Anna Reynal

Versatile Photocatalytic Systems for H2 Generation in Water Based on an Efficient DuBois-Type Nickel Catalyst

The generation of renewable H2 through an efficient photochemical route requires photoinduced electron transfer (ET) from a light harvester to an efficient electrocatalyst in water. Here, we report on a molecular H2 evolution catalyst (NiP) with a DuBois-type [Ni(P2R′N2R″)2]2+ core (P2R′N2R″ = bis(1,5-R′-diphospha-3,7-R″-diazacyclooctane), which contains an outer coordination sphere with phosphonic acid groups. The latter functionality allows for good solubility in water and immobilization on metal oxide semiconductors. Electrochemical studies confirm that NiP is a highly active electrocatalyst in aqueous electrolyte solution (overpotential of approximately 200 mV at pH 4.5 with a Faradaic yield of 85 ± 4%). Photocatalytic experiments and investigations on the ET kinetics were carried out in combination with a phosphonated Ru(II) tris(bipyridine) dye (RuP) in homogeneous and heterogeneous environments. Time-resolved luminescence and transient absorption spectroscopy studies confirmed that directed ET from RuP to NiP occurs efficiently in all systems on the nano- to microsecond time scale, through three distinct routes: reductive quenching of RuP in solution or on the surface of ZrO2 (“on particle” system) or oxidative quenching of RuP when the compounds were immobilized on TiO2 (“through particle” system). Our studies show that NiP can be used in a purely aqueous solution and on a semiconductor surface with a high degree of versatility. A high TOF of 460 ± 60 h–1 with a TON of 723 ± 171 for photocatalytic H2 generation with a molecular Ni catalyst in water and a photon-to-H2 quantum yield of approximately 10% were achieved for the homogeneous system.

Interfacial charge recombination between e(-)-TiO2 and the I(-)/I3(-) electrolyte in ruthenium heteroleptic complexes: dye molecular structure-open circuit voltage relationship.

A series of heteroleptic ruthenium(II) polypyridyl complexes containing phenanthroline ligands have been designed, synthesized, and characterized. The spectroscopic and electrochemical properties of the complexes have been studied in solution and adsorbed onto semiconductor nanocrystalline metal oxide particles. The results show that for two of the ruthenium complexes, bearing electron-donating (-NH2) or electron-withdrawing (-NO2) groups, the presence of the redox-active I(-)/I3(-) electrolyte produces important changes in the interfacial charge transfer processes that limit the device performance. For example, those dyes enhanced the electron recombination reaction between the photoinjected electrons at TiO2 and the oxidized redox electrolyte. In an effort to understand the details of such striking observations, we have monitored the charge transfer reactions taking place at the different interfaces of the devices using time-resolved single photon counting, laser transient spectroscopy, and light-induced photovoltage measurements.

Dynamics of photogenerated holes in undoped BiVO4 photoanodes for solar water oxidation

The dynamics of photogenerated holes in undoped BiVO4 photoanodes for water splitting were studied using transient absorption spectroscopy, correlated with photoelectrochemical and transient photocurrent data. Transient absorption signals of photogenerated holes were identified using electron/hole scavengers and applied electrical bias in a complete photoelectrochemical cell. The yield of long-lived (0.1–1 s) photogenerated holes is observed to correlate as a function of applied electrical bias with the width of the space charge layer, as determined by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. The transient absorption decay time constant of these long-lived holes is also observed to be dependent upon the applied bias, assigned to kinetic competition between water oxidation and recombination of these surface accumulated holes with bulk electrons across the space charge layer. The time constant for this slow recombination measured with transient absorption spectroscopy is shown to match the time constant of back electron transfer from the external circuit determined from chopped light transient photocurrent measurements, thus providing strong evidence for these assignments. The yield of water oxidation determined from these measurements, including consideration of both the yield of long-lived holes, and the fraction of these holes which are lost due to back electron/hole recombination, is observed to be in good agreement with the photocurrent density measured for BiVO4 photoanodes as a function of bias under continuous irradiation. Overall these results indicate two distinct recombination processes which limit photocurrent generation in BiVO4 photoanodes: firstly rapid (≤microseconds) electron/hole recombination, and secondly recombination of surface-accumulated holes with bulk BiVO4 electrons. This second ‘back electron transfer’ recombination occurs on the milliseconds–seconds timescale, and is only avoided at strong anodic biases where the potential drop across the space charge layer provides a sufficiently large energetic barrier to prevent this recombination process.

Electron Transfer in Dye‐Sensitised Semiconductors Modified with Molecular Cobalt Catalysts: Photoreduction of Aqueous Protons

A visible-light driven H(2) evolution system comprising of a Ru(II) dye (RuP) and Co(III) proton reduction catalysts (CoP) immobilised on TiO(2) nanoparticles and mesoporous films is presented. The heterogeneous system evolves H(2) efficiently during visible-light irradiation in a pH-neutral aqueous solution at 25 °C in the presence of a hole scavenger. Photodegradation of the self-assembled system occurs at the ligand framework of CoP, which can be readily repaired by addition of fresh ligand, resulting in turnover numbers above 300 mol H(2) (mol CoP)(-1) and above 200,000 mol H(2) (mol TiO(2) nanoparticles)(-1) in water. Our studies support that a molecular Co species, rather than metallic Co or a Co-oxide precipitate, is responsible for H(2) formation on TiO(2). Electron transfer in this system was studied by transient absorption spectroscopy and time-correlated single photon counting techniques. Essentially quantitative electron injection takes place from RuP into TiO(2) in approximately 180 ps. Thereby, upon dye regeneration by the sacrificial electron donor, a long-lived TiO(2) conduction band electron is formed with a half-lifetime of approximately 0.8 s. Electron transfer from the TiO(2) conduction band to the CoP catalysts occurs quantitatively on a 10 μs timescale and is about a hundred times faster than charge-recombination with the oxidised RuP. This study provides a benchmark for future investigations in photocatalytic fuel generation with molecular catalysts integrated in semiconductors.

Dye structure–charge transfer process relationship in efficient ruthenium-dye based dye sensitized solar cells

The characterization of the interfacial charge transfer processes taking place in dye solar cells made using the most efficient ruthenium complexes, namely cis-bis(isothiocyanato)bis(2,2′-bipyridyl-4,4′-dicarboxylato)-ruthenium(II)bis-tetrabutylammonium (N719), tris(isothiocyanato)-ruthenium(II)-2,2′:6′,2′′-terpyridine-4,4′,4′′- tricarboxylic acid, tris-tertrabutylammonium salt (Black Dye) and cis-bis(isothiocanate)(4,4′-bis(5-hexylthiophene-2-yl)-2,2′-bipyridine)(4-carboxylic acid-4′-carboxylate-2,2′-bipyridine)ruthenium(II) sodium (C101), has been carried out. The comparison between these devices shows that devices made using N719 have the slowest recombination dynamics between the photo-injected electrons and the oxidized electrolyte. Moreover, for devices made using Black Dye, the dye ground state regeneration dynamics are faster than for C101 and N719. The implications for future ruthenium dyes are discussed.

Parameters affecting electron transfer dynamics from semiconductors to molecular catalysts for the photochemical reduction of protons

The aim of this work is to use transient absorption spectroscopy to study the parameters affecting the kinetics and efficiency of electron transfer in a photocatalytic system for water reduction based on a cobalt proton reduction catalyst (CoP) adsorbed on a nanocrystalline TiO2 film. In the first approach, water is used as the proton and electron source and H2 is generated after band gap excitation of TiO2 functionalised with CoP. The second system involves the use of a sacrificial electron donor to regenerate the TiO2/CoP system in water at neutral pH. The third system consists of CoP/TiO2 films co-sensitised with a ruthenium-based dye (RuP). In particular, we focus on the study of different parameters that affect the kinetics of electron transfer from the semiconductor to the molecular catalyst by monitoring the lifetime of charge carriers in TiO2. We observe that low catalyst loadings onto the surface of TiO2, high excitation light intensities and small driving forces strongly slow down the kinetics and/or reduce the efficiency of the electron transfer at the interface. We conclude that the first reduction of the catalyst from CoIII to CoII can proceed efficiently even in the absence of an added hole scavenger at sufficiently high catalyst coverages and low excitation densities. In contrast, the second reduction from CoII to CoI, which is required for hydrogen evolution, appears to be at least 105 slower, suggesting it requires efficient hole scavenging and almost complete reduction of all the adsorbed CoP to CoII. Dye sensitisation enables visible light photoactivity, although this is partly offset by slower, and less efficient, hole scavenging.

Improving the photocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO through immobilisation of a molecular Re catalyst on TiO2.

The photocatalytic activity of phosphonated Re complexes, [Re(2,2′-bipyridine-4,4′-bisphosphonic acid) (CO)3(L)] (ReP; L=3-picoline or bromide) immobilised on TiO2 nanoparticles is reported. The heterogenised Re catalyst on the semiconductor, ReP–TiO2 hybrid, displays an improvement in CO2 reduction photocatalysis. A high turnover number (TON) of 48 molCO molRe−1 is observed in DMF with the electron donor triethanolamine at λ>420 nm. ReP–TiO2 compares favourably to previously reported homogeneous systems and is the highest TON reported to date for a CO2-reducing Re photocatalyst under visible light irradiation. Photocatalytic CO2 reduction is even observed with ReP–TiO2 at wavelengths of λ>495 nm. Infrared and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopies confirm that an intact ReP catalyst is present on the TiO2 surface before and during catalysis. Transient absorption spectroscopy suggests that the high activity upon heterogenisation is due to an increase in the lifetime of the immobilised anionic Re intermediate (t50 %>1 s for ReP–TiO2 compared with t50 %=60 ms for ReP in solution) and immobilisation might also reduce the formation of inactive Re dimers. This study demonstrates that the activity of a homogeneous photocatalyst can be improved through immobilisation on a metal oxide surface by favourably modifying its photochemical kinetics.

Measured binding coefficients for iodine and ruthenium dyes; implications for recombination in dye sensitised solar cells

We have measured the binding coefficients of iodine to three dyes used in Dye Sensitised Solar Cells (DSSCs). Binding coefficients are quantified via the effect of iodine binding on the UV-vis spectrum of the dye. From iodine titration curves of dye sensitised TiO(2) films we find that the binding coefficients of iodine to the dyes C101, N719 and AR24 (vide infra) are in the range of 2000-4000 M(-1). From FTIR results and molecular modelling we show the iodine binds to the thiocyanate group in all these dyes. For the AR24 dye we present evidence that iodine also binds to the amine moiety on this dye. With these binding coefficients we show that the dye-iodine complex will be present at much higher concentrations than free iodine in the pore structure of a DSSC. As we have recently shown that iodine (rather than tri-iodide) is the dominant acceptor in electron recombination, the concentration dye-iodine complexes could influence recombination rates and thus V(oc). By comparison of recombination data on full cells, we show that AR24 accelerates recombination by a factor of 7 over N719, presumably due to the iodine binding to the amine group. We leave open the question why iodine binding to the amine group seems to have a stronger effect on the recombination than does binding to the thiocyanate.

Strongly oxidizing perylene-3,4-dicarboximides for use in water oxidation photoelectrochemical cells

Perylene-3,4-dicarboximide (PMI) based chromophores have demonstrated the ability to inject electrons into TiO2 for dye-sensitized solar cell applications and to accept electrons from metal complexes relevant to water oxidation, but they are nearly unexplored for use in photoelectrochemical cells (PECs) for solar fuels generation. A series of related PMIs with high oxidation potentials and carboxylate binding groups was synthesized and investigated for this purpose. Charge injection and recombination dynamics were measured using transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy on the picosecond to second timescales. The dynamics and electron injection yields were correlated with the PMI energetics and structures. Injection began in less than 1 ps for the dye with the best performance and a significant charge-separated state yield remained at long times. Finally, this chromophore was used to oxidize a covalently bound water oxidation precatalyst following electron injection into TiO2 to demonstrate the utility of the dyes for use in PECs.

Unravelling the pH-dependence of a molecular photocatalytic system for hydrogen production

Photocatalytic systems for the reduction of aqueous protons are strongly pH-dependent, but the origin of this dependency is still not fully understood. We have studied the effect of different degrees of acidity on the electron transfer dynamics and catalysis taking place in a homogeneous photocatalytic system composed of a phosphonated ruthenium tris(bipyridine) dye (RuP) and a nickel bis(diphosphine) electrocatalyst (NiP) in an aqueous ascorbic acid solution. Our approach is based on transient absorption spectroscopy studies of the efficiency of photo-reduction of RuP and NiP correlated with pH-dependent photocatalytic H2 production and the degree of catalyst protonation. The influence of these factors results in an observed optimum photoactivity at pH 4.5 for the RuP–NiP system. The electron transfer from photo-reduced RuP to NiP is efficient and independent of the pH value of the medium. At pH <4.5, the efficiency of the system is limited by the yield of RuP photo-reduction by the sacrificial electron donor, ascorbic acid. At pH >4.5, the efficiency of the system is limited by the poor protonation of NiP, which inhibits its ability to reduce protons to hydrogen. We have therefore developed a rational strategy utilising transient absorption spectroscopy combined with bulk pH titration, electrocatalytic and photocatalytic experiments to disentangle the complex pH-dependent activity of the homogenous RuP–NiP photocatalytic system, which can be widely applied to other photocatalytic systems.