Antonio Sgamellotti

In Situ Noninvasive Study of Artworks: The MOLAB Multitechnique Approach

Driven by the need to study precious and irreplaceable artworks without compromising their integrity, researchers have undertaken numerous efforts to develop noninvasive analytical tools and methodologies that can provide a chemical description of cultural heritage materials without any contact with the object. The challenge is that artworks are made of complex mixtures, often with heterogeneous and unknown layered materials. Their components must be identified over a range of size scales, from the molecular identification of constituent compounds to the mapping of alteration phases. In this Account, we review recent research in spectroscopic techniques accessible from the mobile laboratory (MOLAB). The lab is equipped with an array of state-of-the-art, portable, and noninvasive instruments specifically tailored to tackle the different issues confronted by archaeologists, curators, and conservators. The MOLAB approach is suitable for studying a variety of objects, from ceramics to manuscripts or from historical wall paintings to contemporary canvases. We begin by discussing issues related to the acquisition and interpretation of reflectance or backscattered spectra from the surface of heterogeneous materials. Then we show how the selectivity needed for the noninvasive identification of pigments in paintings, even in mixtures or in layered matrices, can be acquired by combining elemental information from X-ray fluorescence with molecular and structural insights from electronic and vibrational spectroscopies. Discriminating between original pigments and restoration retouches is possible, even when both comprise similar chromophores, as highlighted in the study of paintings by Jordaens and Raphael. The noninvasive approach permits the examination of a very large number of artworks with a virtually limitless number of measurements. Thus, unexpected and uncommon features may be uncovered, as in the case of a lead pyroantimonate yellow doped with zinc that was discovered by micro-Raman and X-ray fluorescence on an Italian Renaissance majolica. For characterizing binding media, we discuss the strengths and limitations of using mid- and near-FTIR (Fourier transform infrared) spectroscopies supported by a multivariate statistical analysis, detailing the study of organic materials in a wall painting by Perugino and a survey of the painting technique on 18 contemporary paintings by Burri. In Michelangelos David, we show how the noninvasive mapping of contaminants and alteration phases might inform decisions on preventive conservation plans. The multitechnique MOLAB approach overcomes the intrinsic limitation of individual spectroscopic methods. Moreover, the ability to analyze artworks without the need to move them is an invaluable asset in the study and preservation of cultural heritage.

On double vacancies in the core

The energies needed to create different types of double core vacancies as well as the resulting redistribution of the valence electrons are analyzed in comparison with single core vacancies. Numerical results are presented for CH4 and in particular for the molecules C2H2, C2H4, and C2H6. A detailed perturbation theory analysis of the relaxation energies in terms of localized and delocalized molecular orbital pictures is presented. It is shown that the binding energies associated with double core vacancies where each of the two core holes is at a different atomic site sensitively probe the chemical environment of the atoms.

Heterogeneous distribution of metal nanocrystals in glazes of historical pottery

It has been recently shown that lustre decoration of medieval and renaissance pottery consists of silver and copper nanocrystals, dispersed within the glassy matrix of the ceramic glaze. Lustre surfaces show peculiar optical effects such as metallic reflection and iridescence. In many cases, lustre appears overlapped to colored drawings. Here we report the findings of a study on glazes, pigments and lustre of several shards belonging to Deruta and Gubbio pottery of XVI century. The components of glazes and pigments have been identified. Lustre is confirmed to be characterised by silver and copper metal nanocrystals inhomogeneously dispersed in the glassy matrix of the glaze. In the case of lustre overlapped to colored decorations, we found two contradictory cases. The first consists of a lustre surface successfully applied over a blue smalt geometrical drawing. The second consists of a lustre surface, unsuccessfully applied over a yellow lead-antimonate pigment. The yellow pigment hinders the formation of lustre and removes crystals of tin dioxide, normally present in the glaze as opacifier.

FT-NIR spectroscopy for non-invasive identification of natural polymers and resins in easel paintings

In the present study, the analytical strengths and limitations of near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy to non-invasively characterize organic components in painting materials have been investigated. In spite of the increased amount of information available today from advanced modern analytical instrumentations dedicated to cultural heritage, the non-invasive identification of materials belonging to the wide class of organic compounds historically used in paintings is still a challenging task. Near-infrared spectroscopy offers several attractive features that make this technique particularly suitable to this purpose. In fact, it is non-invasive, allows for non-contact measurements in reflectance mode, gives molecular information on complex macromolecules, and can be performed on-site by means of portable devices. First-derivative transformation of reflectance spectroscopic data has been applied to provide a simple and fast way to deduce more information from NIR spectra. This approach has allowed spectral features to be identified that can be useful to distinguish different compounds belonging to the classes of lipids, proteins, and resins. To this purpose, at first, a spectral database of pure standard has been collected. Our analytical approach was then successfully validated on pictorial models reproducing the typical stratigraphy of an easel painting. As final step, the study of a real painting has been attempted and a drying oil, animal glue, and a terpenic natural resin, as well as an earth pigment were clearly identified, as cross-validated by GC-MS analysis.

Theoretical investigation of many dicationic states and the Auger spectrum of benzene

The outer valence double ionization transitions in the benzene molecule have been computed using Green’s functions and the results are discussed in connection with the Auger spectrum of this molecule. It is found that already at low energy the double ionization transitions are characterized by strong correlation effects and the appearance of a very large number of satellite states. The 226 computed dicationic states are analyzed in terms of their energy distribution weighted by their two‐hole components. It is shown that the relative energies of the maxima in this distribution agree with the experimental Auger peaks to within 0.3 eV. These results emphasize the extreme usefulness of the method in the investigation of double ionization spectra of large molecules, which are practically beyond the reach of conventional ab initio approaches.

Many dicationic states and two‐hole population analysis as a bridge to Auger spectra: Strong localization phenomena in BF3

The outer valence double ionization spectrum of BF3 is investigated by computing 100 double ionization transitions with the Green’s function method. The results show that one‐site and two‐site hole localization on the fluorine atoms takes place to full extent and the energy split between clusters of states with similar hole distribution exceeds 10 eV. Double hole localization as a symmetry breaking phenomenon is discussed, pointing out the inherent inability of uncorrelated methods to describe it. A two‐hole population analysis of the dicationic states for the quantitative measure of their localized character is presented. The strong effects of hole localization on Auger transition rates are discussed, showing that the two‐hole population analysis can be used to develop a new statistical approach to the computation of Auger line shapes. Application of this method to the fluorine and boron KLL Auger spectra of BF3 permits, for the first time, an accurate reproduction of the spectral profiles and a complete...

Absorption and emission of the apigenin and luteolin flavonoids: a TDDFT investigation.

The absorption and emission properties of the two components of the yellow color extracted from weld (Reseda luteola L.), apigenin and luteolin, have been extensively investigated by means of DFT and TDDFT calculations. Our calculations reproduce the absorption spectra of both flavonoids in good agreement with the experimental data and allow us to assign the transitions giving rise to the main spectral features. For apigenin, we have also computed the electronic spectrum of the monodeprotonated species, providing a rationale for the red-shift of the experimental spectrum with increasing pH. The fluorescence emission of both apigenin and luteolin has then been investigated. Excited-state TDDFT geometry optimizations have highlighted an excited-state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) from the 5-hydroxyl to the 4-carbonyl oxygen of the substituted benzopyrone moiety. By computing the potential energy curves at the ground and excited states as a function of an approximate proton transfer coordinate for apigenin, we have been able to trace an ESIPT pathway and thus explain the double emission observed experimentally.

Proteomic strategies for the identification of proteinaceous binders in paintings

The identification of proteinaceous components in paintings remains a challenging task for several reasons. In addition to the minute amount of sample available, complex and variable chemical composition of the paints themselves, possible simultaneous presence of several binders and contaminants, and degradation of the original materials due to aging and pollution are complicating factors. We proposed proteomic strategies for the identification of proteins in binders of paintings that can be adapted to overcome the requirements and difficulties presented by specific samples. In particular, we worked on (1) the development of a minimally invasive method based on the direct tryptic cleavage of the sample without protein extraction; (2) the use of microwave to enhance the enzymatic digestion yield, followed by the analysis of the peptide mixtures by nanoLC-MS/MS with electrospray ionization (ESI). Moreover, as an additional tool to tackle the problem of contaminating proteins, we exploited the possibility of generating an exclusion list of the mass signals that in a first run had been fragmented and that the mass spectrometer had to ignore for fragmentation in a subsequent run. The methods, tested on model samples, allowed the identification of milk proteins in a sample from paintings attributed to Cimabue and Giotto, thirteenth-century Italian masters, decorating the vaults of the upper church in the Basilica of St. Francis in Assisi, Italy.

Non-invasive identification of organic materials in wall paintings by fiber optic reflectance infrared spectroscopy: a statistical multivariate approach

The aim of this study is to develop a method for the non-invasive and in situ identification of organic binders in wall paintings by fiber optic mid-FTIR reflectance spectroscopy. The non-invasive point analysis methodology was set-up working on a wide set of wall painting replicas of known composition and using statistical multivariate methods, in particular principal component analysis (PCA), for the interpretation, understanding, and management of data acquired with reflectance mid-FTIR spectroscopy. Results show that PCA can be helpful in managing and preliminary sorting of the large amount of spectra typically collected during non-invasive measurement campaigns and highlight further avenues for research. The developed PCA model was finally applied to the case of a Renaissance wall painting by Perugino assessing it predictability as compared to the interpretation of the single spectrum.

Cyclometalated IrIII Complexes with Substituted 1,10‐Phenanthrolines: A New Class of Efficient Cationic Organometallic Second‐Order NLO Chromophores

Cyclometalated cationic Ir(III) complexes with substituted 1,10-phenanthrolines (1,10-phen), such as [Ir(ppy)(2)(5-R-1,10-phen)]Y (ppy=cyclometalated 2-phenylpyridine; R=NO(2), H, Me, NMe(2); Y(-)=PF(6) (-), C(12)H(25)SO(3) (-), I(-)) and [Ir(ppy)(2)(4-R,7-R-1,10-phen)]Y (R=Me, Ph) are characterized by a significant second-order optical non linearity (measured by the electrical field induced second harmonic generation (EFISH) technique). This nonlinearity is controlled by MLCT processes from the cyclometalated Ir(III), acting as a donor push system, to pi* orbitals of the phenanthroline, acting as an acceptor pull system. Substitution of cyclometalated 2-phenylpyridine by the more pi delocalized 2-phenylquinoline (pq) or benzo[h]quinoline (bzq) or by the sulfur-containing 4,5-diphenyl-2-methyl-thiazole (dpmf) does not significantly affect the mubeta absolute value, which instead is affected by the nature of the R substituents on the phenanthroline, the higher value being associated with the electron-withdrawing NO(2) group. By using a combined experimental (the EFISH technique and (1)H and (19)F PGSE NMR spectroscopy) and theoretical (DFT, time-dependent-DFT (TDDFT), sum over states (SOS) approach) investigation, evidence is obtained that ion pairing, which is controlled by the nature of the counterion and by the concentration, may significantly affect the mubeta values of these cationic NLO chromophores. In CH(2)Cl(2), concentration-dependent high absolute values of mubeta are obtained for [Ir(ppy)(2)(5-NO(2)-1,10-phen)]Y if Y is a weakly interacting anion, such as PF(6) (-), whereas with a counterion, such as C(12)H(25)SO(3) (-) or I(-), which form tight ion-pairs, the absolute value of mubeta is lower and quite independent of the concentration. This mubeta trend is partially due to the perturbation of the counterion on the LUMO pi* levels of the phenanthroline. The correlation between the mubeta value and dilution shows that the effect of concentration is a factor that must be taken into careful consideration.