Agnès Lacreuse

Estradiol, but not raloxifene, improves aspects of spatial working memory in aged ovariectomized rhesus monkeys

Estrogen replacement therapy (ERT) alleviates many postmenopausal symptoms but whether it also benefits cognitive function remains controversial. Further, since estrogen increases the risk of breast and uterine cancers, a new class of compounds, called selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) is being considered as possible alternative to ERT. The SERM raloxifene is particularly interesting because, like estrogen, it improves lipid metabolism and reduces bone loss, without adverse effects on the breast or uterus. Little is known, however, about its effect upon cognitive function. We used a rhesus monkey model of human menopause to examine the effects of ERT and raloxifene on cognitive function. We tested 5 aged females (21-24 years old) ovariectomized long-term (10-16 years) on a battery of age-sensitive tasks, including the Delayed Response (DR), the Delayed Non-Matching-to-Sample-10 min (DNMS-10 min) and the spatial-Delayed Recognition Span Test (DRST). Monkeys were tested 5 days a week on each task for 9 consecutive months, while undergoing treatments with placebo, ethinyl estradiol (EE(2)), and raloxifene in alternating 28-days blocks. EE(2) transiently enhanced the working memory component of the spatial-DRST, but did not affect performance on the other tasks of the battery. Raloxifene had no effect on cognitive performance. These findings indicate that estradiol is able to enhance some aspects of spatial working memory in aged monkeys despite many years of estrogenic deprivation. Further, they suggest that raloxifene does not affect cognitive function after long-term ovarian hormone deprivation.

Effects of ovarian hormones on cognitive function in nonhuman primates

Several studies have suggested that estrogen benefits verbal memory and lowers the risk of Alzheimers disease in women, and improves cognitive function in animal models. However, the negative outcome of the Womens Health Initiative Memory Study has challenged the rationale for using estrogen as a protective agent against age-related cognitive decline. In view of the limitations of the Womens Health Initiative Memory Study, it is clear that our understanding of estrogen effects would greatly benefit from further interactions between clinical and basic science. Animal models of menopause can provide crucial information regarding the consequences of estrogen loss and replacement on several systems, including cognition. In this paper, I review the evidence that nonhuman primates, who share numerous cognitive and physiological characteristics with humans, can substantially contribute to our understanding of estrogen influences on the brain and cognition. Studies in young adult females suggest that some aspects of cognition fluctuate with the menstrual cycle, but that ovariectomy and estrogen replacement have only modest effects on cognitive function. In contrast, data in aged, naturally or surgically menopausal monkeys indicate that estrogen modulates a broad range of cognitive domains. Neurobiological data are consistent with the cognitive findings and demonstrate an array of morphological and physiological changes in brain areas important for cognition following ovariectomy and/or estrogen replacement. It is concluded that nonhuman primates, by providing a bridge between rodent and human data, constitute invaluable models to further our understanding of hormonal actions on the brain and cognition and to develop effective hormonal interventions against brain and cognitive aging.

Fluctuations in spatial recognition memory across the menstrual cycle in female rhesus monkeys.

Findings are inconsistent regarding whether womens cognitive performance fluctuates across phases of the menstrual cycle, but differences in methodology and the use of reported cycle phase rather than precise hormonal measures may underlie these disparities. Studies in monkeys may help resolve these discrepant findings, since hormonal status can be reliably determined. We tested four young (5-7 years old) female rhesus monkeys daily during one entire menstrual cycle on three cognitive tasks displayed on a computerized touch-screen system: a Matching to Sample task with a 30 s delay (MTS-30s), a Matching to Sample task without delay (MTS-no delay) and the spatial condition of the Delayed Recognition Span Test (spatial-DRST). Blood samples were collected at specific time intervals throughout the cycle and assayed for estradiol and progesterone in order to identify hormonal status. There was a nonsignificant trend for the MTS-30s scores to be better during the follicular and luteal phases, when estradiol levels were low, than during the peri-ovulatory phase, when estradiol levels were at their highest. MTS-no delay performance did not vary as a function of hormonal status. Spatial-DRST scores were significantly better during the follicular and luteal phases than during the peri-ovulatory phase of the cycle. These data in the female rhesus monkey support the hypothesis that spatial memory performance is sensitive to estradiol variations across the menstrual cycle, with better performance associated with low estradiol levels.

Depletion of Ovarian Follicles with Age in Chimpanzees: Similarities to Humans

Abstract We retrieved ovarian sections taken from necropsies of 19 captive chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) aged 0–47 yr, counted the number of primordial follicles in each, and compared the rate of decline in numbers to declines previously documented in humans. The follicular depletion rate in this sample was indistinguishable from that shown across the same ages in classic human data sets. This result supports earlier suggestions that ovarian senescence occurs at the same ages in chimpanzees and humans, implying that the influence of declining ovarian function on other physiologic systems may be distinctively buffered in humans.

Spatial cognition in rhesus monkeys: male superiority declines with age.

Twelve young (4-7 years of age) and 14 old (20-27 years of age) male and female rhesus monkeys were tested on seven cognitive tasks. Males and females performed similarly on tasks of object memory and executive function, but young males outperformed young females on a spatial memory task (Delayed Recognition Span Test) that requires the identification of a new stimulus among an increasing array of serially presented stimuli. This superior level of spatial ability in young males declined sharply with age, so that old males did not perform significantly better than old females. These findings in the nonhuman primate suggest that biological rather than sociocultural factors underlie the sex differences in cognition and their diminution with age.

Sex, Age, and Training Modulate Spatial Memory in the Rhesus Monkey (Macaca mulatta)

The authors tested 90 rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) on a task of spatial memory, the spatial Delayed Recognition Span Test. The results showed that performance declined significantly with age, males had greater scores than females, and the rate of apparent decline with age was greater in males than in females. Both working and reference memory declined with age, but only working memory showed sex differences. The authors compared these data with that of 22 monkeys who were trained on a simpler version of the task before formal testing. Training had no effect on males but dramatically improved working memory in young females. The results confirm a male advantage in spatial working memory at a young age and confirm a greater decline with age in males than in females. It is important to note that prior training completely reverses the deficits of young females.

Cognitive Function in Aged Ovariectomized Female Rhesus Monkeys

To determine whether ovariectomy exacerbates age-related cognitive decline, the performance of 6 aged monkeys that had been ovariectomized early in life (OVX-Aged) was compared to that of 8 age-matched controls with intact ovaries (INT-Aged) and that of 5 young controls with intact ovaries (INT-Young) in tasks of visual recognition memory, object and spatial memory, and executive function. The OVX-Aged monkeys were marginally more impaired than the INT-Aged monkeys on the delayed nonmatching-to-sample with a 600-s delay. In contrast, they performed significantly better than the INT-Aged controls on the spatial condition of the delayed recognition span test. The hypothesis that prolonged estrogenic deprivation may exaggerate the age-related decline in visual recognition memory will require additional support. However, the findings suggest that long-term ovariectomy may protect against the development with aging of spatial memory deficits.

Estradiol selectively affects processing of conspecifics' faces in female rhesus monkeys.

Estrogen deficiency following ovariectomy or menopause increases the risk of developing diseases such as osteoporosis and may also lead to memory impairment. Although estrogen replacement therapy (ERT) alleviates many symptoms associated with estrogen loss, it is not clear whether it also benefits cognitive function. The effect of estrogens upon cognition can best be studied in an animal model of human menopause, in which estrogen levels can be experimentally manipulated. Six young ovariectomized female rhesus monkeys (6-9 years old) were tested on a battery of touchscreen-based cognitive tasks, including the Matching-to-Sample (MTS) task with mixed delays and the spatial, object, and face conditions of the Delayed Recognition Span Test (DRST). Monkeys were tested 5 days a week, one task per week, for a total of 8 months, while undergoing treatments with placebo and ethinyl estradiol (EE2) in alternating 28-days blocks. Blood samples were collected to verify EE2 levels. We also observed the monkeys by video monitor during test sessions and recorded locomotor activity and response topology. Performance on the face-DRST, a task that involved selecting the new face in an increasing array of rhesus monkey faces, was impaired by EE2 treatment, as compared to placebo. Other tasks were unaffected by EE2. There was no clear evidence of EE2 effects upon motor activity or anxiety. In order to test the reliability of our findings, we conducted an additional experiment in which the monkeys were again given the face-DRST with different categories of face stimuli for 4 months, while receiving placebo and EE2 in alternating 7-days blocks. They performed each task 4-5 days/week for 4 weeks with (1) the same rhesus monkey faces as in the first experiment, (2) human faces, (3) chimpanzee faces, and (4) novel rhesus monkey faces. Face-DRST performance did not vary as a function of treatment when human or chimpanzee faces were used as stimuli. In contrast, periods of EE2 treatment were associated with a lower performance for both sets of rhesus monkey faces. These findings suggest that EE2 treatment has a detrimental effect on processing faces of conspecifics by female rhesus monkeys. We speculate that estrogens may produce this effect by enhancing emotional reactivity to socially relevant stimuli.

Sex differences in age-related motor slowing in the rhesus monkey: behavioral and neuroimaging data

The nigrostriatal system is critical for fine motor function and its deterioration during aging is thought to underlie the decline in fine manual ability of old persons. Because estrogen has a neuroprotective effect on this system, one might expect womens motor function to be less vulnerable to the detrimental effects of aging than that of men. We examined this hypothesis in the rhesus monkey, which has been established as an excellent model of human age-related motor impairment. We tested 28 young and old rhesus monkeys of both sexes in a task involving the retrieval of a Life Saver candy from rods of different complexity to determine whether fine motor ability (1) is sexually dimorphic, (2) declines with age and (3) declines differently in males and females. In addition, we measured the whole brain volume, the volumes of the caudate, putamen, hippocampal formation and the area of the corpus callosum in a subset of the monkeys (n=15) for which magnetic resonance images of the brain were available. All monkeys performed similarly in the test with the simplest rod. In the test with complex rods; however, age-related slowing of motor function was evident in males, but not in females. Age-related decreases in the normalized caudate and putamen volumes were similar in males and in females. In addition, motor speed was not significantly correlated to any of the neuroanatomical measures under study. Further studies will be necessary to uncover the neurohormonal bases of the differential age-related motor decline between males and females.

Menstrual Cycles Continue into Advanced Old Age in the Common Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)

Abstract A long postreproductive lifespan may distinguish women from all other female primates. A long-held consensus among reproductive scientists has been that our closest living relative, the chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes), experiences menstrual cycles until death. However, a recent study of biannual assessments of gonadotropins, but lacking observations of menstruation, concluded that menopause occurs in chimpanzees between 35 and 40 yr of age. A separate report, but on wild chimpanzees, documented fertility through the 40–44 age range in all populations studied. These contradictory reports pose questions about differences between wild and captive populations and about assessments of menopause. The present study revisits this controversy by analyzing longitudinal records of anogenital swelling and menstruation in 89 female chimpanzees aged 6 to 59 yr (n = 2386 records on cycle length), monitored for most of their adult lives at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center. Twenty of these chimpanzees were observed past 39 yr of age; all 20 displayed menstrual cycles beyond this age, as confirmed by at least two observations of menses about 35 days apart. Three of these were older than 50 yr and still displayed menstrual cycles. Only the oldest female appeared menopausal, with cycles of anogenital swelling ceasing 2 yr prior to her death at age 59. Random-effects statistical modeling reveals a slight decrease in cycle length until 20 yr of age and a slight lengthening thereafter. Mean cycle length across the lifespan is 35.4 days. Our findings, based upon actual observations of menstrual cycles, suggest that menopause in the chimpanzee is rare, occurring near the end of the lifespan.