Barbara S. Hawkins

Visual Function Abnormalities and Prognosis in Eyes with Age-related Geographic Atrophy of the Macula and Good Visual Acuity

PURPOSE Geographic atrophy (GA) may cause significant compromise of visual function, even when there still is good visual acuity (VA), because of parafoveal scotomas and foveal function abnormalities antedating visible atrophy. This study evaluates the visual function abnormalities at baseline and the 2-year worsening of VA and reading rate for eyes with GA compared with a group of eyes with drusen only. METHODS Seventy-four eyes with GA and VA greater than or equal to 20/50 from a prospective natural history study of GA were included, as were 13 eyes with only drusen. Baseline visual function testing and 2-year VA and maximum reading rate are reported. RESULTS The worsening of VA in decreased luminance and foveal dark-adapted sensitivity showed severe abnormalities for the GA group. Contrast sensitivity was significantly reduced for the eyes with GA. Half the eyes with GA, but none of the drusen eyes, had maximum reading rates below 100 words per minute. A scanning laser ophthalmoscope (SLO) measure of the scotoma near fixation combined with a measure of residual foveal function accounted for 54% of the variability in maximum reading rate in the eyes with GA. Of 40 eyes with GA observed for 2 years, half lost greater than or equal to 3 lines of VA and one quarter lost greater than or equal to 6 lines. The nine eyes with drusen with follow-up had no significant change in VA. Low foveal dark-adapted sensitivity, SLO measures of the scotoma within 1 degree of fixation, and low maximum reading rate were statistically significant risk factors for doubling of the visual angle. Significant reduction in maximum reading rates at 2 years was present for the eyes with GA. CONCLUSIONS The eyes with GA with good VA have profound decreases in visual function, particularly in dim lighting and in reading. Half the eyes with GA had doubling in visual angle at 2 years after the baseline examination, whereas the drusen eyes remained essentially unchanged. Impaired visual function at baseline was predictive of an adverse outcome for the eyes with GA.

The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) randomized trial of pre- enucleation radiation of large choroidal melanoma II: Initial mortality findings COMS report no. 10

PURPOSE To report initial mortality findings from the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) randomized clinical trial of pre-enucleation radiation of large choroidal melanoma. METHODS Patients were evaluated for eligibility at one of 43 participating centers in the United States and Canada. Eligible consenting patients were assigned randomly at the time of enrollment to standard enucleation or to external radiation of the orbit and globe prior to enucleation. Eligibility was confirmed at the COMS Coordinating Center, Echography Center, and Photograph Reading Center. Adherence to the radiotherapy protocol was monitored at the Radiological Physics Center. The diagnosis of choroidal melanoma was confirmed following enucleation by a three-member Pathology Review Committee. Patient accrual began in November 1986 and was completed in December 1994; 1,003 patients enrolled. Patients have been followed at annual clinical examinations. Cause of death was coded by a Mortality Coding Committee whose members were not involved in the care of COMS patients; the clinical trial was monitored by an independent Data and Safety Monitoring Committee. RESULTS A total of 1,003 patients were enrolled; 506 were assigned to enucleation alone and 497 to pre-enucleation radiation. Treatment groups were well balanced on baseline characteristics. Only nine patients were found to be ineligible after enrollment, seven in the interval between randomization and enucleation and two after enucleation based on histopathology. All but nine patients were treated as assigned; in only six of 491 eyes treated with pre-enucleation radiation was there a major deviation from the radiotherapy protocol. With 5-year outcome known for 801 patients enrolled (80%), the estimated 5-year survival rates and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were 57% (95% CI, 52% to 62%) for enucleation alone and 62% (95% CI, 57% to 66%) for pre-enucleation radiation. Among the baseline covariates evaluated, only age and longest basal diameter of the melanoma affected the prognosis for survival to a statistically significant degree. The risk of death among patients treated with pre-enucleation radiation relative to those treated with enucleation alone after adjustment for baseline characteristics of patients, eyes, and tumors was 1.03 (95% CI, 0.85 to 1.25). Of 435 deaths classified by the Mortality Coding Committee, 269 patients had histologically confirmed melanoma metastases at the time of death. Estimated 5-year survival rates for this secondary outcome were 72% (95% CI, 68% to 76%) for enucleation alone and 74% (95% CI, 69% to 78%) for pre-enucleation radiation. CONCLUSIONS No survival difference attributable to pre-enucleation radiation of large choroidal melanoma, using the COMS fractionation schedule, has been demonstrated to date in this randomized trial. The trial had statistical power of 90% to detect a relative difference in mortality rates between the two treatment arms of 20% or larger. A smaller difference is possible, but a clinically meaningful difference in mortality rates, whether from all causes or from metastatic melanoma, is unlikely.

Epidemiology of age-related macular degeneration

PURPOSE To review the epidemiology of age-related macular degeneration (AMD). DESIGN Evidence from epidemiologic data regarding the natural history of AMD and its risk factors are presented. RESULTS Large, soft drusen associated with pigmentary abnormalities increase the risk of progression to advanced AMD. Large soft drusen may fade over time. Advanced AMD is more likely to be present in whites than blacks, despite the similar prevalence of soft drusen in both groups. Neovascular AMD is more frequent than geographic atrophy in most population-based studies in whites in America, Australia, and the Netherlands than in similar population-based studies in Iceland and Norway. After age and family history, there are few consistent relationships of risk factors to AMD. Of these, the relationship of smoking, hypertension, and cataract surgery to advanced AMD have been most consistent. CONCLUSIONS Long-term epidemiologic studies have provided information on the distribution and the natural history of AMD and its associated risk factors. It is not known what effect reduction of blood pressure and the cessation of smoking might have on the incidence and progression of AMD.

Screening for Metastasis From Choroidal Melanoma: The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study Group Report 23

PURPOSE To describe the predictive value of liver function tests (LFTs), chest x-ray, and diagnostic imaging for detecting melanoma metastasis during routine follow-up after treatment for choroidal melanoma. MATERIALS AND METHODS Prospective longitudinal follow-up of patients enrolled onto two randomized trials was conducted by the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) Group. Baseline and annual or semiannual systemic and laboratory evaluations were performed according to a standard protocol for 2320 patients enrolled on the COMS. RESULTS COMS patients were screened annually for metastasis and new cancers using LFTs (alkaline phosphatase, AST, ALT, or bilirubin). Elevated findings (1.5 to 2 times upper limit of normal) on LFT prompted a diagnostic or imaging test to confirm or rule out cancer recurrence. Of 714 patients with clinical reports of metastasis, 675 patients died. Of these 675 patients, all but four had either histopathologically confirmed or clinically suspected metastatic melanoma present at the time of death. Among all patients, the 5-year cumulative diagnosis rate of metastatic melanoma was 24% (95% CI, 22% to 27%). Based on all patients with reported metastasis, the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value associated with at least one abnormal LFT before first diagnosis of metastasis at any site was 14.7%, 92.3%, 45.7% and 71.0%, respectively. CONCLUSION Use of LFTs results followed by diagnostic tests has high specificity and predictive values but low sensitivity. Better tests are needed to identify earlier metastatic disease associated with choroidal melanoma.

Enucleation Versus Plaque Irradiation for Choroidal Melanoma

The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) is an international, multicenter-controlled study. The organization includes an Executive Committee, Steering Committee, 6 Central Units, 32 Clinical Centers, and a Data and Safety Monitoring Committee. Scientifically, the COMS consists of (1) a randomized trial of patients with medium choroidal melanoma treated with enucleation versus iodine-125 plaque irradiation, (2) a randomized trial of patients with large choroidal melanoma treated with enucleation versus preenucleation external beam irradiation and enucleation, and (3) a prospective observational study of patients with small choroidal melanoma to determine whether a randomized trial of treatment is appropriate. In design and conduct of the COMS, special consideration is given to biostatistics and sample size considerations, iodine-125 plaque irradiation of choroidal melanoma, and coordinated ocular melanoma research. Recruitment is in progress. However, the pool of eligible patients is limited and the COMS needs the continued support and cooperation of ophthalmologists throughout the United States and Canada.

The development of choroidal neovascularization in eyes with the geographic atrophy form of age-related macular degeneration.

OBJECTIVE To determine the rate of developing choroidal neovascularization (CNV) in eyes with geographic atrophy (GA) from age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and the characteristics of the CNV in these eyes. DESIGN Prospective natural history study with cohort analysis. PARTICIPANTS One hundred fifty-two patients with GA and no CNV by fluorescein angiography in at least 1 eye, with annual follow-up. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES The development of CNV. RESULTS Thirteen eyes with GA developed CNV. For patients with bilateral GA and no CNV at baseline, 2% developed CNV by 2 years and 11% by 4 years. For patients with CNV in the fellow eye, 18% developed CNV in the study eye with GA by 2 years and 34% by 4 years. The eyes that developed CNV experienced more acuity loss than did the eyes with only GA. Within the fellow eye CNV group, those study eyes with GA that had less central atrophy (and better acuity) at baseline were more likely to develop CNV. The CNV developed at a peripheral border of GA in nine eyes, in the spared foveal region in two eyes, and in both center and border in one eye. No eye developed CNV in the area of atrophy itself. The appearance of CNV was evanescent in some cases and had a final appearance of an enlarged area of GA. Twelve other eyes had hemorrhages without definite evidence of CNV; three were thought to be suspicious for CNV and the remainder were thought to be hemorrhages that may be seen in elderly patients. CONCLUSION An eye with GA whose fellow eye has CNV is at significant risk for the development of CNV in the GA eye. A patient with bilateral GA and no evidence of CNV is at relatively low risk for developing CNV. The CNV may be evanescent and may not be detected. Intraretinal hemorrhages unrelated to CNV are relatively common in this older population.

Submacular surgery trials randomized pilot trial of laser photocoagulation versus surgery for recurrent choroidal neovascularization secondary to age-related macular degeneration: I. Ophthalmic outcomes. Submacular Surgery Trials Pilot Study report number 1

PURPOSE To report complications and changes in vision during 2 years of follow-up of patients with age-related macular degeneration assigned randomly to surgical removal or to laser photocoagulation of subfoveal recurrent neovascular lesions in a pilot trial designed to test methods, to refine estimates of outcome rates, and to project patient accrual rates for a larger multicenter randomized trial to evaluate submacular surgery. PATIENTS AND METHODS Eligible patients with previous laser photocoagulation of extrafoveal or juxtafoveal choroidal neovascularization secondary to age-related macular degeneration were enrolled at 15 collaborating clinical centers. Assignments to treatment arm were made by personnel at a central coordinating center. Adherence to eligibility criteria and treatment assignment was assessed centrally at a photograph reading center. Patients were examined at 3, 6, 12, and 24 months after treatment for data collection purposes. Outcome measures reported include treatment complications, adverse events, requirements for additional treatment, and 2-year changes in visual acuity from baseline. RESULTS Of 70 patients enrolled, 36 were assigned to laser photocoagulation and 34 to submacular surgery; all were treated as assigned. One patient in each group died before the 2-year examination. Visual acuity was measured at the 2-year examination for 31 of the surviving patients (89%) in the laser arm and for 28 of the surviving patients (85%) in the surgery arm. The 2-year measurements for 36 of the 59 patients (61%) were made by an examiner masked to treatment assignment and to the identity of the study eye. Improvements and losses of visual acuity were observed in both treatment arms; 20 of 31 study eyes (65%) in the laser arm and 14 of 28 study eyes (50%) in the surgery arm had visual acuity 2 years after enrollment that was better than or no more than 1 line worse than the baseline level. Changes in visual acuity and the size of the central macular lesions from baseline to the 2-year examination were similar in the treatment arms. Few serious complications were observed in either arm at the time of initial treatment; serious adverse events were rare. During follow-up, 11 laser-treated eyes and 18 surgically treated eyes had additional intraocular procedures. CONCLUSIONS The data from this pilot trial suggest no reason to prefer submacular surgery over laser photocoagulation for treatment of patients with age-related macular degeneration who have lesions similar to those studied in this pilot trial. Any clinical trial designed to compare submacular surgery with laser photocoagulation in eyes with age-related macular degeneration and subfoveal recurrent neovascular lesions must enroll several hundred patients in order to reach a statistically valid conclusion regarding differences between these two methods of treatment with respect to either changes in visual acuity or complication rates.

The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) randomized trial of pre-enucleation radiation of large choroidal melanoma I: characteristics of patients enrolled and not enrolled COMS report no. 9

PURPOSE To describe the baseline characteristics and status of patients enrolled in the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) randomized clinical trial of pre-enucleation radiation of large choroidal melanoma conducted in the United States and Canada, and to compare characteristics of patients enrolled with those of patients with tumors of eligible size who were not enrolled in order to assess the generalizability of findings from the clinical trial. METHODS For all patients evaluated for the clinical trial at COMS centers from November 1986 through December 15, 1994, selected data were transmitted to the COMS Coordinating Center. For patients who enrolled in the clinical trial, ophthalmic and medical history, examination findings, and visual acuity measurements were recorded prior to enrollment. Standardized A-scan and contact B-scan echographic examinations were performed prior to enrollment, and photoechograms were submitted for central review for consistency with the diagnosis, independent measurement of the apical height of the tumor, and description of tumor configuration and internal reflectivity for each patient enrolled. Until January 1992, wide-angle fundus photographs and fluorescein angiograms taken prior to enrollment also were submitted for central review to confirm consistency with the diagnosis. All data were integrated and analyzed at the COMS Coordinating Center. RESULTS Of 6,078 patients with choroidal melanoma evaluated in COMS centers, 1,860 had tumors of eligible size; of these, 1,302 (70%) were eligible for the clinical trial, and 1,003 (77% of eligible patients) enrolled. The two principal reasons for ineligibility were other primary cancer and predominantly ciliary body melanoma. Ineligible patients were older than eligible patients, had larger choroidal melanoma, and had poorer visual acuity at the time of evaluation for the COMS (P < .01, Wilcoxon rank sum tests). Patients eligible for the clinical trial had a mean age of 60 years; 56% were male; almost all (97%) were non-Hispanic whites. Among eligible patients, mean tumor apical height was 9.5 mm and mean longest basal diameter was 17.2 mm. Eligible patients who enrolled in the trial were similar to eligible patients who did not enroll with respect to most factors considered. Those who enrolled had longer tumor basal diameter and better visual acuity in the fellow eye, more often had their primary residence in Canada, and less often had education beyond high school than did eligible patients who did not enroll (P < .05, Wilcoxon rank sum tests and chi2 tests, respectively). CONCLUSIONS The COMS clinical trial of pre-enucleation radiation was designed to yield internally valid treatment comparisons through random treatment assignment at time of enrollment. Findings also have high external validity because a majority (54%) of all patients with tumors of eligible size, and a large majority (77%) of all eligible patients, were enrolled. Furthermore, patient characteristics are similar to those of patients included in other evaluations of this method of treating large choroidal melanoma. Thus, findings from this clinical trial apply to all patients who have large choroidal melanoma and satisfy COMS eligibility criteria.

Comparative effectiveness of treatments for open-angle glaucoma: A systematic review for the U.S. preventive services task force

BACKGROUND Glaucoma is an acquired degeneration of the optic nerve and a leading cause of blindness worldwide. Medical and surgical treatments that decrease intraocular pressure may prevent visual impairment and blindness. PURPOSE To compare the effectiveness of medical, laser, and surgical treatments in adults with open-angle glaucoma with regard to decreasing intraocular pressure and preventing optic nerve damage, vision loss, and visual impairment. DATA SOURCES MEDLINE, CENTRAL, and an existing database for systematic reviews (through 2 March 2011); MEDLINE, EMBASE, LILACS, and CENTRAL for primary studies (through 30 July 2012). STUDY SELECTION English-language systematic reviews; randomized, controlled trials; and quasi-randomized, controlled trials for most outcomes and observational studies for quality of life and harms. DATA EXTRACTION Two investigators abstracted or checked information about study design, participants, and outcomes and assessed risk of bias and strength of evidence. DATA SYNTHESIS High-level evidence suggests that medical, laser, and surgical treatments decrease intraocular pressure and that medical treatment and trabeculectomy reduce the risk for optic nerve damage and visual field loss compared with no treatment. The direct effect of treatments on visual impairment and the comparative efficacy of different treatments are not clear. Harms of medical treatment are primarily local (ocular redness, irritation); surgical treatment carries a small risk for more serious complications. LIMITATION Heterogeneous outcome definitions and measurements among the included studies; exclusion of many treatment studies that did not stratify results by glaucoma type. CONCLUSION Medical and surgical treatments for open-angle glaucoma lower intraocular pressure and reduce the risk for optic nerve damage over the short to medium term. Which treatments best prevent visual disability and improve patient-reported outcomes is unclear.

Low Luminance Visual Dysfunction as a Predictor of Subsequent Visual Acuity Loss from Geographic Atrophy in Age-Related Macular Degeneration

OBJECTIVE To show that low luminance visual dysfunction is predictive of subsequent visual acuity (VA) loss in eyes with geographic atrophy (GA) resulting from age-related macular degeneration (AMD). DESIGN Cohort study examining the prospective natural history study of GA from 1992 through 2000 at the Wilmer Eye Institute. PARTICIPANTS Ninety-one participants with GA resulting from AMD without choroidal neovascularization in at least 1 eye who completed a 2-year study examination. METHODS Annual examinations included measurement of best-corrected VA, low luminance VA, Pelli-Robson contrast sensitivity, reading speed, examination, and fundus photography. The total GA area was quantified, as was the GA within a 10.2-mm(2) circle centered on the fovea. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Visual acuity loss at 2 years and risk factors for visual loss. RESULTS Participants with baseline VA of 20/50 or more had a 40% 2-year rate of VA loss of 3 lines or more, compared with 13% for the participants with worse baseline acuities. The baseline low-luminance deficit (LLD) in VA was a strong predictor of subsequent VA loss for all levels of baseline VA. Within the good baseline VA group, the relative risk (RR) of 3-line loss for the worse LLD group compared with the better LLD group was 2.88 (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.13-7.35). The LLD is a stable and reproducible measure. Other significant visual function predictors of subsequent VA loss in eyes with good baseline VA included foveal dark-adapted sensitivity (RR, 4.20; 95% CI, 1.39-12.71) and reduced reading rate (RR, 2.43; 95% CI, 1.11-5.31). The rate of VA loss within the good acuity group was higher when the GA included 25% to 75% of the central 10.2 mm(2) than in eyes with GA including less than 25% or more than 75% of the central 10.2 mm(2). The following were not significant predictors of subsequent VA loss among these participants: age, gender, fellow eye diagnosis, fellow eye VA, baseline GA area, and GA enlargement rate. CONCLUSIONS Visual function measures can predict the risk of future VA loss in subjects with GA and good baseline VA. They may allow identification of the highest risk group for VA loss, enabling more efficient design of clinical trials. They also may be appropriate surrogate measures of foveal health in short-term treatment trials.