Alain Pinton

Classical and Molecular Cytogenetics of Disorders of Sex Development in Domestic Animals

The association of abnormal chromosome constitutions and disorders of sex development in domestic animals has been recorded since the beginnings of conventional cytogenetic analysis. Deviated karyotypes consisting of abnormal sex chromosome sets (e.g. aneuploidy) and/or the coexistence of cells with different sex chromosome constitutions (e.g. mosaicism or chimerism) in an individual seem to be the main causes of anomalies of sex determination and sex differentiation. Molecular cytogenetics and genetics have increased our understanding of these pathologies, where human and mouse models have provided a substantial amount of knowledge, leading to the discovery of a number of genes implicated in mammalian sex determination and differentiation. Additionally, other genes, which appeared to be involved in ovary differentiation, have been found by investigations in domestic species such as the goat. In this paper, we present an overview of the biology of mammalian sex development as a scientific background for better understanding the body of knowledge of the clinical cytogenetics of disorders of sex development in domestic animals. An attempt to summarize of what has been described in that particular subject of veterinary medicine for each of the main mammalian domestic species is presented here.

Chromosomal abnormalities, meiotic behavior and fertility in domestic animals

Since the advent of the surface microspreading technique for synaptonemal complex analysis, increasing interest in describing the synapsis patterns of chromosome abnormalities associated with fertility of domestic animals has been noticed during the past three decades. In spite of the number of scientific reports describing the occurrence of structural chromosome abnormalities, their meiotic behavior and gametic products, little is known in domestic animal species about the functional effects of such chromosome aberrations in the germ cell line of carriers. However, some interesting facts gained from recent and previous studies on the meiotic behavior of chromosome abnormalities of domestic animals permit us to discuss, in the frame of recent knowledge emerging from mouse and human investigations, the possible mechanism implicated in the well known association between meiotic disruption and chromosome pairing failure. New cytogenetic techniques, based on molecular and immunofluorescent analyses, are allowing a better description of meiotic processes, including gamete production. The present communication reviews the knowledge of the meiotic consequences of chromosome abnormalities in domestic animals.

Meiotic segregation analysis in cows carrying the t(1;29) Robertsonian translocation.

Heterozygous carriers of Robertsonian translocations generally have a normal phenotype but present reproductive failure. In cattle, the t(1;29) Robertsonian translocation is very common and carriers show a 3–5% decrease in fertility. Some data suggest that female carriers have a higher decrease than male carriers but no direct studies of the chromosome content of oocytes from a t(1;29) carrier cow have been performed so far. Four heterozygous carrier cows underwent hormonal stimulations and follicles punctions and about 800 oocytes were matured in vitro. Six hundred metaphase II preparations were obtained and analysed by fluorescent in situ hybridization with bovine chromosome 1 and 29 painting probes. Proportions of different kinds of oocytes were assessed: 74.11% (292/394) were normal and balanced, 4.06% (16/394) unbalanced and 21.83% (86/394) diploid. For all cows, the number of normal oocytes was not significantly different from the number of translocated oocytes but the diploidy and unbalanced rate were significantly different between them. As found in bulls, the meiotic segregation pattern in cows has shown a preponderance of alternate products. However, the frequency of unbalanced gametes determined in females (4.06%) was significantly higher than the frequency observed in males (2.76%). The divergence in the rate of diploid gametes (0.04% vs. 21.83%) is mainly explained by the difference between males and females.

Fluorescence in situ Hybridization Applied to Domestic Animal Cytogenetics

The aim of this article is not to present an exhaustive review of molecular cytogenetics applications in domestic animal species, but more to illustrate the considerable contribution of these approaches in diagnostics and research in economically important species. A short presentation of the main applications of molecular cytogenetics in humans points out the domains in which it has become an essential tool and underlines the specificities attached to this species in comparison to farm animals. This article is devoted to outlining the current resources available in domestic species and to some examples of fluorescence in situ hybridization applications in the cattle, pig, horse and avian species. From a clinical point of view, these examples illustrate the advantages of FISH for the study of chromosomal abnormalities (identification, characterization and estimation of their effects). Other applications of molecular cytogenetics are also illustrated, particularly ZOO-FISH, an approach which allows the determination of chromosome homologies between species. Finally, a specific emphasis was placed on the usefulness of molecular cytogenetics for the analysis of species such as poultry, which harbour a complex karyotype.

Meiotic studies in an azoospermic boar carrying a Y;14 translocation

A reciprocal translocation between the q arm of the Y chromosome and the q arm of chromosome 14 was identified in a young, phenotypically normal boar presenting azoospermia. Testicular biopsies were analyzed by classical histological and immunolocalization techniques, and by fluorescence in situ hybridization. Meiotic pairing analysis of 85 pachytene spreads showed the presence of an open structure corresponding to a quadrivalent formed by chromosomes 14, X, and the derivative chromosomes 14 and Y in 84.7% of the cases. In the remaining cases (15.3%), a ‘trivalent plus univalent’ configuration was observed. Immunolocalization of γH2AX revealed the presence of this modified histone in the chromatin domains of unsynapsed segments (centromeric region of chromosome 14) and spreading of the γH2AX signal from the XY body throughout chromosome 14 in 7.05% of the cells analyzed. The potential causes of the observed infertility, i.e. activation of meiotic checkpoints and/or silencing of genes necessary for the progression of meiosis, are discussed.

Influence of sex on the meiotic segregation of a t(13;17) Robertsonian translocation: a case study in the pig

BACKGROUND Comparison of male versus female meiotic segregation patterns for Robertsonian translocation (RT) carriers with similar genetic background has rarely been reported in mammalian species. METHODS The aim of this study was to compare the segregation patterns determined for related males and females carrying a 13;17 RT in an animal model (Sus scrofa domestica L.), using dual colour fluorescence in situ hybridization on decondensed sperm nuclei and metaphases II of in vitro-matured oocytes. RESULTS In males, no association between the trivalent and the XY body was observed in any of the 90 pachytene nuclei studied, and the rate of unbalanced spermatozoa ranged between 2.96% and 3.83%. Female meiotic segregation analyses were carried out on 83 metaphase II oocytes. The rate of unbalanced gametes was higher in females than in males (28.91% versus 3.21%, P < 0.001). This difference was due to higher rates of diploid gametes (12.04% versus 0.05%) and unbalanced gametes produced by the adjacent segregation (16.86% versus 3.16%). CONCLUSIONS This study is a new scientific contribution to the comparison of segregation patterns in related males and females carrying an identical chromosomal rearrangement. It allows a better understanding of the meiotic behaviour of RTs. It also clearly illustrates the relevance of swine as an animal model for such meiotic studies.

Spatial distribution of histone isoforms on the bovine active and inactive X chromosomes.

The inactive X chromosome (Xi) in female mammals serves as an important model for studying the role of histone isoforms in directing specific nuclear processes leading to inherited differences in transcription. In the present study, we investigated the distribution of some histone isoforms known to be involved in the process of human X inactivation on their bovine counterparts. To ascertain the identity of active and inactive X chromosome, their distribution was investigated on the X chromosomes in a cell line derived from a bovine female carrying an X;autosome translocation rcp(Xp+;23q–) which allowed the recognition of the maternal (translocated) and paternal (normal) X chromosome. The distribution patterns of histone H3 trimethylated at lysine 9 (H3K9me3) and trimethylated at lysine 27 (H3K27me3), and histone macroH2A1 and macroH2A2 (isoforms specific to heterochromatin) were determined by immunocytochemistry and compared to the temporal pattern of replication using BrdU pulse labeling prior to staining. Immunostaining revealed that H3K9me3, H3K27me3, and macroH2A1 are preferentially concentrated on the Xi, whereas the histone variant macroH2A2 is not a marker for this chromosome. H3K9me3, H3K27me3, and macroH2A1 were consistently located in bands along the Xi, while H3K9me3, macroH2A1 and macroH2A2 localized in the pericentromeric regions of the autosomes. H3K27me3 identified two intense bands on the Xi at Xp22 and Xq31, representing the early replication regions of the chromosome. H3K27me3 and macroH2A1 overlapped in the Xq31 region. It was concluded that different heterochromatin regions on the bovine inactive X chromosome can be identified by their histone isoform composition.

A new reciprocal translocation in a subfertile bull

Three bulls of the Montbéliarde breed that exhibited fertility rates lower than 30% following more than 400 artificial inseminations were examined. Semen quality (sperm motility and morphology) from these bulls was normal. Fertilizing ability estimated from in vitro embryo production results was studied for two of them. In vitro production rate was very low for one bull (A) and normal for the other (B). Cytogenetic analyses were carried out on the three bulls using chromosome banding techniques. These analyses revealed a reciprocal translocation (12;17)(q22;q14) in bull B. Based on family analyses, the hypothesis of a de novo origin of this rearrangement is proposed.

A 3.7 Mb Deletion Encompassing ZEB2 Causes a Novel Polled and Multisystemic Syndrome in the Progeny of a Somatic Mosaic Bull

Polled and Multisystemic Syndrome (PMS) is a novel developmental disorder occurring in the progeny of a single bull. Its clinical spectrum includes polledness (complete agenesis of horns), facial dysmorphism, growth delay, chronic diarrhea, premature ovarian failure, and variable neurological and cardiac anomalies. PMS is also characterized by a deviation of the sex-ratio, suggesting male lethality during pregnancy. Using Mendelian error mapping and whole-genome sequencing, we identified a 3.7 Mb deletion on the paternal bovine chromosome 2 encompassing ARHGAP15, GTDC1 and ZEB2 genes. We then produced control and affected 90-day old fetuses to characterize this syndrome by histological and expression analyses. Compared to wild type individuals, affected animals showed a decreased expression of the three deleted genes. Based on a comparison with human Mowat-Wilson syndrome, we suggest that deletion of ZEB2, is responsible for most of the effects of the mutation. Finally sperm-FISH, embryo genotyping and analysis of reproduction records confirmed somatic mosaicism in the founder bull and male-specific lethality during the first third of gestation. In conclusion, we identified a novel locus involved in bovid horn ontogenesis and suggest that epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition plays a critical role in horn bud differentiation. We also provide new insights into the pathogenicity of ZEB2 loss of heterozygosity in bovine and humans and describe the first case of male-specific lethality associated with an autosomal locus in a non-murine mammalian species. This result sets PMS as a unique model to study sex-specific gene expression/regulation.

Studies of male and female meiosis in inv(4)(p1.4;q2.3) pig carriers

Inversions are well-known structural chromosomal rearrangements in humans and pigs. Such rearrangements generally have no effect on the carriers phenotype. However, the presence of an inversion may impair spermatogenesis and lead to the production of recombinant gametes, responsible for early miscarriages, stillbirth, or congenital abnormalities. This is the first report on meiotic segregation and pairing behavior of the inv(4)(p1.4;q2.3) pericentric inversion in pigs. Despite the very large size of the inverted fragment (76% of the chromosome), SpermFISH results showed that only 4.08% of the gametes produced by male heterozygotes were unbalanced. This low proportion could be explained by the particular behavior of normal and inverted SSC4 chromosomes during the initial stages of meiosis. Indeed, immunohistochemistry analyses revealed that heterosynapsis occurred in 92% of the cells, whereas synaptic adjustment was detected in a few spermatocytes only. Unexpectedly, the proportion of unbalanced gametes produced by female heterozygotes, estimated by FISH on metaphase II oocytes, was also very low (3.69%) and comparable to that in males. According to previous results for male and female meiotic processes, different proportions of recombinant gametes in the two genders would have been expected. Complementary studies should be carried out to further document the meiotic behavior of inversions in pigs.