Anne Marie DeLuca

TOLERANCE OF' PERIPHERAL NERVE TO INTRAOPERATIVE RADIOTHERAPY (IORT): CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES

In our clinical experience combining wide excision and intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT), five patients have developed clinical signs of lumbosacral or sciatic neuropathy within 9 months of receiving IORT to a dose of 20-25 Gy. Three patients showed recovery of nerve function over several months while two patients have shown no recovery and have near complete loss of extremity function. In an attempt to investigate this clinical observation further, the lumbosacral plexus and sciatic nerve of American foxhounds were surgically exposed and received a single dose of IORT ranging from 20-75 Gy. An approximate linear relationship between radiation dose and time to onset of hind limb paresis is found with 19 of 21 irradiated dogs showing clinical signs of nerve injury within an interval of 1-19 months. No recovery of nerve function is seen in these dogs. Histological study of the irradiated nerves demonstrates a loss of nerve fibers, particularly those of the large myelinated type without evidence of vascular occlusion or thrombosis. These studies suggest that peripheral nerve may be a dose-limiting normal tissue in clinical studies of IORT.

Threshold dose for peripheral neuropathy following intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT) in a large animal model

Radiation injury to peripheral nerve is a dose-limiting toxicity in the clinical application of intraoperative radiotherapy, particularly for pelvic and retroperitoneal tumors. Intraoperative radiotherapy-related peripheral neuropathy in humans receiving doses of 20-25 Gy is manifested as a mixed motor-sensory deficit beginning 6-9 months following treatment. In a previous experimental study of intraoperative radiotherapy-related neuropathy of the lumbro-sacral plexus, an approximate inverse linear relationship was reported between the intraoperative dose (20-75 Gy range) and the time to onset of hind limb paresis (1-12 mos following intraoperative radiotherapy). The principal histological lesion in irradiated nerve was loss of large nerve fibers and perineural fibrosis without significant vascular injury. Similar histological changes in irradiated nerves were found in humans. To assess peripheral nerve injury to lower doses of intraoperative radiotherapy in this same large animal model, groups of four adult American Foxhounds (wt 20-25 kg) received doses of 10, 15, or 20 Gy to the right lumbro-sacral plexus and sciatic nerve using 9 MeV electrons. The left lumbro-sacral plexus and sciatic nerve were excluded from the intraoperative field to allow each animal to serve as its own control. Following treatment, a complete neurological exam, electromyogram, and nerve conduction studies were performed monthly for 1 year. Monthly neurological exams were performed in years 2 and 3 whereas electromyogram and nerve conduction studies were performed every 3 months during this follow-up period. With follow-up of greater than or equal to 42 months, no dog receiving 10 or 15 Gy IORT shows any clinical or laboratory evidence of peripheral nerve injury. However, all four dogs receiving 20 Gy developed right hind limb paresis at 8, 9, 9, and 12 mos following intraoperative radiotherapy. These experimental data suggest that intraoperative doses of less than 20 Gy may not result in clinically significant peripheral nerve injury with follow-up of 3.5 years. Longer (5 yrs) follow-up with planned sacrifice of the remaining dogs is scheduled to assess any late peripheral nerve damage.

Evaluation of the hydroxylamine tempol-H as an in vivo radioprotector

Nitroxides are stable free radical compounds that protect against the toxicity of reactive oxygen species in vitro and in vivo. Tempol (Aldrich, Milwaukee, WI, USA) is a cell-permeable hydrophilic nitroxide and has been shown to be an in vitro and in vivo radioprotector. The limitations of Tempol as a systemic radioprotector are that it causes substantial reductions in arterial blood pressure when administered intravenously and is associated with seizure activity. Furthermore, Tempol is rapidly reduced to its hydroxylamine form, Tempol-H, which limits the period of time the active form of the nitroxide is available for radioprotection. Based on initial pharmacological and blood pressure experiments performed in mice, we hypothesized that the systemic administration of Tempol-H in vivo would lead to an equilibration between Tempol and Tempol-H that would limit the toxicity of the nitroxide and provide in vivo radioprotection. Tempol-H was administered in increasing doses via an intraperitoneal route to C3H mice. The maximally tolerated dose was found to be 325 mg/kg. The whole-blood pharmacology of Tempol-H was investigated with electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. These studies demonstrated the appearance of Tempol in whole blood immediately after intraperitoneal injection, suggesting that rapid oxidation of Tempol-H to Tempol takes place in vivo. Although the peak concentration of Tempol in whole blood after administration of Tempol-H did not reach the same levels as those observed when Tempol is administered, the whole-blood levels of Tempol were similar by 10 min after injection. Tempol-H provided protection against the lethality of whole-body radiation in C3H mice at 30 d with a dose modification factor of 1.3, which is similar to the results obtained with Tempol. Hemodynamic measurements in C3H mice after intravenous injection showed that Tempol-H produced little effect on blood pressure or pulse compared with Tempol. Tempol-H is a systemic in vivo radioprotector of C3H mice and is associated with less hemodynamic toxicity than Tempol.

Hemodynamic effect of the nitroxide superoxide dismutase mimics

Reactive oxygen species play critical roles in a number of physiologic and pathologic processes. Nitroxides are stable free radical compounds that possess superoxide dismutase (SOD) mimetic activity and have been shown to protect against the toxicity of reactive oxygen species in vitro and in vivo. Tempol, a cell-permeable hydrophilic nitroxide, protects against oxidative stress and also is an in vitro and in vivo radioprotector. In the course of evaluating the pharmacology and toxicity of the nitroxides, Tempol and another nitroxide, 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL (3-CP), were administered intravenously in various concentrations to miniature swine. Tempol caused dose-related hypotension accompanied by reflex tachycardia and increased skin temperature. Invasive hemodynamic monitoring with Swan Ganz catheterization (SGC) confirmed the potent vasodilative effect of Tempol. However, 3-CP had no effect on porcine blood pressure. The hemodynamic effects of Tempol and 3-CP are discussed in the context of differential catalytic rate constants for superoxide disumation that may impact systemic nitric oxide (NO) levels and lead to vasodilation. These findings are consistent with a role for the superoxide ion in the modulation of blood pressure and have potential implications for the systemic use of nitroxides.

Evaluation of Tempol Radioprotection in a Murine Tumor Model

Tempol, a stable nitroxide free radical compound, is an in vitro and in vivo radioprotector. Previous studies have shown that Tempol protects C3H mice against whole-body radiation-induced bone marrow failure. In this study, the radioprotection of tumor tissue was evaluated. RIF-1 tumor cells were implanted in female C3H mice 10 d prior to radiation. Groups of mice were injected intraperitoneally with Tempol (275 mg/kg) or PBS followed 10 min later by a single dose of radiation to the tumor bed. Tumor growth curves generated after 10 and 33.3 Gy doses of radiation showed no difference in growth between the Tempol- and PBS-treated animals. A full radiation dose-response experiment revealed a tumor control dose in 50% of the animals in 30 d (TCD(50/30)) value of 36.7 Gy for Tempol-treated mice and 41.8 Gy for saline-treated mice suggesting no protection of the RIF-1 tumor by Tempol. Tumor pharmacokinetics were done to determine why Tempol differentially protected bone marrow and not tumor cells. Differential reduction of Tempol in the RIF-1 tumor and bone marrow was evaluated with EPR spectroscopy 10, 20, and 30 min after injection. Bioreduction of Tempol to its corresponding hydroxylamine (which is not a radioprotector) occurred to a greater extent in RIF-1 tumor cells compared to bone marrow. We conclude that the differences in radioprotection may result from enhanced intratumor bioreduction of Tempol to its nonradioprotective hydroxylamine analogue. The nitroxides as a class of compounds may provide a means to exploit the redox differences between normal tissues and tumors.

In vivo radioprotection and effects on blood pressure of the stable free radical nitroxides.

PURPOSE The purpose of this study was to screen several water soluble nitroxides for in vivo radioprotection, to evaluate their pharmacology, and to measure the effect of nitroxides on systemic blood pressure as a means of exploring the mechanism of in vivo radioprotection. METHODS AND MATERIALS A number of water soluble nitroxides were screened for in vivo radioprotection in C3H mice at a single radiation dose. Selected nitroxides were administered by the intraperitoneal route 10 minutes prior to a whole body radiation dose of 9 Gy. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy (EPR) was used to measure whole blood levels of nitroxides. The nitroxides were evaluated for effects on systemic blood pressure in C3H mice. RESULTS All of the nitroxides studied demonstrated radioprotection compared to saline-treated controls. The 6-membered piperidine ring nitroxides including Tempol were reduced to the inactive hydroxylamine rapidly over 10-20 minutes. The 5-membered ring nitroxides were reduced more slowly over time. The 5-membered ring 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL did not produce a substantial decrease in systemic blood pressure after intraperitoneal administration compared to the other nitroxides studied. 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL was further evaluated over a range of whole body radiation doses and was found to provide radioprotection. CONCLUSION All of the nitroxides studied provided radioprotection. In vivo radioprotection for all of the compounds except 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL may be at least partially explained by the induction of hypotension and bone marrow hypoxia. 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL provided in vivo radioprotection similar in magnitude to Tempol and had little effect on blood pressure compared to the other nitroxides. Other mechanisms for radioprotection, including scavenging of free radicals are likely. 3-carbamoyl-PROXYL should be evaluated further as a systemic radioprotector.

Late Effects of Intraoperative Radiation therapy on Retroperitoneal Tissues, Intestine, and Bile Duct in a Large Animal Model.

PURPOSE The late histopathological effects of intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT) on retroperitoneal tissues, intestine, and bile duct were investigated in dogs. METHODS AND MATERIALS Fourteen adult foxhounds were subjected to laparotomy and varying doses (0-45 Gy) of IORT (11 MeV electrons) delivered to retroperitoneal tissues including the great vessels and ureters, to a loop of defunctionalized small bowel, or to the extrahepatic bile duct. One control animal received an aortic transection and reanastomosis at the time of laparotomy; another control received laparotomy alone. This paper describes the late effects of single-fraction IORT occurring 3-5 years following treatment. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION Dogs receiving IORT to the retroperitoneum through a 4 x 15 cm portal showed few gross or histologic abnormalities at 20 Gy. At doses ranging from 30-45 Gy, radiation changes in normal tissues were consistently observed. Retroperitoneal fibrosis with encasement of the ureters and great vessels developed at doses > or = 30 Gy. Radiation changes were present in the aorta and vena cava at doses > or = 40 Gy. A 30 Gy dog developed an in-field malignant osteosarcoma at 3 years which invaded the vertebral column and compressed the spinal cord. A 40 Gy animal developed obstruction of the right ureter with fatal septic hydronephrosis at 4 years. Animals receiving IORT through a 5 cm IORT portal to an upper abdominal field which included a defunctionalized loop of small bowel, showed a few gross or histologic abnormalities at a dose of 20 Gy. At 30 Gy, hyaline degeneration of the intestinal muscularis layer of the bowel occurred. At a dose of 45 Gy, internal intestinal fistulae developed. One 30 Gy animal developed right ureteral obstruction and hydronephrosis at 5 years. A dog receiving 30 Gy IORT through a 5 cm portal to the extrahepatic bile duct showed diffuse fibrosis through the gastroduodenal ligament. These canine studies contribute to the area of late tissue tolerance to IORT.

Tolerance of the canine bladder to intraoperative radiation therapy: an experimental study.

An experimental study of bladder tolerance to intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT) was designed using a large animal model (adult American Foxhounds, weight 25-30 kg) to access acute and late radiation effects. Dogs were subjected to laparotomy where the bladder was mobilized and IORT was delivered using a 5 cm circular cone through a cystotomy incision with 12 MeV electrons. The bladder trigone including both ureteral orifices and the proximal urethra was irradiated in groups of 3 dogs with doses of 0, 20, 25, 30, 35, and 40 Gy. Dogs were followed clinically with repeat urinalysis, intravenous pyelogram (IVP), and cystometrogram at 1 month and then Q6 months for up to 4 years. One dog from each dose group was sacrificed electively at 1 and 2 years, whereas the other dog is being followed clinically for a minimum of 4 years. Complete autopsies were performed with particular attention to genitourinary and pelvic structures. No clinically detectable acute toxicity resulted from IORT to the bladder. Three of 15 IORT dogs (1 each at 25, 35, and 40 Gy) showed obstruction of a ureteral orifice with 2 dogs dying of renal failure secondary to bilateral hydronephrosis within 1-2 years of treatment. The remaining 12 IORT dogs and 3 control dogs have normal repeat IVPs and renal function with up to 4 years of follow-up. Serial cystometry demonstrates no major loss of bladder contractility or volume. At autopsy, histological changes of mucosal thinning and telangiectasia with submucosal fibrosis were confined to the IORT field and appeared dose-related. However, the bladder epithelium remained intact at all doses. The ureterovesical junction in animals receiving 20 Gy showed mild fibrosis of the lamina propria and moderate chronic inflammation. Above 20 Gy, these histological changes at the U-V junction were more pronounced with gross stenosis in 3 animals as predicted by the IVP. We conclude that the bladder trigone will tolerate IORT to 20 Gy without major clinical sequellae. Above 20 Gy, progressive inflammation and fibrosis of the U-V junction resulted in obstructive hydronephrosis in three animals within 1-2 years of IORT. The bladder mucosa remained intact with doses to 40 Gy, although submucosal fibrosis and chronic inflammation were evident and appeared dose-related. However, bladder function as measured by cystometry showed essentially no change with follow-up to 4 years. From this large animal study, IORT for early-stage bladder carcinoma is technically feasible and deserves a careful clinical study.

Response of the mediastinal and thoracic viscera of the dog to intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT)

IORT may be a potentially useful adjunctive treatment combined with surgery and/or external beam irradiation in treating locally advanced lung and esophageal tumors. To begin investigation of this modality, the tolerance of intact mediastinal structures to IORT was studied using adult American Foxhounds (wt. 25-30 kg). Groups of six animals received IORT to doses of 20, 30, or 40 Gy to two separate intrathoracic ports, using 9 MeV electrons to treat a portion of the collapsed right upper lobe, and 12 MeV electrons to treat the mediastinal structures. A group of three dogs received thoracotomy with sham irradiation. Two dogs from each treatment dose group, as well as one sham-irradiated control, were sacrificed electively at 1, 3, and 12 months following IORT. There were no acute nor late IORT related mortalities. Post-operative weight loss was minimal (average 4.5% of pre-operative weight) for all dogs. Serial esophagrams showed no inflammation or ulceration. No cardiac nor pulmonary changes were noted clinically. At autopsy, the irradiated lung showed evidence of acute pneumonitis at 1 month with progressive fibrosis at 3 months and 1 year. Esophageal reactions were minimal, with only two dogs (one 30 Gy and one 40 Gy) demonstrating histologically confirmed esophagitis at 1 month. Tracheal changes were minimal. Cardiac damage was evident in the right atrial tissues. In several dogs, this cardiac damage ranged from myocardial vascular changes to frank ischemic necrosis noted at 1 and 3 months, and dense fibrosis at 1 year. The phrenic nerves showed normal function, but had evidence of perineural fibrosis. The large vessels demonstrated only mild histologic evidence of irradiation. The results of this large animal study suggest that intact mediastinal structures will tolerate small volume IORT to doses of 20 Gy without significant clinical sequellae. Although the histologic changes in the right atrium and contralateral lung are worrisome, no cardiac nor pulmonary problems arose over the 1 year follow-up. Irradiation of the contralateral lung and other sensitive structures can be reduced by careful selection of electron beam energy and use of custom lead shielding.

Delivery of Intraoperative Radiation Therapy after Pneumonectomy: Experimental Observations and Early Clinical Results

Intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) is capable of delivering high doses of radiation to mediastinal structures while sparing lung parenchyma, heart, and other locoregional tissues. A canine model of pulmonary resection and IORT was investigated by performing a pneumonectomy in 15 adult foxhounds followed by 0 cGy, 2,000 cGy, 3,000 cGy, 4,000 cGy. No clinical complications developed in 4 animals in the 2,000-cGy group. However, 2 of the 8 animals given a high dose died of esophageal hemorrhage or carinal necrosis. Esophagitis occurred in 10 of 12 animals, and none of the animals experienced bronchial stump dehiscence. In a limited Phase I protocol, 4 patients with non-small cell lung cancer were treated with resection and 2,500 cGy of IORT to two separate ports encompassing the superior and inferior mediastinum. Two patients experienced life-threatening bronchopleural fistulas, and 2 patients died as a consequence of esophageal problems. One patients had recurrence with brain metastases, and the 1 long-term survivor is free from disease. As opposed to the animal model of thoracic IORT, the clinical study demonstrated major toxicity with respiratory and esophageal morbidity. The therapeutic usefulness of thoracic IORT in the management of lung cancer must be questioned in view of this small but consistent series of patients. Further carefully designed clinical studies using lower doses of IORT are needed.