Aurore Carré

FIVE NEW TTF1/NKX2.1 MUTATIONS IN BRAIN-LUNG-THYROID SYNDROME: RESCUE BY PAX8 SYNERGISM IN ONE CASE

Thyroid transcription factor 1 (NKX2-1/TITF1) mutations cause brain-lung-thyroid syndrome, characterized by congenital hypothyroidism (CH), infant respiratory distress syndrome (IRDS) and benign hereditary chorea (BHC). The objectives of the present study were (i) detection of NKX2-1 mutations in patients with CH associated with pneumopathy and/or BHC, (ii) functional analysis of new mutations in vitro and (iii) description of the phenotypic spectrum of brain-lung-thyroid syndrome. We identified three new heterozygous missense mutations (L176V, P202L, Q210P), a splice site mutation (376-2A-->G), and one deletion of NKX2-1 at 14q13. Functional analysis of the three missense mutations revealed loss of transactivation capacity on the human thyroglobulin enhancer/promoter. Interestingly, we showed that deficient transcriptional activity of NKX2-1-P202L was completely rescued by cotransfected PAX8-WT, whereas the synergistic effect was abolished by L176V and Q210P. The clinical spectrum of 6 own and 40 published patients with NKX2-1 mutations ranged from the complete triad of brain-lung-thyroid syndrome (50%), brain and thyroid disease (30%), to isolated BHC (13%). Thyroid morphology was normal (55%) and compensated hypothyroidism occurred in 61%. Lung disease occurred in 54% of patients (IRDS at term 76%; recurrent pulmonary infections 24%). On follow-up, 20% developed severe chronic interstitial lung disease, and 16% died. In conclusion, we describe five new NKX2.1 mutations with, for the first time, complete rescue by PAX8 of the deficient transactivating capacity in one case. Additionally, our review shows that the majority of affected patients display neurological and/or thyroidal problems and that, although less frequent, lung disease is responsible for a considerable mortality.

NKX2-1 Mutations Leading to Surfactant Protein Promoter Dysregulation Cause Interstitial Lung Disease in "Brain-Lung-Thyroid Syndrome''

NKX2‐1 (NK2 homeobox 1) is a critical regulator of transcription for the surfactant protein (SP)‐B and ‐C genes (SFTPB and SFTPC, respectively). We identified and functionally characterized two new de novo NKX2‐1 mutations c.493C>T (p.R165W) and c.786_787del2 (p.L263fs) in infants with closely similar severe interstitial lung disease (ILD), hypotonia, and congenital hypothyroidism. Functional analyses using A549 and HeLa cells revealed that NKX2‐1‐p.L263fs induced neither SFTPB nor SFTPC promoter activation and had a dominant negative effect on wild‐type (WT) NKX2‐1. In contrast,NKX2‐1‐p.R165W activated SFTPC, to a significantly greater extent than did WTNKX2‐1,whileSFTPB activation was only significantly reduced in HeLa cells. In accordance with our in vitro data, we found decreased amounts of SP‐B and SP‐C by western blot in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (patient with p.L263fs) and features of altered surfactant protein metabolism on lung histology (patient with NKX2‐1‐p.R165W). In conclusion, ILD in patients with NKX2‐1 mutations was associated with altered surfactant protein metabolism, and both gain and loss of function of the mutated NKX2‐1 genes on surfactant protein promoters were associated with ILD in “Brain‐Lung‐Thyroid syndrome”.

Linkage and mutational analysis of familial thyroid dysgenesis demonstrate genetic heterogeneity implicating novel genes

The pathophysiology of thyroid dysgenesis (TD) is not elucidated yet in the majority of cases. The unexpected familial clustering of congenital hypothyroidism due to TD suggests a genetically determined disorder. Four genes have been hitherto involved in thyroid development, including migration and growth. Three of these encode transcription factors (the thyroid transcription factors 1 and 2 (TTF1 or NKX2.1 and TTF2 or FOXE1) and PAX8) while the other encodes the thyrotropin hormone receptor (TSHR). Some mutations have been reported in patients affected by thyroid defects, which supports the relevance of these four genes in TD. However, their involvement in the general TD population remains questionable. Therefore, to document their involvement, we performed a linkage analysis followed by mutational analysis in 19 multiplex TD families. The LOD score results failed to prove linkage between any of the four genes and the TD phenotype, whatever the postulated mode of inheritance. Manual extended haplotypes showed allele sharing among affected individuals of at least one of these four genes in the majority of families. Nevertheless, mutational analysis did not identify mutations in these cases, arguing in favor of identity by descent and not identity by state. Furthermore, as a main result of the present study, extended haplotypes confirmed by mutational analysis showed that the four genes were excluded in five out of the 19 investigated families, demonstrating the relevance of other genes. In conclusion, the present study demonstrates genetic heterogeneity in the TD disorder and suggests the involvement of novel genes.

Hes1 Is Required for Appropriate Morphogenesis and Differentiation during Mouse Thyroid Gland Development

Notch signalling plays an important role in endocrine development, through its target gene Hes1. Hes1, a bHLH transcriptional repressor, influences progenitor cell proliferation and differentiation. Recently, Hes1 was shown to be expressed in the thyroid and regulate expression of the sodium iodide symporter (Nis). To investigate the role of Hes1 for thyroid development, we studied thyroid morphology and function in mice lacking Hes1. During normal mouse thyroid development, Hes1 was detected from E9.5 onwards in the median anlage, and at E11.5 in the ultimobranchial bodies. Hes1 −/− mouse embryos had a significantly lower number of Nkx2-1-positive progenitor cells (p<0.05) at E9.5 and at E11.5. Moreover, Hes1 −/− mouse embryos showed a significantly smaller total thyroid surface area (−40 to −60%) compared to wild type mice at all study time points (E9.5−E16.5). In both Hes1 −/− and wild type mouse embryos, most Nkx2-1-positive thyroid cells expressed the cell cycle inhibitor p57 at E9.5 in correlation with low proliferation index. In Hes1 −/− mouse embryos, fusion of the median anlage with the ultimobranchial bodies was delayed by 3 days (E16.5 vs. E13.5 in wild type mice). After fusion of thyroid anlages, hypoplastic Hes1 −/− thyroids revealed a significantly decreased labelling area for T4 (−78%) and calcitonin (−65%) normalized to Nkx2-1 positive cells. Decreased T4-synthesis might be due to reduced Nis labelling area (−69%). These findings suggest a dual role of Hes1 during thyroid development: first, control of the number of both thyrocyte and C-cell progenitors, via a p57-independent mechanism; second, adequate differentiation and endocrine function of thyrocytes and C-cells.

New Cases of Isolated Congenital Central Hypothyroidism Due to Homozygous Thyrotropin Beta Gene Mutations: A Pitfall to Neonatal Screening

BACKGROUND Congenital central hypothyroidism (CCH) is a rare condition that is often diagnosed in late childhood in countries where neonatal screening programs rely solely on detecting thyrotropin (TSH) elevation. TSHbeta gene mutation is one of the causes of CCH. We describe two cases of c.Q49X mutation and three cases of c.C105Vfs114X mutation in exon 3 of the TSH beta-subunit gene. SUMMARY We found two different TSHbeta gene mutations in two families. In one family, we identified a missense mutation in exon 3 leading to a premature stop at position 49 (c.Q49X) in the two affected twins. In the other family, the three affected siblings had a 313delT nucleotide deletion leading to a frame shift responsible for premature termination at codon 114 (c.C105Vfs114X); neonatal screening showed very low TSH levels in all three patients. The presence of inappropriately low TSH levels at birth in the three affected members of the second family raises questions about the value of the TSH level for CCH screening. CONCLUSIONS The marked phenotypic variability in patients with the c.Q49X mutation suggests modulation by interacting genes and/or differences in the genetic background. TSHbeta gene mutations should be suspected in neonates with inappropriately low TSH levels.

Further delineation of the phenotype of chromosome 14q13 deletions: (positional) involvement of FOXG1 appears the main determinant of phenotype severity, with no evidence for a holoprosencephaly locus

Background Deletions including chromosome 14 band q13 have been linked to variable phenotypes. With current molecular methods the authors aim to elucidate a genotype–phenotype correlation by accurately determining the size and location of the deletions and the associated phenotype. Methods Here the authors report the molecular karyotyping and phenotypic description of seven patients with overlapping deletions including chromosome 14q13. Results The authors show that deletions including 14q13 result in a recognisable phenotype mainly due to haploinsufficiency of two genes (NKX2-1, PAX9). FOXG1 (on chromosome band 14q12) involvement seems to be the main determinant of phenotype severity. The patients in this study without FOXG1 involvement and deletions of up to 10 Mb have a relatively mild phenotype. The authors cannot explain why some patients in literature with overlapping but smaller deletions appear to have a more severe phenotype. A previously presumed association with holoprosencephaly could not be confirmed as none of the patients in this series had holoprosencephaly. Conclusions FOXG1 appears the main determinant of the severity of phenotypes resulting from deletions including 14q13. The collected data show no evidence for a locus for holoprosencephaly in the 14q13 region, but a locus for agenesis of the corpus callosum cannot be excluded.

Multiplex Ligation-Dependent Probe Amplification Improves the Detection Rate of NKX2.1 Mutations in Patients Affected by Brain-Lung-Thyroid Syndrome

Background: NKX2.1 mutations have been identified in patients displaying complete or partial brain-lung-thyroid syndrome, which can include benign hereditary chorea (BHC), hypothyroidism and/or lung disease. Aims and Methods: We evaluated the recently developed Multiplex Ligation-dependent Probe Amplification (MLPA) method to assess the relative copy number of genes. The goal was to determine if MLPA could improve, in addition to direct sequencing, the detection rate of NKX2.1 mutations in a phenotype-selected cohort of 24 patients affected by neurological, thyroid and/or pulmonary disorders. Results: Direct sequencing revealed two heterozygous mutations. Using MLPA, we identified two further heterozygous NKX2.1 gene deletions. MLPA increased the detection rate by 50%. All patients with gene deletions identified were affected by BHC and congenital hypothyroidism. Conclusion: MLPA should be considered as a complementary tool in patients with partial or total brain-lung-thyroid syndrome when direct sequencing failed to identify NKX2.1 mutations. All patients with an NKX2.1 mutation had BHC and congenital hypothyroidism, emphasizing the high prevalence of these signs associated with defective NKX2.1 alleles.

Pregnancy in women heterozygous for MCT8 mutations: risk of maternal hypothyroxinemia and fetal care.

CONTEXT Monocarboxylate transporter 8 (MCT8 or SLC16A2) mutations cause X-linked Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome. Heterozygous females are usually asymptomatic, but pregnancy may modify thyroid function and MCT8 is expressed in the placenta, suggesting that maternal and fetal abnormalities might develop even in the absence of MCT8 fetal mutation. Genetic counseling is so far based on X-linked transmission, and prenatal diagnosis is rarely performed. OBJECTIVE To describe thyroid function and the prenatal diagnosis in pregnant mothers harboring heterozygous MCT8 mutations and management of the persistent maternal hypothyroxinemia. Patients Two women heterozygous for MCT8 mutations (c.1690G>A and c.1393-1G>C) were monitored throughout pregnancy. METHODS Prenatal diagnosis included sex determination, direct MCT8 sequencing, and familial linkage analysis. Ultrasonography and hormonal assays for maternal thyroid function evaluation were performed serially during pregnancy. Neonatal thyroid hormonal status was assessed. RESULTS None of the three fetuses (two males and one female) carried MCT8 mutations. One of the two heterozygous mothers revealed gestational hypothyroxinemia, prompting early levothyroxine (l-T₄) therapy until delivery. The second heterozygous mother showed normal thyroid function but was preventively traited by l-T₄ and all of the three neonates had normal thyroid hormone levels and thyroid gland at birth, suggesting advantages of prenatal care and/or compensatory mechanisms. CONCLUSION Heterozygous MCT8 women should be monitored for requirement of l-T₄ therapy to prevent fetal and neonatal hypothyroidism and to avoid risk of potential cognitive delay due to gestational hypothyroxinemia. Moreover, when the disease-causing mutation is known and/or the first child is affected, prenatal diagnosis for male fetuses should be assessed early for MCT8 mutations by direct sequencing.

Thyroid function in fetuses with down syndrome.

Background/Aims: A mild increase in thyrotropin (thyroid-stimulating hormone; TSH) is common among Down syndrome patients but is rarely detected by neonatal screening at birth. We hypothesized that Down syndrome was associated with fetal hypothyroidism and tried to determine whether Down syndrome fetuses had evidence of hypothyroidism. Methods: We performed a prospective observational study on 13 fetuses with Down syndrome diagnosed prenatally. TSH and free thyroxine (FT4) levels were measured in fetal blood. The results were analyzed and compared with the findings from fetal sonography and histopathology. Results: Of the 13 fetuses, 6 had TSH values greater than the 95th percentile, and FT4 values were low. None of the fetuses had sonographic evidence of goiter. The thyroids were normal by gross examination but exhibited small follicles and histological features suggesting delayed maturation. Conclusion: The absence of goiter even in fetuses with hyperthyrotropinemia suggests a mild decrease in TSH responsiveness.

Down Syndrome and Nonautoimmune Hypothyroidisms in Neonates and Infants

Down syndrome is characterized by a high prevalence of thyroid dysfunction during childhood. In this paper, we review the different kinds of thyroid dysfunction that occur excluding those of autoimmune origin: congenital hypothyroidism (elevated plasma TSH with low plasma T4 occurring at birth usually detected by neonatal screening), subclinical hypothyroidism (elevated plasma TSH with plasma T4 in the normal range, which can be congenital or acquired) and acquired primary hypothyroidism (elevated plasma TSH and low plasma T4 occurring after birth). These dysfunctions, while not due to autoimmunity, are of thyroidal origin. However, the mechanisms leading to these different thyroidal abnormalities have not been clearly defined; in particular, it is difficult to determine whether the different types of dysfunction have a common cause, or if the causes are distinct. Treatment is prescribed according to the type of thyroidal abnormality.