Allin Cottrell

REFLECTIONS ON ECONOMIC DEMOCRACY

We revisit the model of socialism proposed in our Towards a New Socialism (1993) and attempt to answer various questions that have been raised regarding the connection between our view of socialism and our perspective on capitalism, the process of transition to socialism, the failings of the Soviet model, the relationship between socialism and communism, the role of direct democracy under socialism, and the use of labor-time calculation in a socialist economy. We argue that the contradictions of capitalist property relations, and of the accumulation process on a world scale, are set to present once again the necessity of the abolition of private property during the 21st century, and offer some thoughts on transitional forms that could implement this abolition. We defend the ideas of direct democracy and economic calculation in terms of labor time, and argue that these elements distinguish our proposals from the Soviet model. We trace the demise of the latter both to specifics of the Russian situation and to more general problems of Leninism, notably Lenin’s conception of the council state, and of socialism as a long period during which the productive forces are built up in preparation for an eventual communism.

El aspecto empírico de la teoría del valor: respuesta a Nitzan y Bichler

La teoria del valor trabajo, originada en los clasicos y reformulada por Marx, ha encontrado apoyo empirico en numerosos trabajos en los ultimos treinta anos. En diversas economias los sectores en terminos monetarios estan altamente correlacionados con los mismos en terminos de valor trabajo. En su libro Capital as Power (2009), y en una subsecuente discusion en linea, Jonathan Nitzan y Shimshon Bichler afirman que tales resultados son invalidos porque los calculos no obtienen resultados en valor trabajo, sino que se han correlacionado dos variables monetarias. Tambien arguyen Nitzan y Bichler que las correlaciones son espurias por la presencia de una tercera variable. En este articulo se refutan ambas criticas y, consecuentemente, se refuerza el soporte empirico a la teoria del valor trabajo.