Arthur H. White

High levels of inflammatory phospholipase A2 activity in lumbar disc herniations.

Inflammation of neural elements is frequently mentioned clinically in association with lumbar radiculopathy. Mechanical embarrassment of neural elements by definable structural abnormalities is inadequate as a sole explanation of nerve injury in this condition. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate whether an enzymatic marker for inflammation (phospholipase A2) could be identified in human disc samples removed at surgery for radiculopathy due to lumbar disc disease. Samples were assayed for phospholipase A2 activity. The level of activity in the disc samples was compared with values obtained from other human tissues using the same assay. Specific activity (percent hydrolysis radiolabelled substrate) ranged from 238 to 1,014.5 nmol/min/mg. Mean activity for the human disc material was 568.7 nmol/min/mg, compared with 0.006 nmol/min/mg for human PMN, and 12.1 nmol/min/mg for inflammatory human synovial effusion. The pH and cation-related activity were identical to those demonstrated for phospholipase A2 inflammatory conditions. Human lumbar disc phospholipase A2 activity is from 20- to 100,000-fold more active than any other phospholipase A2 that has been described. As the enzyme responsible for the liberation of arachidonic acid from cell membranes, phospholipase A2 is the rate-limiting step in the production of prostaglandins and leukotrienes. These data establish biochemical evidence of inflammation at the site of lumbar disc herniations.

Response to steroid and duration of radicular pain as predictors of surgical outcome.

Prolonged structural compromise of spinal nerve roots can lead to chronic changes that surgical decompression might not be able to reverse. In this study, it was hypothesized that if there were a reversible structural pain component, a steroid injected into the patients symptomatic nerve root should provide temporary pain relief and that these patients should have a favorable surgical outcome. It also was hypothesized that duration of radicular symptoms would correlate inversely with surgical outcome. For postoperative relief of radicular pain, the results showed that patients with pain lasting less than 1 year had a positive surgical result (89%), regardless of response to steroid. Patients with pain lasting more than 1 year and who have had a positive response to steroid injected into the symptomatic nerve root (roots) had a positive surgical outcome of 85%. Patients who did not respond to the steroid and had pain for more than 1 year (95%) generally had a poor surgical outcome. Although the poor outcome in the last group might be explained in some cases by an inadequate structural correction, inadequate stabilization, or functional reasons, the majority of these failures represented irreversible changes in the neural structures.

Clinical efficacy of spinal instrumentation in lumbar degenerative disc disease.

In review of 871 lumbar fusion procedures performed during the last 8 years, the theoretical advantages of lumbar spinal instrumentation are not borne out in simple discogenic disease. Four groups of 30–35 patients without previous surgery who underwent fusion by different techniques were matched for age, sex, length of follow-up, surgeons, number of levels fused, duration of prcoperative symptems, diagnosis, and type of third party payer. At least for the diagnoses of herniated disc with segmental instability and the instrumentation systems used in this study, results were superior with no internal fixation. This is in keeping with the higher complication rates and frequent need for implant removal reported by many authers.

Anterior lumbar fusion improves discogenic pain at levels of prior posterolateral fusion.

STUDY DESIGN A descriptive case review. OBJECTIVES To assess the outcomes of anterior lumbar interbody fusion for painful discs within a solid posterolateral spinal fusion. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA Some patients continue to have pain after posterolateral spinal fusion despite apparently solid arthrodesis. One potential etiology is pain that arises from a disc within the fused levels. METHOD Retrospective review of 176 patients with anterior interbody fusion, which located 20 who had anterior interbody fusion levels of prior posterolateral spinal fusion. All had low back pain, solid posterolateral spinal fusion, and painful disc(s) at the posterolateral spinal fusion level(s) but not elsewhere. Pain was measured by the Numerical Rating Scale, function by Oswestry Disability Questionnaire, and patient satisfaction by the North American Spine Society Outcome Questionnaire. RESULTS Follow-up data were available for 18 patients (90%). Mean follow-up was 58 months (25 to 102). There were 10 men and 8 women. Mean age was 45 years (26 to 72). Diagnoses were degenerative discs, herniated nucleus pulposus, spondylolisthesis, and spinal stenosis. Eight patients had injuries after the previous posterolateral spinal fusion that precipitated new symptoms. Two patients had one level fusion, 14 had two levels, and 1 each had three and four levels. Four patients had one prior surgery, 5 had two, and 9 had three or more. All patients had solid anterior interbody fusion by radiograph. Mean Numerical Rating Scale improved from 7.9 before surgery to 4.7 after (P< 0.001). Mean Oswestry Disability Questionnaire improved from 56.3 before surgery to 47.9 after (P = 0.04). Of 15 patients unable to work before anterior interbody fusion, 5 returned to work. Sixteen patients (89%) were satisfied with their results. CONCLUSION Low back pain that continues or recurs after apparently solid posterolateral spinal fusion may be caused by painful disc(s) at motion segment(s) within the fusion. A solid posterolateral spinal fusion may not protect the residual disc(s) from injury. Anterior interbody fusion can provide significant improvements in pain and function and a high degree of patient satisfaction in this clinical setting.

Childhood psychological trauma correlates with unsuccessful lumbar spine surgery.

In a retrospective study of 86 patients who underwent lumbar spine surgery, patients who had three or more of a possible five serious childhood psychological traumas (risk factors) had and 85% likelihood of an unsuccessful surgical outcome. Conversely, in patients with a poor surgical outcome, the incidence of these traumas was 75%. In the group of 19 patients with no risk factors, there was only a 5% incidence of failure. This study shows that a highly significant correlation exists between unsuccessful lumbar spine surgery and a history of childhood traumas. Although recognition of predictors for unsuccessful outcome can be useful in avoiding surgery in patients whose indications for surgery are borderline, the greater challenge is to help the patient who, despite being at high psychological risk for negative outcome, has severe spinal pathology that will likely require surgery. In such cases, psychiatric treatment is critical. In the group of 19 patients with no risk factors, single-level laminectomies and discectomies were performed on 6 patients. The other 13 cases were complex, Involving a combination of repeat surgeries (n = 4) fusions (n = 3), and/or multilevel laminectomies and discectomies (n = 11).

Early results of spinal fusion using variable spine plating system

Seventy-seven consecutive patients underwent application of variable spine plating (VSP) spinal plates between August 1984 and October 1985. Sixty-four percent had previous procedures at the same level or levels operated. Operative Indications were spinal stenosis, segmental instability, unstable spondylolisthesis, herniated disc with instability, pseudarthrosis, unstable fracture, and failed surgery syndrome with evidence of one of the preceding. Overall results showed 30% excellent, 30% good, 34% fair, 6% poor. There were four deep wound infections and 19 patients with one or more broken screws. Screw alignment and the angular relationship of each screw to the spinal plate are considered important technical factors in minimizing screw failure. Vigorous distraction of the vertebrae using interpedicular screws is rarely indicated. Twenty-four patients required reoperation. We feel the procedure is relatively indicated in cases of moderate to severe instability, such as some cases of spondylolisthesis, failed surgery with marked segmental instability, the obese, deconditioned patient, or cases of spinal stenosis rendered very unstable by surgical decompression, and most strongly indicated in unstable lumbar and thoracolumbar fractures.

Normal magnetic resonance imaging with abnormal discography

In degenerative lumbar spine disease, recent studies have supported the clinical usefulness of discography, especially when used with computed tomography (CT) scanning. The role and capabilities of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanning are currently evolving and being defined. This study reviews a series of patients with prolonged disabling symptoms who had normal MRI scans and abnormal discography. Discograms and discogram-CT scans may at times allow detection of clinically correlative and significant pathology (usually annular disruptions) not suggested by MRI scanning. This fact should be considered in patients with normal MRI scanning and continuing unexplained symptomatology.

High lumbar disc degeneration. Incidence and etiology.

Three hundred seventy-nine consecutive magnetic resonance images (MRIs) with dual-echo images of the entire lumbar spine were reviewed by the authors. All 379 patients presented with back pain and/or leg pain; they were interviewed and examined. Pain drawings were completed by all. There were 42 patients (11.1 %) with disc pathologies involving T12–L1, L1–2, and/or L2–3 levels. Six patients (1.6%) had isolated disc degeneration and/or herniations limited only to these high lumbar segments. The remaining 36 patients had degenerative changes of the higher discs with variable involvement of the lower lumbar discs. Out of 12 spondylolistheses of L5 on S1,7 had high disc pathologies at one or more levels presenting as skipped lesions; more severe high disc lesions were noted in Grade II slips. Isolated high disc degeneration is often associated with pre-existing abnormalities such as end-plate defects, Scheuermanns disease, limbus vertebra, and so forth, and stressful cumulative work activities such as in construction workers, airplane mechanics, and so forth. High disc degeneration was noted above or below previous fractures. High disc involvement with diffuse changes in lower lumbar spine was more commonly found in ascending fashion in older age groups, and in patients who have had previous lower lumbar spine surgeries, prior fusions in particular. Our findings suggest that altered mechanics are associated with the high lumbar disc pathologies.

Lumbar Laminectomy for Herniated Disc: A Prospective Controlled Comparison with Internal Fixation Fusion

This is a controlled prospective study on a matched set of patients with herniated lumbar discs. Both groups received the same bilateral lumbar laminectomy and disc excision by the same surgeon. One group had the addition of an intertransverse fusion with internal fixation. Both groups were studied by an independent examiner at an average of 3 years postoperatively for success rate as determined by activity level, medication, subjective and objective evaluation. Both groups had similar age, sex, and occupational characteristics. No patient had prior surgical treatment or chemonucleolysis. Patients with associated lumbar spine problems such as stenosis, instability, or spondylolisthesis were excluded. Each patient had a positive clinical picture for a herniated lumbar disc, as well as a positive myelogram, venogram or computerized tomographic scan. Most had positive electromyograms. All patients received at least 3 months of conservative care. The 38 patients with fusion had a significantly longer mean time to return to work after surgery versus the 31 patients without fusion. Although the general success rate of both groups was 87%, the best results were in the nonfusion group. A total of 29% of nonfusions had excellent results whereas only 11% of the fusion group had excellent results. The conclusion is that fusions are not necessary and give less excellent results in simple laminectomy cases for herniated lumbar disc.

DIPTHEROIDS AND ASSOCIATED INFECTIONS AS A CAUSE OF FAILED INSTRUMENT STABILIZATION PROCEDURES IN THE LUMBAR SPINE

Between February 1985 and October 1987, the authors identified seven patients with occult lumbar spine infections associated with the presence of spinal fixation hardware. Six of these infections were with organisms of low virulence; four of the seven patients had polymicrobial infections. All of the polymicrobial infections contained a Diptheroid as one of the isolates. Two of the seven patients studied had normal sedimentation rates. All had white blood cell counts less than 12,000 cells. Imaging studies were not helpful with the exception of one case with a positive gallium scan. The diagnoses were supported by clinical presentation, pathologic tissue changes, positive cultures, and response to therapy. Successful therapy was obtained by removal of hardware and treatment with antibiotics.