Avril Mansfield

Relationship between asymmetry of quiet standing balance control and walking post-stroke

Spatial and temporal gait asymmetry is common after stroke. Such asymmetric gait is inefficient, can contribute to instability and may lead to musculoskeletal injury. However, understanding of the determinants of such gait asymmetry remains incomplete. The current study is focused on revealing if there is a link between asymmetry during the control of standing balance and asymmetry during walking. This study involved review of data from 94 individuals with stroke referred to a gait and balance clinic. Participants completed three tests: (1) walking at their usual pace; (2) quiet standing; and (3) standing with maximal loading of the paretic side. A pressure sensitive mat recorded placement and timing of each footfall during walking. Standing tests were completed on two force plates to evaluate symmetry of weight bearing and contribution of each limb to balance control. Multiple regression was conducted to determine the relationships between symmetry during standing and swing time, stance time, and step length symmetry during walking. Symmetry of antero-posterior balance control and weight bearing were related to swing time and step length symmetry during walking. Weight-bearing symmetry, weight-bearing capacity, and symmetry of antero-posterior balance control were related to stance time symmetry. These associations were independent of underlying lower limb impairment. The results support the hypothesis that impaired ability of the paretic limb to control balance may contribute to gait asymmetry post-stroke. Such work suggests that rehabilitation strategies that increase the contribution of the paretic limb to standing balance control may increase symmetry of walking post-stroke.

A perturbation-based balance training program for older adults: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial

BackgroundPrevious research investigating exercise as a means of falls prevention in older adults has shown mixed results. Lack of specificity of the intervention may be an important factor contributing to negative results. Change-in-support (CIS) balance reactions, which involve very rapid stepping or grasping movements of the limbs, play a critical role in preventing falls; hence, a training program that improves ability to execute effective CIS reactions could potentially have a profound effect in reducing risk of falling. This paper describes: 1) the development of a perturbation-based balance training program that targets specific previously-reported age-related impairments in CIS reactions, and 2) a study protocol to evaluate the efficacy of this new training program.Methods/DesignThe training program involves use of unpredictable, multi-directional moving-platform perturbations to evoke stepping and grasping reactions. Perturbation magnitude is gradually increased over the course of the 6-week program, and concurrent cognitive and movement tasks are included during later sessions. The program was developed in accordance with well-established principles of motor learning, such as individualisation, specificity, overload, adaptation-progression and variability. Specific goals are to reduce the frequency of multiple-step responses, reduce the frequency of collisions between the stepping foot and stance leg, and increase the speed of grasping reactions. A randomised control trial will be performed to evaluate the efficacy of the training program. A total of 30 community-dwelling older adults (age 64–80) with a recent history of instability or falling will be assigned to either the perturbation-based training or a control group (flexibility/relaxation training), using a stratified randomisation that controls for gender, age and baseline stepping/grasping performance. CIS reactions will be tested immediately before and after the six weeks of training, using platform perturbations as well as a distinctly different method of perturbation (waist pulls) in order to evaluate the generalisability of the training effects.DiscussionThis study will determine whether perturbation-based balance training can help to reverse specific age-related impairments in balance-recovery reactions. These results will help to guide the development of more effective falls prevention programs, which may ultimately lead to reduced health-care costs and enhanced mobility, independence and quality of life.

Determinants and consequences for standing balance of spontaneous weight-bearing on the paretic side among individuals with chronic stroke.

Hemiparetic stroke patients commonly bear more weight on the non-paretic side which seems intuitively linked to unilateral control deficits. However, there is evidence that some post-stroke favour weighting the paretic side, which may be problematic given altered capacity of the paretic limb to contribute to the control of upright posture. This study explores the prevalence and clinical determinants of stance asymmetry, and the relationship between stance asymmetry and postural control among chronic stroke patients. Subjects (n=147; >6 months post-stroke) stood on two force plates in eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions; 59 were symmetric, 18 had paretic asymmetry (PA), and 70 had non-paretic asymmetry (NPA). Root mean square (RMS) of antero-posterior and medio-lateral centre-of-pressure under each limb and both limbs combined were compared. RMS of total medio-lateral centre-of-pressure was greater for both asymmetric groups compared with the symmetric group. PA subjects relied less on the loaded limb for control than NPA subjects and relied more on visual information for postural control than those who were symmetric. There were no differences in the characteristics of individuals between the PA and NPA groups. The loading of the paretic limb was not related to impaired postural control during stationary standing which was attributable, in part, to individuals relying on control from the non-paretic limb, in spite of lower vertical load, and a greater dependence on visual contributions. There was no evidence that greater loading on the paretic limb was related to persisting dyscontrol but may rather reflect a learned strategy.

Does perturbation-based balance training prevent falls? Systematic review and meta-analysis of preliminary randomized controlled trials.

Background Older adults and individuals with neurological conditions are at an increased risk for falls. Although physical exercise can prevent falls, certain types of exercise may be more effective. Perturbation-based balance training is a novel intervention involving repeated postural perturbations aiming to improve control of rapid balance reactions. Purpose The purpose of this study was to estimate the effect of perturbation-based balance training on falls in daily life. Data Sources MEDLINE (1946–July 2014), EMBASE (1974–July 2014), PEDro (all dates), CENTRAL (1991–July 2014), and Google Scholar (all dates) were the data sources used in this study. Study Selection Randomized controlled trials written in English were included if they focused on perturbation-based balance training among older adults or individuals with neurological conditions and collected falls data posttraining. Data Extraction Two investigators extracted data independently. Study authors were contacted to obtain missing information. A PEDro score was obtained for each study. Primary outcomes were proportion of participants who reported one or more falls (ie, number of “fallers”) and the total number of falls. The risk ratio (proportion of fallers) and rate ratio (number of falls) were entered into the analysis. Data Synthesis Eight studies involving 404 participants were included. Participants who completed perturbation-based balance training were less likely to report a fall (overall risk ratio=0.71; 95% confidence interval=0.52, 0.96; P=.02) and reported fewer falls than those in the control groups (overall rate ratio=0.54; 95% confidence interval=0.34, 0.85; P=.007). Limitations Study authors do not always identify that they have included perturbation training in their intervention; therefore, it is possible that some appropriate studies were not included. Study designs were heterogeneous, preventing subanalyses. Conclusions Perturbation-based balance training appears to reduce fall risk among older adults and individuals with Parkinson disease.

Is Impaired Control of Reactive Stepping Related to Falls During Inpatient Stroke Rehabilitation

Background. Individuals with stroke fall more often than age-matched controls. Although many focus on the multifactorial nature of falls, the fundamental problem is likely the ability for an individual to generate reactions to recover from a loss of balance. Stepping reactions to recover balance are particularly important to balance recovery, and individuals with stroke have difficulty executing these responses to prevent a fall following a loss of balance. Objective. The purpose of this study is to determine if characteristics of balance recovery steps are related to falls during inpatient stroke rehabilitation. Methods. We conducted a retrospective review of individuals with stroke attending inpatient rehabilitation (n = 136). Details of falls experienced during inpatient rehabilitation were obtained from incident reports, nursing notes, and patient interviews. Stepping reactions were evoked using a “release-from-lean” postural perturbation. Poisson regression was used to determine characteristics of stepping reactions that were related to increased fall frequency relative to length of stay. Results. In all, 20 individuals experienced 29 falls during inpatient rehabilitation. The characteristics of stepping reactions significantly related to increased fall rates were increased frequency of external assistance to prevent a fall to the floor, increased frequency of no-step responses, increased frequency of step responses with inadequate foot clearance, and delayed time to initiate stepping responses. Conclusions. Impaired control of balance recovery steps is related to increased fall rates during inpatient stroke rehabilitation. This study informs the specific features of stepping reactions that can be targeted with physiotherapy intervention during inpatient rehabilitation to improve dynamic stability control and potentially prevent falls.

Clinical Correlates of Between-Limb Synchronization of Standing Balance Control and Falls During Inpatient Stroke Rehabilitation

Background. Stroke-related sensorimotor impairment potentially contributes to impaired balance. Balance measures that reveal underlying limb-specific control problems, such as a measure of the synchronization of both lower limbs to maintain standing balance, may be uniquely informative about poststroke balance control. Objective. This study aimed to determine the relationships between clinical measures of sensorimotor control, functional balance, and fall risk and between-limb synchronization of balance control. Methods. The authors conducted a retrospective chart review of 100 individuals with stroke admitted to inpatient rehabilitation. Force plate–based measures were obtained while standing on 2 force plates, including postural sway (root mean square of anteroposterior and mediolateral center of pressure [COP]), stance load asymmetry (percentage of body weight borne on the less-loaded limb), and between-limb synchronization (cross-correlation of the COP recordings under each foot). Clinical measures obtained were motor impairment (Chedoke-McMaster Stroke Assessment), plantar cutaneous sensation, functional balance (Berg Balance Scale), and falls experienced in rehabilitation. Results. Synchronization was significantly related to motor impairment and prospective falls, even when controlling for other force plate–based measures of standing balance control (ie, postural sway and stance load symmetry). Conclusions. Between-limb COP synchronization for standing balance appears to be a uniquely important index of balance control, independent of postural sway and load symmetry during stance.

Determinants of Limb Preference for Initiating Compensatory Stepping Poststroke

OBJECTIVE To investigate the determinants of limb preference for initiating compensatory stepping poststroke. DESIGN Retrospective chart review. SETTING Inpatient rehabilitation. PARTICIPANTS Convenience sample of individuals admitted to inpatient rehabilitation with poststroke hemiparesis. INTERVENTIONS Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Compensatory stepping responses were evoked using a lean-and-release postural perturbation. The limb used to initiate compensatory stepping was determined. The relationships between stepping with the paretic limb and premorbid limb dominance, weight bearing on the paretic limb in quiet standing, ability to bear weight on the paretic limb, preperturbation weight bearing on the paretic limb, and lower-limb motor recovery scores were determined. RESULTS The majority (59.1%) of responses were steps initiated with the nonparetic limb. Increased lower-limb motor recovery scores and preperturbation weight bearing on the nonparetic limb were significantly related to increased frequency of stepping with the paretic limb. When the preferred limb was physically blocked, an inappropriate response was initiated in 21% of trials (ie, nonstep responses or an attempt to step with the blocked limb). CONCLUSIONS This study reveals the challenges that individuals with poststroke hemiparesis face when executing compensatory stepping responses to prevent a fall after a postural perturbation. The inability or challenges to executing a compensatory step with the paretic limb may increase the risk for falls poststroke.

Longitudinal changes in poststroke spatiotemporal gait asymmetry over inpatient rehabilitation.

Background. Little information exists about longitudinal changes in spatiotemporal gait asymmetry during rehabilitation, despite it being a common goal. Objectives. To describe longitudinal changes in spatiotemporal gait asymmetry over rehabilitation and examine relationships with changes in other poststroke impairments. Methods. Retrospective chart reviews were conducted for 71 stroke rehabilitation inpatients. Admission and discharge measures of spatiotemporal symmetry, velocity, motor impairment, mobility and balance were extracted and change scores were calculated. Relationships between changes in spatiotemporal symmetry and other change scores were investigated with Spearman correlations. Individuals were divided into four groups (worse, no change-symmetric, no change-asymmetric, improved) based on (1) symmetry/asymmetry at admission and (2) symmetry change scores >minimal detectable change. Differences in change scores between groups were investigated with analyses of covariance using the admission value as a covariate. Results. At admission, 59% and 49% of individuals were asymmetric in swing time and step length, respectively. Of these individuals, 21% and 14% improved swing symmetry or step symmetry, respectively. In contrast, 30% improved gait velocity, 62% improved functional balance and 73% improved functional mobility. Associations between change in swing symmetry and change in paretic limb weight bearing in standing and change in step symmetry and change in velocity were significant. There were no significant differences in change scores between the symmetry groups. Conclusions. The majority of asymmetric stroke patients did not improve spatiotemporal asymmetry during rehabilitation despite the fact that velocity, balance and functional mobility improved. Future work should investigate other factors associated with improved spatiotemporal symmetry and interventions to specifically improve it.

Use of Accelerometer-Based Feedback of Walking Activity for Appraising Progress With Walking-Related Goals in Inpatient Stroke Rehabilitation A Randomized Controlled Trial

Background. Regaining independent ambulation is important to those with stroke. Increased walking practice during “down time” in rehabilitation could improve walking function for individuals with stroke. Objective. To determine the effect of providing physiotherapists with accelerometer-based feedback on patient activity and walking-related goals during inpatient stroke rehabilitation. Methods. Participants with stroke wore accelerometers around both ankles every weekday during inpatient rehabilitation. Participants were randomly assigned to receive daily feedback about walking activity via their physiotherapists (n = 29) or to receive no feedback (n = 28). Changes in measures of daily walking (walking time, number of steps, average cadence, longest bout duration, and number of “long” walking bouts) and changes in gait control and function assessed in-laboratory were compared between groups. Results. There was no significant increase in walking time, number of steps, longest bout duration, or number of long walking bouts for the feedback group compared with the control group (P values > .20). However, individuals who received feedback significantly increased cadence of daily walking more than the control group (P = .013). From the in-laboratory gait assessment, individuals who received feedback had a greater increase in walking speed and decrease in step time variability than the control group (P values < .030). Conclusion. Feedback did not increase the amount of walking completed by individuals with stroke. However, there was a significant increase in cadence, indicating that intensity of daily walking was greater for those who received feedback than the control group. Additionally, more intense daily walking activity appeared to translate to greater improvements in walking speed.

Cardiovascular Responses Associated with Daily Walking in Subacute Stroke

Despite the importance of regaining independent ambulation after stroke, the amount of daily walking completed during in-patient rehabilitation is low. The purpose of this study is to determine if (1) walking-related heart rate responses reached the minimum intensity necessary for therapeutic aerobic exercise (40%–60% heart rate reserve) or (2) heart rate responses during bouts of walking revealed excessive workload that may limit walking (>80% heart rate reserve). Eight individuals with subacute stroke attending in-patient rehabilitation were recruited. Participants wore heart rate monitors and accelerometers during a typical rehabilitation day. Walking-related changes in heart rate and walking bout duration were determined. Patients did not meet the minimum cumulative requirements of walking intensity (>40% heart rate reserve) and duration (>10 minutes continuously) necessary for cardiorespiratory benefit. Only one patient exceeded 80% heart rate reserve. The absence of significant increases in heart rate associated with walking reveals that patients chose to walk at speeds well below a level that has meaningful cardiorespiratory health benefits. Additionally, cardiorespiratory workload is unlikely to limit participation in walking. Measurement of heart rate and walking during in-patient rehabilitation may be a useful approach to encourage patients to increase the overall physical activity and to help facilitate recovery.