Ahmed Ouali

Role of muscle endopeptidases and their inhibitors in meat tenderness

Abstract Postmortem meat tenderness improvement is generally assumed to result from the softening of the myofibrillar structure by endogenous proteolytic enzymes. In this context, the present paper is a broad overview of the different peptidases so far identified in skeletal muscle, their specific inhibitors and their respective potential role in postmortem muscle. A series of petidase families have been thus considered including calpains, cathepsins, proteasomes, caspases, matrix metallopeptidases (MMP) and serine peptidases.

Revisiting the conversion of muscle into meat and the underlying mechanisms

The conversion of muscle into meat is a complex process in which all mechanisms responsible for the development of meat qualities are very likely interdependent. Colour and flavour are thus both dependent on oxidative mechanisms. Oxidation and proteolysis are probably two processes involved in the development of meat tenderness. This paper reviewed the consequences of programmed cell death or apoptosis on muscle cells structure and biochemistry and on meat qualities as well. We therefore look at different new hypothesis susceptible to highlight the meat science field and provide new supports for a more dynamic meat research. One of them which would have appeared evident for our purpose since a decade, deals with the fact that, after animal bleeding, muscle cells have no other alternative to only enter the programmed cell death procedure or apoptosis. If we introduce an early phase corresponding to apoptosis, taking place before the rigor onset and overlapping it, we will see that the known consequences of that process bring forward possible answers to still unexplained observations. After an overview of the actual state-of-the-art in meat science, we will introduce the programmed cell death and its underlying mechanisms. We then described the strong analogies between the known consequences of apoptosis and the postmortem changes affecting a set of different muscle characteristics.

Calpains and calpastatin distribution in bovine, porcine and ovine skeletal muscles.

The concentration of calpain II and calpastatin was determined in various beef, lamb and pork muscles showing very different metabolic and contractile types as assessed by measurement of lactic dehydrogenase (LDH), citrate synthetase (CS) and ATPase activities. The calpain II: calpastatin ratio, which is a good index of the efficiency of this proteolytic system, was also determined. A species comparison revealed that while calpastatin level was lowest in pork, the ratio of calpain II to calpastatin was highest in this species. For both determinations, lamb was intermediate followed by beef. Conversely, the amount of calpain II was very similar in the three species. In beef and pork, calpain II content decreased as muscle ATPase and LDH activities rose; and conversely increased with CS activity; whereas in lamb, the amount of this enzyme was highest in red muscles regardless of their speed of contraction. Except for masseter muscle, a comparable distribution was observed for calpastatin in beef and pork muscles. In lamb, the calplastatin concentration was highest in slow-twitch red muscles, intermediate in fast-twitch red muscles and lowest in fast-twitch white muscles. Variability of the calpain II: calpastatin ratio with muscle ATPase, LDH and CS activities appeared to be both muscle and species dependent. As results for masseter muscle are rather unexpected, especially in beef and lamb, this muscle was considered separately. The present findings are discussed with regard to the conditioning rate of meat from different species and, within one species, from different muscles. It was concluded that the conditioning rate may be correlated positively to calpain II: calpastatin ratio and negatively to calpastatin content. In contrast, no relationship seems to exist between meat ageing rate and calpain concentrations.

The calpain system and skeletal muscle growth

The first protein of a group of proteins now identified as belonging to the calpain system was purified in 1976. The calpain system presently is known to be constituted of three well-characterized proteins; several lesser studied proteins that have been isolated from invertebrates; and 10 mRNAs, two each in Drosophila and C. elegans and six in vertebrates, that encode proteins, which, based on sequence homology, belong to the calpain family. The three well-characterized proteins in the calpain family include two Ca2+-dependent proteolytic enzymes, µ-calpain and m-calpain, and a protein, calpastatin, that has no known activity other than to inhibit the two calpains. A substantial amount of experimental evidence accumulated during the past 25 yr has shown that the calpain system has an important role both in rate of skeletal muscle growth and in rate and extent of postmortem tenderization. Calpastatin seems to be the variable component of the calpain system, and skeletal muscle calpastatin activity is highl...

Plasma proteasome level is a potential marker in patients with solid tumors and hemopoietic malignancies.

Proteasomes are nonlysosomal proteolytic structures that have been implicated in cell growth and differentiation. Abnormal expression levels of proteasomes have been described in tumor cells, and proteasomes can be detected and measured in plasma. The objective of this study was to characterize differences in proteasome levels between normal, healthy donors and patients with neoplastic disease and to correlate the findings with clinical status and other biologic markers of disease spread.

Predicting variability of ageing and toughness in beef M. Longissimus lumborum et thoracis.

The object of this study was to determine muscle characteristics which might predict meat toughness. Eleven Charolais cattle were slaughtered at approximately 26 months of age and the Longissimus lumborum et thoracis muscle was taken 1 hr post mortem and stored at 12 °C for 24 hr and then at 4 °C. The average half-life for ageing in these raw muscles was 4.6 days but the toughness varied widely between the animals. Toughness varied 3-fold and the rate of ageing varied 20-fold between animals. Correlations were done to determine which characteristics might explain this variability. Toughness was correlated positively with increase in oxidative status of muscle and the initial levels of calpastatin. Toughness was correlated negatively with the initial levels of μ- and m-calpains and cysteine and serine proteinase inhibitors, the initial pH values and the rates of their decline. The rates of ageing were highly correlated positively with the initial levels of proteinase inhibitors and the rates of decline of calpastatin and negatively with the ultimate amounts of expressible juice. There was a wide variability in tenderness in M. Longissimus lumborum et thoracis from similar animals. Variations in metabolism and enzyme activity controlled by inhibitors and calpains appear to be largely responsible for this variability.

Comparative action of cathepsins D, B, H, L and of a new lysosomal cysteine proteinase on rabbit myofibrils

Specific action of cathespins D, B, H, L, and of a new high Mr (molecular weight relative to hydrogen) cysteine proteinase, on rabbit muscle myofibrils was studied at pH 5·7 by following changes affecting their ATPase activities, their calcium sensitivity, their effect on the ultrastructure, as well as the electrophoretic pattern of the contractile proteins in the presence of SDS. With regard to the MgCa-enhanced ATPase activity, all these proteinases had a very similar effect. A decrease in this activity was thus noted concomitantly with a shift of the straight-line graph obtained when plotting the present acto-myosin ATPase activity versus KCl concentrations. Cathepsins D, B, L and the high Mr cysteine proteinase induced a decrease in both the calcium ATPase activity of myosin and the calcium sensitivity of myofibrils. On the contrary, the Mg-EGTA-dependent ATpase activity was increased. Except for cathepsin H, extensive hydrolysis of proteins occurred in myofibrils treated with each of the lysosomal proteinases tested. However, different specificities could be distinguished. On the one hand, cathepsins D and B affected mainly myofibrillar protein running above and below actin, respectively, on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; on the other hand, the high Mr cysteine proteinase exhibited broader specificity since most of the proteins were hydrolyzed irrespective of their Mr. Myofibrils incubated with cathepsins B and the high Mr cysteine proteinase showed ultrastructural modifications at the level of Z-line, M-bands and A-bands. Myofibrils treated with cathepsin D and cathepsin H appeared almost unaltered. On the basis of these characteristics, cathepsin H hardly affected myofibrils. These results provide evidence for the involvement of the lysosomal proteinases in the meat ageing process and are discussed in regard to the changes occurring at the myofibrillar level during conversion of muscle into meat.

PROTEOLYTIC ACTIVITY OF PROTEASOME ON MYOFIBRILLAR STRUCTURES

The physiologic function of proteasome remains unclear. Evidence suggests a role in degradation of ubiquitin-protein conjugates, MHC antigen presentation, and some specificity of substrate within certain cell types. To explore further the properties of proteasome we have examined its effect on a well defined structure, the myofibril. We find that despite its large size (20S) proteasome is able to degrade myofibrils and intact, permeabilized muscle fibrils. The proteins degraded showed some specificity because actin, myosin and desmin were degraded faster than α-actinin, troponin T and tropomyosin. Changes in ultrastructure were slow and included a general loss of structure with Z and I bands effected before the M band and costameres.

Relationships between post-mortem pH changes and some traits of sensory quality in veal

The aim of this study was to evaluate the relationships between the rate and extent of post-mortem pH changes and the colour, the cooking loss and the eating quality of veal. The experiment used 12 calves aged 18 weeks. Variations in ultimate pH were induced by adrenalin administration (0.1-0.4 mg/kg liveweight) to six of the animals. Measurements were made on the Longissimus thoracis muscle. pH and osmotic pressure were measured at 0.5 h, 4 h and 29 h after slaughter. Pigment content, drip loss and cooking loss were measured at 29 h after slaughter, and colour was measured at 2 days and 9 days after slaughter. Cooking loss, tenderness, juiciness and flavour of roasts were assessed at 9 days after slaughter. Correlations between colour traits and pH values were higher with ultimate pH than with pH at 0.5 h or 4 h after slaughter. Lightness, redness and reflectance decreased when the ultimate pH increased. Drip loss was correlated with the rate of pH fall (r = -0.80, P < 0.01 with pH at 4 h), while cooking loss was correlated with ultimate pH (r = -0.94, P < 0.01). Ultimate pH and the sensory quality traits were linearity and positively correlated (r = 0.83) for tenderness, 0.81 for juiciness and 0.71 for flavour, respectively).

Development and evaluation of a sandwich ELISA for quantification of the 20S proteasome in human plasma

Because quantification of the 20S proteasome by functional activity measurements is difficult and inaccurate, we have developed an indirect sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) for quantification of the 20S proteasome in human plasma. This sandwich ELISA uses a combination of a monoclonal antibody (mcp 20) recognizing the C2-beta subunit of human 20S proteasome (Mr approximately 30,000) and a polyclonal rabbit anti-20S antibody which labels different subunits of the complex. The detection limit of the assay was established as 10 ng/ml (n=10, mean of zero standard+2 S.D.) and the recovery rate ranged from 96% to 104%. The within-run and between-run coefficients of variation (CV) ranges were 2.8-3.3 and 3.0-3.4, respectively. Using serial dilutions of plasma to which various amounts of purified 20S proteasome were added, a linear dose-response was observed between 102 and 2050 ng/ml with a slope of 1.004 and a coefficient of determination r(2) of 0.99. In a preliminary experiment performed on a limited number of patients, the present assay was used to quantify the 20S proteasome in plasma from healthy subjects (n=11) and from a limited number of patients with various diseases (two patients with each of the following diagnoses: acute myeloid leukaemia, chronic myeloproliferative syndromes, Hodgkins disease and solid tumors). The average concentration of 20S proteasome in plasma from normal subjects was found to be 2319+/-237 ng/ml (n=11). With reference to this normal range, the plasma proteasome concentration was found to be increased in most of these pathological state and as high as 1200% when solid tumors had been detected. For patients with Hodgkins disease, the changes were more variable whereas in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukaemia, the proteasome concentration was raised during the acute phase of disease and decreased during therapy. We suggest that this robust, accurate and highly reproducible assay could be used to quantify proteasome in human plasma and investigate its value as a biological marker for various malignant and nonmalignant diseases.