Brent C. Satterfield

Tentacle probes: eliminating false positives without sacrificing sensitivity

The majority of efforts to increase specificity or sensitivity in biosensors result in trade-offs with little to no gain in overall accuracy. This is because a biosensor cannot be more accurate than the affinity interaction it is based on. Accordingly, we have developed a new class of reagents based on mathematical principles of cooperativity to enhance the accuracy of the affinity interaction. Tentacle probes (TPs) have a hairpin structure similar to molecular beacons (MBs) for enhanced specificity, but are modified by the addition of a capture probe for increased kinetics and affinity. They produce kinetic rate constants up to 200-fold faster than MB with corresponding stem strengths. Concentration-independent specificity was observed with no false positives at up to 1 mM concentrations of variant analyte. In contrast, MBs were concentration dependent and experienced false positives above 3.88 μM of variant analyte. The fast kinetics of this label-free reagent may prove important for extraction efficiency, hence sensitivity and detection time, in microfluidic assays. The concentration-independent specificity of TPs may prove extremely useful in assays where starting concentrations and purities are unknown as would be the case in bioterror or clinical point of care diagnostics.

Cooperative primers: 2.5 million-fold improvement in the reduction of nonspecific amplification.

The increasing need to multiplex nucleic acid reactions presses test designers to the limits of amplification specificity in PCR. Although more than a dozen hot starts have been developed for PCR to reduce primer-dimer formation, none can stop the propagation of primer-dimers once formed. Even a small number of primer-dimers can result in false-negatives and/or false-positives. Herein, we demonstrate a new class of primer technology that greatly reduces primer-dimer propagation, showing successful amplification of 60 template copies with no signal dampening in a background of 150,000,000 primer-dimers. In contrast, normal primers, with or without a hot start, experienced signal dampening with as few as 60 primer-dimers and false-negatives with only 600 primer-dimers. This represents more than a 2.5 million-fold improvement in reduction of nonspecific amplification. We also show how a probe can be incorporated into the cooperative primer, with 2.5 times more signal than conventional fluorescent probes.

Tentacle probe sandwich assay in porous polymer monolith improves specificity, sensitivity and kinetics

Nucleic acid sandwich assays improve low-density array analysis through the addition of a capture probe and a specific label, increasing specificity and sensitivity. Here, we employ photo-initiated porous polymer monolith (PPM) as a high-surface area substrate for sandwich assay analysis. PPMs are shown to enhance extraction efficiency by 20-fold from 2 μl of sample. We further compare the performance of labeled linear probes, quantum dot labeled probes, molecular beacons (MBs) and tentacle probes (TPs). Each probe technology was compared and contrasted with traditional hybridization methods using labeled sample. All probes demonstrated similar sensitivity and greater specificity than traditional hybridization techniques. MBs and TPs were able to bypass a wash step due to their ‘on–off’ signaling mechanism. TPs demonstrated reaction kinetics 37.6 times faster than MBs, resulting in the fastest assay time of 5 min. Our data further indicate TPs had the most sensitive detection limit (<1 nM) as well as the highest specificity (>1 × 104 improvement) among all tested probes in these experiments. By matching the enhanced extraction efficiencies of PPM with the selectivity of TPs, we have created a format for improved sandwich assays.

Surpassing Specificity Limits of Nucleic Acid Probes via Cooperativity

The failure to correctly identify single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) significantly contributes to the misdiagnosis of infectious disease. Contrary to the strategy of creating shorter probes to improve SNP differentiation, we created larger probes that appeared to increase selectivity. Specifically, probes with enhanced melting temperature differentials (>13x improvement) to SNPs were generated by linking two probes that consist of both a capture sequence and a detection sequence; these probes act cooperatively to improve selectivity over a wider range of reaction conditions. These cooperative probe constructs (Tentacle probes) were then compared by modeling thermodynamic and hybridization characteristics to both Molecular Beacons (stem loop DNA probes) and Taqman probes (a linear oligonucleotide). The biophysical models reveal that cooperative probes compared with either Molecular beacons or Taqman probes have enhanced specificity. This was a result of increased melting temperature differentials and the concentration-independent hybridization revealed between wild-type and variant sequences. We believe these findings of order of magnitude enhanced melting temperature differentials with probes possessing concentration independence and more favorable binding kinetics have the potential to significantly improve molecular diagnostic assay functionality.

Fabrication of porous polymer monoliths in microfluidic chips for selective nucleic acid concentration and purification.

Efficient and rapid isolation of nucleic acids is of significant importance in the field of genomics for a variety of applications. Current techniques for the isolation of specific nucleic acids or genes typically involve multiple rounds of amplification of the target sequence using polymerase chain reaction. Described here is a recent development in the fabrication and modification of porous polymer monoliths for the selective concentration and extraction of nucleic acids sequences. The rigid monoliths are cast to shape and are tunable for functionalization using a variety of amine-terminated molecules including oligonucleotide capture probes. Efficient and rapid isolation of nucleic acids can be performed using polymer monoliths in microchannels in a time frame as short as 2 s. The described materials and methods offer the ability to perform concentration of nucleic acids in solution and elute purified samples in volumes as low as 3 microL without the requirement of altering salt concentration in the wash and elution buffers.