Braden C. Fleming

Treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries, Part I

Anterior cruciate ligament injuries are common among athletes. Although the true natural history remains unclear, anterior cruciate ligament injuries are functionally disabling; they predispose the knee to subsequent injuries and the early onset of osteoarthritis. This article, the first in a 2-part series, was initiated with the use of the PubMed database and a comprehensive search of articles that appeared between January 1994 to the present, using the keywords anterior cruciate ligament. A total of 3810 citations were identified and reviewed to determine the current state of knowledge about the treatment of these injuries. Articles pertaining to the biomechanical behavior of the anterior cruciate ligament, the prevalence of anterior cruciate ligament injury, the natural history of the anterior cruciate ligament–deficient knee, injuries associated with anterior cruciate ligament disruption, risk factors for anterior cruciate ligament injury, indications for treatment of anterior cruciate ligament injuries, and nonoperative and operative treatments were obtained, reviewed, and served as the basis for part I. Part II, to be presented in another issue of this journal, includes technical aspects of anterior cruciate ligament surgery, bone tunnel widening, graft healing, rehabilitation after reconstruction, and the effect of sex, age, and activity level on the outcome of surgery. Our approach was to build on prior reviews and to provide an overview of the literature for each of the before-mentioned areas of study by summarizing the highest level of scientific evidence available. For the areas that required a descriptive approach to research, we focused on the prospective studies that were available; for the areas that required an experimental approach, we focused on the prospective, randomized controlled trials and, when necessary, the highest level of evidence available. We were surprised to learn that considerable advances have been made during the past decade regarding the treatment of this devastating injury.

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Strain Behavior During Rehabilitation Exercises In Vivo

Before studying the biomechanical effects of rehabili tation exercises on the reconstructed knee, it is impor tant to understand their effects on the normal anterior cruciate ligament. The objective of this investigation was to measure the strain behavior of this ligament dur ing rehabilitation activities in vivo. Participants were pa tient volunteers with normal anterior cruciate ligaments instrumented with the Hall effect transducer. At 10° and 20° of flexion, ligament strain values for active exten sion of the knee with a weight of 45 N applied to a sub jects lower leg were significantly greater than active motion without the weight. Isometric quadriceps muscle contraction at 15° and 30° also produced a significant increase in ligament strain, while at 60° and 90° of knee flexion there was no change in ligament strain relative to relaxed muscle condition. Simultaneous quadriceps and hamstrings muscles contraction at 15° produced a significant increase in ligament strain compared with the relaxed state but did not strain the ligament at 30°, 60°, and 90° of flexion. Isometric contraction of hamstrings muscles did not produce change in ligament strain at any flexion angle. Exercises that produce low or un strained ligament values, and would not endanger a properly implanted graft, are either dominated by the hamstrings muscle (isometric hamstring), involve quad riceps muscle activity with the knee flexed at 60° or greater (isometric quadriceps, simultaneous quadri ceps and hamstrings contraction), or involve active knee motion between 35° and 90° of flexion.

Anterior cruciate ligament replacement: comparison of bone-patellar tendon-bone grafts with two-strand hamstring grafts. A prospective, randomized study.

Background: The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate replacement of a torn anterior cruciate ligament with either a bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft or a two-strand semitendinosus-gracilis autograft to compare the results of clinical testing, patient satisfaction, activity level, functional status, and muscle strength.Methods: Fifty-six patients with a torn anterior cruciate ligament were enrolled in a prospective, randomized, controlled study. Twenty-eight underwent reconstruction with a bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft, and twenty-eight were treated with a two-strand semitendinosus-gracilis autograft. Patients were followed for an average of thirty-nine months (range, thirty-six to fifty-seven months). At the time of final follow-up, twenty-two patients in each group were evaluated in terms of clinical test findings, patient satisfaction, activity level, functional status, and isokinetic muscle strength.Results: The objective outcome of replacement of the torn anterior cruciate ligament with a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft was superior to that obtained with a two-strand semitendinosus-gracilis graft. At the three-year follow-up interval, the patients in whom a hamstring graft had been used had an average of 4.4 mm of increased anterior knee laxity compared with the laxity of the contralateral, normal knee, whereas the patients in whom a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft had been used had an average of 1.1 mm of increased knee laxity. Fourteen percent (three) of the twenty-two patients with a hamstring graft had a mild pivot shift, and 27% (six) had a moderate pivot shift. Only 14% (three) of the twenty-two patients with a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft had a mild pivot shift, and none had a moderate pivot shift. At the same follow-up interval, the patients in whom a hamstring graft had been used had significantly lower peak knee-flexion strength than those who had a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft (p = 0.039). In contrast, the two treatments produced similar outcomes in terms of patient satisfaction, activity level, and knee function (ability to perform a one-legged hop, bear weight, squat, climb stairs, run in place, and duckwalk).Conclusions: After three years of follow-up, the objective results of anterior cruciate ligament replacement with a bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft were superior to those of replacement with a two-strand semitendinosus-gracilis graft with regard to knee laxity, pivot-shift grade, and strength of the knee flexor muscles. However, the two groups had comparable results in terms of patient satisfaction, activity level, and knee function.

ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT STRAIN IN-VIVO : A REVIEW OF PREVIOUS WORK

Disruption of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), a primary stabilizer of the knee, can produce disability. The purpose of our work has been to study the normal ACL in humans, in the presence of normal muscle function and body weight, and develop clinical criteria for reconstruction, establish a basis for rehabilitation programs, and evaluate how knee braces protect this important ligament. The strain behavior of the ACL has been measured by arthroscopic implantation of the Differential Variable Reluctance Transducer while subjects are under local anesthesia. Movement of the knee from a flexed to an extended position, either passively or through contraction of the leg muscles, produces an increase in ACL strain values. Isolated contraction of the dominant quadriceps with the knee between 50 degrees and extension creates substantial increases in strain. In contrast, isolated contraction of the hamstrings at any knee position does not increase strain. With the knee un-weighted, the protective strain shielding effect of a functional knee brace decreases as the magnitude of anterior shear load applied to the tibia increases. A different behavior occurs during weight bearing, the strain shielding effect of the brace remains constant as the magnitude of anterior load increases. Our approach is novel in that it can be used to measure on important portion of the ACLs strain distribution while clinically relevant loads are applied to the knee, subjects perform rehabilitation exercises, or in the presence of different orthoses such as functional knee braces.

The effect of weightbearing and external loading on anterior cruciate ligament strain

A force balance between the ligaments, articular contact, muscles and body weight maintains knee joint stability. Thus, it is important to study anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) biomechanics, in vivo, under weightbearing conditions. Our objective was to compare the ACL strain response under weightbearing and non-weightbearing conditions and in combination with three externally applied loadings: (1) anterior-posterior shear forces, (2) internal-external torques, and (3) varus-valgus moments. A strain transducer was implanted on the ACL of 11 subjects. All joint loadings were performed with the knee at 20 degrees of flexion. A significant increase in ACL strain was observed as the knee made the transition from non-weightbearing to weightbearing. During anterior shear loading, the strain values produced during weightbearing were greater than those of the non-weightbearing knee (shear loads <40N). At higher shear loads, the strain values became equal. During axial torsion, an internal torque of 10Nm strained the ACL when the knee was non-weightbearing while an equivalent external torque did not. Weightbearing significantly increased ACL strain values in comparison to non-weightbearing with the application of external torques and low internal torques (<3Nm). The strains became equal for higher internal torques. For V-V loading, the ACL was not strained in the non-weightbearing knee. However, weightbearing increased the ACL strain values over the range of moments tested. These data have important clinical ramifications in the development of rehabilitation protocols following ACL reconstruction since weightbearing has been previously thought to provide a protective mechanism to the healing graft.

The Strain Behavior of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament During Squatting and Active Flexion-Extension A Comparison of an Open and a Closed Kinetic Chain Exercise

The effects of weightbearing (closed kinetic chain) and nonweightbearing (open kinetic chain) exercises on the biomechanical behavior of an injured anterior cru ciate ligament or a healing anterior cruciate ligament graft are unknown. To understand the effects of these exercises on the healing graft, we measured the strain behavior of the normal anterior cruciate ligament in human subjects while they performed squatting, a closed kinetic chain exercise, and active flexion-exten sion of the leg, an open kinetic chain exercise. The maximum anterior cruciate ligament strain values ob tained during squatting did not differ from those ob tained during active flexion-extension. Also, anterior cruciate ligament strain values obtained during squat ting were unaffected by the application of elastic resis tance intended to increase muscle activity. These find ings indicate that squatting, which produces a substantial compressive joint force, does not necessar ily protect the anterior cruciate ligament more than active flexion-extension of the leg, which is character ized primarily by contraction of the dominant quadri ceps muscle. These findings also demonstrate that increasing resistance during the squat exercise does not produce a significant increase in anterior cruciate ligament strain values, unlike increased resistance dur ing active flexion-extension exercise.

Rehabilitation After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction A Prospective, Randomized, Double-Blind Comparison of Programs Administered Over 2 Different Time Intervals

Background There are adverse effects associated with immobilization of the knee after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, yet very little is known about how much activity will promote adequate rehabilitation without permanently elongating the graft, producing graft failure, or creating damage to articular cartilage. Hypothesis Rehabilitation with either an accelerated or nonaccelerated program produces no difference in anterior-posterior knee laxity, clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and the synovial fluid biomarkers of articular cartilage metabolism. Study Design Randomized controlled clinical trial; Level of evidence, 1. Methods Twenty-five patients who tore their anterior cruciate ligament were enrolled and underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Patients were randomized to accelerated rehabilitation or nonaccelerated rehabilitation. At the time of surgery and 3, 6, 12, and 24 months later, measurements of anterior-posterior knee laxity, clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and cartilage metabolism were completed. Results At the 2-year follow-up, there was no difference in the increase of anterior knee laxity relative to the baseline values that were obtained immediately after surgery between the 2 groups (2.2-mm vs 1.8-mm increase relative to the normal knee). The groups were similar in terms of clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, activity level, function, and response of the bio-markers. After 1 year of healing, synthesis of collagen and turnover of aggrecan remained elevated in both groups. Conclusion Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft followed by either accelerated or nonaccelerated rehabilitation produces the same increase of anterior knee laxity. Both programs had the same effect in terms of clinical assessment, patient satisfaction, functional performance, and the biomarkers of articular cartilage metabolism. There is concern that the cartilage biomarkers remained elevated for an extended period.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using quadriceps patellar tendon graft Part I. Long-term followup

Eighty-three patients with ACL reconstructions using the quadriceps patellar tendon graft were evaluated in a 10 year (mean, 5.5 years) follow-up study. A five-part analysis, consisting of physical examination, question naire, Genucom analysis, operative note review, and radiographs, was performed. Seventy-six percent were categorized as satisfactory. Ninety-two percent were content with their results, while only 4% were unsatis fied. Ninety-three percent of the patients had no signif icant pain and 95% had no giving way postreconstruc tion. Ninety-two percent had no more than a mild functional deficit. Eighty-seven percent and 90% of the patients had no significant Lachman or pivot shift by examination, respectively. Our results showed no in crease in failure over time (1 to 10 years), although those operated on during the initial 5 years showed more radiographic degenerative changes. Plotting our results in classification systems of other authors yielded success rates as good as or better than those using our own criteria. An objective means by which to quan tify laxity did not reliably correlate with the quantifying of laxity made by physical examination. Only the lack of a formal rehabilitation program greater than 4 months postoperatively and repaired tears of the medial or lateral collateral ligaments proved to be significant risk factors for poor recovery.

Decreased lubricin concentrations and markers of joint inflammation in the synovial fluid of patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury

OBJECTIVE To study the effect of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury on lubricin concentrations in synovial fluid (SF) and its correlation with time postinjury, inflammatory cytokines, lubricin-degrading enzymes, and SF proteoglycan content. METHODS SF samples were obtained from both knees of 30 patients with unilateral ACL insufficiency, 32-364 days postinjury. Lubricin, inflammatory cytokines (interleukin-1beta [IL-1beta], tumor necrosis factor alpha [TNFalpha], and IL-6), and catabolic enzymes (procathepsin B and neutrophil elastase) were measured in SF from injured and contralateral (uninjured) joints, by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Sulfated glycosaminoglycan (sGAG) levels in the SF were measured by Alcian blue binding assay. RESULTS SF lubricin concentrations were significantly (P < 0.001) reduced at an early stage following ACL injury when compared with those in the contralateral joint. Within 12 months, the lubricin concentration in the injured knee (slope = 0.006, SE = 0.00010, P < 0.001) approached that in the contralateral knee, which did not change with time (slope = -0.0002, SE = 0.00050, P = 0.71). TNFalpha levels showed a significant negative relationship with log2 lubricin levels. IL-1beta, TNFalpha, IL-6, procathepsin B, and neutrophil elastase concentrations in SF from injured knees were greater in samples from recently injured knees compared with those that were chronically injured. There were no detectable cytokines or enzymes in the SF of contralateral joints. Concentrations of sGAG were significantly (P = 0.0002) higher in the SF from injured knees compared with the contralateral joints. CONCLUSION The decrease in SF lubricin concentrations following ACL injury may place the joint at an increased risk of wear-induced damage as a consequence of lack of boundary lubrication, potentially leading to secondary osteoarthritis. The decrease in SF lubricin was associated with an increase in levels of inflammatory cytokines.

The gastrocnemius muscle is an antagonist of the anterior cruciate ligament

Since the proximal tendon of the gastrocnemius muscle wraps around the posterior aspect of the tibia, its contraction could potentially strain the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) by pushing the tibia anteriorly. However, the relationship between contraction of the gastrocnemius muscle and ACL strain has not been studied in vivo. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the ACL strain response due to isolated contractions of the gastrocnemius muscle and to determine how these strains are affected by co‐contraction with the hamstrings and quadriceps muscles. Six subjects with normal ACLs participated in the study: they underwent spinal anesthesia to ensure that their leg musculature was relaxed. Transcutaneous electrical muscle stimulation (TEMS) was used to induce contractions of the gastrocnemius, quadriceps and hamstrings muscles while the strains in the anteromedial bundle of the ACL were measured using a differential variable reluctance transducer. The ACL strain values produced by contraction of the gastrocnemius muscle were dependent on the magnitude of the ankle torque and knee flexion angle. Strains of 2.8% and 3.5% were produced at 5° and 15° of knee flexion, respectively. The ACL was not strained at 30° and 45°. Changes in ankle angle did not significantly affect these strain values. Co‐contraction of the gastrocnemius and quadriceps muscles produced ACL strain values that were greater than those produced by isolated activation of either muscle group when the knee was at 15° and 30°. Co‐contraction of the gastrocnemius and hamstrings muscles produced strains that were higher than those produced by the isolated contraction of the hamstrings muscles. At 15° and 30° of knee flexion, the co‐contraction strain values were less than those produced by stimulation of the gastrocnemius muscle alone. This study verified that the gastrocnemius muscle is an antagonist of the ACL. Since the gastrocnemius is a flexor of the knee, this finding may have important clinical ramifications in ACL rehabilitation since flexor torques are generally thought to be protective of a healing ACL graft.