Anna Kontu

Multiple-Layer Adaptation of HUT Snow Emission Model: Comparison With Experimental Data

Modeling of snow emission at microwave frequencies is necessary in order to understand the complex relations between the emitted brightness temperature and snowpack characteristics such as density, grain size, moisture content, and vertical structure. Several empirical, semiempirical, and purely theoretical models for the prediction of snow emission properties have been developed in recent years. In this paper, we investigate the capability of one such model to simulate snow emission during the peak snow season-a new multilayer version of the Helsinki University of Technology (HUT) snow model. Developed with a single layer, the original HUT model was easily applied over large geographic areas for the estimation of snow cover characteristics by model inversion. A single homogenous layer, however, may not accurately allow the simulation of vertically structured natural snowpacks. The new modification to the model allows the simulation of emission from a snowpack with several snow or ice layers, with the individual component layers treated as in the original HUT model. The results of modeled snowpack emission, using both the original model and the new multilayer modification, are compared with reference measurements made using ground-based radiometers deployed in Finland and Canada. Detailed in situ measurements of the snowpack are used to set the model inputs. We show that, in most cases, use of the multiple-layer model improves estimates for the higher frequencies tested, with up to 38% improvement in rms error. In some cases, however, the use of the multiple-layer model weakens model performance particularly at lower frequencies.

L-Band Radiometer Observations of Soil Processes in Boreal and Subarctic Environments

The launch of the European Space Agency (ESA)s Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) satellite mission in November 2009 opened a new era of global passive monitoring at L-band (1.4-GHz band reserved for radio astronomy). The main objective of the mission is to measure soil moisture and sea surface salinity; the sole payload is the Microwave Imaging Radiometer using Aperture Synthesis. As part of comprehensive calibration and validation activities, several ground-based L-band radiometers, so-called ETH L-Band radiometers for soil moisture research (ELBARA-II), have been deployed. In this paper, we analyze a comprehensive set of measurements from one ELBARA-II deployment site in the northern boreal forest zone. The focus of this paper is in the detection of the evolution of soil frost (a relevant topic, e.g., for the study of carbon and methane cycles at high latitudes). We investigate the effects that soil freeze/thaw processes have on the L-band signature and present a simple modeling approach to analyze the relation between frost depth and the observed brightness temperature. Airborne observations are used to expand the analysis for different land cover types. Finally, the first SMOS observations from the same period are analyzed. Results show that soil freezing and thawing processes have an observable effect on the L-band signature of soil. Furthermore, the presented emission model is able to relate the observed dynamics in brightness temperature to the increase of soil frost.

Simulation of Spaceborne Microwave Radiometer Measurements of Snow Cover Using In Situ Data and Brightness Temperature Modeling

The Helsinki University of Technology (HUT) snow emission model is used to calculate the time series of brightness temperature of snow-covered sparsely forested area for the winter 2006-2007. Brightness temperature simulations that apply in situ observed physical parameters as input are compared with the Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer for Earth Observing System (AMSR-E) observations. Three models for the extinction coefficient of snow and the statistical and physical atmospheric models are compared. Simulation results are presented with full in situ data set and only air temperature and snow depth (SD) as input data. The obtained results indicate that the extinction coefficient model of Hallikainen originally used with the HUT snow emission model is the best suited for the Finnish snow data set used in this paper and also on frequencies which are outside the original range of the extinction coefficient model. The simulation results obtained using only air temperature and SD input data show that the HUT snow model is quite reliable even with a minimal in situ data set. A time series of optimized grain sizes was calculated by minimizing the simulation error. The optimized grain size tended to saturate with large values, and therefore, a new model to calculate an effective grain size was developed. The simulation with the effective grain size as input has lower rms error and higher correlation with AMSR-E data than the simulation with the measured grain size.

SMOS Calibration Subsystem

Interferometric radiometry is a novel concept in remote sensing that is also presenting particular challenges for calibration methods. In this paper, we describe the calibration subsystem (CAS) developed for the Microwave Imaging Radiometer using Aperture Synthesis (MIRAS) interferometer of the Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) satellite. CAS is important for the overall performance of the payload as it calibrates out the differences between the multiple receivers of MIRAS. SMOS is in the final phase of development and is due to launch in 2008.

Differences Between the HUT Snow Emission Model and MEMLS and Their Effects on Brightness Temperature Simulation

Microwave emission models are a critical component of snow water equivalent retrieval algorithms applied to passive microwave measurements. Several such emission models exist, but their differences need to be systematically compared. This paper compares the basic theories of two models: the multiple-layer Helsinki University of Technology (HUT) model and the microwave emission model of layered snowpacks (MEMLS). By comparing the mathematical formulation side by side, three major differences were identified: 1) by assuming that the scattered intensity is mostly (96%) in the forward direction, the HUT model simplifies the radiative transfer equation in 4π space into two one-flux equations, whereas MEMLS uses a two-flux theory; 2) the HUT scattering coefficient is much larger than the one of MEMLS; and 3) MEMLS considers the trapped radiation inside snow due to internal reflection by a six-flux model, which is not included in HUT. Simulation experiments indicate that the large scattering coefficient of the HUT model compensates for its large forward scattering ratio to some extent, but the effects of one-flux simplification and the trapped radiation still result in different TB simulations between the HUT model and MEMLS. The models were compared with observations of natural snow cover at Sodankylä, Finland; Churchill, Canada; and Colorado, USA. No optimization of the snow grain size was performed. It shows that the HUT model tends to underestimate TB for deep snow. MEMLS with the physically based improved Born approximation performed best among the models, with a bias of -1.4 K and a root-mean-square error of 11.0 K.

Evolution of snow and ice temperature, thickness and energy balance in Lake Orajärvi, northern Finland

The seasonal evolution of snow and ice on Lake Orajärvi, northern Finland, was investigated for three consecutive winter seasons. Material consisting of numerical weather prediction model (HIRLAM) output, weather station observations, manual snow and ice observations, high spatial resolution snow and ice temperatures from ice mass balance buoys (SIMB), and Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) lake ice surface temperature observations was gathered. A snow/ice model (HIGHTSI) was applied to simulate the evolution of the snow and ice surface energy balance, temperature profiles and thickness. The weather conditions in early winter were found critical in determining the seasonal evolution of the thickness of lake ice and snow. During the winter season (Nov.–Apr.), precipitation, longwave radiative flux and air temperature showed large inter-annual variations. The uncertainty in snow/ice model simulations originating from precipitation was investigated. The contribution of snow to ice transformation was vital for the total lake ice thickness. At the seasonal time scale, the ice bottom growth was 50–70% of the total ice growth. The SIMB is suitable for monitoring snow and ice temperatures and thicknesses. The Mean Bias Error (MBE) between the SIMB and borehole measurements was −0.7 cm for snow thicknesses and 1.7 cm for ice thickness. The temporal evolution of MODIS surface temperature (three seasons) agrees well with SIMB and HIGHTSI results (correlation coefficient, R=0.81). The HIGHTSI surface temperatures were, however, higher (2.8°C≤MBE≤3.9°C) than the MODIS observations. The development of HIRLAM by increasing its horizontal and vertical resolution and including a lake parameterisation scheme improved the atmospheric forcing for HIGHTSI, especially the relative humidity and solar radiation. Challenges remain in accurate simulation of snowfall events and total precipitation.

The atmosphere influence to AMSR-E measurements over snow-covered areas: Simulation and experiments

In satellite passive microwave measurements, the sky brightness temperature is a function of frequencies, sensitive to parameters such as water vapor content, liquid water (cloud and precipitation), oxygen, hydrometeors and atmospheric temperature. In order to investigate the atmospheric influence to the retrieval of snow parameters quantitatively, firstly, we combined the HUT (Helsinki University of Technology) snow emission model (except the atmosphere parameterization) and an atmosphere model to do theoretical simulation estimations. We indicate that the C and X band atmospheric influence could be ignored, while the atmosphere is a non-negligible absorber and emitter of microwave radiation at frequencies higher than 19 GHz. We also launched a 13-day experimental measurement in winter time over Sodankylä, Finland, with synchronous satellite (AMSR-E) and tower-based radiometer measurements, together with extensive in-situ atmospheric measurement dataset. The evaluation result indicates that the atmosphere plays a relative positive contribution (about 20K for 36.5GHz and 89.0/94.0GHz). The difference between satellite observation and point experiment comparison suggests conducting more physical model work with atmosphere contribution.

Determination of Snow Emission on Lake Ice from Airborne Passive Microwave Measurements

The study focuses on the microwave emission properties of snow-covered lake ice. Lakes typically differ from their surrounding terrain regarding snowpack structure, and thus microwave emission. Ice and water layers beneath the snow also influence the result when compared to frozen ground, decreasing brightness temperatures especially on low frequencies. Estimates of snowpack properties from low-resolution microwave data, such as snow depth or snow water equivalent, are susceptible to these effects. In order to correct for the resulting underestimation, the lake fraction over the area of study as well as the emission properties of those lakes should be known. This could potentially be achieved through the assimilation of modeled estimates of snow-covered lake emissions to satellite data. In this study, a modified HUT snow emission model, including modeled influence from the ice and water layers, is applied to model emission over several lakes in Finland during two winter periods. Input parameters to the model are derived from a large quantity of available ground data. Airborne radiometer data are applied to investigate the quality of the emission estimates. Finally, emissions over several AMSR-E pixels are modeled using fractional lake coverage and available ground data.

Observation and Modeling of the Microwave Brightness Temperature of Snow-Covered Frozen Lakes and Wetlands

Small-scale variability in land cover influences both the snow cover and the microwave response of a snow-covered surface. Since low microwave frequencies penetrate below the snowpack, the differing dielectric properties of soil and water have a significant effect on passive microwave observations and therefore cause errors in the interpretation of snow parameters from satellite data. Here, the brightness temperature of snow- and ice-covered lakes and wetlands is studied using airborne and spaceborne microwave radiometer observations and modeling of brightness temperature from in situ measurements. We aim at assessing the validity of the multilayer Helsinki University of Technology (HUT) snow emission model on lake- and wetland-rich areas and at examining the error from omission of water bodies in the forward modeling of brightness temperature. The results indicate that the model can estimate brightness temperatures of lakes and wetlands with rms errors of 12-28 K and 9-16 K, respectively. The inclusion of lakes in the satellite-scale simulations reduces the simulation error in 52%-100% of the simulated areas at 18.7 and 36.5 GHz. The inclusion of wetlands further improves simulations, resulting in an rms error of satellite scenes of 4-5 K at 18.7 and 36.5 GHz (5-10 K without lakes and wetlands). However, the natural variability of brightness temperature over water bodies is not entirely captured particularly at 10.65 GHz. The inclusion of lakes and wetlands can be used to reduce errors in the forward model and thus increase the accuracy of snow parameters derived from satellite data.

SNORTEX (Snow Reflectance Transition Experiment): Remote sensing measurement of the dynamic properties of the boreal snow-forest in support to climate and weather forecast: Report of IOP-2008

Large discrepancies are observed between snow albedo in Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) models and from satellite observations in the case of high vegetation. Knowledge of the Bidirectional Reflectance Distribution Function (BRDF) of snow-forest system is required to solve the problem. The 3-years SNORTEX (Snow Reflectance Transition Experiment) campaign acquires from 2008 in situ measurements of snow and forest properties in support to the development of modelling tools and to validate coarse resolution satellite products (POLDER, MODIS, MERIS, METOP). The measurement scheme and some first example results are presented from the Intensive Observing Period (IOP) of 2008, which can be decomposed into airborne and ground operations. Multi-temporal BRDF at a metric resolution were acquired from OSIRIS (airPOLDER) onboard a helicopter and from ground with FigiFiGo spectrogoniometer. The same helicopter embarked a pair of UV sensors, pyranometers and a wide-optics camera. Ground component includes exhaustive snow measurements.