Bedros Afeyan

Direct-Drive Laser Fusion; Status and Prospects

Techniques have been developed to improve the uniformity of the laser focal profile, to reduce the ablative Rayleigh–Taylor instability, and to suppress the various laser–plasma instabilities. There are now three direct-drive ignition target designs that utilize these techniques. An evaluation of these designs is still ongoing. Some of them may achieve the gains above 100 that are necessary for a fusion reactor. Two laser systems have been proposed that may meet all of the requirements for a fusion reactor.

Laser–plasma interactions in ignition‐scale hohlraum plasmas

Scattering of laser light by stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) and stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) is a concern for indirect drive inertial confinement fusion (ICF). The hohlraum designs for the National Ignition Facility (NIF) raise particular concerns due to the large scale and homogeneity of the plasmas within them. Experiments at Nova have studied laser–plasma interactions within large scale length plasmas that mimic many of the characteristics of the NIF hohlraum plasmas. Filamentation and scattering of laser light by SBS and SRS have been investigated as a function of beam smoothing and plasma conditions. Narrowly collimated SRS backscatter has been observed from low density, low‐Z, plasmas, which are representative of the plasma filling most of the NIF hohlraum. SBS backscatter is found to occur in the high‐Z plasma of gold ablated from the wall. Both SBS and SRS are observed to be at acceptable levels in experiments using smoothing by spectral dispersion (SSD).

Energy transfer between crossing laser beams

Induced scattering between crossing laser beams is considered, including the effects of long‐wavelength modulations in the plasma. This fundamental process can impact the choice of beam‐smoothing techniques for laser‐driven hohlraums. Study of this process is an ideal way to quantify stimulated scattering instabilities, since one can independently vary the intensity, polarization, and frequency separation of the crossing beams.

Progress in symmetric ICF capsule implosions and wire-array z-pinch source physics for double-pinch-driven hohlraums

Over the last several years, rapid progress has been made evaluating the double-z-pinch indirect-drive, inertial confinement fusion (ICF) high-yield target concept (Hammer et al 1999 Phys. Plasmas 6 2129). We have demonstrated efficient coupling of radiation from two wire-array-driven primary hohlraums to a secondary hohlraum that is large enough to drive a high yield ICF capsule. The secondary hohlraum is irradiated from two sides by z-pinches to produce low odd-mode radiation asymmetry. This double-pinch source is driven from a single electrical power feed (Cuneo et al 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 215004) on the 20 MA Z accelerator. The double z-pinch has imploded ICF capsules with even-mode radiation symmetry of 3.1 ± 1.4% and to high capsule radial convergence ratios of 14–21 (Bennett et al 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 245002; Bennett et al 2003 Phys. Plasmas 10 3717; Vesey et al 2003 Phys. Plasmas 10 1854). Advances in wire-array physics at 20 MA are improving our understanding of z-pinch power scaling with increasing drive current. Techniques for shaping the z-pinch radiation pulse necessary for low adiabat capsule compression have also been demonstrated.

Effects of laser beam smoothing on stimulated Raman scattering in exploding foil plasmas

Time‐resolved spectra of backward stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) were measured from the interaction of a 527 nm laser with a preformed plasma. The effect of laser smoothing by spectral dispersion (SSD) was studied using laser bandwidth (Δλ/λ=0.1%) and varying the laser intensity (2–20×1014 W/cm2). A broad SRS spectrum extending to short wavelengths was observed for the high‐intensity, Δλ/λ=0 case. Narrow spectra corresponding to the peak plasma density were observed for cases with either high intensity and Δλ/λ∼0.1%, or with low intensity and Δλ/λ=0. Simulations of the filamentation process were performed for the conditions of these experiments. The simulations show that laser smoothing stabilizes filamentation for high‐intensity interactions, and that filaments are stable without smoothing for low intensity. The predicted onset of filamentation without smoothing correlates with the growth of short wavelength SRS. These experimental results are presented and models are discussed that may help explain t...

Observation of multiple mechanisms for stimulating ion waves in ignition scale plasmas

The laser and plasma conditions expected in ignition experiments using indirect drive inertial confinement have been studied experimentally. It has been shown that there are at least three ways in which ion waves can be stimulated in these plasmas and have significant effect on the energy balance and distribution in the target. First ion waves can be stimulated by a single laser beam by the process of Stimulated Brillouin Scattering (SBS) in which an ion acoustic and a scattered electromagnetic wave grow from noise. Second, in a plasma where more than one beam intersect, ion waves can Lie excited at the `beat` frequency and wave number of the intersecting beams,, causing the side scatter instability to be seeded, and substantial energy to be transferred between the beams [R. K. Kirkwood et. al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 2065 (1996)]. And third, ion waves may be stimulated by the decay of electron plasma waves produced by Stimulated Raman Scattering (SRS), thereby inhibiting the SRS process [R. K. Kirkwood et. al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2706 (1996)].

The scattering phase shift due to Bragg resonance in one-dimensional fluctuation reflectometry

An explicit integral representation is derived for the tangent of the phase shift due to one-dimensional (1D) scattering of an S-polarized, O-mode, electromagnetic field from a localized wavepacket sitting on top of an inhomogeneous plasma. A Green function technique is used in the derivation together with the Born approximation. The integral representation is evaluated using asymptotic techniques and Bragg resonance is seen to be the dominant mechanism producing the phase shifts due to fluctuations with wavelengths that are short compared to the Airy length. By suitably normalizing the governing differential equation, we have identified the two dominant parameters that control the approximations in our analysis. These are delta n/n0 and kf. The first is the magnitude of the maximum density fluctuation multiplied by the square of the dimensionless length scale that characterizes both the background plasma density profile (with scalelength L) and the incoming microwave field (with vacuum wavenumber k0): delta n/n0 identical to ( delta n/n0)*(k0L)23/. The second is the fluctuation wavenumber normalized to k0 and scaled by the similarly normalized Airy wavenumber: kf identical to (kf/k0)*(k0L)13/. The Born approximation is expected to be valid as long as delta n/n0 1.

Computational study of ultra-short-pulse reflectometry

Ultra-short-pulse reflectometry is studied by means of the numerical integration of a one-dimensional full-wave equation for ordinary modes propagating in a plasma. The numerical calculations illustrate the potential of using the reflection of ultra-short-pulse microwaves as an effective probe of the density profile even in the presence of density fluctuations in a plasma. The difference in time delays of differing frequency components of the microwaves can be used to deduce the density profile. The modification of the reflected pulses in the presence of density fluctuations is examined and can be understood based on considerations of Bragg resonance. A simple and effective profile-reconstruction algorithm using the zero-crossings of the reflected pulse and subsequent Abel inversion is demonstrated. The robustness of the profile reconstruction algorithm in the presence of a sufficiently small-amplitude density perturbation is assessed. The reconstruction algorithm begins to fail when the scaled density perturbation is large enough to invalidate the first Born approximation description of scattering by density fluctuations.

Observation of resonant energy transfer between identical-frequency laser beams*

Enhanced transmission of a low intensity laser beam is observed when crossed with an identical-frequency beam in a plasma with a flow velocity near the ion sound speed. The time history of the enhancement and the dependence on the flow velocity strongly suggest that this is due to energy transfer between the beams via a resonant ion wave with zero frequency in the laboratory frame. The maximum energy transfer has been observed when the beams cross in a region with Mach 1 flow. The addition of frequency modulation on the crossing beams is seen to reduce the energy transfer by a factor of 2. Implications for indirect-drive fusion schemes are discussed.

Optimal control of laser plasma instabilities using Spike Trains of Uneven Duration and Delay (STUD pulses) for ICF and IFE

An adaptive method of controlling parametric instabilities in laser produced plasmas is proposed. It involves fast temporal modulation of a laser pulse on the fastest instabilitys amplification time scale, adapting to changing and unknown plasma conditions. These pulses are comprised of on and off sequences having at least one or two orders of magnitude contrast between them. Such laser illumination profiles are called STUD pulses for Spike Trains of Uneven Duration and Delay. The STUD pulse program includes scrambling the speckle patterns spatially in between the laser spikes. The off times allow damping of driven waves. The scrambling of the hot spots allows tens of damping times to elapse before hot spot locations experience recurring high intensity spikes. Damping in the meantime will have healed the scars of past growth. Another unique feature of STUD pulses on crossing beams is that their temporal profiles can be interlaced or staggered, and their interactions thus controlled with an on-off switch and a dimmer.