Bogdan Sadowski

Opioid and Nonopioid Swim Stress-Induced Analgesia: A Parametric Analysis in Mice

Environmental stress causes the activation of two types of endogenous pain inhibitory systems in animals: opioid analgesia is antagonized by opiate receptor blockers (e.g., naloxone and naltrexone), whereas analgesia produced by nonopioid systems is insensitive to such antagonism. A large literature documents that the parameters of the laboratory stressor will determine the neurochemical identity of the resultant analgesia. In rats, low severity stressors produce opioid analgesia and higher severity stressors produce nonopioid analgesia. A recent parametric analysis of swim stress-induced analgesia (SSIA) in the female Quackenbush mouse, however, observed the opposite pattern. The present study is a parametric analysis of SSIA using a range of swim temperatures (15-38 degrees C), swim durations (45 s to 7 min), and genetic models [male Swiss-Webster mice, and mice selectively bred from this outbred strain for high (HA), low (LA), or control SSIA]. We find that in nonselected mice low severity swims (i.e., warm temperature, short duration) produce naloxone-sensitive opioid SSIA, whereas high severity swims (i.e., cold temperature, long duration) produce nonopioid SSIA. This pattern is also seen in HA mice displaying very high analgesic magnitudes, but not in LA mice displaying minimal SSIA. In the selectively bred mice, analgesia and hypothermia from forced swimming are positively correlated, but can be dissociated both genetically and neurochemically. Furthermore, swimming in body temperature (38 degrees C) water produces analgesia without concommitant hypothermia, and the increased magnitude of 38 degrees C SSIA displayed by HA mice over control levels is entirely opioid.

Inheritance of stress-induced analgesia in mice. Selective breeding study

Random mated Swiss mice swam for 3 min at 20 degrees C. The animals with less than or equal to 10 s and greater than or equal to 50 s postswim latencies on the hot plate (56 degrees C) were selected as progenitors of low (LA) and high (HA) analgesia lines, respectively. Gradual divergence of latency distributions and postswim hind paw flick latencies between the two lines was observed in successive generations. As shown by the tail flick test applied to the sixth offspring generation, postswim analgesia in the HA line was not only more pronounced but also lasted longer compared to the LA line and the unselected controls. Possible differentiation of the endorphin system activity in the course of selection is discussed.

Differentiation of neurochemical basis of stress-induced analgesia in mice by selective breeding

Two selectively bred lines of mice, one responding with high (HA) and the other with low analgesia (LA) to 3 min swims at 20 degrees C were compared with respect to naloxone ability to reverse such swim induced pain threshold elevation. Also, the analgesic effect of morphine was tested in both lines of mice. Naloxone at a dose of 1 mg/kg significantly reduced postswim analgesia determined with hot plate and tail flick tests in HA mice, but was not effective in LA mice. HA mice responded with significant elevation of hot plate threshold to 0.1 mg/kg of morphine hydrochloride, whereas in LA mice comparable level of analgesia developed after 12.8 mg/kg. The data argue for greater involvement of opioid mechanisms in producing analgesia in HA mice than in LA mice, and so for inheritance of endorphin system(s) activity.

One or two genetic loci mediate high opiate analgesia in selectively bred mice

&NA; The analgesic responses of humans and laboratory animals are characterized by substantial individual differences. The genetic basis of this variability can be studied experimentally in rodents using a program of selective breeding. One such program selected for high (HA) and low (LA) swim stress‐induced analgesia (SSIA) on the hot‐plate (56°C) test in Swiss‐Webster mice. These lines, which have been selectively bred for more than 25 generations, display markedly divergent opioid‐mediated SSIA (3‐min swims in 38°C water), morphine analgesia (10 mg/kg, i.p.), and analgesia to the &kgr;‐receptor agonist, U‐50,488H (30 mg/kg, i.p.). The present study investigated the mode of inheritance of these opioid analgesias in HA and LA mice, using Mendelian genetic analyses. We report that the differential sensitivity of HA and LA mice to each of these analgesic manipulations appears to be determined oligogenically, by one or at the most two major genetic loci. The loci associated with each type of analgesia do not co‐segregate, however, indicating that three distinct oligogenic effects have been identified. These findings suggest that the genetic determination of analgesic mechanisms may have simple components and as such may be amenable to further analysis using molecular genetic techniques.

Acoustic startle and open-field behavior in mice bred for magnitude of swim analgesia

Acoustic startle response (ASR) and open-field activity was examined in the 46th generation of mice that have been selectively bred for high analgesia (HA) and for low analgesia (LA) induced by 3-min swimming in 20 degrees C water. These lines were earlier found to differ in brain opioid receptor density and in the expression of opioid-mediated phenomena, as analgesic sensitivity to opiates and reversibility of swim stress-induced analgesia (SSIA) by naloxone. For comparison, a randomly bred control (C) line was used. To measure the amplitude of ASR, the mice were exposed to 110-dB acoustic stimuli in a Coulbourn apparatus. In saline-injected mice, the ASR force was found significantly lower in the LA than in the HA, as well in the C line, but did not differ between the two last lines. Naltrexone hydrochloride (10 mg/kg IP 30 min before ASR testing) augmented the startle in the opioid receptor-dense HA line, but had no effect in the opioid receptor-deficient LA line, as well in the C line; therefore, the ASR magnitude in naltrexone-injected HA mice was significantly higher compared to the C line. HA mice displayed less activity in an open-field test; that is, they remained immobile longer in the center of the field, and thereafter performed less ambulation and less rearing against the wall compared to the LA line. Naltrexone failed to modify the open-field activity in any line. The results confirm that the pattern of ASR depends on the genetic makeup of the animals. The higher amplitude of ASR, taken together with the lower open-field activity of HA mice, can be interpreted in terms of higher anxiety level, compared to the LA line. It is suggested that the higher ASR in HA mice relies on a nonopioid mechanism, which is tonically inhibited by the opioid system.

Mu and delta opioid receptor analgesia, binding density, and mRNA levels in mice selectively bred for high and low analgesia

The present study examined mu and delta opioid analgesia, receptor binding, and receptor mRNA levels in lines of mice from two selective breeding projects of relevance to opioid analgesia. Large differences were observed in the analgesic potency of [d-Ala2, NMPhe4, Gly-ol]enkephalin (DAMGO), [d-Pen2,5]enkephalin (DPDPE), and [d-Ala2]deltorphin II (DELT), selective mu, delta1, and delta2 opioid receptor agonists, respectively, in mice selectively bred for high (HA) and low (LA) swim stress-induced analgesia (SIA). HAR and LAR mice, selectively bred for high and low levorphanol analgesia, respectively, display equally large differences in their analgesic sensitivity to DAMGO, modest differences in sensitivity to DPDPE, and no differences in sensitivity to DELT. These sizable genotypic differences in analgesic potency were accompanied by HA/LA and HAR/LAR differences in whole-brain homogenate [3H]DPDPE and/or [3H]DELT, but paradoxically not [3H]DAMGO, binding. Solution hybridization of mRNA extracts encoding mu (MOR-1) or delta (DOR-1) opioid receptors indicated some regional differences in gene expression between high and low lines. Surprisingly, differences in these in vitro markers were often in the direction of LAR>HAR. The present data indicate that selection for either SSIA or levorphanol analgesia produces differential effects on mu and delta opioid analgesia that are accompanied by alterations on in vitro assays, the significance of which remains to be determined. The data are discussed with regard to the utility of in vitro biological markers and genetic models of analgesia.

Morphine analgesia and tolerance in mice selectively bred for divergent swim stress-induced analgesia.

Morphine-induced analgesia and tolerance were examined in Swiss Webster mice selectively bred for high and low swim stress-induced analgesia. Morphine produced a dose-dependent analgesia in both lines; it was 4-fold more potent in the high analgesia line than in the low analgesia line. Despite the differences in morphine-induced analgesia, the degree of tolerance was the same in both lines. Together, these data suggest that selective breeding of mice for high and low swim stress-induced analgesia produced a striking difference in morphine-induced analgesia without affecting the degree of tolerance. Thus, while there is a common genetic determination in swim stress-induced and morphine-induced analgesia, the development of tolerance to morphine possibly relies on a different genetic background.

Levorphanol and swim stress-induced analgesia in selectively bred mice: evidence for genetic commonalities

Two independent selective breeding programs have developed divergent lines of mice expressing either high and low swim stress-induced analgesia (HA/LA lines; Jastrzebiec, Poland) or high and low levorphanol analgesia (HAR/LAR lines; Portland, OR). In the present study, mice from both programs were tested for both levorphanol analgesia (2 mg/kg) and an opioid-mediated swim stress-induced analgesia (3 min swimming in 32 degrees C water) in the hot-plate test. Mice selected for high and low levorphanol analgesia displayed high and low swim stress-induced analgesia, respectively; mice selected for high and low swim stress-induced analgesia displayed high and low levorphanol analgesia, respectively. This pattern of correlated responses suggests a high degree of common genetic determination in opiate and swim stress-induced analgesia. These findings also suggest that individual differences in analgesic responsiveness to opiate drugs result from genetically determined individual differences in endogenous pain inhibitory mechanisms.

Antagonism of the non-opioid component of ethanol-induced analgesia by the NMDA receptor antagonist MK-801

Recent evidence from our laboratory suggests that the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist MK-801 (dizocilpine) selectively antagonizes non-opioid (i.e. naloxone-insensitive) mechanisms of stress-induced analgesia in mice. For example, we have recently demonstrated that a low dose of MK-801 (0.075 mg/kg, i.p.) antagonizes the non-opioid component of a mixed opioid/non-opioid swim stress-induced analgesia (SSIA) resulting from forced swimming for 3 min in 20 degrees C water. Since ethanol-induced analgesia (EIA) has been found to be only partially attenuated by naloxone, we hypothesized that MK-801 would similarly block the non-opioid component of EIA. The effects of MK-801 and of the opioid receptor antagonist naloxone (10 mg/kg, i.p.) on analgesia produced by ethanol (2.5 g/kg in 20% vol/vol, i.p.) were studied in control mice and in mice selectively bred for high (HA) or low (LA) SSIA. HA mice showed significantly more, and LA mice significantly less, EIA than controls. Naloxone and MK-801 significantly attenuated EIA in control and HA mice, and in these lines the combined administration of both antagonists blocked EIA completely. In LA mice, which displayed very little EIA, naloxone but not MK-801 reversed EIA completely. These findings provide additional evidence for the role of the NMDA receptor in non-opioid mechanisms of analgesia. The finding that mice selectively bred for high and low SSIA, also display high and low EIA suggests common mediation of the effects of stress and ethanol on antinociceptive processes.

Selective breeding of mice for high and low swim analgesia: differential effect on discrete forms of footshock analgesia

&NA; Selective breeding of mice displaying high and low swim‐induced analgesia led to the development of two animal lines divergent in the magnitude of analgesic response to swimming. In this study, animals belonging to the seventh generation of both lines were exposed to two temporally different forms of footshock, one of which produced opioid and the other non‐opioid analgesia. We found that selective breeding for high and low swim‐induced analgesia exerted a striking influence on the magnitude of the opioid‐mediated type of footshock analgesia, but was ineffective on that of the non‐opioid type.