Ben L. Feringa

Making molecular machines work

In this review we chart recent advances in what is at once an old and very new field of endeavour — the achievement of control of motion at the molecular level including solid-state and surface-mounted rotors, and its natural progression to the development of synthetic molecular machines. Besides a discussion of design principles used to control linear and rotary motion in such molecular systems, this review will address the advances towards the construction of synthetic machines that can perform useful functions. Approaches taken by several research groups to construct wholly synthetic molecular machines and devices are compared. This will be illustrated with molecular rotors, elevators, valves, transporters, muscles and other motor functions used to develop smart materials. The demonstration of molecular machinery is highlighted through recent examples of systems capable of effecting macroscopic movement through concerted molecular motion. Several approaches to illustrate how molecular motor systems have been used to accomplish work are discussed. We will conclude with prospects for future developments in this exciting field of nanotechnology.

Catalytic asymmetric conjugate addition and allylic alkylation with Grignard reagents

Catalytic asymmetric C-C bond-forming reactions using organometallic reagents are among the most important of organic transformations. Frequently, these transformations are key steps in the synthesis of complex biologically active molecules. The conjugate addition (CA) and allylic alkylation (AA) with organometallic compounds are especially versatile in asymmetric C-C bond-forming reactions. These transformations are complementary to the catalytic asymmetric allylic alkylation and the Michael addition, both based on soft carbon nucleophiles (Scheme 1A). For both CA and AA, the organic moiety of the organometallic reagent reacts with the sp carbon of an electron-deficient substrate, converting it to an sp carbon (Scheme 1B). In the case of CA, subsequent quenching of the enolate leads to the final product, whereas for the related AA an appropriate leaving group is expelled to form the chiral product. The organometallic compounds used most frequently for these transformations are organozinc, Grignard, organoaluminium, organolithium and cuprate reagents. Over the last three decades considerable effort has been directed toward the development of efficient catalytic systems for the asymmetric CA and AA reactions using organometallic reagents. Complexes derived from Cu salts and chiral ligands have provided the broadest scope in the catalyzed enantioselective CA and AA of organometallic reagents. Organozinc reagents have been the most successful of the organometallic reagents in this respect. Major contributions and progress in the field of asymmetric CA and AA based on organozinc reagents have been summarized in several reviews. Organomagnesium compounds were among the first organometallic compounds to be applied to synthetic organic chemistry and the use of Grignard reagents in Cu-catalyzed CA was first reported in 1941 by Kharash and Tawney. Achieving chemo-, regioand stereocontrol in both asymmetric conjugate addition (ACA) and asymmetric allylic alkylation (AAA), however, has proven to be challenging and has restricted the application of these transformations, in particular, to total synthesis. Typical selectivity issues pertain to 1,2versus 1,4-addition (Scheme 2A) and SN2versus SN2′-substitution (Scheme 2B). The challenge faced in the development of stereoselective C-C bond-forming reactions is apparent when one considers that, despite three decades of intensive research in this area, only recently has efficient Cu-catalyzed enantioselective CA of Grignard reagents been achieved. The earlier discovery of the highly enantioselective Cu-catalyzed CA of dialkylzinc reagents allowed for replacement of Grignard reagents in this asymmetric C-C bond-forming reaction. Dialkylzinc reagents offer distinct advantages over Grignard reagents in their low reactivity in noncatalyzed reactions and their high tolerance to functional groups both on the substrate and on the organozinc reagent itself. Nevertheless, there are several advantages to the use of common mono-alkylMg halide reagents, most importantly their widespread availability and the ability to transfer all of the alkyl groups of the organometallic compound. The synthetic potential of these asymmetric transformations has driven intensive research in this area, and over the past few years major breakthroughs have been realized in the enantioselective CA and AA of Grignard reagents. * Author for correspondence. E-mail: B.L.Feringa@rug.nl Chem. Rev. 2008, 108, 2824–2852 2824

Molecular machines: Nanomotor rotates microscale objects

Nanomachines of the future will require molecular-scale motors that can perform work and collectively induce controlled motion of much larger objects. We have designed a synthetic, light-driven molecular motor that is embedded in a liquid-crystal film and can rotate objects placed on the film that exceed the size of the motor molecule by a factor of 10,000. The changes in shape of the motor during the rotary steps cause a remarkable rotational reorganization of the liquid-crystal film and its surface relief, which ultimately causes the rotation of submillimetre-sized particles on the film.

Electrically driven directional motion of a four-wheeled molecule on a metal surface

Propelling single molecules in a controlled manner along an unmodified surface remains extremely challenging because it requires molecules that can use light, chemical or electrical energy to modulate their interaction with the surface in a way that generates motion. Nature’s motor proteins have mastered the art of converting conformational changes into directed motion, and have inspired the design of artificial systems such as DNA walkers and light- and redox-driven molecular motors. But although controlled movement of single molecules along a surface has been reported, the molecules in these examples act as passive elements that either diffuse along a preferential direction with equal probability for forward and backward movement or are dragged by an STM tip. Here we present a molecule with four functional units—our previously reported rotary motors—that undergo continuous and defined conformational changes upon sequential electronic and vibrational excitation. Scanning tunnelling microscopy confirms that activation of the conformational changes of the rotors through inelastic electron tunnelling propels the molecule unidirectionally across a Cu(111) surface. The system can be adapted to follow either linear or random surface trajectories or to remain stationary, by tuning the chirality of the individual motor units. Our design provides a starting point for the exploration of more sophisticated molecular mechanical systems with directionally controlled motion.

Phosphoramidites: Privileged Ligands in Asymmetric Catalysis

Asymmetric catalysis with transition-metal complexes is the basis for a vast array of stereoselective transformations and has changed the face of modern synthetic chemistry. Key to this success has been the design of chiral ligands to control the regio-, diastereo-, and enantioselectivity. Phosphoramidites have emerged as a highly versatile and readily accessible class of chiral ligands. Their modular structure enables the formation of ligand libraries and easy fine-tuning for a specific catalytic reaction. Phosphoramidites frequently show exceptional levels of stereocontrol, and their monodentate nature is essential in combinatorial catalysis, where a ligand-mixture approach is used. In this Review, recent developments in asymmetric catalysis with phosphoramidites used as ligands are discussed, with a focus on the formation of carbon-carbon and carbon-heteroatom bonds.

Unidirectional molecular motor on a gold surface

Molecules capable of mimicking the function of a wide range of mechanical devices have been fabricated, with motors that can induce mechanical movement attracting particular attention. Such molecular motors convert light or chemical energy into directional rotary or linear motion, and are usually prepared and operated in solution. But if they are to be used as nanomachines that can do useful work, it seems essential to construct systems that can function on a surface, like a recently reported linear artificial muscle. Surface-mounted rotors have been realized and limited directionality in their motion predicted. Here we demonstrate that a light-driven molecular motor capable of repetitive unidirectional rotation can be mounted on the surface of gold nanoparticles. The motor design uses a chiral helical alkene with an upper half that serves as a propeller and is connected through a carbon–carbon double bond (the rotation axis) to a lower half that serves as a stator. The stator carries two thiol-functionalized ‘legs’, which then bind the entire motor molecule to a gold surface. NMR spectroscopy reveals that two photo-induced cis-trans isomerizations of the central double bond, each followed by a thermal helix inversion to prevent reverse rotation, induce a full and unidirectional 360° rotation of the propeller with respect to the surface-mounted lower half of the system.

Catalytic oxidations by vanadium complexes

Vanadium haloperoxidases catalyse the oxidation of halides leading to halogenation of substrates or, in the absence of suitable substrates, to oxidation of hydrogen peroxide into singlet oxygen and water. Furthermore, V-haloperoxidases are capable to give enantioselective sulfoxidation under the appropriate conditions. The most interesting model compounds that have been synthesised and studied as bromination catalysts, and catalysts for, i.e. epoxidation, hydroxylation, sulfoxidation and alcohol oxidation are discussed in this paper. Our recent work includes the investigation on a vanadium complex as potential catalyst for bromination reactions, attempts to synthesise a novel structural model for the active site of V-peroxidase using a tripodal ligand, and the syntheses and characterisation of four new vanadium complexes containing tridentate ligands. The latter compounds have been studied as oxidation catalysts using cinnamyl alcohol as substrate.

Recent advances in the catalytic asymmetric synthesis of β-amino acids

In this critical review, the progress in catalytic asymmetric synthesis of beta-amino acids is discussed, covering the literature since 2002. The review treats transition metal catalysis, organocatalysis and biocatalysis and covers the most important synthetic methods, such as hydrogenation, the Mannich reaction and conjugate additions (160 references).

Recent advances in enantioselective copper-catalyzed 1,4-addition

A comprehensive overview of recent literature from 2003 concerning advances in enantioselective copper catalysed 1,4-addition of organometallic reagents to alpha,beta-unsaturated compounds is given in this critical review. About 200 ligands and catalysts are presented, with a focus on stereoselectivities, catalyst loading, ligand structure and substrate scope. A major part is devoted to trapping and tandem reactions and a variety of recent synthetic applications are used to illustrate the practicality and current state of the art of 1,4-addition of organometallic reagents. Finally several mechanistic studies are discussed (162 references).

Light-Controlled Conductance Switching of Ordered Metal-Molecule-Metal Devices

We demonstrate reversible, light-controlled conductance switching of molecular devices based on photochromic diarylethene molecules. These devices consist of ordered, two-dimensional lattices of gold nanoparticles, in which neighboring particles are bridged by switchable molecules. We independently confirm that reversible isomerization of the diarylethenes employed is at the heart of the room-temperature conductance switching. For this, we take full advantage of the possibility to use optical spectroscopy to follow molecular switching in these samples.