Anne O. Carter

A COMPARISON OF CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE APPRAISAL INSTRUMENTS

OBJECTIVE To identify and compare clinical practice guideline appraisal instruments. METHODS Appraisal instruments, defined as instruments intended to be used for guideline evaluation, were identified by searching MEDLINE (1966-99) using the Medical Subject Heading (MeSH) practice guidelines, reviewing bibliographies of the retrieved articles, and contacting authors of guideline appraisal instruments. Two reviewers independently examined the questions/statements from all the instruments and thematically grouped them. The 44 groupings were collapsed into 10 guideline attributes. Using the items, two reviewers independently undertook a content analysis of the instruments. RESULTS Fifteen instruments were identified, and two were excluded because they were not focused on evaluation. All instruments were developed after 1992 and contained 8 to 142 questions/statements. Of the 44 items used for the content analysis, the number of items covered by each instrument ranged from 6 to 34. Only the instrument by Cluzeau and colleagues included at least one item for each of the 10 attributes, and it addressed 28 of the 44 items. This instrument and that of Shaneyfelt et al. are the only instruments that have so far been validated. CONCLUSIONS A comprehensive, concise, and valid instrument could help users systematically judge the quality and utility of clinical practice guidelines. The current instruments vary widely in length and comprehensiveness. There is insufficient evidence to support the exclusive use of any one instrument, although the Cluzeau instrument has received the greatest evaluation. More research is required on the reliability and validity of existing guideline appraisal instruments before any one instrument can become widely adopted.

The determinants of breast cancer screening behavior: a focus group study of women in the United Arab Emirates.

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES To explore perceptions, knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about breast cancer and its screening among Emirati national women in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates. DESIGN A qualitative study using focus group methods. SETTING Primary healthcare centers and a community-based womens association in the United Arab Emirates. SAMPLE 41 women, aged 25-45 years. METHODS Four 90-minute focus group discussions exploring perceptions, knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and practices regarding breast cancer were audiotaped, transcribed, translated, and analyzed. MAIN RESEARCH VARIABLES Social and cultural themes related to breast cancer and its screening. FINDINGS Focus group methodology worked well in this setting. The womens perceptions, knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs regarding cancer and screening, together with aspects of the healthcare system and social milieu, appeared to strongly influence the womens preventive practices. Some of these factors had an encouraging effect on the womens practices, and others had a deterring effect. The encouraging factors included feelings of susceptibility, high levels of knowledge in some women, attitudes and beliefs about personal responsibility for health, and a supportive social milieu. Deterring factors included anxiety and fear leading to denial; lack of knowledge about cancer and the screening program; fear, embarrassment, and mistrust of health care; and belief in predestination. CONCLUSIONS Health planners and healthcare providers must capitalize on encouraging factors and minimize deterring factors to optimize breast cancer screening practices among these women. IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING Identifying and accounting for the factors that encourage or deter women in their breast cancer screening practices will help to optimize screening programs.

Quantitative ultrasound of the calcaneus in Arabian women: relation to anthropometric and lifestyle factors

OBJECTIVES To determine factors influencing quantitative ultrasound (QUS) parameters of the calcaneus in a population-based sample of United Arab Emirates (UAE) women, and to compare QUS parameters of the calcaneus for healthy young UAE women with the manufacturers reference ranges for other populations. METHODS All subjects completed a questionnaire on reproductive and life style factors. Height and weight were measured, and body composition was determined by bioelectric impedence. Estimated bone mineral density (BMD), Speed of sound (SOS), broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) and quantitative ultrasound index (QUI) of the right calcaneus were determined by Sahara ultrasound. RESULTS In premenopausal women (n=330), age, weight, body mass index (BMI), lean weight, fat weight, education, age at menarche, and number of pregnancies, correlated significantly with QUS parameters. Multiple regression analysis showed that age at menarche, number of pregnancies, and BMI, were the best predictors of QUS parameters although these factors explained only small amounts of the variance (R(2)=0.05). In postmenopausal women (n=81), age, BMI and physical activity were the best predictors of BUA (R(2)=0.35), SOS (R(2)=0.39), and QUI (R(2)=0.43). Mean estimated BMD, QUI and SOS for healthy young UAE women were significantly lower than the manufacturers reference ranges for U.S. Caucasian, European Caucasian, and Chinese Asian healthy young women of the same age range (P<0.001 for all comparisons). Mean BUA was not significantly different, however. CONCLUSIONS Menopausal status, age, BMI and physical activity are strong predictors of QUS parameters of the calcaneus in Arabian women. Healthy young Arabian women have lower estimated calcaneal BMD compared with the manufacturers reference ranges for other populations.

A clinical trial of chronic care diabetic clinics in general practice in the United Arab Emirates: a preliminary analysis.

Control of diabetes mellitus is a high priority for primary health care systems. One innovative method of diabetes care delivery is the use of structured diabetes care in primary care. This includes the use of chronic care diabetes clinics or mini-clinics operated by general practitioners in primary care. There is limited experience with this model in non-Western settings. This study sought to evaluate a multi-component structured approach to diabetes care in primary care including chronic care diabetes clinics in a newly developed country in the Arabian Gulf. The study design used was a controlled before-after methodology. Three primary health centers were chosen for the intervention with six of the remaining clinics in a Health District being used as controls. A multifaceted intervention was initiated in the intervention clinics composed of chronic care diabetes clinics, a diabetic flow chart, and educational programs for clinic nurses and doctors and patients. The study intervention took place over a period of 18 months with three diabetic outcomes (fasting blood glucose, blood pressure and cholesterol) and adherence to seven diabetes guidelines being compared for the year prior to the intervention and during the last 12 months of the intervention period. Knowledge and satisfaction questionnaires were also administered to intervention and control subjects at the end of the study. In this study, 219 subjects were enrolled (130 males and 89 females). They had a mean age of 51.6 years and a mean of 3.1 years of formal education. Of these 109 were enrolled in one of three clinics that had a chronic care diabetes clinic and 110 were enrolled in one of the six control clinics. Subjects had diabetes for a mean of 7.8 ± 4.8 years and the majority was treated with pharmacological therapy. Baseline characteristics in the intervention and the control clinics were similar with the exception of younger age (p = 0.01) and a trend for more males (p = 0.06) in the intervention clinics. There was a statistically insignificant change noted with the intervention in the three clinical outcomes studied (fasting blood glucose, blood pressure and cholesterol) both in comparison to the control group before and after and within the intervention group. However most changes noted were in the expected direction of improvement; six of the seven guidelines were statistically improved in the intervention group when compared with the control group. Within the intervention group, adherence with five of seven guidelines was also statistically significantly increased with the remaining guidelines showing a trend in favor of improvement (fasting blood glucose measurements (p = 0.07) and urine determinations for protein (p = 0.07)). Knowledge questionnaire scores were similar between the intervention and control groups on completion of the study but 2 of 4 items on a satisfaction scale were statistically significantly higher in the intervention group. The intervention described in this setting was successful in improving adherence to diabetes guidelines and increased some aspects of satisfaction with diabetes care. The intervention did not result in a statistically significant improvement in clinical outcomes but changes noted were in the expected direction of improvement. The significant improvement in adherence to diabetes guidelines suggests that this intervention is a promising model for diabetes care for newly developed countries.

Prevalence and Risk Factors Associated With Obesity in the Elderly in Barbados

This article’s objective is to examine the epidemiology of obesity in the urban elderly population of Barbados. A random sample of adults ≥ 60 years underwent comprehensive interviews and measurement of their weight, height, and waist circumference (WC). Outcomes of interest were obesity (body mass index [BMI] > 30 kg/m2), high-risk WC (men ≥ 102 cm; women ≥ 88 cm), and high risk of disease comorbidity (from BMI and WC criteria). Total, 1,508 persons participated (80% response). Women had higher rates of obesity (31% vs. 11.9%), high-risk WC (61.9% vs. 13.9%), and disease co-morbidity risk (51.1% vs. 17.5%) compared to men. Multivariate regression confirmed female gender as an independent predictor of outcomes (p < 0.001). Other predictors were less consistent: self-reported fair/poor health status and eating two (vs. three) meals daily were associated with obesity, whereas semiprofessional occupation and unmarried status predicted high-risk WC. Obesity is highly prevalent among elderly Barbadians. Public health interventions must target this group, particularly women.

Effect of interpregnancy interval on risk of spontaneous preterm birth in Emirati * women, United Arab Emirates

OBJECTIVE To investigate whether a short interpregnancy interval is a risk factor for preterm birth in Emirati women, where there is a wide range of interpregnancy intervals and uniformity in potentially confounding factors. METHODS A case-control design based on medical records was used. A case was defined as a healthy multiparous Emirati woman delivering a healthy singleton spontaneously before 37 weeks of gestation between 1997 and 2000, and a control was defined as the next eligible similar woman delivering after 37 weeks of gestation. Women were excluded if there was no information available about their most recent previous pregnancy or if it had resulted in a multiple or preterm birth. Data collected from charts and delivery room records were analysed using the STATA statistical package. All variables found to be valid, stable and significant by univariate analysis were included in multivariate logistic regression analysis. FINDINGS There were 128 cases who met the eligibility criteria; 128 controls were selected. Short interpregnancy intervals were significantly associated with case status (P<0.05). The multivariate adjusted odds ratios for the 1st, 2nd, and 4th quartiles of interpregnancy interval compared with the lowest-risk 3rd quartile were 8.2, 5.4, and 2.0 (95% confidence intervals: 3.5-19.2, 2.4-12.6, and 0.9- 4.5 respectively). CONCLUSION A short interpregnancy interval is a risk factor for spontaneous preterm birth in Emirati women. The magnitude of the risk and the risk gradient between exposure quartiles suggest that the risk factor is causal and that its modification would reduce the risk of preterm birth.

Correlation of Quantitative Ultrasound Parameters of the Calcaneus With Bone Density of the Spine and Hip in Women With Prevalent Hypovitaminosis D

Quantitative ultrasound (QUS) of the calcaneus correlates modestly with axial dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Because bone mineral density (BMD) might be influenced by vitamin D status, we assessed the correlation between both techniques in 56 Arabian women, a population with high prevalence of hypovitaminosis D. The speed of sound (SOS), broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA), and estimated BMD of the right calcaneus were determined by QUS. Spine and right hip BMD were measured by DXA scan. The serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25OHD) level was measured by radioimmunoassay. The correlations of QUS parameters (estimated calcaneal BMD, BUA, and SOS) with spine and hip BMD were modest (r = 0.50, r = 0.53, r = 0.41 for the spine and r = 0.54, r = 0.56, and r = 0.46 for the hip, respectively; p < 0.01 for all comparisons), but stronger in postmenopausal women. All postmenopausal women with low estimated calcaneal BMD (T-score pound -1) had a T-score pound -1 by DXA of the spine or hip. Of the 21 premenopausal women with spine or hip T-score pound -1 who had 25OHD measurements, 20 (95.2%) had levels below 50 nmol/L and 12 (57%) had levels below 30 nmol/L. The subgroup with 25OHD < 30 nmol/L had significantly lower spine (p < 0.01) and hip BMD (p < 0.05) than the subgroup with 25OHD >/= 30 nmol/L. QUS parameters were not significantly different between the two subgroups. The QUS and DXA correlated modestly well in women with prevalent hypovitaminosis D. QUS could be used in postmenopausal women with hypovitaminosis D to identify those at risk for osteoporotic fracture.

Use of existing data for public health planning: a study of the prevalence of hepatitis B surface antigen and core antibody in Al Ain Medical District, United Arab Emirates

INTRODUCTION Hepatitis B is of major public health importance. Accurate information on its occurrence, with particular reference to the prevalence of immunity and chronic infection (marked by the presence of hepatitis B core antibody and surface antigen, respectively, in serum), is essential for planning public health programmes for the control of the disease. The generation of marker prevalence data through serological surveys is costly and time-consuming. The present study in Al Ain Medical District, United Arab Emirates, investigated the possibility of obtaining sufficiently accurate marker prevalence estimates from existing data to plan public health programmes. METHODS Two antenatal screening databases, one student serological survey database, one immunization programme database and one pre-marriage screening database containing information on marker prevalence were identified. Epidemiological data were abstracted from these databases and analysed. RESULTS The data showed that the prevalence of hepatitis B surface antigen and the prevalence of core antibody in young citizens in 1998 were approximately 2% and 14% respectively, that any immunization campaign aimed at citizens of the United Arab Emirates should target teenagers as they had the highest risk of acquiring the disease, and that pre-immunization screening of young adults would be wasteful. However, the data did not yield information on the prevalence of hepatitis B surface antigen and core antibody in other population subgroups of public health significance. DISCUSSION While data generated by the study are sufficient to support a hepatitis B immunization programme targeted at teenaged citizens, more accurate data, generated by a well-designed serological survey, would be essential for optimal public health planning.

Purchasing online journal access for a hospital medical library: how to identify value in commercially available products

BackgroundMedical practice today requires evaluating large amounts of information which should be available at all times. This information is found most easily in a digital form. Some information has already been evaluated for validity (evidence based medicine sources) and some is in unevaluated form (paper and online journals). In order to improve access to digital information, the School of Clinical Medicine and Research at the University of the West Indies and Queen Elizabeth Hospital decided to enhance the library by offering online full text medical articles and evidence based medicine sources. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the relative value of online journal commercial products available for a small hospital and medical school library.MethodsThree reference standards were chosen to represent the ideal list of core periodicals for a broad range of medical care: 2 Brandon/Hill selected lists of journals for the small medical library (BH and BH core) and the academic medical library core journal collection chosen for the Florida State University College of Medicine Medical Library. Six commercially available collections were compared to the reference standards and to the current paper journal subscription list as regards to number of journals matched and cost per journal matched. Ease of use and presence of secondary sources were also considered.ResultsThe cost per journal matched ranged from US

Improving hospital food.

3194 to