Blair J. Hoplight

In two species, females exhibit superior working memory and inferior reference memory on the water radial-arm maze

Male and female mice and rats were tested on a water escape version of the radial-arm maze designed to measure working and reference memory. In both species, females exhibited superior working memory during acquisition, and were better able to handle a higher memory load. However, male mice and rats exhibited better reference memory than females during the asymptotic portion of testing. Our data suggest that females may be better at working memory when both working and reference memory information must be learned simultaneously, and males better at reference memory when it has been differentiated from working memory.

Learning and memory in the autoimmune BXSB mouse: effects of neocortical ectopias and environmental enrichment

Approximately 40-60% of BXSB mice have ectopic cell clusters in layer 1 of neocortex. Prior studies have shown distinct behavioral differences between those with ectopias and their non-ectopic littermates. In this study, female BXSB mice were reared after weaning in either enriched environments or standard cages. Following an initial round of behavioral testing, all mice were housed in standard cages and retested. Enriched cage mice (both ectopic and non-ectopic) showed increased activity, greater speed, and enhanced learning scores across a variety of tests. Additionally, prior test experience itself had significant positive effects on Hebb-Williams maze learning. The presence of ectopias resulted in better Morris maze learning for standard cage reared mice. Further, ectopic mice, regardless of their housing condition, showed better long-term retention in the Morris maze than did their non-ectopic counterparts. These findings show that abnormalities in corticogenesis need not always result in functional deficit.

Working memory deficits in BXSB mice with neocortical ectopias

Approximately 40-60% of BXSB/MpJ-Yaa mice exhibit neocortical ectopias, which are misplaced clusters of neurons in layer I of cortex. These ectopias are usually located in the prefrontal and/or motor region of cortex in BXSB mice, and are similar in appearance to those found in postmortem analyses of the brains of dyslexic humans. Several within-strain learning differences between mice with ectopias and those without have been reported. In particular, ectopic BXSB mice exhibited superior reference memory learning, but inferior working memory learning in several studies from our laboratory. This study used the Morris water maze delayed matching-to sample task and the water radial-arm maze to asses working memory in female BXSB mice with and without ectopias. In the delayed matching-to sample task, a hidden escape platform remained in a constant position for each four-trial session, but changed position between sessions. Trial 2 was the measure of working memory, i.e., how well did the mouse remember where the platform was located for that session. In the water version of the eight-arm radial maze, hidden escape platforms were located in four of the eight arms, and each platform was removed from the maze once found. This enabled us to assess working and reference memory simultaneously. Ectopic mice demonstrated working memory deficits during the first part of the delayed matching-to sample task compared to nonectopics. Similarly, ectopics made more working memory errors during the latter half of radial-arm maze testing, while not differing from nonectopics in reference memory performance. Additionally, there were significant correlations between measures of working memory in the radial-arm maze and working memory in a delayed matching-to-sample task. These findings are in agreement with other studies demonstrating working memory deficits in ectopic BXSB mice.

Spatial ability of XY sex-reversed female mice

Perinatal gonadal hormones significantly affect subsequent sex differences in reproductive and non-reproductive behaviors in rodents. However, the influence of the sex chromosomes on these behaviors has been largely ignored. To assess the influence of the non-pseudoautosomal region of the Y chromosome, C57BL/JEi male and female mice and mice from the C57BL/6JEi-Y(POS) consomic strain were given behavioral tests known to distinguish males from females. The C57BL/6JEi-Y(POS) strain contains sex-reversed XY-females which, when compared to their XX-female siblings, allow assessment of the influence of the Y chromosome in a female phenotype. XX-females and XY-females did not differ on open-field activity, the Lashley maze, or active avoidance learning, but XY-females were significantly better than XX-females on the Morris hidden platform spatial maze. These findings suggest that males may have both a genetic and a hormonal mechanism to ensure visuospatial superiority.

The uterine environment enhances cognitive competence

GENETICALLY identical mouse embryos were transferred into same-strain uteri (transfer controls) or into hybrid uteri. A third group was not transferred. When adult, the mice were given a series of behavioral tests. In-strain transfer controls differed from non-transfer mice only on two activity measures, and did not differ on any cognitive variable. In contrast, mice reared in hybrid uteri were found to be superior to in-strain transfer mice on discrimination learning, Lashley maze learning and Morris maze learning; they also showed better adaptation in an avoidance learning shuttlebox. To our knowledge this is the first study showing that the uterine environment can have a general enhancing effect upon cognitive competence across a broad range of behaviors.

Effects of neocortical ectopias and environmental enrichment on Hebb-Williams maze learning in BXSB mice.

Approximately 40-60% of BXSB mice have neocortical ectopias, a developmental anomaly characterized by migration of neurons into the neuron-sparse layer I of cortex. Previous studies have shown that ectopic BXSB mice have superior reference, but inferior working, memory on spatial tasks. Female BXSB mice were housed either in an enriched environment or in standard cages at weaning. Subsequently, these animals were tested on four of the Hebb-Williams mazes in a water-based version of this maze. Theoretically, two of the maze configurations placed greater emphasis on reference memory to find the goal, whereas the other two favored working memory. Ectopics reared in standard housing conditions were better than nonectopics on mazes that favored the use of reference memory, but poorer on mazes that favored working memory. In contrast, subjects raised in the enriched environment showed no ectopia differences. A comparison of enriched and standard housing conditions found that the enriched animals had better reference memory but poorer working memory. The latter effect may be because the enriched environment, although more stimulating, did not change in time or space; and other researchers have shown that daily replacement of stimuli in complex environments is correlated with better working memory.

Learning in year-old female autoimmune BXSB mice.

BXSB/ MpJ-Yaa and NZB/BINJ mice have been used as animal models for both developmental learning disability and systemic autoimmune disease. Approximately 40-60% of these animals show ectopic clusters of neurons in Layer I of cortex similar to those found in postmortem analyses of human dyslexics, and all exhibit an autoimmune condition similar to systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in humans. The expression of immune disease in the BXSB strain, unlike in humans, is more severe in males than females. Most previous studies have examined the behavioral sequelae of neocortical ectopias at a relatively young age, when the BXSB females (unlike the male BXSB and female and male NZBs) are not yet showing high titers of autoantibodies associated with their lupus-like form of autoimmune disease. This study examined the behavior of BXSB females at an age subsequent to autoimmune disease onset. When contrasted with younger animals, year-old BXSB females showed good learning behavior, with no differences in Lashley maze learning and remarkably good performance in a visual discrimination learning task. These results are consistent with other data which indicate that many types of learning behavior are apparently unperturbed by systemic autoimmune disease. Results also showed significant interactions between a measure of lateral paw preference and the presence or absence of ectopias in Lashley maze learning. Animals without ectopias that exhibited a right lateral paw preference showed the greatest number of errors on a number of test measures. These findings support previous results indicating that behavioral effects associated with ectopias may vary based upon the behavioral laterality of affected animals.

A computer-aided procedure for measuring Hebb-Williams maze performance

We describe a shortened procedure for testing mice over a 5-day interval on a swimming version of the Hebb-Williams maze. The mice are given 1 day of adaptation training, and are tested over the next 4 days on Hebb-Williams problems 1, 6, 12, and 5, in that order. As an animal swims through one of the maze problems, the computer screen shows the maze pattern, and an observer traces the path taken with a computer mouse. The computer program, Observe Software, stores the path sequence, determines the error score for that trial, and sends the information to a spreadsheet where it is available for statistical analyses.