Aldert H. Piersma

Endocrine effects of tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBPA) in Wistar rats as tested in a one-generation reproduction study and a subacute toxicity study.

Endocrine effects of the brominated flame retardant tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBPA) were studied in a one-generation reproduction assay in Wistar rats via repeated dietary exposure, applying eight dose groups at 0-3-10-30-100-300-1,000-3,000 mg/kg body weight/day (mkd). This design enables dose-response analysis and calculation of benchmark doses (BMDL). This reproduction study was preceded by a 28-day repeat dose subacute toxicity study, at 0-30-100-300 mkd. Major effects in the reproduction study included decreased circulating thyroxine (T4) with BMDLs of 31 (m) and 16 (f) mkd, and increased weight of testis and male pituitary (BMDLs of 0.5 and 0.6 mkd). The hypothyroxinemia correlated to a cluster of developmental parameters including delayed sexual development in females, decreased pup mortality, and effects on brainstem auditory evoked potentials [Lilienthal, H., Verwer, C.M., Van der Ven, L.T.M., Piersma, A.H., Vos, J.G., 2008. Neurobehavioral effects of tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) in rats after pre- and postnatal exposure. Toxicology]. A second cluster of parameters in F1 animals was correlated to increased testis weight, and included female gonad weight, endometrium height, CYP19/aromatase activity in the ovary, and plasma testosterone levels in males. These two correlation clusters suggest a dual action of TBBPA. The only effects in the subacute study were decreased circulating T4 and increased T3 levels in males (BMDLs 48 and 124mkd), and non-significant trends for these parameters in females, suggesting that the other effects in the reproduction study were induced during development. Combined with data of human exposure to environmental TBBPA, the margin of exposure for highly exposed populations can be calculated at 2.6, and current use of TBBPA may therefore be a matter of concern for human health.

In vitro developmental toxicity test detects inhibition of stem cell differentiation by silica nanoparticles.

While research into the potential toxic properties of nanomaterials is now increasing, the area of developmental toxicity has remained relatively uninvestigated. The embryonic stem cell test is an in vitro screening assay used to investigate the embryotoxic potential of chemicals by determining their ability to inhibit differentiation of embryonic stem cells into spontaneously contracting cardiomyocytes. Four well characterized silica nanoparticles of various sizes were used to investigate whether nanomaterials are capable of inhibition of differentiation in the embryonic stem cell test. Nanoparticle size distributions and dispersion characteristics were determined before and during incubation in the stem cell culture medium by means of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and dynamic light scattering. Mouse embryonic stem cells were exposed to silica nanoparticles at concentrations ranging from 1 to 100 microg/ml. The embryonic stem cell test detected a concentration dependent inhibition of differentiation of stem cells into contracting cardiomyocytes by two silica nanoparticles of primary size 10 (TEM 11) and 30 (TEM 34) nm while two other particles of primary size 80 (TEM 34) and 400 (TEM 248) nm had no effect up to the highest concentration tested. Inhibition of differentiation of stem cells occurred below cytotoxic concentrations, indicating a specific effect of the particles on the differentiation of the embryonic stem cells. The impaired differentiation of stem cells by such widely used particles warrants further investigation into the potential of these nanoparticles to migrate into the uterus, placenta and embryo and their possible effects on embryogenesis.

Relative embryotoxicity of two classes of chemicals in a modified zebrafish embryotoxicity test and comparison with their in vivo potencies

The zebrafish embryotoxicity test (ZET) is a fast and simple method to study chemical toxicity after exposure of the complete vertebrate embryo during embryogenesis in ovo. We developed a novel quantitative evaluation method to assess the development of the zebrafish embryo based on specific endpoints in time, the general morphology score (GMS) system. For teratogenic effects a separate scoring list was developed. The relative effects of eight glycol ethers and six 1,2,4-triazole anti-fungals were evaluated in this system and results were compared with in vivo developmental toxicity potencies. Methoxyacetic acid and ethoxyacetic acid appeared as the most potent glycol ether metabolites, inducing growth retardation and malformations. Other glycol ethers showed no developmental toxicity. Flusilazole appeared the most potent triazole, followed by hexaconazole, cyproconazole, triadimefon, myclobutanil and triticonazole, respectively. In general, the potency ranking of the compounds within their class in the ZET was comparable to their in vivo ranking. In conclusion, the ZET with the GMS system appears an efficient and useful test system for screening embryotoxic properties of chemicals within the classes of compounds tested. This alternative test method may also be useful for the detection of embryotoxic properties of other classes of chemicals.

A Category Approach for Reproductive Effects of Phthalates

In regulatory toxicology, the experimental assessment of reproductive toxicity is one of the most costly endpoints to perform. Categorizing chemicals is an approach that can be used to reduce animal tests in risk assessments of chemicals, for example, via REACH (Registration, Evaluation, and Authorization of Chemicals). The category approach was tested for reproductive toxicity with a group of 10 ortho-phthalate esters, with different side chain lengths. Three ortho-phthalates were used for testing the category. Phthalates with side-chain lengths C4 to C6 that are commonly known to cause reproductive effects were included, as well as the recently discovered mechanism that indicates antiandrogenic effects. The differences in physicochemical properties, absorption rates, and metabolism between the phthalates investigated could not fully explain the difference in reproductive toxicity. It was concluded that phthalates with the alkyl side-chain length from C4 to C6 produce similar severe reproductive effects in experimental animals. It is expected that phthalates included in the tight boundaries of the proposed category would all show severe reproductive effects, especially the antiandrogenic effects. Further testing might not be needed for phthalates within these boundaries. If necessary, limited testing could focus on the critical endpoints. Detailed mechanistic information is needed on phthalates to apply the categories for regulatory toxicology.

Endocrine effects of hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) in a one-generation reproduction study in Wistar rats.

The brominated flame retardant (BFR) hexabromocyclododecane was tested in a one-generation reproduction assay in Wistar rats, enhanced for endocrine parameters. A solution of the compound in corn oil was mixed in the feed, targeting at dietary exposure of 0-0.1-0.3-1-3-10-30-100 mg/kg body weight/day (mkd) in parental rats during 10 (males) or 2 (females) weeks premating, during gestation and lactation, and in their F1 offspring from weaning until final necropsy. Effects were assessed in F1 animals. Livers of these animals showed increased HBCD concentrations, in a dose-dependent way. The trabecular bone mineral density of the tibia was dose-dependently decreased in females (BenchMark Dose Lower confidence bound, BMDL=0.056 mkd). The IgG response after immunization with sheep red blood cells (SRBC) was increased in males (BMDL=0.46 mkd). Further sensitive effects were decreased weight of the testis (BMDL=1.5 mkd), increased fraction of neutrophilic granulocytes (BMDL=7.7 mkd), decreased concentration of apolar retinoids in female livers (BMDL=1.3 mkd), and decreased plasma alkaline phosphatase in females (BMDL=8.6 mkd). CYP19/aromatase activity in the ovary was correlated to the concentration of gamma-HBCD in the liver. A developmental origin of these effects is considered, and this is also true for sensitive effects observed in neurobehavioural testing in littermates from the same experiment, i.e. in the brainstem auditory evoked potentials and in a catalepsy test [Lilienthal, H., Van der Ven, L.T.M., Piersma, A.H., Vos, J.G. Neurobehavioral effects of the brominated flame retardant hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) in rats after pre- and postnatal exposure, in press]. The low BMDLs of these effects may raise concern for human health, particularly when based on body burdens of HBCD, which leads to critical margins of exposure particularly for the occupational setting.

The use of in vitro toxicity data and physiologically based kinetic modeling to predict dose-response curves for in vivo developmental toxicity of glycol ethers in rat and man.

At present, regulatory assessment of systemic toxicity is almost solely carried out using animal models. The European Commissions REACH legislation stimulates the use of animal-free approaches to obtain information on the toxicity of chemicals. In vitro toxicity tests provide in vitro concentration-response curves for specific target cells, whereas in vivo dose-response curves are regularly used for human risk assessment. The present study shows an approach to predict in vivo dose-response curves for developmental toxicity by combining in vitro toxicity data and in silico kinetic modeling. A physiologically based kinetic (PBK) model was developed, describing the kinetics of four glycol ethers and their embryotoxic alkoxyacetic acid metabolites in rat and man. In vitro toxicity data of these metabolites derived in the embryonic stem cell test were used as input in the PBK model to extrapolate in vitro concentration-response curves to predicted in vivo dose-response curves for developmental toxicity of the parent glycol ethers in rat and man. The predicted dose-response curves for rat were found to be in concordance with the embryotoxic dose levels measured in reported in vivo rat studies. Therefore, predicted dose-response curves for rat could be used to set a point of departure for deriving safe exposure limits in human risk assessment. Combining the in vitro toxicity data with a human PBK model allows the prediction of dose-response curves for human developmental toxicity. This approach could therefore provide a means to reduce the need for animal testing in human risk assessment practices.

Developmental toxicity of butyl benzyl phthalate in the rat using a multiple dose study design

The developmental toxicity of butyl benzyl phthalate (BBP) was investigated in the rat using ten dose groups between 270 and 2100 mg/kg/day. Exposure was by daily gavage from gestation day 5 through 16 or gestation day 5 through 20. Dose-response data were analyzed using the benchmark approach by fitting dose-response models to the various endpoints. BBP induced increased liver and kidney weights in dams, accompanied by liver enzyme increases in maternal serum. Extramedullary hematopoiesis, which was already substantial in control pregnant animals, was increased after BBP treatment. Fetotoxicity included increased resorptions, reduced fetal weights, increased incidence of skeletal anomalies, and reduced fetal testis weights in the presence of an increased incidence of retarded testicular descent. As embryotoxicity was found at lower dosages compared to observed maternal toxicity, BBP appeared to be a specifically embryotoxic compound. The extended exposure protocol (gestation day 5 through 20) appeared more sensitive for measuring fetotoxic effects. We recommend the use of more doses in toxicity tests, together with the benchmark approach as an appropriate and more accurate method for analyzing dose-response data compared to the NOAEL approach.

A 28-day oral dose toxicity study enhanced to detect endocrine effects of a purified technical pentabromodiphenyl ether (pentaBDE) mixture in Wistar rats

A 28-day subacute oral toxicity study was performed in Wistar rats with a purified preparation of the commercial pentabromodiphenyl ether (pentaBDE), DE-71. The applied OECD407 protocol was enhanced for endocrine and immune parameters, and to enable benchmark dose analysis. A vehicle control group and 7 dose groups were included, which received 0.27, 0.82, 2.47, 7.4, 22.2, 66.7 or 200 mg pentaBDE/kg bw/d (mkd). The liver appeared to be a key target organ, showing a marked increase of weight and centrilobular hepatocellular hypertrophy, probably due to the observed induction of P450 enzymes, notably CYP1A and CYP2B. A marked decrease of circulating total thyroxine (TT4) and an increase of plasma cholesterol were probably secondary to the liver effects. Furthermore, dose-dependently decreased weight of epididymis, seminal vesicles, and prostate, as well as sperm head deformities in males, and induction of CYP17 activity in adrenals in females were observed, all possibly related to anti-androgenic activity. Finally, we observed a substantial increase of large unstained cells in the blood and a decrease of apolar retinoids in the liver. All these effects had benchmark doses at the lower confidence bound (BMDL) in the low- or mid-dose range, but particular sensitive, potentially adverse effects were TT4 decrease (BMDLs 1.1 in males and 1.8 mkd in females), and decrease of hepatic apolar retinoids (BMDLs 0.5 mkd in males and 2.3 mkd in females). These results contribute to refinement of the hazard identification of pentaBDE and improved risk assessment of human exposure to this industrial chemical and environmental pollutant.

State of the art in developmental toxicity screening methods and a way forward: a meeting report addressing embryonic stem cells, whole embryo culture, and zebrafish.

A meeting was convened so that users of three models for in vitro developmental toxicity (embryonic stem cells, whole embryo culture, and zebrafish) could share their experiences with each model, and explore the areas for improvement. We present a summary of this meeting and the recommendations of the group.

Exposure to tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) in Wistar rats: neurobehavioral effects in offspring from a one-generation reproduction study.

Within the framework of an EU project on risk assessment of brominated flame retardants, TBBPA was studied for neurobehavioral effects in rats. To permit benchmark dose analysis, eight dose levels were chosen ranging from 0 to 3000mg/kg body weight. Exposure of parental rats started 10 and 2 weeks before mating in males and females, respectively, and was continued throughout mating, gestation and lactation. After weaning, exposure was continued in the offspring throughout life. Previous studies had indicated TBBPA-induced effects on thyroid hormones. Because of the known implication of thyroid hormones in neurodevelopment, the present experiments tested if TBBPA exposure affects thyroid-dependent neurobehavioral functions in offspring, such as auditory responses and conditioned fear. Sweet preference was included because of sex-specific effects in littermates. No statistically significant effects were found on context or cue conditioned fear or sweet preference. Auditory responses were examined with brainstem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs) at approximately 50-110 days of age. BAEP thresholds and wave IV latency were increased in exposed female rats in the low frequency range. In male rats, thresholds were unaffected, but absolute latency of wave IV and interpeak latencies II-IV showed exposure-related increases at low frequencies. The outcome pattern suggests a predominant cochlear effect of TBBPA in females while in males neural effects are more apparent. According to benchmark analysis, the critical effect doses (CED) for prolongations of wave IV latency at 0.5kHz were in the range of 35-70mg/kg body weight with lower bounds (BMDL) of approximately 8mg/kg in males and females. The BMDL values for elevation of hearing thresholds in females were in the range of 1-40mg/kg body weight, depending on frequency. The benchmark doses for effects on the BAEP were similar to values for decreases in circulating thyroid hormones. The comparison of the exposure level at which the most sensitive effect was found with current human exposure levels yielded a margin of exposure of about 5, according to a recent risk assessment. Further investigations are needed to examine exposure pathways, fate in the body and effects of TBBPA.