Avital Beig

A Win–Win Solution in Oral Delivery of Lipophilic Drugs: Supersaturation via Amorphous Solid Dispersions Increases Apparent Solubility without Sacrifice of Intestinal Membrane Permeability

Recently, we have revealed a trade-off between solubility increase and permeability decrease when solubility-enabling oral formulations are employed. We have shown this trade-off phenomenon to be ubiquitous, and to exist whenever the aqueous solubility is increased via solubilizing excipients, regardless if the mechanism involves decreased free fraction (cyclodextrins complexation, surfactant micellization) or simple cosolvent solubilization. Discovering a way to increase drug solubility without concomitant decreased permeability represents a major advancement in oral delivery of lipophilic drugs and is the goal of this work. For this purpose, we sought to elucidate the solubility-permeability interplay when increased apparent solubility is obtained via supersaturation from an amorphous solid dispersion (ASD) formulation. A spray-dried ASD of the lipophilic drug progesterone was prepared in the hydrophilic polymer hydroxypropyl methylcellulose acetate succinate (HPMC-AS), which enabled supersaturation up to 4× the crystalline drugs aqueous solubility (8 μg/mL). The apparent permeability of progesterone from the ASD in HPMC-AS was then measured as a function of increasing apparent solubility (supersaturation) in the PAMPA and rat intestinal perfusion models. In contrast to previous cases in which apparent solubility increases via cyclodextrins, surfactants, and cosolvents resulted in decreased apparent permeability, supersaturation via ASD resulted in no decrease in apparent permeability with increasing apparent solubility. As a result, overall flux increased markedly with increasing apparent solubility via ASD as compared to the other formulation approaches. This work demonstrates that supersaturation via ASDs has a subtle yet powerful advantage over other solubility-enabling formulation approaches. That is, increased apparent solubility may be achieved without the expense of apparent intestinal membrane permeability. Thus, supersaturation via ASDs presents a markedly increased opportunity to maximize overall oral drug absorption.

The solubility-permeability interplay: mechanistic modeling and predictive application of the impact of micellar solubilization on intestinal permeation.

Surfactants are routinely employed to increase the apparent aqueous solubility of poorly soluble drugs. Yet the impact of micellar solubilization on the intestinal membrane permeability of a lipophilic drug is often overlooked and poorly understood. In this work, the interplay between the apparent solubility increase and intestinal membrane permeability decrease that exists when surfactants are used as drug solubility enhancers is described. A quasi-equilibrium mechanistic mass transport analysis was developed and employed to describe the effect of micellar solubilization by sodium taurocholate (STC) and sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) on the intestinal membrane permeability of the lipophilic drug progesterone. The model considers the effects of micellar solubilization on both the membrane permeability (P(m)) and the unstirred water layer (UWL) permeability (P(aq)), to predict the overall effective permeability (P(eff)) dependence on surfactant concentration (C(S)). The analysis reveals that (1) the effective UWL thickness (h(aq)) quickly decreases with increasing C(S) above the critical micelle concentration (CMC), such that P(aq) markedly increases with increasing C(S); (2) the free fraction of drug available for membrane permeation decreases with increasing C(S) above CMC, such that P(m) decreases with increasing C(S); and (3) P(aq) increases and P(m) decreases with increasing C(S) above CMC, consequently the UWL is effectively shorted out and the overall P(eff) tends toward membrane control with increasing C(S). The model enabled excellent quantitative prediction of the progesterone P(eff) as a function of C(S) in the rat jejunal perfusion model. This work demonstrates that a trade-off exists between micellar apparent solubility increase and permeability decrease that must be taken into account to strike the optimal solubility-permeability balance. The model presented in this work offers the formulation scientist a simple method for a priori prediction of this interplay, in order to maximize the overall oral absorption.

The solubility-permeability interplay when using cosolvents for solubilization: revising the way we use solubility-enabling formulations.

We have recently reported the interplay between apparent aqueous solubility and intestinal membrane permeability, showing the trade-off between the two when using cyclodextrin- and surfactant-based systems as solubility-enabling formulations. In these cases, the decreased permeability could be attributed directly to decreased free fraction of drug due to the complexation/micellization inherent in these solubilization methods. The purpose of this study was to investigate the direct solubility-permeability interplay, using formulations in which complexation is not the mechanism for increased solubilization. The apparent aqueous solubility (S(aq)) and rat intestinal permeability (P(eff)) of the lipophilic drug progesterone were measured in systems containing various levels of the cosolvents propylene glycol and PEG-400, since this solubilization method does not involve decreased free fraction. Thermodynamic activity was maintained equivalent in all permeability studies (75% equilibrium solubility). Both cosolvents increased progesterone S(aq) in nonlinear fashion. Decreased P(eff) with increased S(aq) was observed, despite the constant thermodynamic activity, and the nonrelevance of free fraction. A mass-transport analysis was developed to describe this interplay. The model considers the effects of solubilization on the membrane permeability (P(m)) and the unstirred water layer (UWL) permeability (P(aq)), to predict the overall P(eff) dependence on S(aq). The analysis revealed that (1) the effective UWL thickness quickly decreases with ↑S(aq), such that P(aq) markedly increases with ↑S(aq); (2) the apparent membrane/aqueous partitioning decreases with ↑S(aq), thereby reducing the thermodynamic driving force for permeability such that ↓P(m) with ↑S(aq); (3) since ↑P(aq) and ↓P(m) with ↑S(aq), the UWL is shorted out and P(eff) becomes membrane control with ↑S(aq). The model enabled excellent quantitative prediction of P(eff) as a function of S(aq). This work demonstrates that a direct trade-off exists between the apparent solubility and permeability, which must be taken into account when developing solubility-enabling formulations to strike the optimal solubility-permeability balance, in order to maximize the overall oral absorption.

Accounting for the solubility-permeability interplay in oral formulation development for poor water solubility drugs: the effect of PEG-400 on carbamazepine absorption.

The purpose of this paper was to study the solubility-permeability interplay in formulation development for oral administration of poor aqueous solubility drugs. The apparent solubility of the lipophilic drug carbamazepine was measured in systems containing various levels of the co-solvent PEG-400. The corresponding permeability was then measured in the PAMPA assay and in the rat jejunal perfusion model. Thermodynamic activity was maintained equivalent in all permeability studies (50% saturation). PEG-400 increased carbamazepine solubility in a concentration-dependent fashion. Decreased carbamazepine intestinal permeability with increased apparent solubility was observed in both PAMPA and rat perfusion models. Additionally, we have shown that the intestinal absorption of carbamazepine is membrane-controlled, with essentially no effective barrier function of the unstirred water layer. A mass transport analysis was employed to describe the solubility-permeability interplay. It was shown that the increased solubility in the aqueous GI milieu reduced the apparent membrane/aqueous partitioning, thereby reducing the driving force for membrane permeability. The model enabled excellent quantitative prediction of the effective permeability as a function of the solubility. In conclusion, a direct tradeoff between solubility increase and permeability decrease has been shown, which has to be accounted for when developing oral formulation for lipophilic drugs.

Oral Delivery of Lipophilic Drugs: The Tradeoff between Solubility Increase and Permeability Decrease When Using Cyclodextrin-Based Formulations

The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of oral cyclodextrin-based formulation on both the apparent solubility and intestinal permeability of lipophilic drugs. The apparent solubility of the lipophilic drug dexamethasone was measured in the presence of various HPβCD levels. The drug’s permeability was measured in the absence vs. presence of HPβCD in the rat intestinal perfusion model, and across Caco-2 cell monolayers. The role of the unstirred water layer (UWL) in dexamethasone’s absorption was studied, and a simplified mass-transport analysis was developed to describe the solubility-permeability interplay. The PAMPA permeability of dexamethasone was measured in the presence of various HPβCD levels, and the correlation with the theoretical predictions was evaluated. While the solubility of dexamethasone was greatly enhanced by the presence of HPβCD (K1∶1 = 2311 M−1), all experimental models showed that the drug’s permeability was significantly reduced following the cyclodextrin complexation. The UWL was found to have no impact on the absorption of dexamethasone. A mass transport analysis was employed to describe the solubility-permeability interplay. The model enabled excellent quantitative prediction of dexamethasone’s permeability as a function of the HPβCD level. This work demonstrates that when using cyclodextrins in solubility-enabling formulations, a tradeoff exists between solubility increase and permeability decrease that must not be overlooked. This tradeoff was found to be independent of the unstirred water layer. The transport model presented here can aid in striking the appropriate solubility-permeability balance in order to achieve optimal overall absorption.

The solubility-permeability interplay and oral drug formulation design: Two heads are better than one.

Poor aqueous solubility is a major challenge in todays biopharmaceutics. While solubility-enabling formulations can significantly increase the apparent solubility of the drug, the concomitant effect on the drugs apparent permeability has been largely overlooked. The mathematical equation to describe the membrane permeability of a drug comprises the membrane/aqueous partition coefficient, which in turn is dependent on the drugs apparent solubility in the GI milieu, suggesting that the solubility and the permeability are closely related, exhibit a certain interplay between them, and treating the one irrespectively of the other may be insufficient. In this article, an overview of this solubility-permeability interplay is provided, and the available data is analyzed in the context of the effort to maximize the overall drug exposure. Overall, depending on the type of solubility-permeability interplay, the permeability may decrease, remain unchanged, and even increase, in a way that may critically affect the formulation capability to improve the overall absorption. Therefore, an intelligent design of solubility-enabling formulation needs to consider both the solubility afforded by the formulation and the permeability in the new luminal environment resulting from the formulation.

In-situ intestinal rat perfusions for human Fabs prediction and BCS permeability class determination: Investigation of the single-pass vs. the Doluisio experimental approaches

Intestinal drug permeability has been recognized as a critical determinant of the fraction dose absorbed, with direct influence on bioavailability, bioequivalence and biowaiver. The purpose of this research was to compare intestinal permeability values obtained by two different intestinal rat perfusion methods: the single-pass intestinal perfusion (SPIP) model and the Doluisio (closed-loop) rat perfusion method. A list of 15 model drugs with different permeability characteristics (low, moderate, and high, as well as passively and actively absorbed) was constructed. We assessed the rat intestinal permeability of these 15 model drugs in both SPIP and the Doluisio methods, and evaluated the correlation between them. We then evaluated the ability of each of these methods to predict the fraction dose absorbed (Fabs) in humans, and to assign the correct BCS permeability class membership. Excellent correlation was obtained between the two experimental methods (r(2)=0.93). An excellent correlation was also shown between literature Fabs values and the predictions made by both rat perfusion techniques. Similar BCS permeability class membership was designated by literature data and by both SPIP and Doluisio methods for all compounds. In conclusion, the SPIP model and the Doluisio (closed-loop) rat perfusion method are both equally useful for obtaining intestinal permeability values that can be used for Fabs prediction and BCS classification.

The interaction of nifedipine with selected cyclodextrins and the subsequent solubility-permeability trade-off.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the interaction of 2-hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin (HPβCD) and 2,6-dimethyl-β-cyclodextrin (DMβCD) with the lipophilic drug nifedipine and to investigate the subsequent solubility-permeability interplay. Solubility curves of nifedipine with HPβCD and DMβCD in MES buffer were evaluated using phase solubility methods. Then, the apparent permeability of nifedipine was investigated as a function of increasing HPβCD/DMβCD concentration in the hexadecane-based PAMPA model. The interaction with nifedipine was CD dependent; significantly higher stability constant was obtained for DMβCD in comparison with HPβCD. Moreover, nifedipine displays different type of interaction with these CDs; a 1:1 stoichiometric inclusion complex was apparent with HPβCD, while 1:2 stoichiometry was apparent for DMβCD. In all cases, decreased apparent intestinal permeability of nifedipine as a function of increasing CD level and nifedipine apparent solubility was obtained. A quasi-equilibrium mass transport analysis was developed to explain this solubility-permeability interplay; the model enabled excellent quantitative prediction of nifedipines permeability as a function of CD concentrations. This work demonstrates that when using CDs in solubility-enabling formulations, a trade-off exists between solubility increase and permeability decrease that must not be overlooked. This trade-off was found to be independent of the type of CD-drug interaction. The transport model presented here can aid in striking the appropriate solubility-permeability balance in order to achieve optimal overall absorption.

Head-To-Head Comparison of Different Solubility-Enabling Formulations of Etoposide and Their Consequent Solubility–Permeability Interplay

The purpose of this study was to conduct a head-to-head comparison of different solubility-enabling formulations, and their consequent solubility-permeability interplay. The low-solubility anticancer drug etoposide was formulated in several strengths of four solubility-enabling formulations: hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin, the cosolvent polyethylene glycol 400 (PEG-400), the surfactant sodium lauryl sulfate, and an amorphous solid dispersion formulation. The ability of these formulations to increase the solubility of etoposide was investigated, followed by permeability studies using the parallel artificial membrane permeability assay (PAMPA) and examination of the consequent solubility-permeability interplay. All formulations significantly increased etoposides apparent solubility. The cyclodextrin-, surfactant-, and cosolvent-based formulations resulted in a concomitant decreased permeability that could be modeled directly from the proportional increase in the apparent solubility. On the contrary, etoposide permeability remained constant when using the ASD formulation, irrespective of the increased apparent solubility provided by the formulation. In conclusion, supersaturation resulting from the amorphous form overcomes the solubility-permeability tradeoff associated with other formulation techniques. Accounting for the solubility-permeability interplay may allow to develop better solubility-enabling formulations, thereby maximizing the overall absorption of lipophilic orally administered drugs.

Segmental-dependent permeability throughout the small intestine following oral drug administration: Single-pass vs. Doluisio approach to in-situ rat perfusion

Intestinal drug permeability is position dependent and pertains to a specific point along the intestinal membrane, and the resulted segmental-dependent permeability phenomenon has been recognized as a critical factor in the overall absorption of drug following oral administration. The aim of this research was to compare segmental-dependent permeability data obtained from two different rat intestinal perfusion approaches: the single-pass intestinal perfusion (SPIP) model and the closed-loop (Doluisio) rat perfusion method. The rat intestinal permeability of 12 model drugs with different permeability characteristics (low, moderate, and high, as well as passively and actively absorbed) was assessed in three small intestinal regions: the upper jejunum, mid-small intestine, and the terminal ileum, using both the SPIP and the Doluisio experimental methods. Excellent correlation was evident between the two approaches, especially in the upper jejunum (R2=0.95). Significant regional-dependent permeability was found in half of drugs studied, illustrating the importance and relevance of segmental-dependent intestinal permeability. Despite the differences between the two methods, highly comparable results were obtained by both methods, especially in the medium-high Peff range. In conclusion, the SPIP and the Doluisio method are both equally useful in obtaining crucial segmental-dependent intestinal permeability data.