A. W. Hood

Kink instability of solar coronal loops as the cause of solar flares

Solar coronal loops are observed to be remarkably stable structures. A magnetohydrodynamic stability analysis of a model loop by the energy method suggests that the main reason for stability is the fact that the ends of the loop are anchored in the dense photosphere. In addition to such line-tying, the effect of a radial pressure gradient is incorporated in the analysis.Two-ribbon flares follow the eruption of an active region filament, which may lie along a magnetic flux tube. It is suggested that the eruption is caused by the kink instability, which sets in when the amount of magnetic twist in the flux tube exceeds a critical value. This value depends on the aspect ratio of the loop, the ratio of the plasma to magnetic pressure and the detailed transverse magnetic structure. For a force-free field of uniform twist the critical twist is 3.3π, and for other fields it is typically between 2π and 6π. Occasionally active region loops may become unstable and give rise to small loop flares, which may also be a result of the kink instability.

Emergence of magnetic flux from the convection zone into the corona

Numerical experiments of the emergence of magnetic flux from the uppermost layers of the solar interior to the photosphere and its further eruption into the low atmosphere and corona are carried out. We use idealized models for the initial stratification and magnetic field distribution below the photosphere similar to those used for multidimensional flux emergence experiments in the literature. The energy equation is adiabatic except for the inclusion of ohmic and viscous dissipation terms, which, however, become important only at interfaces and reconnection sites. Three-dimensional experiments for the eruption of magnetic flux both into an unmagnetized corona and into a corona with a preexisting ambient horizontal field are presented. The shocks preceding the rising plasma present the classical structure of nonlinear Lamb waves. The expansion of the matter when rising into the atmosphere takes place preferentially in the horizontal directions: a flattened (or oval) low plasma-β ball ensues, in which the field lines describe loops in the corona with increasing inclination away from the vertical as one goes toward the sides of the structure. Magnetograms and velocity field distributions on horizontal planes are presented simultaneously for the solar interior and various levels in the atmosphere. Since the background pressure and density drop over many orders of magnitude with increasing height, the adiabatic expansion of the rising plasma yields very low temperatures. To avoid this, the entropy of the rising fluid elements should be increased to the high values of the original atmosphere via heating mechanisms not included in the present numerical experiments. The eruption of magnetic flux into a corona with a preexisting magnetic field pointing in the horizontal direction yields a clear case of essentially three-dimensional reconnection when the upcoming and ambient field systems come into contact. The coronal ambient field is chosen at time t = 0 perpendicular to the direction of the tube axis and thus, given the twist of the magnetic tube, almost anti-parallel to the field lines at the upper boundary of the rising plasma ball. A thin, dome-shaped current layer is formed at the interface between the two flux systems, in which ohmic dissipation and heating are taking place. The reconnection proceeds by merging successive layers on both sides of the reconnection site; however, this occurs not only at the cusp of the interface, but, also, gradually along its sides in the direction transverse to the ambient magnetic field. The topology of the magnetic field in the atmosphere is thereby modified: the reconnected field lines typically are part of the flanks of the tube below the photosphere but then join the ambient field system in the corona and reach the boundaries of the domain as horizontal field lines.

A twisted flux-tube model for solar prominences. I. General properties

It is proposed that a solar prominence consists of cool plasma supported in a large-scale curved and twisted magnetic flux tube. As long as the flux tube is untwisted, its curvature is concave toward the solar surface, and so it cannot support dense plasma against gravity. However, when it is twisted sufficiently, individual field lines may acquire a convex curvature near their summits and so provide support. Cool plasma then naturally tends to accumulate in such field line dips either by injection from below or by thermal condensation. As the tube is twisted up further or reconnection takes place below the prominence, one finds a transition from normal to inverse polarity. When the flux tube becomes too long or is twisted too much, it loses stability and its true magnetic geometry as an erupting prominence is revealed more clearly. 56 refs.

The Three-dimensional Interaction between Emerging Magnetic Flux and a Large-Scale Coronal Field: Reconnection, Current Sheets, and Jets

Using MHD numerical experiments in three dimensions, we study the emergence of a bipolar magnetic region from the solar interior into a model corona containing a large-scale, horizontal magnetic field. An arch-shaped concentrated current sheet is formed at the interface between the rising magnetized plasma and the ambient coronal field. Three-dimensional reconnection takes place along the current sheet, so that the corona and the photosphere become magnetically connected, a process repeatedly observed in recent satellite missions. We show the structure and evolution of the current sheet and how it changes in time from a simple tangential discontinuity to a rotational discontinuity with no null surface. We find clear indications that individual reconnection events in this three-dimensional environment in the advanced stage are not one-off events, but instead take place in a continuous fashion, with each field line changing connectivity during a finite time interval. We also show that many individual field lines of the rising tube undergo multiple processes of reconnection at different points in the corona, thus creating photospheric pockets for the coronal field. We calculate global measures for the amount of subphotospheric flux that becomes linked to the corona during the experiment and find that most of the original subphotospheric flux becomes connected to coronal field lines. The ejection of plasma from the reconnection site gives rise to high-speed and high-temperature jets. The acceleration mechanism for those jets is akin to that found in previous two-dimensional models, but the geometry of the jets bears a clear three-dimensional imprint, having a curved-sheet appearance with a sharp interface to the overlying coronal magnetic field system. Temperatures and velocities of the jets in the simulations are commensurate with those measured in soft X-rays by the Yohkoh satellite.

3D simulations identifying the effects of varying the twist and field strength of an emerging flux tube

Aims. We investigate the effects of varying the magnetic field strength and the twist of a flux tube as it rises through the solar interior and emerges into the atmosphere. Methods. Using a 3D numerical MHD code, we consider a simple stratified model, comprising of one solar interior layer and three overlying atmospheric layers. We set a horizontal, twisted flux tube in the lowest layer. The specific balance of forces chosen results in the tube being fully buoyant and the temperature is decreased in the ends of the tube to encourage the formation of an Ω-shape along the tube’s length. We vary the magnetic field strength and twist independently of each other so as to give clear results of the individual effects of each parameter. Results. We find a self-similar evolution in the rise and emergence of the flux tube when the magnetic field strength of the tube is modified. During the rise through the solar interior, the height of the crest and axis, the velocity of the crest and axis, and the decrease in the magnetic field strength of the axis of the tube are directly dependent upon the initial magnetic field strength given to the tube. No such self-similarity is evident when the twist of the flux tube is changed, due to the complex interaction of the tension force on the rise of the tube. For low magnetic field strength and twist values, we find that the tube cannot fully emerge into the atmosphere once it reaches the top of the interior since the buoyancy instability criterion cannot be fulfilled. For those tubes that do advance into the atmosphere, when the magnetic field strength has been modified, we find further self-similar behaviour in the amount of tube flux transported into the atmosphere. For the tubes that do emerge, the variation in the twist results in the buoyancy instability, and subsequent emergence, occurring at different locations along the tube’s length.

Magnetic instability of coronal arcades as the origin of two-ribbon flares

The generally accepted scenario for the events leading up to a two-ribbon flare is that a magnetic arcade (supporting a plage filament) responds to the slow photospheric motions of its footpoints by evolving passively through a series of (largely) force-free equilibria. At some critical amount of shear the configuration becomes unstable and erupts outwards. Subsequently, the field closes back down in the manner modelled by Kopp and Pneuman (1976); but the main problem has been to explain the eruptive instability.The present paper analyses the magnetohydrodynamic stability of several possible arcade configurations, including the dominant stabilizing effect of line-tying at the photospheric footpoints. One low-lying force-free structure is found to be stable regardless of the shear; also some of the arcades that lie on the upper branch of the equilibrium curves are shown to be stable. However, another force-free configuration appears more likely to represent the preflare structure. It consists of a large flux tube, anchored at its ends and surrounded by an arcade, so that the field transverse to the arcade axis contains a magnetic island. Such a configuration is found to become unstable when either the length of the structure, the twist of the flux tube, or the height of the island becomes too great; the higher the tube is situated, the smaller is the twist required for instability.

Heating the corona by nanoflares: simulations of energy release triggered by a kink instability

Context. The heating of solar coronal plasma to millions of degrees is likely to be due to the superposition of many small energy-releasing events, known as nanoflares. Nanoflares dissipate magnetic energy through magnetic reconnection. Aims. A model has been recently proposed in which nanoflare-like heating naturally arises, with a sequence of dissipation events of various magnitudes. It is proposed that heating is triggered by the onset of ideal instability, with energy release occurring in the nonlinear phase due to fast magnetic reconnection. The aim is to use numerical simulations to investigate this heating process. Methods. Three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic numerical simulations of energy release are presented for a cylindrical coronal loop model. Initial equilibrium magnetic-field profiles are chosen to be linearly unstable, with a two-layer parameterisation of the current profile. The results are compared with calculations of linear instability, with line-tying, which are extended to account for a potential field layer surrounding the loop. The energy release is also compared with predictions that the field relaxes to a state of minimum magnetic energy with conserved magnetic helicity (a constant a force-free field). Results. The loop initially develops a helical kink, whose structure and growth rate are generally in accordance with linear stability theory, and subsequently a current sheet forms. During this phase, there is a burst of kinetic energy while the magnetic energy decays. A new relaxed equilibrium is established that corresponds quite closely to a constant a field. The fraction of stored magnetic energy released depends strongly on the initial current profile, which agrees with the predictions of relaxation theory. Conclusions. Energy dissipation events in a coronal loop are triggered by the onset of ideal kink instability. Magnetic energy is dissipated, leading to large or small heating events according to the initial current profile.

The damping of slow MHD waves in solar coronal magnetic fields - II. The effect of gravitational stratification and field line divergence

This paper continues the study of De Moortel & Hood ([CITE]) into the propagation of slow MHD waves in the solar corona. Firstly, the damping due to optically thin radiation is investigated and compared to the effect of thermal conduction. In a second stage, gravitational stratification is included in the model and it is found that this increases the damping length significantly. Finally, the effect of different magnetic field geometries on the damping of the slow waves is investigated. As a first approximation, a purely radial magnetic field is considered and although the amplitudes of the perturbations decrease due to the divergence of the field, the effect is small compared to the effect of thermal conduction. A more realistic local geometry, estimated from the observations, is investigated and it is demonstrated that a general area divergence can cause a significant, additional, decrease of the amplitudes of the perturbations. The results of numerical simulations, incorporating the effects of gravitational stratification, the magnetic field geometry and thermal conduction are compared with TRACE observations of propagating waves in coronal loops. It is found that a combination of thermal conduction and (general) area divergence yields detection lengths that are in good agreement with observed values.

The Effect of the Relative Orientation between the Coronal Field and New Emerging Flux. I. Global Properties

The emergence of magnetic flux from the convection zone into the corona is an important process for the dynamical evolution of the coronal magnetic field. In this paper we extend our previous numerical investigations, by looking at the process of flux interaction as an initially twisted flux tube emerges into a plane-parallel, coronal magnetic field. Significant differences are found in the dynamical appearance and evolution of the emergence process depending on the relative orientation between the rising flux system and any preexisting coronal field. When the flux systems are nearly antiparallel, the experiments show substantial reconnection and demonstrate clear signatures of a high-temperature plasma located in the high-velocity outflow regions extending from the reconnection region. However, the cases that have a more parallel orientation of the flux systems show very limited reconnection and none of the associated features. Despite the very different amount of reconnection between the two flux systems, it is found that the emerging flux that is still connected to the original tube reaches the same height as a function of time. As a compensation for the loss of tube flux, a clear difference is found in the extent of the emerging loop in the direction perpendicular to the main axis of the initial flux tube. Increasing amounts of magnetic reconnection decrease the volume, which confines the remaining tube flux.

Formation of Ellerman bombs due to 3D flux emergence

Aims. We investigate the emergence of a “sea-serpent” magnetic field into the outer solar atmosphere and the connection between undulating fieldlines and formation of Ellerman bombs. Methods. We perform 3D numerical experiments solving the time-dependent and resistive MHD equations. Results. A sub-photospheric magnetic flux sheet develops undulations due to the Parker instability. It rises from the convectively unstable sub-photospheric layer and emerges into the highly stratified atmosphere through successive reconnection events along the undulating system. Brightenings with the characteristics of Ellerman bombs are produced due to reconnection, which occurs during the emergence of the field. At an advanced stage of the evolution of the system, the resistive emergence leads to the formation of long, arch-like magnetic fields that expand into the corona. The enhancement of the magnetic field at the low atmosphere and episodes of emergence of new magnetic flux are also discussed.