Achour Amiri

Phenotypic Characterization of Multifungicide Resistance in Botrytis cinerea Isolates from Strawberry Fields in Florida

Chemical control has always been essential for the management of gray mold, caused by Botrytis cinerea, to ensure sustainable strawberry production. However, lack of knowledge about actual resistance development may have disastrous consequences and lead to severe epidemics such as the one that affected several strawberry fields in 2012 in Florida. In this study, we tested 392 isolates collected from Florida strawberry fields between 2010 and 2012 for their sensitivity to boscalid (Bosc), a succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SdhI); pyraclostrobin, a quinone outside inhibitor (QoI); boscalid + pyraclostrobin (Pristine); fenhexamid, a hydroxyanilide (Hyd); pyrimethanil and cyprodinil, anilinopyrimidines; fludioxonil, a phenylpyrrole; and fludioxonil + cyprodinil (Switch). The respective resistance frequencies for boscalid, pyraclostrobin, Pristine, fenhexamid, cyprodinil, and pyrimethanil were 85.4, 86.5, 86.0, 44.4, 52.7, and 59.5%. Overall, 17.8 and 19.8% of isolates showed reduced sensitivity to fludioxonil and Switch, respectively. All fungicides sprayed preventively on detached strawberry fruit failed to control isolates with high levels of resistance to each fungicide except for fludioxonil and Switch. Four phenotypes with multifungicide resistance (MFR) were detected in B. cinerea populations from Florida. Isolates resistant to one fungicide (FR1), two (MFR2), three (MFR3), and four (MFR4) fungicides from different chemical groups represented 5.9, 28.6, 41.8, and 23.7% of the total resistant population, respectively. The MFR3 isolates were predominant and contained two subpopulations, the Bosc-QoI-APR isolates (56.5%) and the Bosc-QoI-HydR isolates (40.6%). In addition to reporting on very highly resistant populations to boscalid and QoI fungicides, we show evidence for a widespread multifungicide resistance to B. cinerea that warrants immediate implementation of novel management strategies to impede the development of more resistant populations.

Reduced sensitivity in Monilinia fructicola field isolates from South Carolina and Georgia to respiration inhibitor fungicides.

Quinone outside inhibitor (QoI) and succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SdhI) fungicides are respiration inhibitors (RIs) used for preharvest control of brown rot of stone fruit. Both chemical classes are site-specific and, thus, prone to resistance development. Between 2006 and 2008, 157 isolates of Monilinia fructicola collected from multiple peach and nectarine orchards with or without RI spray history in South Carolina and Georgia were characterized based upon conidial germination and mycelial growth inhibition for their sensitivity to QoI fungicides azoxystrobin and pyraclostrobin, SdhI fungicide boscalid, and a mixture of pyraclostrobin + boscalid. There was no significant difference (P = 0.05) between EC50 values for inhibition of conidial germination versus mycelial growth. The mean EC50 values based upon mycelial growth tests for 25 isolates from an orchard without RI-spray history were 0.15, 0.06, 2.23, and 0.09 μg/ml for azoxystrobin, pyraclostrobin, boscalid, and pyraclostrobin + boscalid, respectively. The respective mean EC50 values for 76 isolates from RI-sprayed orchards in South Carolina were 0.9, 0.1, 10.7, and 0.13 μg/ml and for 56 isolates from RI-sprayed orchards in Georgia were 1.2, 0.1, 8.91, and 0.17 μg/ml. Overall, mean EC50 values of populations from RI-sprayed orchards increased three-, two-, five-, and twofold between 2006 and 2008 for azoxystrobin, pyraclostrobin, boscalid, and pyraclostrobin + boscalid, respectively. A subset of 10 M. fructicola isolates representing low and high EC50 values for azoxystrobin, boscalid, and boscalid + pyraclostrobin was selected for a detached fruit assay to determine disease incidence and severity following protective treatments of formulated RI fungicides at label rates. Brown rot incidence was greater than 50% when fruit were inoculated with isolates having EC50 values of 2, 4, and 0.6 μg/ml for azoxystrobin, boscalid, and pyraclostrobin + boscalid, respectively. Pyraclostrobin failed to control any of the isolates tested in detached fruit assays. Based on minimum inhibitory concentration and brown rot incidence data, we recommend using 3 and 0.75 μg/ml as discriminatory doses to distinguish between sensitive isolates and those with reduced sensitivity to azoxystrobin and pyraclostrobin + boscalid, respectively. Results from our in vitro and in vivo assays indicate a shift toward reduced sensitivity in M. fructicola from the southeastern United States. No cross-resistance was observed between the QoI and the SdhI fungicides, which implies that rotation or tank mixtures of these two chemical classes can be used as a resistance management strategy.

Resistance to Fluopyram, Fluxapyroxad, and Penthiopyrad in Botrytis cinerea from Strawberry

Succinate dehydrogenase inhibitors (SDHIs) constitute a mainstay in management of gray mold caused by Botrytis cinerea in strawberry and several other crops. In this study, we investigated the risks of resistance development to three newer SDHIs (i.e., fluopyram, fluxapyroxad, and penthiopyrad) and their cross-resistance with the previously registered boscalid. We investigated the mutations in the SdhB subunit and evaluated their impact on microbial fitness in field populations of B. cinerea. Amino acid substitutions associated with resistance to SDHIs were detected at three codons of the SdhB subunit (BH272R/Y/L, BP225F, and BN230I) in the succinate dehydrogenase gene of field isolates from Florida. The BH272R, BH272Y, BH272L, BP225F, and BN230I mutations were detected at frequencies of 51.5, 28.0, 0.5, 2.5, and 4%, respectively. Strong cross-resistance patterns were evident between boscalid and fluxapyroxad and penthiopyrad but not with fluopyram, except in BH272L, BP225F, and BN230I mutants. All five mutations conferred moderate to very high resistance to boscalid whereas the BH272Y conferred resistance to fluxapyroxad and penthiopyrad. The BH272L, BN230I, and BP225F mutations conferred high resistance to all four SDHIs tested. Resistance monitoring following the first use of penthiopyrad in strawberry fields in Florida in 2013 suggests potential for quick selection for highly resistant populations and warrants careful use of the newer SDHIs. No evidence of major fitness costs due to the mutations in the SdhB subunit was found, which indicates the potential ability of the mutants to survive and compete with wild-type isolates. Our study suggests high risks for rapid widespread occurrence of B. cinerea populations resistant to the novel SDHIs unless appropriate rotation strategies are implemented immediately upon registration.

Fungicide Resistance Profiles in Botrytis cinerea from Strawberry Fields of Seven Southern U.S. States

The sensitivity to seven chemical classes of fungicides was investigated in 1,810 Botrytis cinerea isolates collected from strawberry blossoms and fruit in 181 strawberry fields from seven southern states in the United States across 2 years. Ten isolates were examined from each field. Fungicide sensitivity assays were carried out based on visual assessment of diametrical mycelial growth after 4 days of incubation on media amended with discriminatory doses of fungicides in microtiter plates. Results of visual assessments were verified with selected isolates using a previously published germination assay and by inoculating representative isolates with resistant phenotypes on fungicide-sprayed fruit. The overall resistance frequencies of 750 isolates collected in 2012 for thiophanate-methyl, pyraclostrobin, boscalid, cyprodinil, fenhexamid, iprodione, and fludioxonil were 76, 42, 29, 27, 25, 3, and 1%, respectively. Frequencies of 1,060 isolates collected in 2013 were 85, 59, 5, 17, 26, 2, and 1%, respectively. Resistance to thiophanate-methyl and pyraclostrobin was found in virtually every location in both years, whereas resistance to iprodione and fludioxonil was rarely found. Resistant isolates were resistant to either one (23%), two (18%), three (19%), four (14%), five (3%), or six (0.1%) chemical classes of fungicides in 2012. In 2013, this distribution was 24, 29, 26, 8, 2, and 0.3%, respectively. Multifungicide-resistant isolates of B. cinerea were widespread in southern states and evidence suggests that the frequency of isolates with multifungicide resistance increased from 2012 to 2013. The data also show that fungicide resistance in B. cinerea was already present in blossoms, indicating that resistance management needs to be implemented early in the season.

Characterization of Iprodione Resistance in Botrytis cinerea from Strawberry and Blackberry

Gray mold, caused by the fungal pathogen Botrytis cinerea, is one of the most destructive diseases of strawberry. Control of the disease in commercial fields is largely dependent on the application of fungicides, including the dicarboximide iprodione. Single-spore isolates were collected from strawberry fields in Florida, North Carolina, and South Carolina and subjected to an assay using conidial germination that distinguished sensitive (S) isolates from isolates with various levels of resistance to iprodione. Of the 245 isolates, 1 was highly resistant (HR), 5 were moderately resistant (MR), and 43 had low resistance (LR) to iprodione. LR and MR strains were found in the Florida population and in 9 of 11 locations from North Carolina and South Carolina, indicating that resistance was widespread but accounted for only a relatively small percentage of the B. cinerea population. Sequence analysis of the target gene bos1, which codes for a class III histidine kinase, revealed that the MR phenotype was associated with Q369P and N373S mutations and that the LR phenotype was associated with either a I365S or a I365N mutation. The I365S and I365N mutations were also present in five additionally included HR isolates from North Carolina and South Carolina blackberry fields and one HR isolate from a Virginia strawberry field but no mutation or mutation combinations in bos1 were uniquely associated with the HR phenotype. Expression analysis of bos1 in S and HR isolates did not reveal convincing evidence of the genes involvement in HR resistance either. The six HR isolates had three different phenotypes with respect to their sensitivity to fludioxonil; two were S, two were LR, and two were MR. The fludioxonil LR and MR isolates were also resistant to tolnaftate, an indication of multidrug efflux pump activity. These data suggest that, in addition to point mutations in bos1, drug efflux pump activity and potentially a third mechanism of resistance may be contributing to the iprodione HR phenotype. Detached fruit studies showed that field rates of Rovral 4 Flowable (iprodione) did not control iprodione MR and HR isolates.

Evaluation of strategies for reducing patulin contamination of apple juice using a farm to fork risk assessment model

The numerous studies conducted so far on the issue of patulin contamination have focused mainly on aspects like growth of Penicillium expansum, patulin production under different conditions and the influence of processing on the patulin concentration in apple juice. The purpose of the present study was to collect the necessary information and to develop a quantitative risk assessment model (QRAM) in order to evaluate different strategies to reduce patulin contamination. For apple juice (AJ) production 3 types of apples are considered, namely fresh apples, apples stored under cold air (short term storage) and apples stored under controlled atmosphere (CA) (long term storage). The QRAM described the complete chain from the picking of apples until storage of produced AJ. In comparison to a traditional chemical analysis, the QRAM was found accurate in predicting the concentration of patulin in cloudy and clear AJs commercialised in Belgium. Simulation of the model demonstrated that the use of apples stored under CA contributes to a large extent to the patulin contamination of AJ. Since apples stored in CA are used from more or less January onwards, AJ with high patulin concentration can be produced from January onwards. It would be useful in this respect to take this into account when sampling plans are made by apple juice producers in the framework of their HACCP-system and by governments and control agencies when monitoring programmes are elaborated. The duration of deck storage between the delivery at the apple juice producer (AJP) and the processing of the apples had a large influence on the patulin concentration, and this effect was more pronounced for apples stored under controlled atmosphere compared to apples stored under cold air. The duration of the deck storage should therefore be considered as a Critical Control Point (CCP) within HACCP-systems. Also the application of a sorting step was evaluated to be efficient to reduce the high patulin concentration in AJ. Therefore, a combination of the 2 most effective measures (namely sorting out apples with an infection lesion larger than 10 cm(2) and a reduction of the volume of CA apples) was tested and resulted in a reduction to levels below 25 μg/kg in 99.7 to 99.9% of the clear and cloudy apple juices, respectively. It is therefore advisable to include a sorting step prior to processing, when apples stored in CA are used.

Laboratory Evaluation of Three Rapid, Agar-Based Assays to Assess Fungicide Sensitivity in Monilinia fructicola

Three rapid, agar-based assays were compared with a traditional petri dish method for assessing the sensitivity of Monilinia fructicola to propiconazole (0.3 and 2.0 μg/ml), thiophanate-methyl (1.0 and 50 μg/ml), and azoxystrobin (1.0 and 35 μg/ml) in the laboratory. The three assays were based on mycelial growth inhibition on agar disks sliced from lipbalm tubes filled with fungicide-amended potato dextrose agar (PDA), on PDA-coated cotton swabs, or in PDA-filled microcentrifuge tubes. Mycelial growth inhibition of eight previously characterized isolates (two resistant to propiconazole, two highly resistant to thiophanate-methyl, two with low levels of resistance to thiophanate-methyl, and two sensitive to all three fungicides) was determined visually 24, 48, and 72 h after inoculation. The 48-h time point was the earliest suitable time to collect data for all methods because insufficient growth was recorded in the petri dish and tube assays after 24 h. With the exception of the swab assay, all methods classified the isolates previously determined to be fungicide sensitive correctly (i.e., no fungal growth was observed for these isolates). For propiconazole-resistant isolates, the lipbalm assay resulted in levels of growth inhibition very similar to the petri dish method, whereas the swab assay and the tube assay overestimated and underestimated, respectively, the level of resistance. Both the lipbalm and the swab assays classified isolates correctly as being thiophanate-methyl resistant, and both were able to discriminate the isolates previously classified as having low versus high levels of resistance when treated with this fungicide at 50 μg/ml, as was the petri dish method. None of the eight isolates which previously were determined to be azoxystrobin sensitive grew on azoxystrobin-amended media, regardless of the assay type. Overall, the average percentage of correct isolate classifications (relative to their previously determined resistance status) on propiconazole- and thiophanate-methyl-amended media after 48 h ranged from 87.5 to 100, 85.3 to 100, 63.2 to 94.5, and 50.5 to 81.0% for the petri dish, lipbalm, swab, and tube assays, respectively. The lipbalm assay provided the most accurate assessments (85.3 to 100%) after only 24 h of incubation, supporting its use as a rapid and simple tool to monitor resistance levels in M. fructicola field populations.

A New Selective Medium for the Recovery and Enumeration of Monilinia fructicola, M. fructigena, and M. laxa from Stone Fruits

Isolation of Monilinia spp. from stone and pome fruit surfaces is difficult due to the presence of several fast-growing fungal species such as Rhizopus, Alternaria, and Penicillium spp. Therefore, a new selective medium (acidified potato dextrose agar [pH 3.6] amended with fosetyl-aluminum [fosetyl-AL] at 500 microg/ml) (APDA-F500) was developed for the recovery of Monilinia propagules. The antifungal agents fosetyl-Al, dichloran, ammonium molybdate, and 2-deoxy-D-glucose (2-dD-glucose) were tested in potato dextrose agar (PDA) for their selective activity against Monilinia fructicola and seven common fungal contaminants of peach, including Alternaria alternata, Aspergillus niger, Colletotrichum acutatum, Gilbertella persicaria, Penicillium expansum, Phomopsis amygdali, and Rhizopus stolonifer. Dichloran, ammonium molybdate, and 2-dD-glucose inhibited spore germination and mycelial growth of all test fungi, including M. fructicola, at comparable levels. Fosetyl-Al added to PDA (PDA-F) at 500 or 1,000 microg/ml did not inhibit germination of any of the fungi but had a strong effect on mycelial growth of six of eight test fungi at 1,000 microg/ml, with the exceptions being R. stolonifer and M. fructicola. Germination and mycelial growth of M. fructicola were least affected on APDA-F500 compared with the other test fungi. On APDA-F500 at pH 3.2 and 3.6, germination of M. fructicola was not inhibited but mycelial growth was reduced by 54.2 and 24.2%, respectively. In all, 17 M. fructicola, 6 M. fructigena, and 6 M. laxa isolates collected from different geographic locations and diverse hosts were evaluated for their germination and mycelial growth on APDA-F500 (at pH 3.6). Germination was not inhibited for any isolate and relative mycelial growth was 45.8 to 83.3%. Field-grown peach fruit from South Carolina and Hungary and plum fruit from Hungary were used to test the selectivity of APDA-F500 for the recovery of three Monilinia spp. compared with PDA-F500 and Monilinia selective medium (MSM) previously developed for Monilinia spp. detection. Percent recovery of M. fructicola from South Carolinian peach fruit was highest on APDA-F500 (0, 17, and 69% in June, July, and August, respectively) compared with PDA-F500 (0, 3.5, and 50%, respectively) and MSM (0, 0, and 6.8%, respectively). Moreover, APDA-F500 selectively recovered M. fructigena and M. laxa propagules from the surfaces of Hungarian peach and plum fruit. Our results indicate that APDA-F500 is a useful medium for selective isolation and enumeration of the three most common Monilinia spp. attacking stone fruits worldwide.

Diversity in the erg27 Gene of Botrytis cinerea Field Isolates from Strawberry Defines Different Levels of Resistance to the Hydroxyanilide Fenhexamid

The hydroxyanilide (Hyd) fenhexamid has played a major role in gray mold management in Florida strawberry fields since 2000. Recent monitoring of the sensitivity of Botrytis cinerea to fenhexamid indicated that resistance has emerged. In this study, mutations in the target gene erg27 encoding the 3-keto reductase enzyme were investigated and the shift in fenhexamid sensitivity over time was evaluated in 630 isolates collected between 2005 and 2013 from locations sprayed with different spray programs. Overall, 227, 155, 48, and 200 isolates were sensitive (HydS), had reduced sensitivity (HydR2), or were moderately (HydR3-) and highly (HydR3+) resistant, respectively. Analysis of complete sequences of the erg27 gene from 70 isolates revealed seven and five mutations and one deletion in the HydR3- and HydR3+ isolates, respectively, at eight and five different codons, respectively. In addition to the three mutations (F412S, -I, and -V) reported previously at codon 412, two new mutations from glycine to arginine at codon 170 (G170R, two isolates) and from alanine to glycine at codon 210 (A210G, eight isolates) were detected for the first time in HydR3+ isolates from Florida. These isolates were not controlled on detached fruit sprayed with the recommended field rate of fenhexamid, whereas all HydS, HydR2, and HydR3- isolates were controlled on detached fruit. Overall, there was no clear correlation between the spray frequency of fenhexamid and the frequency of resistant phenotypes. This study provides an overview of the current distribution of erg27 genotypes in Florida and will serve as a baseline for future studies on shifts in population diversity and resistance. The frequency of fenhexamid-resistant populations has increased progressively in different strawberry fields but has not reached a plateau yet, indicating that the effective life of fenhexamid could be extended if appropriate rotation and management strategies are implemented. Sensitivity to other sterol biosynthesis inhibitors is discussed.

First Report on Resistance to Pyraclostrobin, Thiophanate-methyl, Fenhexamid and Boscalid in Botrytis cinerea from Eucalyptus Seedlings in Florida Greenhouses

Botryotinia fuckeliana de Bary (anamorph Botrytis cinerea Pers.) is an ubiquitous plant pathogen causing gray mold disease on more than 200 crops grown in the field or in greenhouses. Eucalyptus seedlings originating from three different greenhouses showing stem lesions were submitted to the Gulf Coast Research and Education Center Disease Clinic in June 2012. Ten single spore isolates of B. cinerea were obtained and tested for sensitivity using spore germination and germ tube elongation assays described previously (4). Fungicides tested were pyraclostrobin at 100 μg/ml (Cabrio, BASF, Research Triangle Park, NC), thiophanate-methyl at 100 μg/ml (Topsin-M, UPI, King of Prussia, PA), fenhexamid at 1 and 50 μg/ml (Elevate, Arysta Life Sciences, Cary, NC), fludioxonil at 0.1 and 10 μg/ml (Medallion, Syngenta Crop Protection, Research Triangle Park, NC), and iprodione at 5 and 50 μg/ml (Rovral, Bayer CropScience, Greensboro, NC) on 1% malt extract agar (MEA, 10 g malt extract and 15 g agar), and to cyprodinil at 1 and 25 μg/ml (Vanguard, Syngenta Crop Protection) on 0.5% sucrose agar (4). Sensitivity to the succinate dehydrogenase inhibitors (SDHIs) boscalid at 5 μg/ml (Endura, BASF), penthiopyrad at 1 and 3 μg/ml (Fontelis, DuPont Crop Protection, Willington, DE), and fluopyram at 3 μg/ml (Luna Privilege, Bayer CropScience) was evaluated on yeast bacto acetate agar (YBA) (3). The discriminatory dose for boscalid was adapted from (2) whereas those used for penthiopyrad and fluopyram were developed in this study. Isolates were grown on malt yeast extract agar for 7 to 10 days and spore suspensions were prepared in sterile distilled water and diluted to 106 conidia/ml. Respective media in 9-cm petri dishes were seeded with 7-μl droplets from each isolate allowing testing for all isolates on one plate. Two plates were used for each fungicide and sensitivity tests were repeated twice. Germination and germ tube growth were assessed microscopically after 16 to 24 h incubation at 22°C. The frequency of isolates resistant to two, three, and four fungicides was 90, 60, and 10%, respectively. Nine isolates (90%) were resistant to thiophanate-methyl and pyraclostrobin, simultaneously, whereas six (60%) and two isolates (20%) were resistant to boscalid and fenhexamid, respectively. All boscalid-resistant isolates were also resistant to pyraclostrobin and thiophanate-methyl, but one fenhexamid-resistant isolate was sensitive to the other three fungicides. Eight isolates that germinated at 5 μg/ml iprodione but not at 50 μg/ml were considered sensitive. All isolates were sensitive to the SDHIs penthiopyrad and fluopyram as well as to cyprodinil and fludioxonil. To our knowledge, this is the first report of resistance to pyraclostrobin, thiophanate-methyl, fenhexamid, and boscalid in B. cinerea from eucalyptus seedlings in Florida. The absence of resistance to fludioxonil and iprodione is likely because these fungicides are not registered in nurseries as well as fluopyram and penthiopyrad which were developed only recently. Management practices should be developed to limit the selection and spread of additional resistant populations in eucalyptus nurseries as has occurred in Florida strawberries where multi-fungicide resistance is widespread (1). References: (1) A. Amiri et al. Plant Dis. 97:393, 2013. (2) M. Leroch et al. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 79:159, 2013. (3) G. Stammler and J. Speakman. J. Phytopathol. 154:508, 2006. (4) R. W. S. Weber and M. Hahn. J. Plant Dis. Prot. 118:17, 2011.