude responses in the right ears. The difference was not significant between male right and left ears. A rate effect was also demonstrated with the amplitude of the MLS OAEs decreasing with an increase in rate. The study provides normative data for MLS OAE testing and shows that females have MLS OAEs of larger amplitude than males and that as the click stimulus rate increases the significance of this difference decreases. Female right ears also have MLS OAEs of greater amplitude than female left ears.