Bela B. Hackman

Suicide in the home in relation to gun ownership

BACKGROUND It has been suggested that limiting access to firearms could prevent many suicides, but this belief is controversial. To assess the strength of the association between the availability of firearms and suicide, we studied all suicides that took place in the homes of victims in Shelby County, Tennessee, and King County, Washington, over a 32-month period. METHODS For each suicide victim (case subject), we obtained data from police or the medical examiner and interviewed a proxy. Their answers were compared with those of control subjects from the same neighborhood, matched with the victim according to sex, race, and age range. Crude and adjusted odds ratios were calculated with matched-pairs methods. RESULTS During the study period, 803 suicides occurred in the two counties, 565 of which (70 percent) took place in the home of the victim. Fifty-eight percent (326) of these suicides were committed with a firearm. After excluding 11 case subjects for various reasons, we were able to interview 80 percent (442) of the proxies for the case subjects. Matching controls were identified for 99 percent of these subjects, producing 438 matched pairs. Univariate analyses revealed that the case subjects were more likely than the controls to have lived alone, taken prescribed psychotropic medication, been arrested, abused drugs or alcohol, or not graduated from high school. After we controlled for these characteristics through conditional logistic regression, the presence of one or more guns in the home was found to be associated with an increased risk of suicide (adjusted odds ratio, 4.8; 95 percent confidence interval, 2.7 to 8.5). CONCLUSIONS Ready availability of firearms is associated with an increased risk of suicide in the home. Owners of firearms should weigh their reasons for keeping a gun in the home against the possibility that it might someday be used in a suicide.

In-hospital resuscitation following unsuccessful prehospital advanced cardiac life support: ‘Heroic Efforts’ or an exercise in futility?

From our emergency department logbook we identified 281 consecutive patients transported to the Regional Medical Center at Memphis following failed prehospital advanced cardiac life support (ACLS). Medical records were obtained for 240 cases (85.4%). Initial cardiac rhythms in the ED included ventricular fibrillation or pulseless ventricular tachycardia (29%), electromechanical dissociation (18%), and asystole (51%). Thirty-two patients (13.3%) were successfully resuscitated in the ED, but only four (1.7%) survived to hospital discharge. Two patients had good neurologic outcomes; both degenerated to cardiac arrest shortly prior to arrival in the ED. The remaining two survivors were discharged to nursing homes with severe neurologic deficits. Of the 41 cases for whom no medical records could be found, 39 were noted in our logbook to have died in the ED. No record of subsequent hospital admission could be found for the other two. Both are presumed to have died. Failure to respond to prehospital ACLS predicts nonsurvival and may warrant cessation of efforts in the field. Future programs and research efforts in the management of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest should be focused on optimal provision of prehospital care prior to the onset of irreversible deterioration.

Injuries Due to Firearms in Three Cities

BACKGROUND To describe the incidence and outcome of injuries due to firearms, we conducted a population-based study of fatal and nonfatal gunshot wounds in three cities: Memphis, Tennessee; Seattle; and Galveston, Texas. METHODS Records of the police, medical examiners, ambulance crews, and hospital emergency departments and hospital admissions were monitored to identify all injuries caused by firearms that were severe enough to prompt emergency medical treatment. These records were linked to generate a complete picture of each event. Census data were used to calculate rates of injury for various population groups. RESULTS A total of 1915 cases of injury due to firearms were identified between November 16, 1992, and May 15, 1994. The crude rate of firearm injury per 100,000 person-years was 222.6 in Memphis, 143.6 in Galveston, and 54.1 in Seattle. Approximately 88 percent of the injuries were incurred during confirmed or probable assaults; 7 percent were sustained in the course of suicide or attempted suicide; unintentional injuries accounted for 4 percent of the cases. Handguns were used in 88 percent of the cases in which the type of weapon was recorded. Five percent of the 1677 victims who were brought to a hospital emergency department could not be resuscitated; 53 percent were hospitalized, and 42 percent were treated and released. Ninety-seven percent of the deaths occurred within 24 hours of the injury. Emergency department and inpatient charges exceeded

Dispatcher-assisted cardiopulmonary resuscitation: validation of efficacy

16.5 million. CONCLUSIONS Injuries due to firearms, most involving handguns, are a major cause of morbidity and mortality in U.S. urban areas. The incidence varies greatly from city to city.

Do blacks get bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation as often as whites

Dispatcher-delivered telephone instruction in cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) has been proposed to increase rates of bystander CPR in cases of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. We tested the efficacy of a previously developed CPR message using a recording mannikin in a high stress, simulated cardiac arrest scenario. Community volunteers were unaware they would perform CPR until immediately before each trial. Performance of volunteers without prior CPR training (group A, n = 65) who received telephone instruction was compared with that of previously trained volunteers (group B, n = 43) who received the same message. Performances of both groups were also compared with a third group (group C, n = 43) composed of previously trained volunteers who did not receive the message. Quality of CPR was graded by three CPR instructors using explicit criteria. Printout strips from the recording mannikins were also analyzed. Evaluators were unaware of the training status of volunteers. The three groups were of comparable sex, race, and educational level, but group C was significantly younger than groups A and B (31.7 vs. 37.7 years, p less than 0.001). Because of the time required for telephone instruction, groups A and B started chest compressions a mean of 4.0 minutes after collapse compared with 1.2 minutes for group C (p less than 0.0001). We found that the previously untrained volunteers of group A performed CPR of an overall quality comparable to that performed by previously trained members of group C. Group A performed chest compressions significantly better than group C (p less than 0.02) but had greater problems performing effective ventilations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Impact of portable pulse oximetry on arterial blood gas test ordering in an urban emergency department

STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine whether there is an association between the race of a victim of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and the provision of bystander-initiated CPR. DESIGN Record review of 1,068 consecutive cases of nontraumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. SETTING Memphis, Tennessee, a city of more than 600,000 with roughly equal numbers of white and black residents. PARTICIPANTS Every adult who was seen by municipal emergency medical services personnel for nontraumatic cardiac arrest between March 1, 1989, and June 5, 1992. INTERVENTION None. RESULTS Although black and white cardiac arrest victims were similar in many respects, black victims received bystander CPR substantially less frequently than whites (9.8% versus 21.4%; odds ratio, 0.46; 95% confidence interval, 0.34 to 0.61). This difference was slightly more pronounced when the victim collapsed in a public place. In addition to race of the victim, location of the arrest outside the home and having the arrest witnessed were independent determinants of whether a victim was given bystander CPR. Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that the effect of race was independent of the other variables studied. CONCLUSION Black victims of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest receive bystander CPR less frequently than white victims. Targeted training programs may be needed to improve the rates of bystander CPR among certain groups.

Three-Rescuer CPR: The Method of Choice for Firefighter CPR?

STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine the impact of portable pulse oximetry on physician use of arterial blood gas tests (ABGs) in an urban emergency department. DESIGN Prospective, controlled clinical trial. SETTING The ED of the Regional Medical Center at Memphis, a publicly subsidized, 450-bed, acute care hospital staffed by residents and faculty of the University of Tennessee, Memphis. TYPE OF PARTICIPANTS Rotating housestaff treating adult ED patients with a wide variety of medical and surgical problems. INTERVENTION Introduction of a portable pulse oximeter for noninvasive measurement of blood oxygenation. MEASUREMENTS Rates of ABG test ordering, housestaff reason(s) for ordering an ABG, and the incidence of adverse clinical outcomes before and after introduction of portable pulse oximetry. MAIN RESULTS A total of 20,120 patient visits occurred during the four-month study. Before oximeter introduction, emergency physicians ordered 699 ABGs, 63% of which were indicated by explicit criteria. After oximeter introduction, 440 ABGs were ordered (a 37% decrease). Almost all of this decrease was due to fewer ABGs ordered to assess oxygenation (260 before vs 75 after; chi 2, P less than .001). These reductions were not explained by differences in total patient visits or case mix. Physicians decreased ordering of indicated ABGs by almost as great an extent as they reduced ordering of unindicated tests, suggesting they did not consistently distinguish between the two. However, decreased testing did not result in any serious adverse outcomes, defined as unanticipated respiratory or cardiac arrest in the ED, unanticipated arrest on the floor within 24 hours of admission, or death within two days of hospital discharge. CONCLUSION Portable pulse oximetry can provide a simple, noninvasive way to determine oxygen saturation in the ED. Routine use of portable pulse oximetry may substantially reduce rates of ABG testing and associated patient charges without adversely affecting the quality of emergency care.

Gun ownership as a risk factor for homicide in the home

STUDY OBJECTIVE To compare the quality of CPR provided by firefighters performing three-rescuer CPR with that achieved by firefighters trained to provide standard two-rescuer CPR. DESIGN Eight months after training a large number of firefighters to perform three-rescuer CPR, we used a quasi-experimental design to compare the performance of a randomly selected subset of these companies to that achieved by a control group of engine companies that received refresher training in standard two-rescuer CPR. Both groups used bag-valve masks to provide rescue ventilations. Testing was conducted on a no-notice basis with a recording mannequin. Key actions were scored by an experienced observer using explicit pass-fail criteria. Mannequin-generated strip charts were used to calculate the rate and depth of chest compressions and the ventilatory rate, volume, and minute ventilation in a blinded manner. SETTING Fire stations of the Memphis Fire Department. The department is the sole provider of first-responder emergency care to the citizens of Memphis, Tennessee (population, 610,000). RESULTS Three-rescuer teams delivered a mean minute ventilation substantially greater than that produced by two-rescuer teams (7.7 +/- 5.3 L versus 4.9 +/- 4.2 L, P < .001). Intergroup differences in the mean depth of chest compressions were less marked, but they were still significant (17.2 +/- 8.3 mm of recorder-needle deflection versus 13.7 +/- 7.0 mm, P < .001). CONCLUSION Three rescuers can produce better CPR than two when a bag-valve-mask device is used. The technique is easily learned and readily retained.