B.J. Cummings

SEMINOMA OF THE TESTIS: RESULTS OF TREATMENT AND PATTERNS OF FAILURE AFTER RADIATION THERAPY

Four hundred and forty-four patients with the histological diagnosis of pure seminoma were treated at The Princess Margaret Hospital between 1958 and 1976. Using the Walter Reed Hospital staging classification, 338 patients (76.1%) were Stage I, 86 (19.4%) were Stage II, and 20 (4.7%) were Stage III. The 5 year actuarial survival rate (5 yr Sa) for all stages was 87%, and for Stages I, II and III: 94%, 74% and 32% respectively. In Stage II the 5-year Sa was significantly worse when palpable abdominal disease was present (62%, vs 87% when it was absent, p less than .02). Prophylactic mediastinal irradiation was not used for patients with Stage II disease. None of 40 Stage II patients without palpable abdominal disease recurred in the non-irradiated mediastinum. Ten of 46 Stage II patients with palpable abdominal disease recurred in the mediastinum; 7 of the 10 were cured with mediastinal irradiation at the time of relapse. Prophylactic mediastinal irradiation appears unnecessary in Stage II patients. The Stage III category includes a subgroup of patients who were curable with radiation therapy:L 5/6 with supradiaphragmatic nodal disease without palpable abdominal or visceral disease were cured. Exploration of new treatment methods appears indicated for the salvage of patients recurring in sites other than the mediastinum or supraclavicular fossa and for patients presenting with visceral disease.

ETHMOID SINUS CANCER: TWENTY-NINE CASES MANAGED WITH PRIMARY RADIATION THERAPY

PURPOSEnTo describe the outcome of patients with carcinoma of the ethmoid sinus managed with a policy of primary radiation therapy with surgery for salvage of persistent or progressive disease.nnnMETHODS AND MATERIALSnA retrospective chart review was undertaken of 29 patients with the diagnosis of carcinoma of the ethmoid complex who underwent treatment in the period between January 1976 and December 1994 at the Princess Margaret Hospital. Analysis was confined to those patients with epithelial invasive histology (squamous carcinoma, adenocarcinoma, or undifferentiated carcinoma) managed with curative intent with primary radiation therapy. The median patient age was 62, with a median follow-up time of 4 years. Staging was assigned according to a modification of the UICC 1997 system with 19 (66%) of patients presenting with T4 category tumors. The most common radiation dose regimes were 60 Gy in 30 daily fractions over 6 weeks, or 50 Gy in 20 daily fractions over 4 weeks. Outcome was analyzed with respect to overall survival, cause-specific survival, and local progression-free survival. The influence of a variety of clinical and therapeutic factors on outcome is discussed, the patterns of disease failure are described, and the rationale for this treatment approach is outlined.nnnRESULTSnThe 5-year rates of overall survival, cause-specific survival, and local progression-free survival were 39%, 58%, and 41%, respectively. A total of 18 of 29 patients died during the period of review. Of these, 12 deaths were due to ethmoid cancer, one was due to a second primary lung cancer, and five were attributed to nononcologic causes. No patients died due to treatment-related toxicity. Increasing T category predicted for worse outcome on univariate analysis. Local progression was the major cause of treatment failure and was documented in 15 of 29 patients treated (52%). Six patients were offered salvage surgery for local progression, of whom two remained disease free at 15 and 17 months follow-up.nnnCONCLUSIONSnOutcome of patients with ethmoid cancer managed with primary radiation therapy with surgery for salvage is comparable to that achieved with planned combined modality approaches. Nevertheless, outcome remains poor and is dependent on the local extent of tumor, with 40-50% of patients eventually succumbing to disease.

Whole abdominal radiation in the management of metastatic gastrointestinal carcinoid tumor

Abstract Twenty-eight patients with metastatic gastrointestinal carcinoid tumor were treated with whole abdominal radiation. Twenty-one of these patients had the carcinoid syndrome. The prescribed mid-line tumor dose was 2000 to 2500 rad. in 20 to 25 fractions in 4 to 5 weeks. The overall 5 year survival was 35% (median survival 2.5 years). A marked survival difference was noted in those patients with carcinoid syndrome compared to the non-functioning group. None of the syndrome patients survived five years (median survival 1.7 years) whereas six of the seven non-syndrome patients are five year survivors.

Postoperative local abdominal irradiation for cancer of the colon above the peritoneal reflection

A retrospective analysis of 82 patients with cancer of the colon above the peritoneal reflection who received postoperative local abdominal irradiation was undertaken to assess the survival, patterns of failure, and toxicity of treatment. Forty-eight patients (adjuvant group) had a complete resection, but were felt to be at high risk for local relapse and received postoperative local abdominal irradiation. Thirty-four patients had gross residual disease following surgery. The 5-year actuarial survival and local relapse free survival were 67 and 67%, respectively, in the adjuvant group. In this group, local relapse was observed in 9 of 28 patients with Stage C disease in contrast to 3 of 20 patients with Stage B2 disease; 1 of 14 patients with lesions in the right colon failed locally compared to 11 of 35 patients with lesions in the left. Only 2 of the 34 patients with gross residual disease remained relapse free from 93% of patients having a component of local failure. The majority of the treatment morbidity was seen in patients with gross residual disease. Prospective randomized studies should be done to determine the efficacy of postoperative irradiation in patients with colon carcinoma who are at high risk for local recurrence following surgical resection.

Concomitant Radiation and 5-Fluorouracil for Head and Neck Cancer

One of the first trials of concomitant radiation and chemotherapy to show any improvement in survival rates included the administration of 5- fluorouracil (5-FU) during the course of radiation treatment of oral and oropharyngeal cancers (Lo et al. 1976). Nevertheless, while the premise that the cure rates for squamous cell cancers of the head and neck can be increased by the addition of chemotherapy to radiotherapeutic and surgical protocols is attractive, any clear demonstration of benefit from such combinations remains elusive. If a cytotoxic drug has demonstrable activity against the cancer being treated, combining such a drug with radiation might improve local control rates and reduce the incidence of distant metastases. If there is any synergistic interaction between the drug and radiation, a greater level of control might be achieved in tissues exposed to both agents than would result from the additive cytotoxic effects of the combination (Steel and Peckham 1979). However, if synergistic or additive effects also increase damage to normal tissues, the therapeutic ratio could be adversely affected by combined modality therapy. The many difficulties in interpreting the literature relating to laboratory studies and to clinical trials of combinations of radiation and cytotoxic drugs have been reviewed recently (Fu 1985; Iscoe 1987; Steel 1988; Tannock 1989).