A Soriani

Psychopathology, Temperament, and Past Course in Primary Major Depressions. 2. Toward a Redefinition of Bipolarity with a New Semistructured Interview for Depression

We report on the utility of a new instrument to identify subtypes of major depressive episodes with special reference to pseudo-unipolar conditions. By incorporating reliable measures of depressive and hyperthymic temperamental characteristics in subtype definitions, we achieve the sharpest possible demarcation between unipolar and bipolar disorders. The new procedures also reveal that 1 out of 3 primary depressives in a consecutive series of 405 patients belong to the bipolar spectrum. Furthermore, among bipolars, bipolar II disorder (redefined as major depressions with hypomania or hyperthymic temperament) represents the most common variant. We discuss the nosologic, therapeutic, methodologic and theoretical implications of these considerations on the unipolar-bipolar dichotomy. Given that major depression emerges as the final common clinical expression of a heterogeneous group of disorders, it underscores the importance of focusing on temperament and course of illness in subclassification efforts such as attempted here.

Single episode of major depressive disorder : first episode of recurrent mood disorder or distinct subtype of late-onset depression ?

SummaryOf 687 consecutive inpatients and outpatients with primary major depressive illness, 213 (31%) were categorized as single episode (SE) by DSM-III-R criteria. Systematic evaluation of familial, sociodemographic, temperamental and symptomatological characteristics permitted the nearly equal division of SE into two categories: a. early-onset (<45 years) “first episode” superimposed on either depressive or hyperthymic temperaments (against a bipolar and unipolar familial background), more severe depression, higher rates of suicide attempts, greater anxiety-somatization and psychotic tendencies, and with the potential for recurrence; b. late-onset (≥45 years) isolated episode (against an unipolar familial background) with greater life stressors, pursuing a protracted course with less likelihood of recurrence. In most other respects, early-onset SE was intermediate between recurrent major depression and lateonset SE. The implications of these findings for the now largely abandoned category of “involutional melancholia” are discussed.