B. Anne Croy

Uterine natural killer cells: a specialized differentiation regulated by ovarian hormones

Summary:  In adult females of many species, a transient population of natural killer (NK) cells appears in cycles within the uterine endometrium (lining). Appearance of these lymphocytes coincides with specific phases of the ovarian hormone cycle and/or early pregnancy. Studies in rodents, women, and pigs dominate the literature and suggest the uterine (u)NK cells are an activated subset sharing many but not all features with circulating or lymphoid organ‐residing NK cells. During successful murine pregnancy, uNK cells appear to regulate initiation of structural changes in the feed arterial systems that support maternal endometrial tissue at sites of implantation and subsequent placental development. These changes, which reverse after pregnancy, create a higher volume arterial bed with flaccid vessels unresponsive to vasoactive compounds. These unique pregnancy‐associated arterial changes elevate the volume of low‐pressure, nutrient‐rich, maternal arterial blood available to conceptuses. Regulation of the differentiation, activation, and functions of uNK cells is only partially known, and there is lively debate regarding whether and how uNK cells participate in infertility or spontaneous abortion. This review highlights the biology of uNK cells during successful pregnancy.

Changes in systemic type 1 and type 2 immunity in normal pregnancy and pre-eclampsia may be mediated by natural killer cells.

A bias of T cell immunity towards type 2 (Th2) is thought to be critical for normal pregnancy. Pathological pregnancies, such as pre‐eclampsia, are characterised by cell‐mediated (Th1) immune dominance. The Th1/Th2 paradigm, however, is too simplistic. Normal pregnancy is associated with a systemic inflammatory response which increases throughout gestation. This inflammatory response is exaggerated in pre‐eclampsia, a syndrome of the third trimester. T helper (Th) cells are considered the primary mediators of these altered immune responses, and other T cells, i.e. T cytotoxic (Tc) cells, and lymphocytes of the innate immune system, i.e. natural killer (NK) and NKT cells, have been largely disregarded. In this study, we have used novel pan type 1 (IL‐18 receptor) and pan type 2 (ST2L) lymphocyte function markers in four‐colour flow cytometry to broadly characterise peripheral blood lymphocyte populations from non‐pregnant, normal pregnant and pre‐eclamptic women. There were no changes in the Th1/Th2 or Tc1/Tc2 cell ratios between the three groups; however, the NK1/NK2 and NKT1/NKT2 cell ratios were significantly decreased in normal pregnancy compared with non‐pregnant (p <0.001 and p <0.01, respectively) and pre‐eclamptic women (p <0.05). These results confirm that immunoregulation occurs in pregnancy, but suggest a dominant role of the innate rather than the adaptive immune system.

Contributions from self-renewal and trafficking to the uterine NK cell population of early pregnancy

Uterine NK (uNK) cells are abundant in human and murine uteri during decidualization. It is unclear whether precursors of uNK (pre-uNK) cells self-renew or are recruited from other sites. To assess self-renewal of pre-uNK cells, uterine segments from NK cell-competent mice were grafted orthotopically into NK/uNK cell-deficient or wild-type mice. Only in wild-type recipients did decidualized grafts contain uNK cells, indicating that pre-uNK cells do not self-renew in uterus. To identify pre-uNK cell sources, thymus, bone marrow, lymph node, or spleen cells were grafted from virgin or pregnant NK cell-competent donors into mated NK/uNK cell-deficient recipients. Cells from secondary lymphoid tissues of pregnant donors gave high level uNK cell reconstitution, which was independent of chemokine receptors CCR2 or CCR5. Pregnancy-induced changes to lymphocyte-endothelial cell interactions were documented using adhesion of human lymphocytes to frozen mouse tissue sections under shear. A dynamic increase was observed in L-selectin- and α4 integrin-dependent adhesion of CD56bright NK cells to decidualizing uterus and in human PBL adhesion to lymph node endothelium. These data support a model that attributes the dramatic increases in human and murine uNK cells during decidualization to precursor cell recruitment.

Interferon Gamma in Successful Pregnancies

Abstract Interferon gamma (IFNG) is a proinflammatory cytokine secreted in the uterus during early pregnancy. It is abundantly produced by uterine natural killer cells in maternal endometrium but also by trophoblasts in some species. In normal pregnancies of mice, IFNG plays critical roles that include initiation of endometrial vasculature remodeling, angiogenesis at implantation sites, and maintenance of the decidual (maternal) component of the placenta. In livestock and in humans, deviations in these processes are thought to contribute to serious gestational complications, such as fetal loss or preeclampsia. Interferon gamma has broader roles in activation of innate and adaptive immune responses to viruses and tumors, in part through upregulating transcription of genes involved in cell cycle regulation, apoptosis, and antigen processing/presentation. Despite this, rodent and human trophoblast cells show dampened responses to IFNG that reflect the resistance of these cells to IFNG-mediated activation of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II transplantation antigen expression. Lack of MHC class II antigens on trophoblasts is thought to facilitate survival of the semiallogeneic conceptus in the presence of maternal lymphocytes. This review describes the dynamic roles of IFNG in successful pregnancy and briefly summarizes data on IFNG in gestational pathologies.

Natural killer cell-triggered vascular transformation: maternal care before birth?

Natural killer (NK) cells are found in lymphoid and non-lymphoid organs. In addition to important roles in immune surveillance, some NK cells contribute to angiogenesis and circulatory regulation. The uterus of early pregnancy is a non-lymphoid organ enriched in NK cells that are specifically recruited to placental attachment sites. In species with invasive hemochorial placentation, these uterine natural killer (uNK) cells, via secretion of cytokines, chemokines, mucins, enzymes and angiogenic growth factors, contribute to the physiological change of mesometrial endometrium into the unique stromal environment called decidua basalis. In humans, uNK cells have the phenotype CD56brightCD16dim and they appear in great abundance in the late secretory phase of the menstrual cycle and early pregnancy. Gene expression studies indicate that CD56brightCD16dim uterine and circulating cells are functionally distinct. In humans but not mice or other species with post-implantation decidualization, uNK cells may contribute to blastocyst implantation and are of interest as therapeutic targets in female infertility. Histological and genetic studies in mice first identified triggering of the process of gestation spiral arterial modification as a major uNK cell function, achieved via interferon (IFN)-γ secretion. During spiral arterial modification, branches from the uterine artery that traverse the endometrium/decidua transiently lose their muscular coat and ability to vasoconstrict. The expression of vascular markers changes from arterial to venous as these vessels dilate and become low-resistance, high-volume channels. Full understanding of the vascular interactions of human uNK cells is difficult to obtain because endometrial time-course studies are not possible in pregnant women. Here we briefly review key information concerning uNK cell functions from studies in rodents, summarize highlights concerning human uNK cells and describe our preliminary studies on development of a humanized, pregnant mouse model for in vivo investigations of human uNK cell functions.

Differential Gene Expression in Endometrium, Endometrial Lymphocytes, and Trophoblasts during Successful and Abortive Embryo Implantation

Prenatal mortality reaching 30% occurs during the first weeks of gestation in commercial swine. Mechanisms for this are unknown although poor uterine blood supply has been postulated. In other species, vascular endothelial growth factor, hypoxia-inducible factor 1-α, and IFN-γ regulate gestational endometrial angiogenesis. Vascular endothelial growth factor and hypoxia-inducible factor 1-α are also important for placental angiogenesis while trophoblastic expression of Fas ligand is thought to protect conceptuses against immune-mediated pregnancy loss. In this study, we document dynamic, peri-implantation differences in transcription of genes for angiogenesis, cytokine production, and apoptosis regulation in the endometrium, and laser capture microdissected endometrial lymphocytes and trophoblasts associated with healthy or viable but arresting porcine fetuses. In healthy implantation sites, endometrial gene expression levels differed between anatomic subregions and endometrial lymphocytes showed much greater transcription of angiogenic genes than trophoblasts. In arresting fetal sites, uterine lymphocytes had no angiogenic gene transcription and showed rapid elevation in transcription of proinflammatory cytokines Fas and Fas ligand while trophoblasts showed elevated transcription of IFN-γ and Fas. This model of experimentally accessible spontaneous fetal loss, involving blocked maternal angiogenesis, should prove valuable for further investigations of peri-implantation failure of normally conceived and surgically transferred embryos in many species, including the human.

Genetic Deletion of Placenta Growth Factor in Mice Alters Uterine NK Cells

Placenta growth factor (PlGF; formerly PGF), a vascular endothelial growth factor gene family member, is expressed in human implantation sites by maternal uterine NK (uNK) and fetal trophoblast cells. Lower than normal concentrations of blood and urinary PlGF have been associated with impending onset of pre-eclampsia, a hypertensive disease of late human gestation characterized by limited intravascular trophoblast invasion. In pregnant rodents, delivery of the PlGF antagonist sFlt-1 or S-endoglin induces pre-eclampsia-like lesions. Mice genetically deleted in PlGF reproduce, but neither their implantation sites nor their uNK cell development are described. We combined real-time PCR of endometrium from nonpregnant and gestation day (gd)6–18 C57BL6/J (B6) mice with immunohistology to analyze PlGF expression in normal mouse pregnancy. To estimate the significance of uNK cell-derived PlGF, PlGF message was quantified in mesometrial decidua from pregnant alymphoid Rag2 null/common γ chain null mice and in laser capture-microdissected B6 uNK cells. Histopathologic consequences from PlGF deletion were also characterized in the implantation sites from PlGF null mice. In B6, decidual PlGF expression rose between gd8–16. uNK cells were among several types of cells transcribing PlGF in decidualized endometrium. Immature uNK cells, defined by their low numbers of cytoplasmic granules, were the uNK cells displaying the greatest number of transcripts. PlGF deletion promoted the early differentiation high numbers of binucleate uNK cells (gd8) but had no other significant, morphometrically detectable impact on implantation sites. Thus, in mice, PlGF plays an important role in successful uNK cell proliferation and/or differentiation.

Normal murine and porcine embryos recruit NK cells to the uterus.

Decidual NK cells, indistinguishable from those found in lymphoid tissues, are present in cell suspensions prepared from maternal decidua of random-bred mice between Days 6.5 and 10.5 of first gestation. The stringency of the correlation between NK cells and normal embryos during successful pregnancy is unknown. Our previous finding that active NK cells were unable to mediate lysis of fresh embryonic tissues at any stage during gestation suggests that if NK cells play a functional role in normal pregnancy it would be a noncytolytic role. Before studies on the function of uterine NK cells were undertaken, evidence that the association of NK cells with normal embryos is widespread was sought by assessing NK cell activity in cell suspensions from decidua of syngeneically mated mice, from decidua of multiparous, random-bred mice, and from the endometrium of pigs during first pregnancy. Neither parity nor maternal-fetal compatibility changed the pattern of high levels of decidual NK cell activity early in pregnancy followed by decline. Porcine NK cell activity was not detected in uterine cells isolated from cycling pigs but in pregnant animals it gradually increased during the preattachment period and reached levels greater than those in blood, postattachment (Day 28). Some of this activity was hormone dependent but sustained increases in NK cell activity required the presence of an embryo. These studies demonstrate that the association of functional NK cells with normal embryos is widespread during early pregnancy.

Uterine natural killer cells are targets for a trophoblast cell-specific cytokine, prolactin-like protein A

PRL-like protein A (PLP-A) is a member of the PRL family expressed in trophoblast cells coincident with establishment of the chorioallantoic placenta. The purpose of this investigation was to identify targets for PLP-A. Using an alkaline phosphatase-tagging strategy, we show that PLP-A specifically interacts with a population of natural killer (NK) lymphocytes within the mesometrial compartment of decidua from pregnant and pseudopregnant rats. These observations are supported by the codistribution of PLP-A targets with cells expressing the rat NK cell surface marker, gp42, the absence of PLP-A binding in conceptuses from NK cell-deficient tge26 mice, and the specific interaction of PLP-A with a rat NK cell line, RNK-16. We have further demonstrated that PLP-A effectively suppresses RNK-16 cell cytolytic activities. Our results provide evidence for a new paradigm of embryonic-maternal communication involving a PLP-A signaling pathway between trophoblast cells and uterine NK lymphocytes.

Disordered IL-33/ST2 Activation in Decidualizing Stromal Cells Prolongs Uterine Receptivity in Women with Recurrent Pregnancy Loss

Decidualization renders the endometrium transiently receptive to an implanting blastocyst although the underlying mechanisms remain incompletely understood. Here we show that human endometrial stromal cells (HESCs) rapidly release IL-33, a key regulator of innate immune responses, upon decidualization. In parallel, differentiating HESCs upregulate the IL-33 transmembrane receptor ST2L and other pro-inflammatory mediators before mounting a profound anti-inflammatory response that includes downregulation of ST2L and increased expression of the soluble decoy receptor sST2. We demonstrate that HESCs secrete factors permissive of embryo implantation in mice only during the pro-inflammatory phase of the decidual process. IL-33 knockdown in undifferentiated HESCs was sufficient to abrogate this pro-inflammatory decidual response. Further, sequential activation of the IL-33/ST2L/sST2 axis was disordered in decidualizing HESCs from women with recurrent pregnancy loss. Signals from these cultures prolonged the implantation window but also caused subsequent pregnancy failure in mice. Thus, Il-33/ST2 activation in HESCS drives an autoinflammatory response that controls the temporal expression of receptivity genes. Failure to constrain this response predisposes to miscarriage by allowing out-of-phase implantation in an unsupportive uterine environment.