Brigitte Reniers

Spectroscopic characterization of a novel electronic brachytherapy system

The Axxent developed by Xoft Inc. is a novel electronic brachytherapy system capable of generating x-rays up to 50 keV. These low energy photon-emitting sources merit attention not only because of their ability to vary the dosimetric properties of the radiation, but also because of the radiobiological effects of low energy x-rays. The objective of this study is to characterize the x-ray source and to model it using the Geant4 Monte Carlo code. Spectral and attenuation curve measurements are performed at various peak voltages and angles and the source is characterized in terms of spectrum and half-value layers (HVLs). Also, the effects of source variation and source aging are quantified. Bremsstrahlung splitting, phase-space scoring and particle-tagging features are implemented in the Geant4 code, which is bench-marked against BEAMnrc simulations. HVLs from spectral measurements, attenuation curve measurements and Geant4 simulations mostly agree within uncertainty. However, there are discrepancies between measurements and simulations for photons emitted on the source transverse plane (90 degrees).

The radial dose function of low-energy brachytherapy seeds in different solid phantoms: comparison between calculations with the EGSnrc and MCNP4C Monte Carlo codes and measurements.

The use of low-energy photon emitters for brachytherapy applications, as in the treatment of the prostate or of eye tumours, has drastically increased in the last few years. New seed models for 103Pd and 125I have recently been introduced. The American Association of Physicists in Medicine recommends that measurements are made to obtain the dose rate constant, the radial dose function and the anisotropy function. These results must then be compared with Monte Carlo calculations to finally obtain the dosimetric parameters in liquid water. We have used the results obtained during the characterization of the new InterSource (furnished by IBt, Seneffe, Belgium) palladium and iodine sources to compare two Monte Carlo codes against experiment for these low energies. The measurements have been performed in three different media: two solid water plastics, WT1 and RW1, and polymethylmetacrylate. The Monte Carlo calculations were made using two different codes: MCNP4C and EGSnrc. These codes use photon cross-section data of a different origin. Differences were observed between both sets of input data below 100 keV, especially for the photoelectric effect. We obtained differences in the radial dose functions calculated with each code, which can be explained by the difference between the input data. New cross-section data were then tested for both codes. The agreement between the calculations using these new libraries is excellent. The differences are within the statistical uncertainties of the calculations. These results were compared with the experimental data. A good agreement is reached for both isotopes and in the three phantoms when the measured values are corrected for the presence of the TLDs in the phantom.

Dosimetric study of the new InterSource125 iodine seed

The use of low energy photon emitters for brachytherapy applications, as in the treatment of the prostate or of eye tumors, has significantly increased these last few years. New seed models for 125I have been recently introduced. The aim of this study is to determine the dosimetric parameters as recommended by the AAPM in the TG43 formalism for a new iodine seed design: the InterSource125 (Furnished by IBt, Seneffe, Belgium). Measurements are made with LiF thermoluminescent dosimeters (size of 1 mm3) in solid water phantoms to obtain the dose constant, the radial dose function, and the anisotropy function. The TLDs were calibrated at 6 MV and an energy correction factor of 1.41 has been applied. The same dose parameters are also obtained by Monte Carlo calculations (MCNP4B) in solid water and in liquid water. The radial function was measured at 1, 1.5, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 cm and calculated between 0.3 and 7 cm. The anisotropy functions were measured at 2, 3, and 5 cm and calculated between 0.3 and 7 cm. The calculated and the measured TG43 functions for solid water are in excellent agreement. We have then calculated these functions in liquid water to obtain the dosimetric information for clinical applications as per TG43 recommendations. In WTI, the calculated dose rate constant is 0.98+/-1% and the measured value is 1.03 +/- 7 %. The calculated value for water is 1.02+/- 1 %. In conclusion, the dosimetric functions for the new iodine seed InterSource125 have been determined. They are quite different from the data of the well-known model 6711 from Amersham due to the absence of silver in the new seed. The characteristics are very similar to those of model 6702.

Monte Carlo study of LDR seed dosimetry with an application in a clinical brachytherapy breast implant

A Monte Carlo (MC) study was carried out to evaluate the effects of the interseed attenuation and the tissue composition for two models of 125I low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy seeds (Medi-Physics 6711, IBt InterSource) in a permanent breast implant. The effect of the tissue composition was investigated because the breast localization presents heterogeneities such as glandular and adipose tissue surrounded by air, lungs, and ribs. The absolute MC dose calculations were benchmarked by comparison to the absolute dose obtained from experimental results. Before modeling a clinical case of an implant in heterogeneous breast, the effects of the tissue composition and the interseed attenuation were studied in homogeneous phantoms. To investigate the tissue composition effect, the dose along the transverse axis of the two seed models were calculated and compared in different materials. For each seed model, three seeds sharing the same transverse axis were simulated to evaluate the interseed effect in water as a function of the distance from the seed. A clinical study of a permanent breast 125I implant for a single patient was carried out using four dose calculation techniques: (1) A TG-43 based calculation, (2) a full MC simulation with realistic tissues and seed models, (3) a MC simulation in water and modeled seeds, and (4) a MC simulation without modeling the seed geometry but with realistic tissues. In the latter, a phase space file corresponding to the particles emitted from the external surface of the seed is used at each seed location. The results were compared by calculating the relevant clinical metrics V85, V100, and V200 for this kind of treatment in the target. D90 and D50 were also determined to evaluate the differences in dose and compare the results to the studies published for permanent prostate seed implants in literature. The experimental results are in agreement with the MC absolute doses (within 5% for EBT Gafchromic film and within 7% for TLD-100). Important differences between the dose along the transverse axis of the seed in water and in adipose tissue are obtained (10% at 3.5 cm). The comparisons between the full MC and the TG-43 calculations show that there are no significant differences for V85 and V100. For V200, 8.4% difference is found coming mainly from the tissue composition effect. Larger differences (about 10.5% for the model 6711 seed and about 13% for the InterSource125) are determined for D90 and D50. These differences depend on the composition of the breast tissue modeled in the simulation. A variation in percentage by mass of the mammary gland and adipose tissue can cause important differences in the clinical dose metrics V200, D90, and D50. Even if the authors can conclude that clinically, the differences in V85, V100, and V200 are acceptable in comparison to the large variation in dose in the treated volume, this work demonstrates that the development of a MC treatment planning system for LDR brachytherapy will improve the dose determination in the treated region and consequently the dose-outcome relationship, especially for the skin toxicity.

Dosimetric characterization of a novel intracavitary mold applicator for 192Ir high dose rate endorectal brachytherapy treatment

The dosimetric properties of a novel intracavitary mold applicator for Ir192 high dose rate (HDR) endorectal cancer treatment have been investigated using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and experimental methods. The 28cm long applicator has a flexible structure made of silicone rubber for easy passage into cavities with deep-seated tumors. It consists of eight source catheters arranged around a central cavity for shielding insertion, and is compatible for use with an endocavitary balloon. A phase space model of the HDR source has been validated for dose calculations using the GEANT4 MC code. GAFCHROMIC™ EBT model film was used to measure dose distributions in water around shielded and unshielded applicators with two loading configurations, and to quantify the shielding effect of a balloon injected with an iodine solution (300mgI∕mL). The film calibration procedure was performed in water using an Ir192 HDR source. Ionization chamber measurements in a Lucite phantom show that placing a tungsten rod in the applicator attenuates the dose in the shielded region by up to 85%. Inserting the shielded applicator into a water-filled balloon pushes the neighboring tissues away from the radiation source, and the resulting geometric displacement reduces the dose by up to 53%; another 8% dose reduction can be achieved when the balloon is injected with an iodine solution. All experimental results agree with the GEANT4 calculations within measurement uncertainties.

Dosimetric study of a new palladium seed.

In this paper, the dosimetric parameters for a new palladium seed design: the InterSource(103,)(1) are presented as recommended by the AAPM in the TG-43 formalism. Measurements are made with LiF thermoluminescent dosimeters (size of 1mm(3)) in solid water phantoms WT1 to obtain the dose constant, the radial dose function and the anisotropy function. The TLD were calibrated at 6 MV and an energy correction factor of 1.40 has been applied. The same dose parameters are also obtained by Monte Carlo calculations (MCNP4B) in solid water and in liquid water. The calculated and the measured TG-43 functions for solid water are in excellent agreement. In WT1, the calculated dose rate constant is 0.657+/-1% and the measured value is 0.672+/-7%. The calculated value for water is 0.692+/-1%. The comparison with the previous study (Med. Phys. 27(5) (2000)) shows a very good agreement for the dose rate constant. The agreement for the radial function is poorer. For the measurements, it can be due to the difference of TLD settings. For the calculations the discrepancy could come from the different cross-section data utilized in the different Monte Carlo codes. In conclusion, the dosimetric functions for the new iodine seed InterSource(103) have been determined using the MCNP4B Monte Carlo code and TLD measurement in solid water WT1.

Clinical implementation of a digital tomosynthesis-based seed reconstruction algorithm for intraoperative postimplant dose evaluation in low dose rate prostate brachytherapy

PURPOSE The low dose rate brachytherapy procedure would benefit from an intraoperative postimplant dosimetry verification technique to identify possible suboptimal dose coverage and suggest a potential reimplantation. The main objective of this project is to develop an efficient, operator-free, intraoperative seed detection technique using the imaging modalities available in a low dose rate brachytherapy treatment room. METHODS This intraoperative detection allows a complete dosimetry calculation that can be performed right after an I-125 prostate seed implantation, while the patient is still under anesthesia. To accomplish this, a digital tomosynthesis-based algorithm was developed. This automatic filtered reconstruction of the 3D volume requires seven projections acquired over a total angle of 60 degrees with an isocentric imaging system. RESULTS A phantom study was performed to validate the technique that was used in a retrospective clinical study involving 23 patients. In the patient study, the automatic tomosynthesis-based reconstruction yielded seed detection rates of 96.7% and 2.6% false positives. The seed localization error obtained with a phantom study is 0.4 +/- 0.4 mm. The average time needed for reconstruction is below 1 min. The reconstruction algorithm also provides the seed orientation with an uncertainty of 10 degrees +/- 8 degrees. The seed detection algorithm presented here is reliable and was efficiently used in the clinic. CONCLUSIONS When combined with an appropriate coregistration technique to identify the organs in the seed coordinate system, this algorithm will offer new possibilities for a next generation of clinical brachytherapy systems.

Comparison of dose calculation algorithms for colorectal cancer brachytherapy treatment with a shielded applicator

Colorectal cancer patients are treated at our hospital with 192Ir high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy using an applicator that allows the introduction of a lead or tungsten shielding rod to reduce the dose to healthy tissue. The clinical dose planning calculations are, however, currently performed without taking the shielding into account. To study the dose distributions in shielded cases, three techniques were employed. The first technique was to adapt a shielding algorithm which is part of the Nucletron PLATO HDR treatment planning system. The isodose pattern exhibited unexpected features but was found to be a reasonable approximation. The second technique employed a ray tracing algorithm that assigns a constant dose ratio with/without shielding behind the shielding along a radial line originating from the source. The dose calculation results were similar to the results from the first technique but with improved accuracy. The third and most accurate technique used a dose-matrix-superposition algorithm, based on Monte Carlo calculations. The results from the latter technique showed quantitatively that the dose to healthy tissue is reduced significantly in the presence of shielding. However, it was also found that the dose to the tumor may be affected by the presence of shielding; for about a quarter of the patients treated the volume covered by the 100% isodose lines was reduced by more than 5%, leading to potential tumor cold spots. Use of any of the three shielding algorithms results in improved dose estimates to healthy tissue and the tumor.

Dose reduction in LDR brachytherapy by implanted prostate gold fiducial markers.

PURPOSE The dosimetric impact of gold fiducial markers (FM) implanted prior to external beam radiotherapy of prostate cancer on low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy seed implants performed in the context of combined therapy was investigated. METHODS A virtual water phantom was designed containing a single FM. Single and multi source scenarios were investigated by performing Monte Carlo dose calculations, along with the influence of varying orientation and distance of the FM with respect to the sources. Three prostate cancer patients treated with LDR brachytherapy for a recurrence following external beam radiotherapy with implanted FM were studied as surrogate cases to combined therapy. FM and brachytherapy seeds were identified on post implant CT scans and Monte Carlo dose calculations were performed with and without FM. The dosimetric impact of the FM was evaluated by quantifying the amplitude of dose shadows and the volume of cold spots. D(90) was reported based on the post implant CT prostate contour. RESULTS Large shadows are observed in the single source-FM scenarios. As expected from geometric considerations, the shadows are dependent on source-FM distance and orientation. Large dose reductions are observed at the distal side of FM, while at the proximal side a dose enhancement is observed. In multisource scenarios, the importance of shadows appears mitigated, although FM at the periphery of the seed distribution caused underdosage (<prescription dose). In clinical cases, the FM reduced the dose to some voxels by up to 50% and generated shadows with extents of the order of 4 mm. Within the prostate contour, cold spots (<95% prescription dose) of the order of 20 mm(3) were observed. D(90) proved insensitive to the presence of FM for the cases selected. CONCLUSIONS There is a major local impact of FM present in LDR brachytherapy seed implant dose distributions. Therefore, reduced tumor control could be expected from FM implanted in tumors, although our results are too limited to draw conclusions regarding clinical significance.

Monte Carlo iodine brachytherapy dosimetry: study for a clinical application

At present, all clinical algorithms used in brachytherapy are based on the TG-43 algorithm, which has the advantage to offer very fast calculation time. However, this formalism has many simplifications, assuming for example the patient tissue composition equivalent to water. For low energy brachytherapy seeds such as iodine seeds, it is of interest to evaluate the dosimetric differences between calculations based on Monte Carlo simulations (considered the gold standard) and the TG-43 formalism. For a 6711 model 125I seed calculated photon spectra were compared to spectra measured with a CdTe spectrometer. Good agreement was found except for the lowest energy peak which seems to be over-estimated by the experiment due to the contribution of the spectrometer CdTe diode to the measurement. Dose distributions in water are measured with EBT Gafchromic film and compared to the Monte Carlo calculation. A very good agreement is found. Finally, the method to create a MCNPX input file from computed tomography (CT) scanner images is explained and some preliminary isodose distributions are presented.