Adriana Cardozo

The natural history of multiple system atrophy: a prospective European cohort study

Summary Background Multiple system atrophy (MSA) is a fatal and still poorly understood degenerative movement disorder that is characterised by autonomic failure, cerebellar ataxia, and parkinsonism in various combinations. Here we present the final analysis of a prospective multicentre study by the European MSA Study Group to investigate the natural history of MSA. Methods Patients with a clinical diagnosis of MSA were recruited and followed up clinically for 2 years. Vital status was ascertained 2 years after study completion. Disease progression was assessed using the unified MSA rating scale (UMSARS), a disease-specific questionnaire that enables the semiquantitative rating of autonomic and motor impairment in patients with MSA. Additional rating methods were applied to grade global disease severity, autonomic symptoms, and quality of life. Survival was calculated using a Kaplan-Meier analysis and predictors were identified in a Cox regression model. Group differences were analysed by parametric tests and non-parametric tests as appropriate. Sample size estimates were calculated using a paired two-group t test. Findings 141 patients with moderately severe disease fulfilled the consensus criteria for MSA. Mean age at symptom onset was 56·2 (SD 8·4) years. Median survival from symptom onset as determined by Kaplan-Meier analysis was 9·8 years (95% CI 8·1–11·4). The parkinsonian variant of MSA (hazard ratio [HR] 2·08, 95% CI 1·09–3·97; p=0·026) and incomplete bladder emptying (HR 2·10, 1·02–4·30; p=0·044) predicted shorter survival. 24-month progression rates of UMSARS activities of daily living, motor examination, and total scores were 49% (9·4 [SD 5·9]), 74% (12·9 [8·5]), and 57% (21·9 [11·9]), respectively, relative to baseline scores. Autonomic symptom scores progressed throughout the follow-up. Shorter symptom duration at baseline (OR 0·68, 0·5–0·9; p=0·006) and absent levodopa response (OR 3·4, 1·1–10·2; p=0·03) predicted rapid UMSARS progression. Sample size estimation showed that an interventional trial with 258 patients (129 per group) would be able to detect a 30% effect size in 1-year UMSARS motor examination decline rates at 80% power. Interpretation Our prospective dataset provides new insights into the evolution of MSA based on a follow-up period that exceeds that of previous studies. It also represents a useful resource for patient counselling and planning of multicentre trials. Funding Fifth Framework Programme of the European Union, the Oesterreichische Nationalbank, and the Austrian Science Fund.

Presentation, diagnosis, and management of multiple system atrophy in Europe: Final analysis of the European multiple system atrophy registry†

Multiple system atrophy (MSA) is a Parkinsons Disease (PD)‐like α‐synucleinopathy clinically characterized by dysautonomia, parkinsonism, cerebellar ataxia, and pyramidal signs in any combination. We aimed to determine whether the clinical presentation of MSA as well as diagnostic and therapeutic strategies differ across Europe and Israel. In 19 European MSA Study Group centres all consecutive patients with a clinical diagnosis of MSA were recruited from 2001 to 2005. A standardized minimal data set was obtained from all patients. Four‐hundred thirty‐seven MSA patients from 19 centres in 10 countries were included. Mean age at onset was 57.8 years; mean disease duration at inclusion was 5.8 years. According to the consensus criteria 68% were classified as parkinsonian type (MSA‐P) and 32% as cerebellar type (MSA‐C) (probable MSA: 72%, possible MSA: 28%). Symptomatic dysautonomia was present in almost all patients, and urinary dysfunction (83%) more common than symptomatic orthostatic hypotension (75%). Cerebellar ataxia was present in 64%, and parkinsonism in 87%, of all cases. No significant differences in the clinical presentation were observed between the participating countries. In contrast, diagnostic work up and therapeutic strategies were heterogeneous. Less than a third of patients with documented orthostatic hypotension or neurogenic bladder disturbance were receiving treatment. This largest clinical series of MSA patients reported so far shows that the disease presents uniformly across Europe. The observed differences in diagnostic and therapeutic management including lack of therapy for dysautonomia emphasize the need for future guidelines in these areas.

Red Flags for Multiple System Atrophy

The clinical diagnosis of multiple system atrophy (MSA) is fraught with difficulty and there are no pathognomonic features to discriminate the parkinsonian variant (MSA‐P) from Parkinsons disease (PD). Besides the poor response to levodopa, and the additional presence of pyramidal or cerebellar signs (ataxia) or autonomic failure as major diagnostic criteria, certain other clinical features known as “red flags” or warning signs may raise the clinical suspicion of MSA. To study the diagnostic role of these features in MSA‐P versus PD patients, a standardized red flag check list (RFCL) developed by the European MSA Study Group (EMSA‐SG) was administered to 57 patients with probable MSA‐P and 116 patients with probable PD diagnosed according to established criteria. Those red flags with a specifity over 95% were selected for further analysis. Factor analysis was applied to reduce the number of red flags. The resulting set was then applied to 17 patients with possible MSA‐P who on follow‐up fulfilled criteria of probable MSA‐P. Red flags were grouped into related categories. With two or more of six red flag categories present specificity was 98.3% and sensitivity was 84.2% in our cohort. When applying these criteria to patients with possible MSA‐P, 76.5% of them would have been correctly diagnosed as probable MSA‐P 15.9 (±7.0) months earlier than with the Consensus criteria alone. We propose a combination of two out of six red flag categories as additional diagnostic criteria for probable MSA‐P.

Progression of multiple system atrophy (MSA): A prospective natural history study by the European MSA study group (EMSA SG)

The disease‐specific Unified Multiple System Atrophy Rating Scale (UMSARS) has been developed recently and validated for assessing disease severity in multiple system atrophy (MSA). Here, we aimed at (1) assessing rates of disease progression in MSA and (2) validating UMSARS for sensitivity to change over time. Impairment was assessed at two time points 12 months apart using UMSARS Part I (historical review), UMSARS Part II (motor examination), as well as measures of global disease severity, including UMSARS Part IV, Hoehn and Yahr (HY) Parkinsons disease staging, Schwab England Activities of Daily Living (SE ADL), and a three‐point global Severity Scale (SS3). Fifty patients (male:female ratio, 1:0.9; possible MSA, 16%; probable MSA, 84%; MSA‐parkinsonian, 58%; MSA‐cerebellar, 42%) were assessed twice with an interval of 12.3 months. UMSARS II scores progressed by 57.3% (P < 0.0001) and UMSARS I scores by 35.6% (P < 0.0001) in relation to the respective baseline scores with no differences between motor subtypes, diagnostic categories and gender. Significant inverse correlations between (1) UMSARS I or UMSARS II progression and (2) baseline disability measures (i.e., the respective UMSARS or SS3 scores) and disease duration were found. Furthermore, the increases in HY staging, SE ADL and SS3 correlated significantly with UMSARS I, UMSARS II, and UMSARS IV progression. This report is the first prospective study showing rapid annual UMSARS rates of decline in MSA. Our data contribute to the ongoing validation process of UMSARS, and they facilitate the planning and implementation of future neuroprotective intervention trials.

G2019S LRRK2 mutation causing Parkinson’s disease without Lewy bodies

The G2019S leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 gene (LRRK2) mutation has been identified in a significant proportion of familial and sporadic cases of Parkinson’s disease (PD). Until now, information on the neuropathological changes associated with the G2019S LRRK2 mutation has been sparse. We report a 77-year-old patient who presented with a 14 year history of PD but, unexpectedly, histopathological examination disclosed mild neuronal loss in the substantia nigra without α-synuclein, tau or ubiquitin cytoplasmic inclusions. A G2019S LRRK2 mutation was eventually detected. The present case confirms that clinical PD caused by G2019S mutations can be associated with non-specific nigral degeneration without Lewy bodies.

The European Multiple System Atrophy-Study Group (EMSA-SG)

Summary.Introduction. The European Multiple System Atrophy-Study Group (EMSA-SG) is an academic network comprising 23 centers across Europe and Israel that has constituted itself already in January 1999. This international forum of established experts under the guidance of the University Hospital of Innsbruck as coordinating center is supported by the 5th framework program of the European Union since March 2001 (QLK6-CT-2000-00661). Objectives. Primary goals of the network include (1) a central Registry for European multiple system atrophy (MSA) patients, (2) a decentralized DNA Bank, (3) the development and validation of the novel Unified MSA Rating Scale (UMSARS), (4) the conduction of a Natural History Study (NHS), and (5) the planning or implementation of interventional therapeutic trials. Methods. The EMSA-SG Registry is a computerized data bank localized at the coordinating centre in Innsbruck collecting diagnostic and therapeutic data of MSA patients. Blood samples of patients and controls are recruited into the DNA Bank. The UMSARS is a novel specific rating instrument that has been developed and validated by the EMSA-SG. The NHS comprises assessments of basic anthropometric data as well as a range of scales including the UMSARS, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS), measures of global disability, Red Flag list, MMSE (Mini Mental State Examination), quality of live measures, i.e. EuroQoL 5D (EQ-5D) and Medical Outcome Study Short Form (SF-36) as well as the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). In a subgroup of patients dysautonomic features are recorded in detail using the Queen Square Cardiovascular Autonomic Function Test Battery, the Composite Autonomic Symptom Scale (COMPASS) and measurements of residual urinary volume. Most of these measures are repeated at 6-monthly follow up visits for a total study period of 24 months. Surrogate markers of the disease progression are identified by the EMSA-SG using magnetic resonance and diffusion weighted imaging (MRI and DWI, respectively). Results. 412 patients have been recruited into the Registry so far. Probable MSA-P was the most common diagnosis (49% of cases). 507 patients donated DNA for research. 131 patients have been recruited into the NHS. There was a rapid deterioration of the motor disorder (in particular akinesia) by 26.1% of the UMSARS II, and – to a lesser degree – of activities of daily living by 16.8% of the UMSARS I in relation to the respective baseline scores. Motor progression was associated with low motor or global disability as well as low akinesia or cerebellar subscores at baseline. Mental function did not deteriorate during this short follow up period. Conclusion. For the first time, prospective data concerning disease progression are available. Such data about the natural history and prognosis of MSA as well as surrogate markers of disease process allow planning and implementation of multi-centre phase II/III neuroprotective intervention trials within the next years more effectively. Indeed, a trial on growth hormone in MSA has just been completed, and another on minocycline will be completed by the end of this year.

Safety and tolerability of growth hormone therapy in multiple system atrophy: A double-blind, placebo-controlled study

The objective of this study was to investigate tolerability and possible neurotrophic effects of growth hormone (GH) in treatment of multiple system atrophy (MSA). In this double‐blind pilot study, MSA patients were randomized to recombinant human growth hormone (r‐hGH, n = 22), 1 mg every second day (6 months) followed by alternating daily injections of 1 mg and 0.5 mg (6 months), or matched placebo (n = 21). Safety analysis demonstrated no obvious between‐group differences. In both groups, there was progressive worsening of Unified Parkinsons Disease Rating Scale total score, which tended to be less in r‐hGH‐treated patients (12.9% at 6 months, 25.3% at 12 months) than in placebo (17.0% and 35.7%). Similarly, there was a trend to less worsening in Unified MSA Rating Scale total score with r‐hGH (13.2% and 21.2%) than with placebo (21.1% and 36.5%). Cardiovascular reflex autonomic testing also tended to show less deterioration with r‐hGH than with placebo at 12 months. However, 95% CI did not indicate treatment differences for any efficacy measures. In conclusion, r‐hGH administration in MSA patients for up to 1 year appears safe and might influence disease symptoms, signs and, possibly, progression. The results support further studies utilizing higher doses in more patients.

Screening for the LRRK2 G2019S and codon-1441 mutations in a pathological series of parkinsonian syndromes and frontotemporal lobar degeneration

BACKGROUND The neuropathology associated with LRRK2 mutations is heterogeneous but Lewy body (LB) type pathology is the most common substrate encountered. While the prevalence of LRRK2 mutations has been extensively studied in Parkinsons disease (PD), limited information is available on the frequency of LRRK2 mutations in dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) and in other pathological conditions associated with these mutations, such as non-specific nigral degeneration without LB, tau-immunopositive neurofibrillary tangle pathology, and ubiquitin-positive neuronal inclusions resembling those observed in a subtype of frontotemporal lobar degeneration (FTLD-U). OBJECTIVE To further investigate the neuropathology associated with LRRK2 mutations. METHODS We have screened for the LRRK2 G2019S and codon-1441 (R1441G/C/H) mutations in 110 cases from a Spanish Brain Bank, which include: 66 synucleinopathies (33 PD, 25 DLB and 8 multiple system atrophy cases), 29 tauopathies (21 progressive supranuclear palsy, 3 corticobasal degeneration and 5 tau-positive FTLD cases), 3 cases of non-specific nigral degeneration and 12 tau-negative FTLD (9 FTLD-U and 3 dementia lacking distinctive histology cases). RESULTS The G2019S mutation was found in two cases: One case had a clinical and pathological diagnosis of PD and the other suffered from typical PD and on neuropathological examination had non-specific nigral degeneration without LB. A synonymous variant (R1441R; c.4323C>T) was detected in another PD case. CONCLUSIONS In this brain bank-based series, LRRK2 G2019S mutation occurred in patients with parkinsonism associated with either typical brainstem LB pathology or non-specific nigral degeneration. LRRK2 mutations were not encountered in other neurodegenerative disorders associated with synuclein and tau deposition.

Intranuclear inclusions, neuronal loss and CAG mosaicism in two patients with Machado-Joseph disease

UNLABELLED The presence of neuronal intranuclear inclusions (NIIs) and neuronal mosaicism has been described in some autosomal dominant spinocerebellar ataxias (SCA), but their implication in neurodegenerative mechanisms still remains unclear. OBJECTIVE To investigate the correlation between neuronal loss and NIIs, and the size of CAG triplet expansion in selected areas of the CNS in two SCA3 patients. MATERIAL AND METHODS Postmortem neuropathological study was carried out, and the regional distribution of neuronal loss was compared with NIIs. CAG expansion was analysed by PCR amplification in the same regions. RESULTS Marked neuronal loss was seen in the anterior horn of the spinal cord, pontine nuclei and motor nuclei of the brain stem. Moderate neurone loss was found in the locus ceruleus, colliculus and substantia nigra. Loss of granule and Purkinje cells was found in the cerebellum, mainly in the vermis. NIIs were present in neurones of the involved nuclei of the anterior horn of the spinal cord, medulla oblongata and pons, but not in the locus ceruleus, substantia nigra and cerebellum. A few NIIs were found in the striatum. The number of CAG repeats was 27/70 in the first patient and 21/74 in the second patient. The variation of the expanded allele size among different cerebral areas was +/-1-3 CAG repeats. CONCLUSION The partial correlation between neuronal loss and NIIs suggests that other factors distinct from NII formation may be involved in the neuronal death. Moreover, the low degree of mosaicism between regions without neuronal loss and regions with marked neuronal loss points to the existence of selective cellular vulnerability to the genetic defect.

Unclassifiable parkinsonism in two European tertiary referral centres for movement disorders

In view of reports on high frequencies of atypical parkinsonism from different parts of the world and in non‐white communities in the United Kingdom, we have prospectively surveyed 1,000 consecutive patients with parkinsonism presenting to two European tertiary referral centres for movement disorders (London, UK, and Barcelona, Spain). The aims of our study were to assess in a cross‐sectional, prospective manner the proportion of patients who could not be classified diagnostically, to identify the factors precluding classification, and to determine which diagnostic measures would increase the rate of classifiable cases. Diagnoses were established using published clinical diagnostic criteria for Parkinsons disease (PD) and for other conditions associated with parkinsonism. Twenty‐nine patients in London and 25 in Barcelona were initially considered unclassifiable; nine could be classified after further investigations. Levodopa (L‐dopa) responsiveness was found to have a pivotal role in establishing a clinical diagnosis in previously unclassifiable patients: In those 45 patients who remained unclassifiable, failure to respond to L‐dopa without other exclusion criteria for PD was the most common finding in each centre. Our results show that 4.0 to 5.0% of parkinsonian patients presenting to specialist clinics in Western Europe cannot be categorised using currently available clinical diagnostic criteria for parkinsonian syndromes. Prolonged follow‐up and neuropathological diagnosis will be needed to determine whether all these cases represent atypical presentations of established clinico‐pathological entities or whether some represent unrecognised new disorders.