Alessandra Ferlini

Dystrophin and mutations: one gene, several proteins, multiple phenotypes

A large and complex gene on the X chromosome encodes dystrophin. Many mutations have been described in this gene, most of which affect the expression of the muscle isoform, the best-known protein product of this locus. These mutations result in the Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD). However, there are several other tissue specific isoforms of dystrophin, some exclusively or predominantly expressed in the brain or the retina. Mutations affecting the correct expression of these tissue-specific isoforms have been associated with the CNS involvement common in DMD. Rare mutations also account for the allelic disorder X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy, in which dystrophin expression or function is affected mostly or exclusively in the heart. Genotype definition of the dystrophin gene in patients with dystrophinopathies has taught us much about functionally important domains of the protein itself and has provided insights into several regulatory mechanisms governing the gene expression profile. Here, we focus on current understanding of the genotype-phenotype relation for mutations in the dystrophin gene and their implications for gene functions.

Mitochondrial dysfunction in the pathogenesis of Ullrich congenital muscular dystrophy and prospective therapy with cyclosporins

Ullrich congenital muscular dystrophy is a severe genetically and clinically heterogeneous muscle disorder linked to collagen VI deficiency. The pathogenesis of the disease is unknown. To assess the potential role of mitochondrial dysfunction in the onset of muscle fiber death in this form of dystrophy, we studied biopsies and myoblast cultures obtained from patients with different genetic defects of collagen VI and variable clinical presentations of the disease. We identified a latent mitochondrial dysfunction in myoblasts from patients with Ullrich congenital muscular dystrophy that matched an increased occurrence of spontaneous apoptosis. Unlike those in myoblasts from healthy donors, mitochondria in cells from patients depolarized upon addition of oligomycin and displayed ultrastructural alterations that were worsened by treatment with oligomycin. The increased apoptosis, the ultrastructural defects, and the anomalous response to oligomycin could be normalized by Ca2+ chelators, by plating cells on collagen VI, and by treatment with cyclosporin A or with the specific cyclophilin inhibitor methylAla3ethylVal4-cyclosporin, which does not affect calcineurin activity. Here we demonstrate that mitochondrial dysfunction plays an important role in muscle cell wasting in Ullrich congenital muscular dystrophy. This study represents an essential step toward a pharmacological therapy of Ullrich congenital muscular dystrophy with cyclosporin A and methylAla3ethylVal4 cyclosporin.

Phenotypic and genotypic heterogeneity in transthyretin-related cardiac amyloidosis: Towards tailoring of therapeutic strategies?

Transthyretin-related hereditary amyloidosis (ATTR) is genotypically/phenotypically heterogeneous. We investigated myocardial involvement in ATTR in a cohort of patients with a wide range of mutations. Clinical/echocardiographic follow-up of 41 consecutive symptomatic ATTR patients from a single referral center was analyzed according to TTR mutation. Diagnosis was based on histology, immunohistochemistry and genotyping. Median follow up was 40 months (range 8–120). Among the 12 different mutations identified, Val30Met was found in 10 patients and Glu89Gln in seven. Compared with Val30Met, Glu89Gln was associated with higher LV mass index, lower left ventricular ejection fraction and shorter E-wave deceleration time. All Glu89Gln carriers had cardiomyopathy, which was more severe (for left ventricular thickness, left ventricular mass and restrictive pathophysiology) than in the six affected Val30Met patients. Glu89Gln was independently associated with higher risk of major cardiovascular events among cardiomyopathy patients. This follow-up study of ATTR patients carrying a wide range of mutations indicates that (1) cardiac involvement is a very important component of phenotypic expression; and (2) genotype is an important source of heterogeneity in myocardial involvement, with Glu89Gln being associated with a severe, heart-driven prognosis. We think that combined heart–liver transplantation could be considered for Glu89Gln carriers with established, morphologically severe cardiomyopathy.

Screening of mutations in the CFTR gene in 1195 couples entering assisted reproduction technique programs

Genetic testing of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance (CFTR) gene is currently performed in couples undergoing assisted reproduction techniques (ART), because of the high prevalence of healthy carriers in the population and the pathogenic relationship with congenital bilateral absence of vas deferens (CBAVD). However, discordant data have been reported concerning the usefulness of this genetic test in couples with no family history of cystic fibrosis (CF). In this study, we report the results of CFTR molecular screening in 1195 couples entering ART. Genetic testing was initially carried out in a single partner of each couple. CFTR mutations were detected in 55 subjects (4.6%), a percentage that overlaps with the one reported in the general population. However, significantly higher frequencies of were found in CBAVD individuals (37.5%) and in males with nonobstructive azoospermia (6.6%). The 5T allele was found in 78 patients (6.5%). This figure was again significantly different in males with nonobstructive-azoospermia (9.9%) and in those with CBAVD (100%). All together, 139 subjects (11.6%) had either a CFTR mutation or the 5T allele. Subsequent molecular analysis of their partners disclosed a CFTR mutation or 5T allele in nine cases (6.5%). However, none of these couples had CFTR alterations in both members, a CFTR mutation being invariably present in one partner and the 5T allele in the other. In order to improve genetic counselling of these couples, the TG-M470V-5T association was analyzed, and a statistically significant relationship between 12TG-V470 and CBAVD was detected.

Multiple exon skipping and RNA circularisation contribute to the severe phenotypic expression of exon 5 dystrophin deletion

Deletion and duplication of one or more exons in the dystrophin gene account for 70% of patients with Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD) and other allelic clinical entities such as raised serum creatine kinase and X linked dilated cardiomyopathy (XLDC).1 The severity of the resulting phenotype can be generally predicted by whether these mutations lead to translation frame disruption and premature termination of protein synthesis.2 Nevertheless, the occurrence of severely affected patients with in frame deletions as well as mild phenotypes associated with frameshift, indicate that factors other than the frame disruption should contribute to the clinical severity. Exceptions to the “frame rule” are found in about 8% of patients with mutations occurring both at the 5′ and 3′ end of the dystrophin gene,1,3,4 although they seem to predominate in the 5′ region.4 Despite extensive clinical, immunocytochemical, and transcriptional studies, the basis of genotype-phenotype correlation in these “atypical” cases remains controversial and its clarification will surely provide relevant information about normal and abnormal dystrophin function. Several reports suggest a role for alternative splicing in altering the clinical phenotype by modulating the editing of the translation reading frame.3,5,6 Patients with BMD carrying the frameshift deletions of exons 3–7 and 45 show alternative splicing phenomena theoretically restoring the reading frame.5,7 However, the relevance of these events in contributing to a milder phenotype is still unclear.3,8,9 Supporting the bridging role of the dystrophin splicing machinery as active modulator between genotype (deletion mutation) and protein production, cell specific somatic exon skipping has been documented in skeletal muscle revertant fibres in DMD.10nn### Key points

Occurrence of Del(GIB6-D13S1830) mutation in Italian non-syndromic hearing loss patients carrying a single GJB2 mutated allele

Molecular screening for GJB2 (connexin 26) mutations represents the standard diagnostic approach for the genotype definition of non-syndromic deafness. Nevertheless, a single GJB2 pathogenic mutation is detectable in a relevant number of cases, therefore failing to explain the phenotype. We aimed at assessing the occurrence of the recently described del(GIB6-D13S1830) mutation, occurring in the connexin 30 gene, in a group of Italian hearing-impaired patients carrying a single GJB2 mutated allele. A total of 59 non-syndromic hearing loss (NSHL) patients were screened for GJB2 mutations. Among these, nine NSHL patients were found to be heterozygous for a single GJB2 mutation. These patients, heterozygotes for different GJB2 mutated alleles (35delG, L90P, M34T, V153I), together with 11 additional 35delG/neg cases previously described, were studied for the presence of the del(GIB6-D13S1830) mutation. Two double heterozygotes del(GIB6-D13S1830)/35delG were identified. In both cases the degree of hearing loss was profound. Furthermore, GJB2 molecular screening led to the identification of a novel change (T55G) occurring in compound heterozygosity with the V37I mutation. In conclusion, our data suggest a significant frequency of del(GIB6-D13S1830) mutation in Italian hearing-impaired subjects (10% of unexplained GJB2 heterozygotes) similar to that reported in other European countries.

Genomic and transcription studies as diagnostic tools for a prenatal detection of X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy due to a dystrophin gene mutation

X‐linked dilated cardiomyopathy (XLDC) represents a form of dystrophinopathy with exclusive heart involvement. Here a prenatal diagnosis of this condition performed in a family with XLDC is described. In this family, the causative mutation was a pure intronic deletion, which induces the splicing of a novel, aberrant, and out‐of‐frame exon into the dystrophin transcript. The genetic test was performed by defining both the DNA (villous) and the RNA (amniocyte) configuration. The prenatal diagnosis determined that the fetus was female, and a carrier of the genomic deletion. RNA analysis on cultured amniocytes revealed the presence of an easily detectable dystrophin transcript, as well as the co‐existence of both the wild‐type and the abnormal splicing profile. Our analysis represents the first report of a prenatal diagnosis in XLDC and also indicates the feasibility of dystrophin mutation detection on RNA from amniocytes. This finding suggests that the dystrophin splicing pattern in amniocytes and skeletal muscle is similar, and that, therefore, this approach could be used in other prenatal dystrophin mutation detection, where abnormal RNA splicing is thought to play a role, or for specific cases in which no mutations have been identified in the coding regions.

Genomic definition of a pure intronic dystrophin deletion responsible for an XLDC splicing mutation: in vitro mimicking and antisense modulation of the splicing abnormality☆

We characterised a dystrophin gene rearrangement in a previously described family with X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy and we demonstrated that it represents an 11 kb deletion occurring within intron 11. This unique deletion joined two physiologically distant intronic regions and brought adjacent two cryptic splice sites, generating a 159 bp sequence recognised as a novel alternative exon and spliced into the dystrophin transcript. Comparative analysis of the intronic region involved in the breakpoint revealed the presence of a LINE1 element (L1P_MA2), containing a 5 unconventional region (L1M1_5). This region provides the 5 cryptic splice site utilised by the novel exon, includes part of the region spliced into the dystrophin transcript and contains two short GA rich regions compatible with splicing motifs. We performed an in vitro splicing assay by using a minigene containing the patient minimal genomic rearrangement and we reproduced the inclusion of the novel alternative exon seen in the patient tissues. Antisense splicing modulation targeting the 3 cryptic splice site succeeded in restoring the canonical splicing. This represents a novel intronic mutational mechanism affecting the dystrophin gene and generating a splicing pathology. The definition of this mechanism might open perspectives in unravelling splicing regulatory motifs and their involvement in human genetic diseases.

Recurrent syncope as persistently isolated feature of transthyretin amyloidotic polyneuropathy

In transthyretin familial amyloid polyneuropathy (TTR-FAP), single clinical features rarely remain isolated and are usually accompanied by other symptoms. We describe a patient with TTR-FAP, who had recurrent episodes of syncope for 4 years as an overt and isolated symptom. Later, he experienced paresthesia in the hands, and impotence. Molecular analysis of the TTR gene revealed a Thr49Ala mutation. The unusual clinical presentation presents a diagnostic challenge.

Atypical familial motor neuropathy in patients with mutant TTR Ile68Leu

Two sisters from an Italian family shared progressive motor symptoms, preceding the onset of sensory and auto-nomic disturbances. The familial occurrence of axonal and slowly progressive polyneuropathy led us to consider these patients as candidates for TTR molecular analysis. We found a missense mutation causing Ile68Leu TTR substitution in both. The aims of this work are to report the possibility of a motor onset of amyloid polyneuropathy and to suggest the search for TTR mutations in familial cases of axonal polyneuropathy. Second, to stress the possible occurrence of amyloid within the spinal canal as the potential pathogenesis and responsible for motor presentation.