Barry L. Taylor

PAS domain residues involved in signal transduction by the Aer redox sensor of Escherichia coli

PAS domains sense oxygen, redox potential and light, and are implicated in behaviour, circadian rhythmicity, development and metabolic regulation. Although PAS domains are widespread in archaea, bacteria and eukaryota, the mechanism of signal transduction has been elucidated only for the bacterial photo sensor PYP and oxygen sensor FixL. We investigated the signalling mechanism in the PAS domain of Aer, the redox potential sensor and aerotaxis transducer in Escherichia coli. Forty‐two residues in Aer were substituted using cysteine‐replacement mutagenesis. Eight mutations resulted in a null phenotype for aerotaxis, the behavioural response to oxygen. Four of them also led to the loss of the non‐covalently bound FAD cofactor. Three mutant Aer proteins, N34C, F66C and N85C, transmitted a constant signal‐on bias. One mutation, Y111C, inverted signalling by the transducer so that positive stimuli produced negative signals and vice versa. Residues critical for signalling were mapped onto a three‐dimensional model of the Aer PAS domain, and an FAD‐binding site and ‘active site’ for signal transduction are proposed.

Aer on the inside looking out: paradigm for a PAS–HAMP role in sensing oxygen, redox and energy

Aer, the Escherichia coli aerotaxis (oxygen‐sensing) receptor, is representative of a small class of receptors that face the cytoplasm in bacteria. Instead of sensing oxygen directly, Aer detects redox changes in the electron transport system or cytoplasm when the bacteria enter or leave a hypoxic microniche. As a result, Aer sensing also enables bacteria to avoid environments where carbon deficiency, unfavourable reduction potential or other insults would limit energy production. An FAD‐binding PAS domain is the sensor for Aer and a HAMP domain interacts with the PAS domain to form an input–output module for signal transduction. By analogy to the first solution structure of an isolated HAMP domain from Archaeoglobus, Aer HAMP is proposed to fold into a four‐helix bundle that rotates between a signal‐on and signal‐off conformation. Aer is the first protein in which a PAS–HAMP input–output module has been investigated. The structure and signal transduction mechanism of Aer is providing important insights into signalling by PAS and HAMP domains.

In search of higher energy: metabolism-dependent behaviour in bacteria

Bacteria use different strategies to navigate to niches where environmental factors are favourable for growth. Chemotaxis is a behavioural response mediated by specific receptors that sense the concentration of chemicals in the environment. Recently, a new type of sensor has been described in Escherichia coli that responds to changes in cellular energy (redox) levels. This sensor, Aer, guides the bacteria to environments that support maximal energy levels in the cells. A variety of stimuli, such as oxygen, alternative electron acceptors, light, redox carriers that interact with the electron transport system and metabolized carbon sources, effect changes in the cellular energy (redox) levels. These changes are detected by Aer and by the serine chemotaxis receptor Tsr and are transduced into signals that elicit appropriate behavioural responses. Diverse environmental signals from Aer and chemotaxis receptors converge and integrate at the level of the CheA histidine kinase. Energy sensing is widespread in bacteria, and it is now evident that a variety of signal transduction strategies are used for the metabolism‐dependent behaviours. The occurrence of putative energy‐sensing domains in proteins from cells ranging from Archaea to humans indicates the importance of this function for all living systems.

Structure-Function Relationships in the HAMP and Proximal Signaling Domains of the Aerotaxis Receptor Aer

Aer, the Escherichia coli aerotaxis receptor, faces the cytoplasm, where the PAS (Per-ARNT-Sim)-flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) domain senses redox changes in the electron transport system or cytoplasm. PAS-FAD interacts with a HAMP (histidine kinase, adenylyl cyclase, methyl-accepting protein, and phosphatase) domain to form an input-output module for Aer signaling. In this study, the structure of the Aer HAMP and proximal signaling domains was probed to elucidate structure-function relationships important for signaling. Aer residues 210 to 290 were individually replaced with cysteine and then cross-linked in vivo. The results confirmed that the Aer HAMP domain is composed of two alpha-helices separated by a structured loop. The proximal signaling domain consisted of two alpha-helices separated by a short undetermined structure. The Af1503 HAMP domain from Archaeoglobus fulgidus was recently shown to be a four-helix bundle. To test whether the Af1503 HAMP domain is a prototype for the Aer HAMP domain, the latter was modeled using coordinates from Af1503. Several findings supported the hypothesis that Aer has a four-helix HAMP structure: (i) cross-linking independently identified the same residues at the dimer interface that were predicted by the model, (ii) the rate of cross-linking for residue pairs was inversely proportional to the beta-carbon distances measured on the model, and (iii) clockwise lesions that were not contiguous in the linear Aer sequence were clustered in one region in the folded HAMP model, defining a potential site of PAS-HAMP interaction during signaling. In silico modeling of mutant Aer proteins indicated that the four-helix HAMP structure was important for Aer stability or maturation. The significance of the HAMP and proximal signaling domain structure for signal transduction is discussed.

Differentiation between electron transport sensing and proton motive force sensing by the Aer and Tsr receptors for aerotaxis

Aerotaxis (oxygen‐seeking) behaviour in Escherichia coli is a response to changes in the electron transport system and not oxygen per se. Because changes in proton motive force (PMF) are coupled to respiratory electron transport, it is difficult to differentiate between PMF, electron transport or redox, all primary candidates for the signal sensed by the aerotaxis receptors, Aer and Tsr. We constructed electron transport mutants that produced different respiratory H+/e– stoichiometries. These strains expressed binary combinations of one NADH dehydrogenase and one quinol oxidase. We then introduced either an aer or tsr mutation into each mutant to create two sets of electron transport mutants. In vivo H+/e– ratios for strains grown in glycerol medium ranged from 1.46 ± 0.18–3.04 ± 0.47, but rates of respiration and growth were similar. The PMF jump in response to oxygen was proportional to the H+/e– ratio in each set of mutants (r2 = 0.986–0.996). The length of Tsr‐mediated aerotaxis responses increased with the PMF jump (r2 = 0.988), but Aer‐mediated responses did not correlate with either PMF changes (r2 = 0.297) or the rate of electron transport (r2 = 0.066). Aer‐mediated responses were linked to NADH dehydrogenase I, although there was no absolute requirement. The data indicate that Tsr responds to changes in PMF, but strong Aer responses to oxygen are associated with redox changes in NADH dehydrogenase I.

How do bacteria find the optimal concentration of oxygen

Abstract Aerobic bacteria avoid the twin dangers of too little oxygen or too much oxygen by utilizing their electron transport system as the sensor for a positive behavioral response to oxygen (aerotaxis) and a different receptor for negative aerotaxis. Salmonella typhimurium swims up a gradient of oxygen until the terminal oxidase (cytochrome o ) is saturated by oxygen. If the bacteria happen to swim too far up the gradient they are repelled by the high oxygen concentrations. The mechanism of positive aerotaxis is quite different from chemotaxis. Adaptation to most chemicals is dependent on methylation of a transducer protein, but adaptation to oxygen is independent of methylation.

Interactions between the PAS and HAMP domains of the Escherichia coli aerotaxis receptor Aer.

The Escherichia coli energy-sensing Aer protein initiates aerotaxis towards environments supporting optimal cellular energy. The Aer sensor is an N-terminal, FAD-binding, PAS domain. The PAS domain is linked by an F1 region to a membrane anchor, and in the C-terminal half of Aer, a HAMP domain links the membrane anchor to the signaling domain. The F1 region, membrane anchor, and HAMP domain are required for FAD binding. Presumably, alterations in the redox potential of FAD induce conformational changes in the PAS domain that are transmitted to the HAMP and C-terminal signaling domains. In this study we used random mutagenesis and intragenic pseudoreversion analysis to examine functional interactions between the HAMP domain and the N-terminal half of Aer. Missense mutations in the HAMP domain clustered in the AS-2 alpha-helix and abolished FAD binding to Aer, as previously reported. Three amino acid replacements in the Aer-PAS domain, S28G, A65V, and A99V, restored FAD binding and aerotaxis to the HAMP mutants. These suppressors are predicted to surround a cleft in the PAS domain that may bind FAD. On the other hand, suppression of an Aer-C253R HAMP mutant was specific to an N34D substitution with a predicted location on the PAS surface, suggesting that residues C253 and N34 interact or are in close proximity. No suppressor mutations were identified in the F1 region or membrane anchor. We propose that functional interactions between the PAS domain and the HAMP AS-2 helix are required for FAD binding and aerotactic signaling by Aer.

The FAD-PAS Domain as a Sensor for Behavioral Responses in Escherichia coli

Aer, the aerotaxis receptor in Escherichia coli, is a member of a novel class of flavoproteins that act as redox sensors. The internal energy of the cell is coupled to the redox state of the electron transport system, and this status is sensed by Aer(FAD). This is a more versatile sensory response system than if E. coli sensed oxygen per se. Energy-depleting conditions that decrease electron transport also alter the redox state of the electron transport system. Aer responds by sending a signal to the flagellar motor to change direction. The output of other sensory systems that utilize redox sensors is more commonly transcriptional regulation than a behavioral response. Analysis in silico showed Aer to be part of a superfamily of PAS domain proteins that sense the intracellular environment. In Aer, FAD binds to the PAS domain. By using site-specific mutagenesis, residues critical for FAD binding and sensory transduction were identified in the PAS domain. The PAS domain appears to interact with a linker region in the C-terminus. The linker region is a member of a HAMP domain family, which has signal transduction roles in other systems.

Genetic Analysis of the HAMP Domain of the Aer Aerotaxis Sensor Localizes Flavin Adenine Dinucleotide-Binding Determinants to the AS-2 Helix

HAMP domains are signal transduction domains typically located between the membrane anchor and cytoplasmic signaling domain of the proteins in which they occur. The prototypical structure consists of two helical amphipathic sequences (AS-1 and AS-2) connected by a region of undetermined structure. The Escherichia coli aerotaxis receptor, Aer, has a HAMP domain and a PAS domain with a flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) cofactor that senses the intracellular energy level. Previous studies reported mutations in the HAMP domain that abolished FAD binding to the PAS domain. In this study, using random and site-directed mutagenesis, we identified the distal helix, AS-2, as the component of the HAMP domain that stabilizes FAD binding. AS-2 in Aer is not amphipathic and is predicted to be buried. Mutations in the sequence coding for the contiguous proximal signaling domain altered signaling by Aer but did not affect FAD binding. The V264M residue replacement in this region resulted in an inverted response in which E. coli cells expressing the mutant Aer protein were repelled by oxygen. Bioinformatics analysis of aligned HAMP domains indicated that the proximal signaling domain is conserved in other HAMP domains that are not involved in chemotaxis or aerotaxis. Only one null mutation was found in the coding sequence for the HAMP AS-1 and connector regions, suggesting that these are not active signal transduction sites. We consider a model in which the signal from FAD is transmitted across a PAS-HAMP interface to AS-2 or the proximal signaling domain.

PAS Domain of the Aer Redox Sensor Requires C-Terminal Residues for Native-Fold Formation and Flavin Adenine Dinucleotide Binding

The Aer protein in Escherichia coli is a membrane-bound, FAD-containing aerotaxis and energy sensor that putatively monitors the redox state of the electron transport system. Binding of FAD to Aer requires the N-terminal PAS domain and residues in the F1 region and C-terminal HAMP domain. The PAS domains of other PAS proteins are soluble in water. To investigate properties of the PAS domain, we subcloned segments of the aer gene from E. coli that encode the PAS domain with and without His6 tags and expressed the PAS peptides in E. coli. The 20-kDa His6-Aer2-166 PAS-F1 fragment was purified as an 800-kDa complex by gel filtration chromatography, and the associating protein was identified by N-terminal sequencing as the chaperone protein GroEL. None of the N-terminal fragments of Aer found in the soluble fraction was released from GroEL, suggesting that these peptides do not fold correctly in an aqueous environment and require a motif external to the PAS domain for proper folding. Consistent with this model, peptide fragments that included the membrane binding region and part (Aer2-231) or all (Aer2-285) of the HAMP domain inserted into the membrane, indicating that they were released by GroEL. Aer2-285, but not Aer2-231, bound FAD, confirming the requirement for the HAMP domain in stabilizing FAD binding. The results raise an interesting possibility that residues outside the PAS domain that are required for FAD binding are essential for formation of the PAS native fold.