Bárbara Côrrea Krug

Medicamentos de alto custo para doenças raras no Brasil: o exemplo das doenças lisossômicas

This paper approaches in a critical way aspects of Brazilian public policies for drugs, emphasizing those classified as high cost and for rare diseases. The lysosomal storage diseases was taken as an example because of their rarity and the international trend for the development of new drugs for their treatment, all at high costs. Three lysosomal storage diseases were approached: Gaucher disease, Fabry disease and mucopolysaccharidosis type I. Gaucher disease has its treatment drug licensed in Brazil and guidelines for its use are established through a clinical protocol by the Ministry of Health. The others have their drug treatments registered in Brazil; however, no treatment guidelines for them have been developed by the government. The objective of the paper was to foster the discussion on the role of health technology assessment for high-cost drugs for rare diseases in Brazil, emphasizing the need for establishing health policies with legitimacy towards these diseases. Despite the difficulties in establishing a health policy for each rare disease, it is possible to create rational models to deal with this growing challenge.

Enzyme replacement therapy for Fabry disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis

The specific treatment available for Fabry disease (FD) is enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) with agalsidase alfa or beta. A systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted to assess the efficacy and safety of ERT for FD. Only double-blind, randomized clinical trials (RCTs) comparing agalsidase alfa or beta and placebo were included. ERT with either agalsidase alfa or beta was considered similar for the purposes of analysis. Ten RCTs were identified, which showed improvements in neuropathic pain, in heart abnormalities and in globotriaosylceramide (GL-3) levels. A meta-analysis showed increased odds for fever, rigors, development of IgG antibodies to agalsidase, and no significant association with development of hypertension or reduction in the QRS complex duration on electrocardiogram. The RCTs included in this comparison enrolled few patients, were highly heterogeneous, and were focused mainly on surrogate endpoints, limiting any conclusions as to the real effect of ERT for FD. The available evidence suggests that response to ERT is variable across patient subgroups and that agalsidase may slow progression of FD, with slight improvement of existing changes. Nevertheless, many uncertainties remain, and further studies are necessary.

Ethical issues related to the access to orphan drugs in Brazil: the case of mucopolysaccharidosis type I

Background/Aims Mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS I) is a rare lysosomal storage disorder treated with bone marrow transplantation or enzyme replacement therapy with laronidase, a high-cost orphan drug. Laronidase was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration and the European Medicines Agency in 2003 and by the Brazilian National Health Surveillance Agency in 2005. Many Brazilian MPS I patients have been receiving laronidase despite the absence of a governmental policy regulating access to the drug. Epidemiological and treatment data concerning MPS I are scarce. This study aims to present a demographic profile of Brazilian patients with MPS I, describe the routes of access to laronidase in Brazil, and discuss associated ethical issues relating to public funding of orphan drugs. Methods In this cross-sectional observational study, data were collected nationwide between January and September 2008 from physicians, public institutions and non-governmental organisations involved with diagnosis and treatment of MPS I, using two data collection instruments specifically designed for this purpose. Results The minimum prevalence of MPS I in Brazil was estimated at 1/2 700 000. Most patients (69.8%) were younger than 15 years; 60 (88.2%) received laronidase. The most common route of access to the drug was through lawsuits (86.6%). Conclusions In Brazil, MPS I is predominantly a paediatric illness. Even though the cost of laronidase treatment is not officially covered by the Brazilian government, most MPS I patients receive the drug, usually through litigation. This gives rise to major ethical conflicts concerning drug access in a low-resource context. The Brazilian health policy framework lacks evidence-based clinical protocols for the distribution of orphan drugs.

Quality of Life of Brazilian Patients with Gaucher Disease and Fabry Disease

OBJECTIVE To evaluate QoL in a sample of Brazilian patients with Gaucher (GD) and Fabry (FD) disease using the SF-36 survey. METHOD Observational cross-sectional study. The SF-36 survey was administered to cognitively able patients 12 years or older, who were seen in the Medical Genetics Service of Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, Brazil. RESULTS Thirty-five patients were included in the study (GD = 21, FD = 14), mean age was 29.8 ± 14.2 years and 29 (82.9%) were receiving ERT. Patients with GD receiving ERT had better scores in the general health (p = 0.046) domain of the SF-36 than patients with FD receiving ERT. Comparison of patients with GD naive to ERT and those receiving ERT revealed differences only in the bodily pain domain (p = 0.036). The Zimran score showed a moderate negative correlation with the following domains of the SF-36: physical functioning (p = 0.035), role-physical (p = 0.036), general health (p = 0.023) and role emotional (p = 0.021). DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Although limited because of the small number of patients included, findings suggest that patients with GD receiving ERT have a better QoL than patients with FD or with GD not receiving ERT. Imiglucerase has a beneficial effect against pain for patients with GD. Further studies should be conducted to confirm our findings.

Access to treatment for phenylketonuria by judicial means in Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.

Treatment of phenylketonuria (PKU) includes the use of a metabolic formula which should be provided free of charge by the Unified Health System (SUS). This retrospective, observational study sought to characterize judicial channels to obtain PKU treatment in Rio Grande do Sul (RS), Brazil. Lawsuits filed between 2001- 2010 and having as beneficiaries PKU patients requesting treatment for the disease were included. Of 20 lawsuits filed, corresponding to 16.8% of RS patients with PKU, 19 were retrieved for analysis. Of these, only two sought to obtain therapies other than metabolic formula. In all the other 17 cases, prior treatment requests had been granted by the State Department of Health. Defendants included the State (n = 19), the Union (n = 1), and municipalities (n = 4). In 18/19 cases, the courts ruled in favor of the plaintiffs. Violation of the right to health and discontinuation of State-provided treatment were the main reasons for judicial recourse. Unlike other genetic diseases, patients with PKU seek legal remedy to obtain a product already covered by the national pharmaceutical assistance policy, suggesting that management failures are a driving factor for judicialization in Brazil.

The Management of Gaucher Disease in Developing Countries: A Successful Experience in Southern Brazil

Objective: Gaucher disease (GD) is a genetic disease caused by glucocerebrosidase deficiency. GD is treated by enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) with imiglucerase, a high-cost drug provided by the Brazilian Ministry of Health (BMH). This study reports the implementation of the BMH guidelines for GD in the southernmost state of the country. Methods: We review the clinical and laboratorial data for patients seen at the reference center for GD from Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil (July 2003 to June 2006). Results: Twenty-five patients were included in this study. At baseline, 19/20 were on ERT (mean dosage of imiglucerase = 51.8 U/kg/infusion), 3/17 presented anemia, and 5/16 thrombocytopenia. The amount of imiglucerase prescribed to these patients was adjusted according to the guidelines in July 2003; out of them, 18 were receiving ERT in the reference center at month 36 (mean dosage of imiglucerase = 27.5 U/kg/infusion), 2/18 presented anemia, and 4/18 presented thrombocytopenia. The analysis of the liver, spleen, and bone data presented some limitations, but the available information suggests that patients did not deteriorate. GD patients who initiated ERT after July 2003 (n = 5) received lower dosage of imiglucerase since the beginning of the treatment; most of them demonstrated clinical and laboratorial response. From baseline to month 36, the consumption of imiglucerase by the reference center showed a significant reduction, which represented savings of USD 3 million to the public health system. Conclusions: The model of care of GD patients suggested by the BMH guidelines appears to be cost-effective and could be an example for management of rare diseases in underdeveloped countries.

Adherence to Treatment of Phenylketonuria: A Study in Southern Brazilian Patients

Introduction:Phenylketonuria (PKU) is caused by the deficient activity of phenylalanine hydroxylase.Aim:To identify the factors associated with treatment adherence among patients with PKU seen at a southern Brazil reference center.Methodology:A cross-sectional, outpatient-based study including 56 patients with PKU (median age, 12 years) for whom a Phe-restrict diet plus specific metabolic formula have been prescribed. Patients were considered adherent or nonadherent depending on the median phenylalanine concentration for the 12 months prior to study and target levels of phenylalanine for each age range (<13 years = ≤360 µmol/L; ≥13 years = ≤900 µmol/L). Data were collected through a review of patient’s medical records and a set of interviews with patients and their relatives.Results:Eighteen patients (32.1%; ≥13 years, 11) were classified as treatment adherent. Among all factors analyzed, only mental retardation, living with parents, and level of maternal education were associated with adherence to treatm...

PP044 Adherence To Enzyme Replacement Therapy In Gaucher Disease

No publications reporting on flare/pseudoseptic reactions with Synolis V-A were found. There are limited case series of patients treated with Synolis V-A, with most evidence coming from a prospective post-marketing surveillance case series, which showed reduced pain and functional impairment at 6 months. Adverse reactions were rare. CGH’s own small trial of Synolis V-A did not show any flare reactions.