Anne-Frances Miller

Superoxide dismutases: ancient enzymes and new insights.

Superoxide dismutases (SODs) catalyze the de toxification of superoxide. SODs therefore acquired great importance as O2 became prevalent following the evolution of oxygenic photosynthesis. Thus the three forms of SOD provide intriguing insights into the evolution of the organisms and organelles that carry them today. Although ancient organisms employed Fe‐dependent SODs, oxidation of the environment made Fe less bio‐available, and more dangerous. Indeed, modern lineages make greater use of homologous Mn‐dependent SODs. Our studies on the Fe‐substituted MnSOD of Escherichia coli, as well as redox tuning in the FeSOD of E. coli shed light on how evolution accommodated differences between Fe and Mn that would affect SOD performance, in SOD proteins whose activity is specific to one or other metal ion.

Superoxide dismutases and superoxide reductases.

Superoxide, O2•–, is formed in all living organisms that come in contact with air, and, depending upon its biological context, it may act as a signaling agent, a toxic species, or a harmless intermediate that decomposes spontaneously. Its levels are limited in vivo by two different types of enzymes, superoxide reductase (SOR) and superoxide dismutase (SOD). Although superoxide has long been an important factor in evolution, it was not so when life first emerged on Earth at least 3.5 billion years ago. At that time, the early biosphere was highly reducing and lacking in any significant concentrations of dioxygen (O2), very different from what it is today. Consequently, there was little or no O2•– and therefore no reason for SOR or SOD enzymes to evolve. Instead, the history of biological O2•– probably commences somewhere around 2.4 billion years ago, when the biosphere started to experience what has been termed the “Great Oxidation Event”, a transformation driven by the increase in O2 levels, formed by cyanobacteria as a product of oxygenic photosynthesis.1 The rise of O2 on Earth caused a reshaping of existing metabolic pathways, and it triggered the development of new ones.2 Its appearance led to the formation of the so-called “reactive oxygen species” (ROS), for example, superoxide, hydrogen peroxide, and hydroxyl radical, and to a need for antioxidant enzymes and other antioxidant systems to protect against the growing levels of oxidative damage to living systems. Dioxygen is a powerful four-electron oxidizing agent, and the product of this reduction is water. 1 When O2 is reduced in four sequential one-electron steps, the intermediates formed are the three major ROS, that is, O2•–, H2O2, and HO•. 2 3 4 5 Each of these intermediates is a potent oxidizing agent. The consequences of their presence to early life must have been an enormous evolutionary challenge. In the case of superoxide, we find the SOD and SOR enzymes to be widely distributed throughout current living organisms, both aerobic and anaerobic, suggesting that, from the start of the rise of O2 on Earth, the chemistry of superoxide has been an important factor during evolution. The SORs and three very different types of SOD enzymes are redox-active metalloenzymes that have evolved entirely independently from one another for the purpose of lowering superoxide concentrations. SORs catalyze the one-electron reduction of O2•– to give H2O2, a reaction requiring two protons per superoxide reacted as well as an external reductant to provide the electron (eq 6). SODs catalyze the disproportionation of superoxide to give O2 and H2O2, a reaction requiring one proton per superoxide reacted, but no external reductant (eq 7). 6 7 All of the SOR enzymes contain only iron, while the three types of SODs are the nickel-containing SODs (NiSOD), the iron- or manganese-containing SODs (FeSOD and MnSOD), and the copper- and zinc-containing SODs (CuZnSOD). Although the structures and other properties of these four types of metalloenzymes are quite different, they all share several characteristics, including the ability to react rapidly and selectively with the small anionic substrate O2•–. Consequently, there are some striking similarities between these otherwise dissimilar enzymes, many of which can be explained by considering the nature of the chemical reactivity of O2•– (see below). Numerous valuable reviews describing the SOD and SOR enzymes have appeared over the years, but few have covered and compared all four classes of these enzymes, as we attempt to do here. Thus, the purpose of this Review is to describe, compare, and contrast the properties of the SOR and the four SOD enzymes; to summarize what is known about their evolutionary pathways; and to analyze the properties of these enzymes in light of what is known of the inherent chemical reactivity of superoxide.

A GUIDE TO ELECTRON PARAMAGNETIC RESONANCE SPECTROSCOPY OF PHOTOSYSTEM II MEMBRANES

This guide is intended to aid in the detection and identification of paramagnetic species in Photosystem II membranes, by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. The spectral features and occurrence of each of the electron paramagnetic resonance signals from Photosystem II are discussed, in relation to the nature of the moiety giving rise to the signal and the role of that species in photosynthetic electron transport. Examples of most of the signals discussed are shown. The electron paramagnetic resonance signals produced by the cytochrome b6f and Photosystem I complexes, as well as the signals from other common contaminants, are also reviewed. Furthermore, references to seminal experiments on bacterial reaction centers are included. By reviewing both the spectroscopic and biochemical bases for the electron paramagnetic resonance signals of the cofactors that mediate photosynthetic electron transport, this paper provides an introduction to the use and interpretation of electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy in the study of Photosystem II.

Synthesis and Structural Characterization of Crystalline Nonacenes

these linearly fused hydro-carbons have made significant contributions to the under-standing of electronic processes in organic semiconductors.Despite the utility of these compounds, the selection ofmaterials suitable for exploration essentially stops at penta-cene. Although numerous studies have predicted enticingelectronic properties for larger acenes,

Structures of nitroreductase in three states: effects of inhibitor binding and reduction.

The crystal structure of the nitroreductase enzyme from Enterobacter cloacae has been determined for the oxidized form in separate complexes with benzoate and acetate inhibitors and for the two-electron reduced form. Nitroreductase is a member of a group of enzymes that reduce a broad range of nitroaromatic compounds and has potential uses in chemotherapy and bioremediation. The monomers of the nitroreductase dimer adopt an α+β fold and together bind two flavin mononucleotide prosthetic groups at the dimer interface. In the oxidized enzyme, the flavin ring system adopts a strongly bent (16°) conformation, and the bend increases (25°) in the reduced form of the enzyme, roughly the conformation predicted for reduced flavin free in solution. Because free oxidized flavin is planar, the induced bend in the oxidized enzyme may favor reduction, and it may also account for the characteristic inability of the enzyme to stabilize the one electron-reduced semiquinone flavin, which is also planar. Both inhibitors bind over the pyrimidine and central rings of the flavin in partially overlapping sites. Comparison of the two inhibitor complexes shows that a portion of helix H6 can flex to accommodate the differently sized inhibitors suggesting a mechanism for accommodating varied substrates.

Redox tuning over almost 1 V in a structurally conserved active site: lessons from Fe-containing superoxide dismutase.

Metalloenzymes catalyze some of the most demanding reactions in biochemistry, thereby enabling organisms to extract energy from redox reactions and utilize inorganic starting materials such as N 2 and CH 4. Bound metal ions bring to enzymes greater chemical versatility and reactivity than would be possible from amino acids alone. However the host proteins must control this broad reactivity, activating the metal for the intended reaction while excluding the rest of its chemical repertoire. To this end, metalloproteins must control the metal ion reduction midpoint potential ( E m), because the E m determines what redox reactions are possible. We have documented potent redox tuning in Fe- and Mn-containing superoxide dismutases (FeSODs and MnSODs), and manipulated it to generate FeSOD variants with E ms spanning 900 mV (21 kcal/mol or 87 kJ/mol) with retention of overall structure. This achievement demonstrates possibilities and strategies with great promise for efforts to design or modify catalytic metal sites. FeSODs and MnSODs oxidize and reduce superoxide in alternating reactions that are coupled to proton transfer, wherein the metal site is believed to cycle between M3+ x OH- and M2+ x OH2 (M = Fe or Mn). Thus the E m reflects the ease both of reducing the metal ion and of protonating the coordinated solvent molecule. Moreover similar E ms are achieved by Fe-specific and Mn-specific SODs despite the very different intrinsic E(m)s of high-spin Fe3+/2+ and Mn3+/2+. We provide evidence that E(m) depression by some 300 mV can be achieved via a key enforced H-bond that appears able to disfavor proton acquisition by coordinated solvent. Based on 15N-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), stronger H-bond donation to coordinated solvent can explain the greater redox depression achieved by the Mn-specific SOD protein compared with the Fe-specific protein. Furthermore, by manipulating the strength and polarity of this one H-bond, with comparatively minor perturbation to active site atomic and electronic structure, we succeeded in raising the E m of FeSOD by more than 660 mV, apparently by a combination of promoting protonation of coordinated solvent and providing an energetically favorable source of a redox-coupled proton. These studies have combined the use of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), NMR, magnetic circular dichroism (MCD), and optical spectrophotometry to characterize the electronic structures of the various metal sites, with complementary density functional theoretical (DFT) calculations, NMR spectroscopy, and X-ray crystallography to define the protein structures and protonation states. Overall, we have generated structurally homologous Fe sites that span some 900 mV, and have demonstrated the enormous redox tuning accessible via the energies associated with proton transfer coupled to electron transfer. In this regard, we note the possible significance of coordinated solvent molecules in numerous biological redox-active metal sites besides that of SOD.

Steady-state kinetic mechanism, stereospecificity, substrate and inhibitor specificity of Enterobacter cloacae nitroreductase

Enterobacter cloacae nitroreductase (NR) is a flavoprotein which catalyzes the pyridine nucleotide-dependent reduction of nitroaromatics. Initial velocity and inhibition studies have been performed which establish unambiguously a ping-pong kinetic mechanism. NADH oxidation proceeds stereospecifically with the transfer of the pro-R hydrogen to the enzyme and the amide moiety of the nicotinamide appears to be the principal mediator of the interaction between NR and NADH. 2,4-Dinitrotoluene is the most efficient oxidizing substrate examined, with a kcat/KM an order of magnitude higher than those of p-nitrobenzoate, FMN, FAD or riboflavin. Dicoumarol is a potent inhibitor competitive vs. NADH with a Ki of 62 nM. Several compounds containing a carboxyl group are also competitive inhibitors vs. NADH. Yonetani-Theorell analysis of dicoumarol and acetate inhibition indicates that their binding is mutually exclusive, which suggests that the two inhibitors bind to the same site on the enzyme. NAD+ does not exhibit product inhibition and in the absence of an electron acceptor, no isotope exchange between NADH and 32P-NAD+ could be detected. NR catalyzes the 4-electron reduction of nitrobenzene to hydroxylaminobenzene with no optically detectable net formation of the putative two-electron intermediate nitrosobenzene.

Peroxynitrite Mediates Active Site Tyrosine Nitration in Manganese Superoxide Dismutase. Evidence of a Role for the Carbonate Radical Anion

Protein tyrosine nitration has been observed in a variety of human diseases associated with oxidative stress, such as inflammatory, neurodegenerative, and cardiovascular conditions. However, the pathways leading to nitration of tyrosine residues are still unclear. Recent studies have shown that peroxynitrite (PN), produced by the reaction of superoxide and nitric oxide, can lead to protein nitration and inactivation. Tyrosine nitration may also be mediated by nitrogen dioxide produced by the oxidation of nitrite by peroxidases. Manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD), which plays a critical role in cellular defense against oxidative stress by decomposing superoxide within mitochondria, is nitrated and inactivated under pathological conditions. In this study, MnSOD is shown to catalyze PN-mediated self-nitration. Direct, spectroscopic observation of the kinetics of PN decay and nitrotyrosine formation (k(cat) = 9.3 × 10(2) M(-1) s(-1)) indicates that the mechanism involves redox cycling between Mn(2+) and Mn(3+), similar to that observed with superoxide. Distinctive patterns of tyrosine nitration within MnSOD by various reagents were revealed and quantified by MS/MS analysis of MnSOD trypsin digest peptides. These analyses showed that three of the seven tyrosine residues of MnSOD (Tyr34, Tyr9, and Tyr11) were the most susceptible to nitration and that the relative amounts of nitration of these residues varied widely depending upon the nature of the nitrating agent. Notably, nitration mediated by PN, in both the presence and absence of CO2, resulted in nitration of the active site tyrosine, Tyr34, while nitration by freely diffusing nitrogen dioxide led to surface nitration at Tyr9 and Tyr11. Flux analysis of the nitration of Tyr34 by PN-CO2 showed that the nitration rate coincided with the kinetics of the reaction of PN with CO2. These kinetics and the 20-fold increase in the efficiency of tyrosine nitration in the presence of CO2 suggest a specific role for the carbonate radical anion (•CO3(-)) in MnSOD nitration by PN. We also observed that the nitration of Tyr34 caused inactivation of the enzyme, while nitration of Tyr9 and Tyr11 did not interfere with the superoxide dismutase activity. The loss of MnSOD activity upon Tyr34 nitration implies that the responsible reagent in vivo is peroxynitrite, acting either directly or through the action of •CO3(-).

Proton-coupled electron transfer in Fe-superoxide dismutase and Mn-superoxide dismutase

Fe-containing superoxide dismutase (FeSOD) and MnSOD are widely assumed to employ the same catalytic mechanism. However this has not been completely tested. In 1985, Bull and Fee showed that FeSOD took up a proton upon reduction [J. Am. Chem. Soc. 107 (1985) 3295]. We now demonstrate that MnSOD incorporates the same crucial coupling between electron transfer and proton transfer. The redox-coupled H(+) acceptor has been presumed to be the coordinated solvent molecule, in both FeSOD and MnSOD, however this is very difficult to test experimentally. We have now examined the most plausible alternative: that Tyr34 accepts a proton upon SOD reduction. We report specific incorporation of 13C in the C(zeta) positions of Tyr residues, assignment of the C(zeta) signal of Tyr34 in each of oxidized FeSOD and MnSOD, and direct NMR observations showing that in both cases, Tyr34 is in the neutral protonated state. Thus Tyr34 cannot accept a proton upon SOD reduction, and coordinated solvent is concluded to be the redox-coupled H(+) acceptor instead, in both FeSOD and MnSOD. We have also confirmed by direct 13C observation that the pK of 8.5 of reduced FeSOD corresponds to deprotonation of Tyr34. This work thus provides experimental proof of important commonalities between the detailed mechanisms of FeSOD and MnSOD.

1H dynamic nuclear polarization based on an endogenous radical.

We demonstrate a 15-fold enhancement of solid-state NMR signals via dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) based on a stable, naturally occurring radical in a protein: the flavin mononucleotide (FMN) semiquinone of flavodoxin. The line width of flavodoxins EPR signal suggests that the dominant DNP mechanism is the solid effect, consistent with the field-dependent DNP enhancement profile. The magnitude of the enhancement as well as the bulk-polarization build-up time constant (τ(B)) with which it develops are dependent on the isotopic composition of the protein. Deuteration of the protein to 85% increased the nuclear longitudinal relaxation time T(1n) and τ(B) by factors of five and seven, respectively. Slowed dissipation of polarization can explain the 2-fold higher maximal enhancement than that obtained in proteated protein, based on the endogenous semiquinone. In contrast, the long τ(B) of TOTAPOL-based DNP in nonglassy samples was not accompanied by a similarly important long T(1n), and in this case the enhancement was greatly reduced. The low concentrations of radicals occurring naturally in biological systems limit the magnitude of DNP enhancement that is attainable by this means. However, our enhancement factors of up to 15 can nonetheless make an important difference to the feasibility of applying solid-state NMR to biochemical systems. We speculate that DNP based on endogenous radicals may facilitate MAS NMR characterization of biochemical complexes and even organelles, and could also serve as a source of additional structural and physiological information.