Anne H. Delcour

Outer membrane permeability and antibiotic resistance

To date most antibiotics are targeted at intracellular processes, and must be able to penetrate the bacterial cell envelope. In particular, the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria provides a formidable barrier that must be overcome. There are essentially two pathways that antibiotics can take through the outer membrane: a lipid-mediated pathway for hydrophobic antibiotics, and general diffusion porins for hydrophilic antibiotics. The lipid and protein compositions of the outer membrane have a strong impact on the sensitivity of bacteria to many types of antibiotics, and drug resistance involving modifications of these macromolecules is common. This review will describe the molecular mechanisms for permeation of antibiotics through the outer membrane, and the strategies that bacteria have deployed to resist antibiotics by modifications of these pathways.

Complex Inhibition of OmpF and OmpC Bacterial Porins by Polyamines

The effects of four polyamines (putrescine, cadaverine, spermidine, and spermine) on the activity of bacterial porins OmpC and OmpF were investigated by electrophysiology. Membrane vesicles made from the outer membrane of Escherichia colistrains expressing only OmpC or OmpF were reconstituted into liposomes probed by patch clamp. The channel activity was recorded in control solutions and in the presence of increasing concentrations of a specific polyamine. In all cases, concentration- and voltage-dependent inhibitory effects were observed. They include both the suppression of channel openings and the enhancement of channel closures as well as the promotion of blocked or inactivated states. OmpF and OmpC, although highly homologous, have distinct sensitivities to modulation, especially by spermine. This compound inhibits OmpF in the nanomolar range, which is in agreement with its potency on eukaryotic channels. Putrescine was the least effective (upper millimolar range) and also had inhibitory effects qualitatively distinct from those exerted by the other polyamines. The compounds appear to bind to at least two distinct binding sites, one of which resides within the pore. The potencies to this site are lower when the polyamines are applied from the extracellular side than from the periplasmic side, suggesting an asymmetric binding site.

Vibrio cholerae OmpU and OmpT Porins Are Differentially Affected by Bile

ABSTRACT OmpT and OmpU are pore-forming proteins of the outer membrane of Vibrio cholerae, a pathogen that colonizes the intestine and produces cholera. Expression of the ompU and ompT genes is under the regulation of ToxR, a transmembrane transcriptional activator that also controls expression of virulence factors. It was recently shown that bile stimulates the ToxR-mediated transcription of ompU and that ompU-expressing strains are more resistant to bile and anionic detergents than ompT-expressing cells. In order to further understand the role of the OmpT and OmpU porins in the ability of V. cholerae to survive and colonize the host intestine, we examined the outer membrane permeability of cells expressing only ompU or only ompT or both genes in the absence and in the presence of bile. By comparing various strains in terms of the rate of degradation of the β-lactam antibiotic cephaloridine by the periplasmic β-lactamase, we found that the permeation of the antibiotic through the outer membrane of OmpU-containing cells was slower than the permeation in OmpT-containing cells. In addition, the OmpU-mediated outer membrane permeability was not affected by external bile, while the OmpT-mediated antibiotic flux was reduced by bile in a concentration-dependent manner. Our results confirm that OmpT and OmpU provide a passageway for hydrophilic solutes through the outer membrane and demonstrate that bile might interfere with this traffic in OmpT-producing cells by functionally inhibiting the OmpT pore. The insensitivity of OmpU to bile may be due to its small pore size and may provide an explanation for the resistance of OmpU-producing cells to bile in vivo.

Cadaverine Inhibition of Porin Plays a Role in Cell Survival at Acidic pH

When grown at acidic pH, Escherichia coli cells secrete cadaverine, a polyamine known to inhibit porin-mediated outer membrane permeability. In order to understand the physiological significance of cadaverine excretion and the inhibition of porins, we isolated an OmpC mutant that showed resistance to spermine during growth and polyamine-resistant porin-mediated fluxes. Here, we show that the addition of exogenous cadaverine allows wild-type cells to survive a 30-min exposure to pH 3.6 better than cells expressing the cadaverine-insensitive OmpC porin. Competition experiments between strains expressing either wild-type or mutant OmpC showed that the lack of sensitivity of the porin to cadaverine confers a survival disadvantage to the mutant cells at reduced pH. On the basis of these results, we propose that the inhibition of porins by excreted cadaverine represents a novel mechanism that provides bacterial cells with the ability to survive acid stress.

Modulating Effects of the Plug, Helix, and N- and C-terminal Domains on Channel Properties of the PapC Usher

The chaperone/usher system is one of the best characterized pathways for protein secretion and assembly of cell surface appendages in Gram-negative bacteria. In particular, this pathway is used for biogenesis of the P pilus, a key virulence factor used by uropathogenic Escherichia coli to adhere to the host urinary tract. The P pilus individual subunits bound to the periplasmic chaperone PapD are delivered to the outer membrane PapC usher, which serves as an assembly platform for subunit incorporation into the pilus and secretion of the pilus fiber to the cell surface. PapC forms a dimeric, twin pore complex, with each monomer composed of a 24-stranded transmembrane β-barrel channel, an internal plug domain that occludes the channel, and globular N- and C-terminal domains that are located in the periplasm. Here we have used planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology to characterize the pore properties of wild type PapC and domain deletion mutants for the first time. The wild type pore is closed most of the time but displays frequent short-lived transitions to various open states. In comparison, PapC mutants containing deletions of the plug domain, an α-helix that caps the plug domain, or the N- and C-terminal domains form channels with higher open probability but still exhibiting dynamic behavior. Removal of the plug domain results in a channel with extremely large conductance. These observations suggest that the plug gates the usher channel closed and that the periplasmic domains and α-helix function to modulate the gating activity of the PapC twin pore.

E.coli PhoE porin has an opposite voltage‐dependence to the homologous OmpF

We used patch clamp analysis to compare the electrophysiological behavior of two related porins from Escherichia coli, the anion‐specific PhoE and the cation‐selective OmpF. Outer membrane fractions were obtained from strains expressing just one of these porin types, and the channels were reconstituted into liposomes without prior purification. We show that the orientation of the reconstituted channels is not random and is the same for both PhoE and OmpF. Like cation‐selective porins, PhoE shows fast and slow gating to closed levels of various amplitudes, testifying that the channels visit multiple functional states and behave as cooperative entities. The voltage‐dependence of PhoE closure is asymmetric, but strikingly, occurs at voltages of inverse polarity from those promoting closures of OmpC and OmpF. Both slow kinetics and inverse voltage‐dependence are removed when 70 amino acids from the N–terminal of OmpF are introduced into the homologous region of PhoE. This novel observation regarding the voltage‐dependence of the two channel types, along with published results on PhoE and OmpF mutants, allows us to propose a molecular mechanism for voltage sensing and sensor charge movements in bacterial porins. It also offers new cues on the possible physiological relevance in bacteria of this common form of channel modulation.

Deoxycholic Acid Blocks Vibrio cholerae OmpT but Not OmpU Porin

OmpT and OmpU are general diffusion porins of the human intestinal pathogen Vibrio cholerae. The sole presence of OmpT in the outer membrane sensitizes cells to the bile component deoxycholic acid, and the repression of OmpT in the intestine may play an important role in the adaptation of cells to the host environment. Here we report a novel important functional difference between the two porins, namely the sensitivity to deoxycholic acid. Single channel recordings show that submicellar concentrations of sodium deoxycholate induce time-resolved blocking events of OmpT but are devoid of any effect on OmpU. The effects are dose-, voltage-, and pH-dependent. They are elicited by deoxycholate applied to either side of the membrane, with some asymmetry in the sensitivity. The voltage dependence remains even when deoxycholate is applied symmetrically, indicating that it is intrinsic to the binding site. The pH dependence suggests that the active form is the neutral deoxycholic acid and not the negatively charged species. The results are interpreted as deoxycholic acid acting as an open-channel blocker, which may relate to deoxycholic acid permeation.

Colicins, spermine and cephalosporins: a competitive interaction with the OmpF eyelet.

The L3 loop is an important feature of the OmpF porin structure, contributing to both channel size and electrostatic properties. Colicins A and N, spermine, and antibiotics that use OmpF to penetrate the cell, were used to investigate the structure-function relationships of L3. Spermine was found to protect efficiently cells expressing wild-type OmpF from colicin action. Among other solutes, sugars had minor effects on colicin A activity, whereas competitions between colicin A and antibiotic fluxes were observed. Among the antibiotics tested, cefepime appeared the most efficient. Escherichia coli cells expressing various OmpF proteins mutated in the eyelet were tested for their susceptibility to colicin A, and resistant strains were found only among L3 mutants. Mutations at residues 119 and 120 were the most effective at conferring resistance to colicin A, probably due to epitope structure alteration, as revealed by a specific antipeptide. More detailed information was obtained on mutants D113A and D121A, by focusing on the kinetics of colicin A and colicin N activities through measurements of potassium efflux. D113 appeared to play an essential role for colicin A activity, whereas colicin N activity was more dependent on D121 than on D113.

Molecular basis of usher pore gating in Escherichia coli pilus biogenesis

Significance Gram-negative bacteria use chaperone-usher pathway (CUP) pili to colonize host tissues and mediate biofilm formation. CUP ushers are outer membrane (OM) pore proteins that catalyze pilus assembly and mediate pilus extrusion in a gated fashion to maintain OM homeostasis. Using antibiotic sensitivity and electrophysiology experiments, specific residues of two ushers, FimD of type 1 pili and PapC of P pili, were identified as crucial for proper usher gating. Further, deletion of the P pilus anchoring/terminator subunit resulted in an open usher conformation, indicating this subunit may be a target for antivirulence compounds to potentiate antibiotic treatment. Identification of mechanisms that can be used to increase bacterial sensitivity to antibiotics is crucial for development of novel compounds to fight infections. Extracellular fibers called chaperone-usher pathway pili are critical virulence factors in a wide range of Gram-negative pathogenic bacteria that facilitate binding and invasion into host tissues and mediate biofilm formation. Chaperone-usher pathway ushers, which catalyze pilus assembly, contain five functional domains: a 24-stranded transmembrane β-barrel translocation domain (TD), a β-sandwich plug domain (PLUG), an N-terminal periplasmic domain, and two C-terminal periplasmic domains (CTD1 and 2). Pore gating occurs by a mechanism whereby the PLUG resides stably within the TD pore when the usher is inactive and then upon activation is translocated into the periplasmic space, where it functions in pilus assembly. Using antibiotic sensitivity and electrophysiology experiments, a single salt bridge was shown to function in maintaining the PLUG in the TD channel of the P pilus usher PapC, and a loop between the 12th and 13th beta strands of the TD (β12–13 loop) was found to facilitate pore opening. Mutation of the β12–13 loop resulted in a closed PapC pore, which was unable to efficiently mediate pilus assembly. Deletion of the PapH terminator/anchor resulted in increased OM permeability, suggesting a role for the proper anchoring of pili in retaining OM integrity. Further, we introduced cysteine residues in the PLUG and N-terminal periplasmic domains that resulted in a FimD usher with a greater propensity to exist in an open conformation, resulting in increased OM permeability but no loss in type 1 pilus assembly. These studies provide insights into the molecular basis of usher pore gating and its roles in pilus biogenesis and OM permeability.

Modulation of Vibrio cholerae porin function by acidic pH.

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria contains porins, large pore-forming proteins which allow the traffic of hydrophilic compounds between the external medium and the periplasm. The oral mode of infection of Vibrio cholerae, the agent of cholera, implies that the bacteria must adapt to severe changes in the environment, such as acidic pH and the presence of bile. Because of their localization and the regulation of their expression in response to these external factors, the OmpU and OmpT porins of V. cholerae are thought to be involved in the adaptation of the bacteria to the host environment. Using patch clamp and planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology, we assessed the effect of pH on the channel properties of OmpU and OmpT. OmpT does not show any major modification in its activity between pH 4 and pH 7.2. In the case of OmpU, the effect of acidic pH is manifested by promoting single-step closures, whose duration, frequency and current size increase as pH is lowered, thereby producing a pH-dependent decrease in the channel open probability. Surprisingly, the increase in current size of this single-step closure is not coupled with an increase of the total current through the porin, indicating that the trimeric conductance remains unchanged. This observation suggests that coordinated events take place at the level of the trimer, and various explanations for this peculiar effect of acidic pH on porin gating and conductance are provided.