Andrew Mooney

Comparison of survival analysis and palliative care involvement in patients aged over 70 years choosing conservative management or renal replacement therapy in advanced chronic kidney disease

Background: There are limited data on the outcomes of elderly patients with chronic kidney disease undergoing renal replacement therapy or conservative management. Aims: We aimed to compare survival, hospital admissions and palliative care access of patients aged over 70 years with chronic kidney disease stage 5 according to whether they chose renal replacement therapy or conservative management. Design: Retrospective observational study. Setting/participants: Patients aged over 70 years attending pre-dialysis clinic. Results: In total, 172 patients chose conservative management and 269 chose renal replacement therapy. The renal replacement therapy group survived for longer when survival was taken from the time estimated glomerular filtration rate <20 mL/min (p < 0.0001), <15 mL/min (p < 0.0001) and <12 mL/min (p = 0.002). When factors influencing survival were stratified for both groups independently, renal replacement therapy failed to show a survival advantage over conservative management, in patients older than 80 years or with a World Health Organization performance score of 3 or more. There was also a significant reduction in the effect of renal replacement therapy on survival in patients with high Charlson’s Comorbidity Index scores. The relative risk of an acute hospital admission (renal replacement therapy vs conservative management) was 1.6 (p < 0.05; 95% confidence interval = 1.14–2.13). A total of 47% of conservative management patients died in hospital, compared to 69% undergoing renal replacement therapy (Renal Registry data). Seventy-six percent of the conservative management group accessed community palliative care services compared to 0% of renal replacement therapy patients. Conclusions: For patients aged over 80 years, with a poor performance status or high co-morbidity scores, the survival advantage of renal replacement therapy over conservative management was lost at all levels of disease severity. Those accessing a conservative management pathway had greater access to palliative care services and were less likely to be admitted to or die in hospital.

Serum aminoacylase-1 is a novel biomarker with potential prognostic utility for long-term outcome in patients with delayed graft function following renal transplantation

Early identification and prognostic stratification of delayed graft function following renal transplantation has significant potential to improve outcome. Mass spectrometry analysis of serum samples, before and on day 2 post transplant from five patients with delayed graft function and five with an uncomplicated transplant, identified aminoacylase-1 (ACY-1) as a potential outcome biomarker. Following assay development, analysis of longitudinal samples from an initial validation cohort of 55 patients confirmed that the ACY-1 level on day 1 or 2 was a moderate predictor of delayed graft function, similar to serum creatinine, complementing the strongest predictor cystatin C. A further validation cohort of 194 patients confirmed this association with area under ROC curves (95% CI) for day 1 serum (138 patients) of 0.74 (0.67–0.85) for ACY-1, 0.9 (0.84–0.95) for cystatin C, and 0.93 (0.88–0.97) for both combined. Significant differences in serum ACY-1 levels were apparent between delayed, slow, and immediate graft function. Analysis of long-term follow-up for 54 patients with delayed graft function showed a highly significant association between day 1 or 3 serum ACY-1 and dialysis-free survival, mainly associated with the donor–brain–dead transplant type. Thus, proteomic analysis provides novel insights into the potential clinical utility of serum ACY-1 levels immediately post transplantation, enabling subdivision of patients with delayed graft function in terms of long-term outcome. Our study requires independent confirmation.

Upregulation of Hic-5 in glomerulosclerosis and its regulation of mesangial cell apoptosis

Glomerulosclerosis is characterized by the loss of glomerular cells by apoptosis and deposition of collagen type I into the normal collagen IV-containing mesangial matrix. We sought to determine the alterations that might contribute to these changes by performing proteomic analysis of rat mesangial cell lysates comparing cells cultured on normal collagen type IV to those grown on abnormal collagen type I surfaces. Subculture on collagen type I was associated with changed expression of several proteins, including a significant upregulation of the paxillin-like LIM protein, hydrogen-peroxide-induced clone 5 (Hic-5), and increased the susceptibility of the cells to apoptosis in response to physiological triggers. When we knocked down Hic-5 (using siRNA), we found mesangial cells grown on collagen type I were protected from apoptosis to the same degree as untreated cells grown on collagen type IV. Further we found that the level of Hic-5 in vivo was almost undetectable in control rats but increased dramatically in the glomerular mesangium of remnant kidneys 90 and 120 days after subtotal nephrectomy. This induction of Hic-5 paralleled the upregulation of mesangial collagen type I expression and glomerular cell apoptosis. Our results suggest that Hic-5 is pivotal in mediating the response of mesangial cells to attachment on abnormal extracellular matrix during glomerular scarring.

Quality standards for predialysis education: results from a consensus conference

This position statement was compiled following an expert meeting in March 2013, Zurich, Switzerland. Attendees were invited from a spread of European renal units with established and respected renal replacement therapy option education programmes. Discussions centred around optimal ways of creating an education team, setting realistic and meaningful objectives for patient education, and assessing the quality of education delivered.

Inhibition of collagen I accumulation reduces glomerulosclerosis by a Hic-5-dependent mechanism in experimental diabetic nephropathy.

Glomerulosclerosis of any cause is characterized by loss of functional glomerular cells and deposition of excessive amounts of interstitial collagens including collagen I. We have previously reported that mesangial cell attachment to collagen I leads to upregulation of Hic-5 in vitro, which mediates mesangial cell apoptosis. Furthermore, glomerular Hic-5 expression was increased during the progression of experimental glomerulosclerosis. We hypothesized that reducing collagen I accumulation in glomerulosclerosis would in turn lower Hic-5 expression, reducing mesangial cell apoptosis, and thus maintaining glomerular integrity. We examined archive renal tissue from rats undergoing experimental diabetic glomerulosclerosis, treated with the transglutaminase-2 inhibitor NTU281. Untreated animals exhibited increased glomerular collagen I accumulation, associated with increased glomerular Hic-5 expression, apoptosis, and mesangial myofibroblast transdifferentiation characterized by α-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) expression. NTU281 treatment reduced glomerular collagen I accumulation, Hic-5 and α-SMA expression, and apoptosis. Proteinurea and serum creatinine levels were significantly reduced in animals with reduced Hic-5 expression. In vitro studies of Hic-5 knockdown or overexpression show that mesangial cell apoptosis and expression of both α-SMA and collagen I are Hic-5 dependent. Together, these data suggest that there exists, in vitro and in vivo, a positive feedback loop whereby increased levels of collagen I lead to increased mesangial Hic-5 expression favoring not only increased apoptosis, but also mesangial myofibroblast transdifferentiation and increased collagen I expression. Prevention of collagen I accumulation interrupts this Hic-5-dependent positive feedback loop, preserving glomerular architecture, cellular phenotype, and function.

Post-embedding double-labeling of antigen-retrieved ultrathin sections using a silver enhancement-controlled sequential immunogold (SECSI) technique.

In electron microscopy, the post-embedding immunogold technique provides a high degree of resolution and the possibility of quantitation owing to the intrinsic characteristics of the colloidal gold marker. Application of this technique to the subcellular localization of multiple antigens by differential labeling using gold markers of different sizes, or to double labeling using the same primary antibody isotype with serial silver enhancement, has been reported. We have incorporated this double labeling technique into a modified procedure that produces excellent labeling and ultrastructural preservation, even after exposure of ultrathin sections large enough to cover a 300-μm-diameter single-hole grid to hot antigen retrieval solutions and prolonged labeling protocols.

Priority topics for European multidisciplinary guidelines on the management of chronic kidney disease in older adults.

PurposeTo identify and prioritize potential topics to be addressed in the development of European multidisciplinary guidelines on the management of chronic kidney disease stage 3b–5 in older patients.MethodsWe composed a list of 47 potential guideline topics by reviewing the literature, consulting online 461 nephrologists and 107 geriatricians, and obtaining expert input. A multidisciplinary panel of twelve experts then prioritized the topics during a face-to-face consensus meeting, following a nominal group technique structure with two voting rounds. Topics were rated on a 9-point scale ranging from 1 (‘not at all important’) to 9 (‘critically important’).ResultsThe highest rating (median; range) was assigned to ‘Screening and referral’ (8.5; 2.0). Eight topics shared the second highest rating with a median priority score of 8.0 (2.0) and included ‘Starting dialysis or not’ and ‘Accurate assessment of renal function.’ ‘Targets for and treatment of diabetes’ received the lowest rating with (3.0; 6.0).ConclusionsThis joint initiative of the European Renal Association–European Dialysis Transplant Association (ERA–EDTA) and the European Union Geriatric Medicine Society (EUGMS) prioritized the development of guidance on interdisciplinary referral of older patients with chronic kidney disease stage 3b–5. Future guidance will therefore focus on identifying prognostic scores to predict death and progression to end-stage renal disease, as well as accurate tests for assessment of renal function in older kidney patients. This will contribute to more informed treatment decision making in this growing patient population.

Predialysis education in practice: a questionnaire survey of centres with established programmes

BackgroundThere is growing evidence that renal replacement therapy option education (RRTOE) can result in enhanced quality of life, improved clinical outcomes, and reduced health care costs. However, there is still no detailed guidance on the optimal way to run such programmes. To help address this knowledge gap, an expert meeting was held in March 2013 to formulate a position statement on optimal ways to run RRTOE. Experts were selected from units that had extensive experience in RRTOE or were performing research in this field. Before the meeting, experts completed a pilot questionnaire on RRTOE in their own units. They also prepared feedback on how to modify this questionnaire for a large-scale study.MethodsA pilot, web-based questionnaire was used to obtain information on: the renal unit and patients, the education team, RRTOE processes and content, how quality is assessed, and funding.ResultsFour nurses, 5 nephrologists and 1 clinical psychologist (9 renal units; 6 EU countries) participated. Nurses were almost always responsible for organising RRTOE. Nephrologists spent 7.5% (median) of their time on RRTOE. Education for the patient and family began several months before dialysis or according to disease progression. Key topics such as the ‘impact of the disease’ were covered by every unit, but only a few units described all dialysis modalities. Visits to the unit were almost always arranged. Materials came in a wide variety of forms and from a wide range of sources. Group education sessions were used in 3/9 centres. Expectations on the timing of patients’ decisions on modality and permanent access differed substantially between centres. Common quality assurance measures were: patient satisfaction, course attendance, updated materials. Only 1 unit had a dedicated budget.ConclusionsThere were substantial variations in how RRTOE is run between the units. A modified version of this questionnaire will be used to assess RRTOE at a European level.

A pilot study to investigate the potential of mass spectrometry profiling in the discovery of novel serum markers in chronic renal disease.

Purpose: There has been significant criticism of how technologies such as SELDI have been used in biomarker discovery and how the data have been analysed. We initiated a proof‐of‐principle pilot study using SELDI with stringent pre‐analytic and analytical procedures with robust statistical analysis, to determine whether, under such conditions, using different degrees of renal dysfunction as a model, useful data could be obtained.

Continuing education: Preparing patients to choose a renal replacement therapy

SUMMARY Background Patients with progressive chronic kidney disease face a series of treatment decisions that will impact the quality of life of themselves and their family. Renal replacement therapy option education (RRTOE), generally provided by nurses, is recommended by international guidelines Objectives To provide nurses with advice and guidance on running RRTOE. Design A consensus conference. Participants Four nurses, 5 nephrologists and 1 clinical psychologist (9 renal units; 6 European countries) from units that had extensive experience in RRTOE or were performing research in this field. Approach Experts brainstormed and discussed quality standards for the education team, processes, content/topics, media/material/funding and quality measurements for RRTOE. Results Conclusions and recommendations from these discussions that are particularly pertinent to nurses are presented in this paper. Conclusions Through careful planning and smooth interdisciplinary cooperation, it is possible to implement an education and support programme that helps patients choose a form of RRT that is most suited to their needs. This may result in benefits in quality of life and clinical outcomes. Application to Practice There are large differences between renal units in terms of resources available and the demographics of the catchment area. Therefore, nurses should carefully consider how best to adapt the advice offered here to their own situation. Throughout this process, it is crucial to keep in mind the ultimate goal – providing patients with the knowledge and skill to make a modality choice that will enhance their quality of life to the greatest degree.