Brian Myhr

The L5178Y/tk+/− mouse lymphoma specific gene and chromosomal mutation assay: A phase III report of the U.S. environmental protection agency Gene-Tox program

The L5178Y/tk+/- (-)3.7.2C mouse lymphoma assay (MLA) which detects mutations affecting the heterozygous thymidine kinase (tk) locus is capable of responding to chemicals acting as clastogens as well as point mutagens. Improvements in the assay to enhance detection of this spectrum of genetic events are summarized, and criteria for evaluating the data are defined. Using these criteria, the Phase III Work Group reviewed and evaluated literature containing MLA results published from 1976 through 1993. The data base included 602 chemicals of which 343 were evaluated as positive, 44 negative, 18 equivocal, 54 apparently inappropriate for evaluation in this test system with the published protocols, and 142 that were inadequately tested, and thus a definitive call could not be made. The overall performance of the assay is summarized by chemical class, and the outcome of testing 260 chemicals in the MLA is compared with Gene-Tox and National Toxicology Program evaluations of rodent carcinogenesis bioassay results for the same chemicals. Based on the Work Groups evaluation of published MLA data for chemicals that were considered adequately tested, it is concluded that for most chemicals the L5178Y/tk+/- mouse lymphoma assay is eminently well suited for genotoxicity testing and for predicting the potential for carcinogenicity.

The concomitant detection of gene mutation and micronucleus induction by mitomycin C in vivo using lacZ transgenic mice

A new assay system that can simultaneously provide gene mutagenicity and clastogenicity data in vivo is described. Transgenic mice (Muta Mouse) harboring the lacZ gene as a target for mutation analysis were injected intraperitoneally with mitomycin C (MMC), either once or on 5 successive days. Micronucleus assays were performed with small amounts of peripheral blood collected from a tail vessel. The spontaneous frequency of micronucleated reticulocytes was 0.42%. For the mutation analysis, DNA was extracted from bone marrow and liver cells at several harvest times. The lacZ gene was rescued by lambda packaging and infection of E. coli C (lac-), followed by plating on agarose plates containing X-gal. The spontaneous lacZ mutant frequencies were 37 and 29 x 10(-6) in bone marrow and liver, respectively. In the micronucleus assay, single treatments with 1.0 and 2.0 mg/kg of MMC induced micronuclei in 3.6 and 5.8% of reticulocytes, respectively, peaking 48 h after treatment. Muta Mouse sensitivity to micronucleus induction was similar to nontransgenic strains used routinely for the micronucleus test. On the other hand, single treatments with MMC at 1.0 and 2.0 mg/kg did not induce any significant increases in the frequency of lacZ- mutants in bone marrow or liver. N-Ethyl-N-nitrosourea, used at 100 mg/kg as a positive control, yielded a 5-fold increase in mutant frequency above untreated animals in bone marrow only. After 5-day treatments, MMC induced approximately a 2-fold increase in mutant frequency in bone marrow only for the sublethal dose of 2 mg/kg. Therefore, this study indicated that the strong clastogenic activity of MMC in bone marrow was not accompanied by significant gene mutagenic activity.

Mouse Lymphoma thymidine kinase locus gene mutation assay : International Workshop on Genotoxicity Test Procedures Workgroup Report

The Mouse Lymphoma Assay (MLA) Workgroup addressed and reached consensus on a number of issues. Discussion focused on five areas: (1) acceptable assay versions; (2) cytotoxicity measure; (3) 24‐hr treatment; (4) microwell colony counting and sizing; and (5) data acceptability/statistical analysis. Although the International Conference on Harmonisation (ICH) indicated a preference for the microwell over the soft agar method, all of the workgroup members agreed that both versions of the MLA are equally acceptable. The workgroup agreed that it is desirable for both assay versions to use the same measure of cytotoxicity to define the acceptable and required concentration range. Currently, laboratories using the microwell version use the relative survival (RS) determined by cloning immediately after the treatment. Laboratories using the soft agar method do not obtain an RS but use the relative total growth (RTG), a combination of the relative suspension growth (RSG) during the expression period and the relative cloning efficiency determined at the time of mutant selection. The workgroup agreed to investigate the RSG, the RS, and the RTG and to develop further guidance. In the interim, the workgroup reached consensus that the RTG be used as the standard measure of cytotoxicity. The ICH recommended a 24‐hr treatment in the absence of S9 when negative results are obtained with short (3–4 hr) treatments. The workgroup agreed to retain this requirement but acknowledged that more data are needed prior to making final recommendations concerning the need for and the specific protocol for the 24‐hr treatment. Environ. Mol. Mutagen. 35:185–190, 2000 Published 2000 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.

Effect of pH shifts on the mutant frequency at the thymidine kinase locus in mouse lymphoma L5178Y TK+/- cells.

Evidence has been accumulating that conditions of nonphysiological pH may affect the results of in vitro genetic tests by mechanisms unrelated to the chemical being tested. Medium was pH-adjusted with HCl, NaOH or with organic buffers (Goods zwitterions). In the absence of S9 mix, no changes in mutant frequency were observed over a pH range of 6.4-9.2; a small, 1.9-fold increase was observed for a moderately toxic treatment (24% relative growth) at pH 6.3. However, in the presence of S9 mix, the mutant frequency increased sharply for pH values below 6.8. At pH 6.4, a 4-fold increase was induced, and pH 6.0 resulted in a 10-fold increase in mutant frequency. Basic pH shifts in the presence of S9 mix caused no changes in mutant frequency up to pH 8.0; treatment with pH 8.8 was highly toxic (5.3% relative growth) and caused a 3-fold increase in mutant frequency. Thirteen mutant clones induced at pH 6.0 with S9 mix were challenged with trifluorothymidine after their expansion in nonselective medium and all retained their resistance; another 14 clones were tested for thymidine utilization and all incorporated only 0.1-5.5% of the 14C-labeled thymidine used by the parental line. The induced mutants were primarily of the small-colony phenotype, which indicated clastogenic activity. This was confirmed with chromosome studies which showed a large increase in cells with aberrations consisting of chromatid breaks and complex rearrangements. The results show that the combination of weak acidity (pH 6-6.8) and S9 mix is mutagenic and clastogenic to L5178Y TK+/- cells.

A comparison of the genotoxicity of ethylnitrosourea and ethyl methanesulfonate in lacZ transgenic mice (Muta™Mouse)

We compared the induction of gene mutations and chromosomal aberrations by ethylating agents in lacZ transgenic mice (Muta Mouse). Chromosomal aberrations were detected by the peripheral blood micronucleus assay. Gene mutations were detected in the lacZ transgene. A small amount of blood was sampled from a tail vessel during the expression time for fixation of gene mutations in vivo; this enabled us to detect and compare clastogenicity and gene mutations in the identical mouse. Single intraperitoneal injections of ENU (50-200 mg/kg) and EMS (100-400 mg/kg) strongly induced micronucleated reticulocytes (MN) detectable in peripheral blood 48 h after treatment. The maximum MN frequencies induced were 6.6% and 3.3% for ENU (100 mg/kg) and EMS (400 mg/kg), respectively (the control value was 0.3%). lacZ mutant frequency (MF) was analyzed in bone marrow and liver 7 days after treatment. Spontaneous MFs were 2.0-4.6 x 10(-6). MF in bone marrow was increased by ENU to 3.4 x 10(-5) at 200 mg/kg and induced by EMS to 1.8 x 10(-5) at 400 mg/kg. In liver, however, both chemicals at their highest doses induced only slight increases in MF. The induction of both micronuclei and lacZ mutations in bone marrow by both ENU and EMS correlated better with O6-ethylguanine adducts than with N7-ethylguanine adducts. The mutants (19 for ENU and 12 for EMS) were subjected to DNA sequence analysis. Among EMS-induced mutations, 75% were GC to AT transitions, which were probably caused by O6-ethylguanine. Among ENU-induced mutations, in contrast, 40% occurred as AT base pair substitutions (6 AT to TA transversions and 2 AT to GC transitions) (no such mutations were induced by EMS). These results, together with the known reactivity of ENU to thymine suggest that thymine adducts play a significant role in the ENU mutagenesis.

Mutagenicity of rat-liver S9 to L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells

Rat-liver S9 preparations became highly mutagenic to cultured L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells when the exposure period was increased to 18-24 h or when S9 mix was preincubated in Fischers medium at 37 degrees C for 19 h and then used to treat the cells for 4 h. Five different S9 preparations (from untreated and Aroclor 1254-treated Fischer 344 or Sprague-Dawley male rats) behaved similarly. S9 mix, which contained 1 mM NADP and 5 mM isocitrate as cofactors, was more mutagenic than S9 alone. Heat treatment of S9 did not destroy its mutagenic activity, but the addition of cofactors no longer stimulated an increase in mutagenicity, as observed with native S9. Treatment with cofactors was not mutagenic. These results implied the involvement of both energy-independent and NADPH-dependent enzymatic changes in S9 mix in producing mutagenic substances. The mutagenic treatments with S9 or S9 mix induced predominantly small TFT-resistant mutant colonies, which suggested that these treatments should be clastogenic to cultured mammalian cells. A warning was given that test chemicals evaluated as mutagenic only in the presence of S9 mix may instead be accelerating the decomposition of S9 mix into mutagens, and it may become necessary to experimentally distinguish between these two mechanisms before a chemical can be regarded as mutagenic.